Mustard Family

Main Page

Mustard, Crouch, DeLay, Purget(t)

Lydia A. Mustard, wife of Henry Purget


Compiled by Judy & Gary Griffin, 2007 - email address




John Mustard

Richard Loveless was the author of at least two publications that included information on the Mustard family. (1) His information is noted in many of the individuals in this family.

The Mustard family was in Delaware from the early 1700s. They moved to Pennsylvania and then to Ohio, though some probably remained in Delaware and Washington County, Pennsylvania. One researcher states that there were three children of an early Mustard, our John Mustard, Robert Mustard (died 1756), and a daughter.

John Mustard was born circa 1700 or 1715 and died between 1759-1760 in Sussex, Delaware. He married Jane [Jean?] who was born circa 1715 and died in 1773. Loveless may have a John Mustard, died in 1760, married Jean Rankin (?), who died in 1773. After John’s death, Jean married Samuel Beasley. There was a marriage record for a Jane Mustard to Samuel Beasley, November 3, 1762 (he had two or three wives).

John Mustard’s will, made on August 13, 1759, was probated on February 16, 1760. (2) Heirs were his wife Jane (Jean) Mustard; sons John, James and David Mustard, and daughter Elizabeth Mustard. No Robert was named. Jane was the executor and witnesses were Thomas Gray, Joseph Martin and Francis McIlvain. In Sussex County an account on John’s estate was filed in 1763 and 1764. (3)

Children of John and Jane:

John Mustard Jr.’s wife married a Marnix Virden after her husband’s death in 1775. Marnix made his will on November 25, 1795, probated on April 16, 1796. (5) The heirs were his wife Lydia Virden, daughters Alice and Lydia Virden, Mary Martin (widow of James Martin); granddaus. Elizabeth and Mary Martin (children of dau. Mary Martin); grandchildren, Cornelia, Eunice, Burton, Woolsey and David Hall (children of dau. Bathsheba Hall, dec’d). His wife Lydia and his brother William Virden were executors and witnesses were William Hopkins, Josiah Hopkins, and John Mustard, Jr. [John and Lydia’s son]. Two other wills are of interest since Hessy Mustard (John and Lydia’s daughter) married a William Coulter, Ruth Mustard (John and Lydia’s daughter) married a Anderson Hudson and the Mustard-Stephenson connection (John married Lydia Stephenson). A Samuel Coulter made his will in 1767, probated 1768, with a witness Samuel Stevenson [possible father of Lydia]. A Hugh Virden made his will in 1772, probated in 1773, with David Stevenson and Samuel Hudson as witnesses.

The 1790 census for Delaware was lost or destroyed. A researcher has listed the following 1700s weddings in Sussex County, Delaware:

November 3, 1762, Jane Mustard to Samuel Beasley (he had 2 or 3 wives)
January 12, 1769, David Mustard to Elizabeth Hopkins. [son of first John Mustard]
September 7, 1775, Abi Mustard, widow of James Mustard to David Rakin [Abi, daughter of first John Mustard]
October 1, 1778, Lydia Mustard (widow of John) to Mareneux Virden
June 18, 1795, Ruth Mustard to Anderson Hudson [John and Lydia’s daughter]
December 25, 1799, Ruthy [Ruth] Mustard to Phillip Russel [daughter of John and Lydia]
Death: September 16, 1797, Hester, wife of John Mustard, [at] Lewis.

In 1800 there was a John Mustard in Sussex County, Delaware with one male over 45, one male 26-44, one male 16-25, one female 26-44 and one female 16-25. There were no others or slaves in the household. This could be the John, son of John and Lydia Mustard. In 1810 a John Mustard was in the same location with one male less than 10, one male 16-25, one male 26-44, three females under 10, one female 26-44, one slave. A Polly Mustard was listed on the same page. One marriage was found before 1810: February 25, 1801, John Mustard to Polly Olivir C.S.

