Harrington Family

Ohio, USA and Nova Scotia, Canada

 

&

Related Family Lines

 

 

by Richard E. Harrington

 

Published: 15 November 2016

 

Copyright: 15 November 2016

 

 

The “Harrington Family” book chronicles several of the oldest family lines in Ohio. Many of these pioneering families arrived before Ohio was a state. We are proud of these ancestors and hope that they would be proud of the several hundred descendants they have propagated. We hope you enjoy the book. Please feel free to copy any parts of the book that you like. Please give credit where it is due. This website-version is structured so that you can copy it to a CD or similar media, if you like. CDs or similar media make great gifts.

 

 

 

 

Click here to go to the Table of Contents (TOC)

[Click here to go to the Table of Contents (TOC) sorted by Page Number

 

or, Click here to go to TOC sorted alphabetically.

From the TOC you can click to any part of the book.]

 

Index of this book (excluding the Album)

 Click here to go to the First Page of this book

 

Click here to go to the Album Index

 

 

i

 

Acknowledgements

          Much work has gone into the making of this book. In almost every branch of the family some person or people have donated time and effort to provide information and photographs that added leaves to our family tree. I am deeply indebted to all who helped me collect and interpret material for this book. I am also grateful for the opportunity to meet so many relatives, some for the very first time. Thank you.

 

 

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

ii

 

 

 

 

Harrington Family of Ohio, USA

& Nova Scotia, Canada

and

Related Family Lines

 

 

This is one in a series of family history books written to describe the genealogy of the author’s Harrington and related families. Books in this series include:

 

         - An Odyssey in Time – The Young/Jung Family – January 2000

         - Jackson Family of Monroe County, Ohio – January 2014

         - Wolfe Family of Pickaway and Ross Counties, Ohio – December 2014

         - The Summers-Greene Family Tree – April 2016

         - