Herriman Mansion Restoration Project - Article: Reminder of Old Days in Fayette County

Newspaper Unknown, about 1949

Herriman Mansion is Reminder of Old Days in Fayette County

HERRIMAN MANSION TODAY -- Above is the Herriman mansion as it appears today, a far cry from its glamorous past.

A familiar landmark to folks around Wadena is a big, ramshackle brick house which stands a mile east of town as a three-story monument to a man whose wealth and influence where powerful factors in the early development of eastern Fayette county.

This house was the show-place mansion of Major David B. Herriman, a brilliant eccentric who earned a military title and made a fortune as an Indian agent in Minnesota.

He came to Fayette county in 1857, trading land he held in Minnesota for the Illyria township holdings of George Culver. Culver was an Indian trader who had established a post in 1841 about a mile east of the present site of Wadena. When the Winnebagos were removed to Minnesota in 1848, he had followed them there and had become acquainted with Herriman.

Herriman made the land swap sight-unseen. He was so satisfied with Illyria township, however , that he eventually acquired 1,400 acres of land there. He first built a two-story log house near Culver's old trading post on what is now the Wilder Mattocks farm, but about 1860 he moved into his mansion, the huge dimensions of which were a marvel to his struggling pioneer neighbors.

The building had room for the Major and his five boys from his first marriage, for a young second wife and her little sister and for a dozen or more hired men. The hired men slept in a low ceiling attic room where, legend has it, the major often won back his men's pay in Saturday night card games.

Herriman Mansion newspaper photo
Maj. David B. Herriman

In those early days, the Herriman mansion was the hub of business and social activity in the eastern part of the county. And of the happy young folks who grew up in the house there is one survivor -- 94-year-old Mrs. Mary Ann Hidinger who now lives in Oelwein. She is a half-sister of the 16-year-old girl whom the Major took as his second wife soon after coming to Iowa. Herriman, then almost 50, sent his young wife, Elizabeth Dye, to school in Dubuque, and not until she was 19 did they live together as husband and wife, She subsequently bore him two daughters.

The major's fortune made him powerful in the poorly developed pioneer community and he was a proud and tyrannical man who liked to make his influence felt, according to Mrs. Hidinger, A staunch Democrat, he and his sons had influence enough to keep Illyria township Democratic for years, and if someone crossed him politically, in business or personally, the major could make life uncomfortable for the upstart through his control of township officials and his "pull , with county officers.

But despite all this, the major was looked upon as a benevolent sort of a despot by his poor neighbors. His mills and lumbering operations meant jobs for many men and he was always the ready source of a loan, if he liked a person. But woe be to the debtor who would not, or could not, pay up at the appointed time.

The major's daughters were sent to the Catholic schools in Dubuque where, among other things, they learned to play the piano and to dance. Mrs. Hidinger relates that he traded 40 some acres of timberland for the best piano in West Union so his girls would have an instrument on which to practice.

Occasionally the hired" men would bring out their fiddles and the girls would play the piano and young folks for all around would gather in the plain, high-ceilinged rooms to dance. And in moments of youthful enthusiasm the portly, paunchy major would join-the party and sing and dance gaily to his favorite tune, "Polly Put the Kettle On".

But those bawdy days have slipped by and their memory lies dim in the mind of the one survivor who lived them. The major's fortune, power and holdings are all gone and the name of Herriman no longer has its old impact. The walls of his mansion are rent by long cracks and only a few of the 90-year-old shutters are left to sag at the broken windows of the upper stories.

And not far off, within sight of his old home, the major lies beneath his grave stone which is still the most impressive of all in Wadena's cemetery, The elements have left. the inscription hardly legible, but if one looks closely he can still make out--

Maj. David Herriman
Born Oct. 17, 1808
Died Dec. 17, 1875

And his aged sister-in-law will tell you that there lies a man who was considered so brilliant that his sons had his brain weighed when he died. This investigation, of course, revealed nothing unusual. But the man's huge old mansion, his big marble tombstone and the many tales Illyrians still repeat about him mark him as one of the unusually colorful characters in Fayette county's early history.