In the 1820 Census for Sussex County, Delaware, were listed a David, John and Elizabeth Mustard. The David and John could be the sons of the John Mustard who married Lydia Stephenson. David (b. 1773) probably married circa 1793. For David, in this 1820 Sussex County, Delaware census, the ages of the family members fit, none older than 26 (none born before 1795) and two oldest members are in the 26-44 and 45+ age brackets. This David was involved in agriculture and had one free black female in the household. John (b. 1763) probably married circa 1783. The John Mustard family in this same census fits, none born before 1784, two oldest members are in the 45+ and 26-44 age brackets. This John was also involved in agriculture, had two free black males and one black female in the household. Who the Elizabeth Mustard was is unknown. In her household were one male 10-15. Females: one <10, one 16-25, two 45+. No one employed in any business. Three marriages in Sussex County were found for the 1820s:

December 21, 1820, Mary Mustard to Isaac Holland [uncertain connection]
January 30, 1822, Lydia Mustard to John Hopkins [uncertain connection]
January 5, 1826, Lydia A. Mustard to William Perry (Lydia born April 20, 1807) [the Lydia Mustard, daughter of our William’s brother, Samuel Mustard, who is said to have married Ashur Howard 1825 and William Bennett 1836]



William Mustard

William Mustard, Sr., Reverend, (John2, John1) born July 23, 1759 in Cool Springs, Sussex, Delaware, died circa July 1837 in Pike County, Ohio. William married Elizabeth Williams in 1780/82, probably in Pennsylvania. He married, second, Elizabeth Crouch after 1808/11, probably in Ross County, Ohio. See Crouch history. Loveless has: William married (1) Elizabeth Henry, (2) Elizabeth Crouch DeLay. Elizabeth Crouch was born between 1760-1763 in Pennsylvania and died before August 1850. Elizabeth Crouch first married Henry Delay circa 1770, probably in Virginia. They had eleven children, and Henry died about 1805-1811. Elizabeth then married William Mustard Sr., who had a previous marriage, perhaps to Elizabeth Williams. Elizabeth Crouch had no children with William. By 1810, William (b. 1759) and his son Samuel (b. 1771) were in Scioto County, Ohio. By 1820 William’s sons George, Samuel and William, Jr. were listed.

William’s will was probated on July 24, 1837 in Pike County, written on April 21, 1837. (6) It did not list a wife. The children listed were: John, Samuel, Joseph, Lydia Smith wife of William Smith, George, William, Enos, Sarah Zarley, Ann Pollock and Elizabeth Mustard. Samuel and William were listed as executors. Joseph and Nancy (married John Smith) were not named.

The children of William and his first wife, Elizabeth were:




George Mustard

George Mustard (William3, John2, John1) was born 1780 or 1790 in Pennsylvania and died after 1850 in Indiana. George married Eleanor DeLay on June 28, 1810 in Scioto County, Ohio. In 1816 George was a proprietor with William Mustard in Pike County, Ohio. (8) A George Mustard entered 160 acres of land on October 15, 1835 in Indiana. According to the History of Madison County, George Mustard came to Lafayette Township circa 1832 from Ross County, Ohio. However, it appears he came from Pike County, Ohio, which was formed in 1815 from Ross, Scioto and Adams counties.

The History of Madison County, Indiana, gives some information on George and his family. (9) George was a “pioneer settler of Madison county and the maiden name of his wife was Miss Delay.” Under Lafayette Township, “Later in the same year Reuben Junks, George Mustard and John B. Penniston came from Ross county, Ohio, and founded homes in this township.” This refers to either 1828 or 1832. Circa 1836 “James Hollingsworth circulated a petition for the organization of the township. Signed by John B. Penniston, John Croan, Isaac Jones, Reuben Junks, Reed Wilson, Henry Ry, Jordan Newton, George Mustard, George Moore, William Lower, Enos Mustard, John Maggart, George Rains, Samuel Fetty, David Gooding and James Finney – the entire voting population within the territory it was proposed to incorporate in the new township.” “George Mustard planted the first orchard in the township soon after settling there, procuring his trees from Dempsy Wilson, of Anderson township. A small log school house was erected in 1840, . . . first school in the township was taught there in the fall of that year by John Penniston.”

John B. Penniston was also an early settler and he married Mariah Purget(t). Mariah was a sister of Sidney Purget(t) who married Henry Mustard. John Penniston was a teacher in the school erected in 1840. John and Maria were listed in the 1850 Indiana census.

Several Mustards had migrated to Indiana by 1840. An Enos, George and William were enumerated in Madison County. A Jacob and William were in Tippecanoe County and a James was in Marion County. By 1850 William, Enos, George and Henry were in Madison County (William in Anderson Township, the others in Lafayette Township). A William, Jacob and Samuel were in Tippecanoe County. A Jacob Mustard was in Marion County.

Enumerated in 1850 in Lafayette Township, just after our Lydia Mustard and her husband Henry Purget, were George and Eleanor Mustard. George and Eleanor were now 61 and only their daughter Elizabeth was living with them. George was still farming, with real estate value of $300. Enumerated only five pages later was their son Enos, with son Henry on the following page. Enos and Henry were farmers with real estate value of $800 and $600 respectively. By 1870 Henry was not found in the census, although he is said to have died on August 11, 1888 in Elwood, Madison County, Indiana (also not found in 1880 census).

The children of George and Eleanor:



Endnotes

1 Two hundred American ancestors : the progenitors of Richard William Loveless, R. W. Loveless. Delaware families, some hitherto unpublished by Richard William Loveless, Oshkosh Press 1968.

2 Will Book: Arch. vol. A91; Reg. of Wills, Liber B, Page: 21; folios 203-207. Calendar of Sussex County, Delaware Probate Records, 1680-1800. Georgetown, DE: Public Archives Commission, 1964.

3 Sussex County Delaware Court House Orphan’s Docket Index 1737 – 1847, no book, pp. 90, 98. ftp.rootsweb.com/pub/usgenweb/de/sussex/court/sussexm.txt.

4 Mustard, John, dec’d, Account of Administratrix, 1775. Sussex County Delaware Court House Orphan’s Docket Index 1737 – 1847, Libro A, p. 324. ftp.rootsweb.com/pub/usgenweb/de/sussex/court/sussexm.txt.

5 Calendar of Sussex County, Delaware Probate Records, 1680-1800. Georgetown, DE: Public Archives Commission, 1964. Will Book: Arch. vol. A103; Reg. of Wills, Liber E, Page: 180; folios 83-84.

6 1837 July 24, Will of William Mustard Probated, Pike Co, Ohio. Probate Book A, p. 106 and Book 1, p. 78. Written 21 April 1837.

7 Helen Enz Christian, Echo of Rarden History, New York, NY: Vantage Press, Inc., 1980, p. 3. "The muster roll of Captain David Roop’s company in the First Regiment of Ohio Volunteers, commanded by Colonel Duncan in the War of 1812, contained 46 names. Their term of enlistment commenced on October 1, 1812 and expired May 7, 1813. Ten of those volunteers were early pioneers in Brush Creek township. Thomas Arnold-lieutenant; Daniel Rarden-fourth corporal; Enos Mustard-drummer; Joseph Mustard, John Rarden, James Rarden, John Smith, Isaac Smith, Paul Stewart, and William Wright-privates."

8 Ohio Records and Pioneer Families Vol 9 & 10 p 112.

9 Ancestry.com. Madison County, Indiana History [database online]. Provo, Utah: MyFamily.com, Inc., 2004. Original data: Forkner, John L. History of Madison County Indiana. Chicago and New York: Lewis Publishing, 1914.

10 History of Madison County Indiana, Volume II, compiled by John L. Forkner, Chicago and New York: Lewis Publishing, 1914, pp. 552-554.