Vol. VI NO 4. | THE ELLER FAMILY ASSOCIATION | NOV 1992 |
---|
Page - 268
BEHIND THE LINES
With the Ellers in the Civil War
Byron H. Eller
A talk was given at the Estes Park Eller Conference, July 1991, presenting same recent statistical findings, and a recapitulation of casualty figures for Eller soldiers of the Civil War, and comparing these figures with the National averages. A hand-out was not prepared for the attendees, though a few transparencies of the tables and figures were shown by projector and screen. The reasons for the failure to prepare a written report are varied and will not be presented here. However, it is the writers opinion that the information given then is of sufficient interest and value to this Association that a summary of that presentation has been prepared and is given here for the readers of "The Eller Chronicles" to peruse, and in doing so perhaps find a new piece of information on one of their ancestors.
It has been said that more men died during the Civil War than in all the rest of the U.S. wars combined through Vietnam, (McPherson, James M., Battle Cry of Freedom, P. 854) so, before considering the information contained in the charts and tables concerning the Eller, let us look at some of those figures concerning the Civil War, following which are a few statements to put the figures into perspective. Though these statements may vary a bit, in essence they come to the same conclusion: the Civil War was a catastrophic experience in United States History.
A total of 620,000 men lost their lives in the Civil War from all causes. | |
U.S.A., | Total--336,480 |
K.I.A.-111,900 | |
Died of Disease-224,580, or 67% of the total deaths. | |
C.S.A., | Total--258,000 |
K.I.A.-94,000 | |
Died of Disease-164,000, or 64% of the total deaths. | |
"64%, or 164,000, of the Confederates who died in the war succumbed to disease". T/L Index, p. 140 (appendix); C.W.T.I. Oct. "84, p. 18. "Of the 620,000 men who lost their lives in the Civil War, more than 60% died of disease". T/L, Sherman March, p. 106. "Twice as many Civil War soldiers died of disease as were killed and mortally wounded in combat". Battle Cry of Freedom, p. 485, 487. "Three times as many men died of illness as died of wounds". Archives of Surgery, Sept. 1988, p. 1050. "Approximately one out of ten able bodied Northerners (out of the total number available for conscription) was dead or incapacitated, while for the South it was one out of four, including her noncombatant Negroes." Battle Cry of Freedom, p. 1040.
ELLER CHRONICLES Vol. VI:4, | November 1992 | pp. 269 |
Now let us look at the accompanying charts to see how the information contained therein compares with the National statistics, and also to see if any additional points of interest can be gleaned from them.
The first chart is self explanatory, though there are sane facts of interest that may be pointed out. Since this chart was prepared an additional death has been brought to light by Ethel Bernice Johnson, in EC VI:2, p. 74. (More on John Adam Eller later). Since this case had not been applied to this study, the figures and percentages would be changed somewhat. One question that my be asked is why the percentages of men killed in action were greater comparatively for Union than Confederate Ellers. There is no truly apparent reason, though perhaps it could be suggested that the greater number of Southern Ellers were from North Carolina and their units remained in their home state on patrol and guard duty, etc. It is a fact, however, that a greater number of Confederate Ellers were wounded and captured. Striking is the fact that the "died of disease" are statistically close for both North and South, and is very close to the overall figure of the National averages, as presented above, though more Confederate Ellers (87%) died of disease than the overall Confederate figure of 64%. Here the figure for the Union is very close, 70% Ellers as compared to 67% nationally.
Coming to the second chart there will be seen a list of the Confederate Ellers who died in the war, either killed in action or died of disease. From information obtained on these men from the service records received from the National Archives, one can readily see that the principal disease causing death was typhoid fever, South, 26%, though when adding other diarrheas it increases to 52%. For the Union soldiers, 71%. Two Confederates died of smallpox, but while both were in a Northern prison cap, Elmira, New York.
Please note the following facts and figures that appear not only interesting but typical of the times, and is a very classic example of taking healthy young men from a rural home setting and placing them in an environment of inadequate hygiene, sanitation, diet, and poor shelters with exposure to inclement weather. And certainly one of the leading factors would be the lack of natural immunity to the communicable diseases.
In examining the duration of time from enlistment to date of death there appears to be a logical breaking off point. For the Union men it was between six months and sixteen months, which occurred in the Spring, or February 1863. For the Confederates the breaking point appears to be between six months and eleven months, and this was also in February 1863. Significantly this was just half way through the war. By this time much of the living conditions had been improved, the sanitation and inadequacies in food rectified, and especially the medical corps of both armies had definitely improved their facilities and techniques. By February 1863 thirteen Confederate men had died after an average of 5.2 months in the service. -Noting the Union figures on this particular point it is significant that five Union soldiers had died with an average time of enlistment of 5.1 months, identical figures for both armies. What if such a horrible and early death rate by disease had occurred in our recent wars, remembering "Desert Storm"?
