My
Lord Tom Noddy
A strange medical condition and a case of manslaughter
By Michael Newark
George Newark of Stoke on Trent,
Staffordshire came from a family of potters, a very common trade in a part of
England renowned for its pottery manufacture.
He was born about 1811 to John Newark and his wife Sarah (née Barber)
and was one of eight siblings.
However, most of what is known about George comes from his army
service record as he joined the Second Regiment of Life Guards at age
nineteen years seven months. A tall
young man, standing over 6 feet 1 inch, he enlisted for the usual bounty of
the King's shilling on November 18, 1830 as a Private, service number
406. Altogether he served fifteen
years and 156 days in the regiment during which his conduct was described as
very good and for which he was awarded two distinguishing Marks of Good
Conduct. One of these was forfeited for being absent from 1 pm on July 11,
1841 to 8.10 am on July 13, 1841 but regained a couple of years later. All of his service time was spent in his
home country with no overseas service and at the end of his military
engagement he remained a private.
Discharge from the
Regiment He was discharged from the Regiment at the
Windsor Cavalry Barracks on the 22nd of April 1846. Except for the
circumstances of his discharge for medical reasons, it might be said that his
service career was not particularly distinguished. The Surgeon's certificate when George was
recruited stated "he has no Rupture nor mark of an
old Wound or Ulcer adhering to the bone: he is free from Varicose Veins of
the legs, and has the full power of motion of the joints and Limbs. He is well formed, and has no Scrofulous
Affection of the Glands, Scald Head, or other inveterate Cutaneous eruptions:
he is free from any trace of corporal Punishment: His respiration is easy, and his Lungs
appear to be sound ....I consider him fit for His Majesty's
Service". By April 22, 1846 his state of health had
radically changed. A Medical Report by
the Regimental Surgeon at that times reads as follows; "Pt. George Newark
is now, and has been for months past the subject of a very severe and unusual
form of chronic Bronchitis. I believe
the trachea at its bifurcation to be diminished in caliber from some unknown
cause. A great deal has been done for
him both in and out of hospital but without avail. His breathing is
occasionally so much affected that I do not believe him fit for any kind of
labour. The sight of his left eye is
likewise imperfect and this occasionally interferes much with the vision of
the right one". Poor
George's health was so bad in fact that he died at age 35 years in 1846 very
shortly after his discharge. |
||
Manslaughter
Now let's move on to a seemingly unrelated
situation involving Elizabeth Newark who was brought before the Old Bailey
Court in London to face a charge of manslaughter. On July 13, 1842, Elizabeth, described as
"a servant at one of the questionable houses" in the vicinity of
York Square, Regent's Park, entered the Sovereign Public House. There she encountered an intoxicated
William Oates, 29, a journeyman painter, an alcoholic known in the
neighbourhood as "My Lord Tom Noddy". Accounts in the press vary but it appears
that they had some gin together after which he tried to kiss her. She pushed him away and upon him making a
second attempt she declared "if you do I will knock you down Tom Noddy".
Notwithstanding her warning he attempted a second time to kiss her and
she struck him in the face with a door key she held in her hands. Bleeding, he went home to his mother's and
stated "that Irish prostitute" had struck him on the nose and then
he went to bed. The next day he
threatened to take out an assault warrant against her but lacked the money to
do so. Shortly after, according to the Morning Post of Aug 12, 1842, he was
removed to the University College Hospital, Gower Street in great pain
"with his face frightfully swollen and was attacked with
erysipelas". On July 19th., six days after being struck by Elizabeth, he
died. Following an inquest, the jury
returned a verdict of manslaughter against Elizabeth and she was remanded to
the New Prison to await trial.
Evidence presented at her Old Bailey trial by two surgeons indicated
that erysipelas was the cause of William Oates death and they could not say
with any certainty that the blow caused the erysipelas and was therefore the
reason for the death. The prisoner
Elizabeth Newark was acquitted on August 22, 1842. |
||
Death of Elizabeth Throughout the media attention drawn to
this case, no information was reported about Elizabeth Newark herself other
than derogatory comments impuning her morals. It is not until another tragic event some
four years later, this time the death of Elizabeth, that we learn anything
about her. According to news reports,
she drowned in a canal near the Sovereign Public House on April 17,
1846. The following, obviously
inaccurate and biased report, was published in The Morning Post, Tuesday April
21, 1846 and reprinted in several newspapers:
"Suicide of a
female recently liberated from imprisonment for manslaughter - On Monday, Mr.
T Wakley, M.P. held an inquest at the Elephant and
Castle, Camden Town, on the body of Elizabeth Newarke,
aged thirty three, the wife of a
soldier in the second regiment of Life Guards now stationed at Windsor. The object of the inquiry was well known as
a dissolute and dissipated character, in the neighbourhood of the Regent's
Park, and the proceedings excited some interest, from the following
circumstances connected with her history.
About two and a half years ago the deceased was indicted at the old
Bailey for the manslaughter of a poor fellow called ‘My Lord Tom Noddy’ whom she killed at the Sovereign public-house in
Munster Street, Regent's Park, by poking his eye out with her street-door
key. She was sentenced to two years
imprisonment, which being completed about six months back, she resorted to
her old habits of intemperance, and again frequented the Royal sovereign,
which house she left at about half-past one on Friday Morning last,
apparently sober, although she had been drinking there for some hours. She was then seen walking on the Canal
banks by a constable, and in a little while after,
her body was found in the Canal, by the same officer. The Jury returned a verdict of ‘Found dead
in the Regent's Canal’; but how she came into the water not known" This information tells us that Elizabeth
Newark was born about 1813 and that she was the wife of a soldier in the
second Regiment of Life Guards stationed at Windsor - obviously none other
than George Newark from Staffordshire (although no marriage record has been
found). With her death at age 33
coming just five days before his discharge from the Windsor Cavalry Barracks
and his own imminent death, the question that springs to mind is whether the
two events are related. Perhaps in
despondency over her situation and the worse for alcohol, maybe she did drown
her sorrows and herself. We will never
know. Strange but
similar Afflictions This does not quite end the somewhat
strange events surrounding George Newark.
There is the case of his strange affliction, namely stricture of the
trachea, blindness and early death.
For some insight we can turn to the condition of Charles Newrick
(1793-1841) of Lowestoft, Suffolk. We know of him today due to his death from
a constricted trachea and the scientific paper that was written about it. In
1833 Charles contracted syphilis. By
1837 he was emaciated, very feeble and confined to his house. He also suffered much uneasiness in his
throat, so much so that his situation came to the attention of W.C.
Worthington, Senior Surgeon of the Lowestoft Infirmary. Doctor Worthington was surprised by
Charles’ breathing, describing it as follows; “his (Charles)
state of breathing more particularly arrested my attention, as regarded both
the peculiarity of the noise attendant upon inspiration, and the very painful
effort required for its accomplishment. In the ordinary act of inspiring, a
sound was produced, exactly resembling that produced by an unsound horse,
called a roarer or whistler…each inspiration
occupied ten seconds, the chest expanding only six times in a minute”. Dr. Worthington determined that the problem
was an impediment in either the trachea or the larynx to the free passage of
air into the lungs. Restricted by the
state of medical knowledge in the 1830s there was little Dr. Worthington
could do beyond palliative treatment.
On the 15th March 1841 Charles Newrick died,
suffocated in less than five minutes by particles of food from his breakfast
of bread and milk. An autopsy on Charles found a constriction in the trachea
“the calibre of the strictured portion not
exceeding that of a crow-quill”. An
old ulceration of the epiglottis was also found and it was concluded
extremely probable that the tracheal disease had a syphilitic origin. The scientific report published by Dr.
Worthington in 1842 had in all probability not come to the notice of the army
surgeon who attended George Newark about four years later. Even if it had, there would have been very
little that could have been done to help George. It also seems sad to think that possibly it
was through conjugal relations with his wife Elizabeth that he contracted
syphilis leading to the tracheal complications that caused his death, or that
on the other hand he contracted it elsewhere and passed it to her. As a footnote to this story, Newrick is a variation of the name Newark. Charles Newrick's
father was actually named Newark but from Suffolk and not at all related to
the Newark families of Staffordshire.
“My Lord Tom Noddy” was the title of a
popular 18th and 19th century song which parodied the
idle, ne’er-do-well, privileged sons of the peerage. This title, by which William Oates was
known, was doubly ironic given that he was clearly a low-class ne’er-do-well
not remotely entitled even to be called My Lord Tom Noddy.
With regard to erysipelas (a streptococcal infection), it is now known that
people with alcoholism are at increased risk of it, a complication is the
deadly necrotizing fasciitis or flesh-eating disease and erysipelas
infections can enter the skin through minor trauma (among other methods).
Stricture of the trachea is today known as laryngotracheal
stenosis (LTS) and is considered a term for a group of very rare conditions
caused by chronic inflammatory diseases among other things. Sources (1)
Various newspapers on FindMyPast.co.uk (2)
A Case“ of Stricture of the Trachea” by W.C.Worthington, Esq., senior surgeon to the Lowestoft
Infirmary, in Medico-Chirurgical Transactions published by the Medical And
Chirurgical Society of London, 1842 pp 220 – 226. (3)
Royal Hospital Chelsea: Soldiers Service Documents WO
97/7/107. The National Archives (4)
Proceedings of the Old Bailey, Tenth Session, 1841-42 pp 843-844 |