C.S.A. | U.S.A. | |||
TOTAL MEN ENLISTED | 140 | 63 | ||
KILLED IN ACTION | 3 (13%) | 3 (30%) | ||
DIED OF DISEASES | 20 (87%) | 7 (70%) | ||
TOTAL DEATHS | 23 | 16.4% | 10 | 15.8% |
WOUNDED | 24 | 17.1% | 6 | 9.5% |
CAPTURED | 39 | 28% | 3 | 4.8% |
DESERTED | 24 | 17.1% | 7 | 11% |
MUTINIED | 1 | |||
C. S. A. | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
NAME | AGE | PIACE OF BIRTH | DATE ENL. | DATE DEATH | MONTHS | CAUSE DEATH | PLACE DEATH |
WILLIM H., 53rd NC | 19 | Wilkes Co., NC | 2/26/62 | 7/13/64 | 29 mo. | K.I.A. | In actim near Washingtai |
THCMAS J., lst NC | 23 | Wilkes Co., NC | 7/l/61 | 5/3/63 | 22 mo. | K.I.A. | Battle of Chancellorsville |
F. Eller, F., lst NC "Rowan Art" | ? | Rowan Co. , NC | ? | ? | ? | Killed | "Accidentally" |
JOHN H., 37th NC | 19 | Wilkes Co., NC | 9/24/61 | 5/30/62 | 8 mo. | Typhoid | Charlottsville, VA |
WILLIAM, 4th VA | ? | Grayson Co., VA | 3/20/62 | 7/9/62 | 4 mo. | Typhoid | Charlottsville, VA |
EDWARD, 4th NC | 38 | Rowan Co., NC | 3/14/62 | 7/19/62 | 4 mo. | Chr. Diarrhea | Danville, VA |
ALEXANDER, 49th NC | 21 | Catawba Co., NC | 4/16/62 | 7/26/62 | 3 mo. | Typhoid | Petersburg, VA |
W.R., 52nd GA | ? | Georgia | ? | 9/11/62 | 4 mo. | Disease (?) | Knoxville, TN |
DAVID H., 53rd NC | 31 | Wilkes Co., NC | 3/26/62 | 9/13/62 | 6 mo. | Fever, type ? | Drewry's Bluff, VA |
RICHARD E., 23rd NC | 30 | Rowan Co., NC | 9/6/62 | 11/?/62 | 2 m. | Disease (?) | Winchester, VA |
HARVEY GORDON, 53rd NC | 21 | Wilkes Co., NC | 2/12/62 | 11/21/62 | 9 mo. | Typhoid | Drewry's Bluff, VA |
MOSES, 23rd NC | 34 | Rowan Co., NC | 9/6/62 | 12/22/62 | 3 mo. | "Abscessus" | Mt. Jackson, VA |
CORNELIUS, 42nd NC | 28 | Rowan Co., NC | 3/24/62 | 12/25/62 | 9 Mo. | Meningitis | Petersburg, VA |
ELI, 23rd NC | 27 | Rowan Co., NC | 9/3/62 | 2/2/63 | 5 mo. | Typhoid | Richmond, VA., |
W.W., 30th NC | 38 | Wilkes Co., NC | 9/23/62 | 2/25/63 | 5 mo. | Pneumonia | Richmond, VA |
Avg=5.2mo | |||||||
JOSEPH, 57th NC | 19 | Rowan Co., NC | 7/4/62 | 6/28/63 | 11 mo. | Chr. Diarrhea | Rowan Co., NC |
JAMES P., 4th VA | 19 | Virginia | 3/20/62 | 7/11/63 | 16 mo. | Typhoid | Richmond, VA |
MATHIS, 53rd NC | 34 | Wilkes Co., NC | 3/25/62 | 9/25/63 | 18 mo. | acute diarrhea | Harrisburg, PA, w. 7/l/63 P.O.W. 7/33/63 |
THOMAS, lst TN Bn | 22 | White Co., TN | 4/23/63 | 6/20/63 | 2 mo. | ? | Yazoo City, MISS. |
JESSE, 7th NC | 32 | Rowan Co., NC | 8/20/62 | 2/29/64 | 18 mo. | ? | Winchester, VA |
JESSE B., 42nd NC | 20 | Rowan Co., NC | 1/27/62 | 8/10/64 | 31 mo. | ? | Richmond, VA |
JACOB F., 24th GA | 20 | Tomes Co., GA, | 8/24/61 | 2/9/65 | 42 mo. | Variola | Elmira, NY, captured 8/16/64 Front Royal, VA |
DAVID, 42nd NC | 28 | Rowan Co., NC | 3/24/62 | 3/10/65 | 36 mo. | Variola | Elmira, NY captured 6/3/64 Cold Harbor, VA |
U. S. A. | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
NAME | AGE | PIACE OF BIRTH | DATE ENL. | DATE DEATH | MONTHS | CAUSE DEATH | PLACE DEATH |
THCMAS J. Co. D, 79th Ind. | 27 | Marion Co. Ind. | 1/2/63 | 1/2/63 | 5 mo. | K.I.A. | Battle of Stone River |
JOHN Co. G, 20th OH | 37 | Richland Co., OH | 12/13/62 | 5/6/63 | 5 mo. | K.I.A. | Battle of Champion Hill |
GEORGE W. lst KY Cav. | 22 | Wayne Co., KY. | 9/14/61 | 2/2/63 | 17 mo. | 'Killed in a personal dif ficulty" | Wayne Co., KY |
DANIEL Co. E, 9th Iowa | 18 | Pulaski Co., Ind. | 9/5/61 | 12/22/61 | 3 mo. | chr. Diarrhea | Pacific City, Mo., "Sequelae Rubeola" |
Henry Co. H, 8th Ind.Cav. | 20 | Ind. (KY.?) | 11/l/61 | 12/31/61 | 2 MO. | "Camp fever" | Louisville, Ky., While on furlough |
DAVID (COTHERN) Co. F, 59th Ind. | 35 | Marion Co., Ind. | 12/16/61 | 6/17/62 | 6 mo. | Typhoid | New Albany, Ind. |
JAMES M. Co. G, 31st Ind. | 23 | Monroe Co., Ind. | 9/5/61 | 7/31/62 | 8 mo. | Typhoid | New Albany, Ind. |
ANDREW, JR. Co. D, 79th Ind. | 19 | Maricn Co., Ind. | 8/16/62 | 2/12/63 | 6 mo. | Typhoid | Injured 12/31/62, d. Murfreesboro, TN. |
Avg=5.1mo | |||||||
HARVEY H. 22nd Pa. Cav | 22 | Wash. Co., PA. | 8/13/62 | 12/16/63 | 16 mo. | Chr. Diarrhea | Captured 9/4/63, d. Richmond VA. |
DAVID Co. D, 79th Ind. | 23 | Marion Co., Ind. | 8/16/62 | 4/8/64 | 20 mo. | Typhoid | Knoxville, TN. |
The service records of the men who died of disease will not be examined further in this presentation, however it might be well to note something about each man that died during battle or else "killed in action". First, consider the Confederate soldiers as listed in the accompanying chart.
UNION SOLDIERS
ELLER CHRONICLES Vol. VI:4, | November 1992 | pp. 274 |
ELLER CHRONICLES Vol. VI:4, | November 1992 | pp. 275 |
(Eds. The Eller Family Association is unusually fortunate to have as a member such enthusiastic and meticulous researcher as Dr. Byron Eller of California. We can say the same for Buddy Lovette and Lynn Eller. Since the above report was presented at Conference '91, Byron has spent considerable research time at Gettysburg and in other battle fields in Virginia. During the second week of November 1992 he will spend several days at Vicksburg National Cemetery and Battleground researching for information on Ellers in the Civil War. Those who attend Conf. '93 will hear another of his masterful presentations on his favorite subject.
During the first week of November 1992, Byron, Lynn Eller of Atlanta and Gerald Eller spent three days in Ashe and Wilkes County with Buddy Lovette, J. C. Ashley and others. Buddy Lovette showed us the original land on which Peter and John Eller, sons of George Michael Eller settled in Ashe County on the South Fork of New River. While in Ashe County we meet the charming Mrs. Ethel (Mrs. Ed) Eller and her daughter Daphne; also Mr. Truett Eller, retired public school teacher and principal. While in Ashe County we visited the homesites of Gertrude Eller Waddell and her grandfather James Eller.
Clinton Eller of Wilkes County showed us the New Hope Church and cemetery and the homesites of many other early Eller settlers in that county. He loaned us a genealogy of his line which adds considerably to Hook's compilations of Ellers in Wilkes County, NC; this will appear in a future issue of the Chronicles. Byron was the house guest of your editors for a week-end before departing for Vicksburg. Lynn will be returning soon for another work session with Juanita on the ELLER FAMILY COOKBOOK. The greatest compensation for our work as editors of the Chronicles is meeting such fine people as those mentioned above.)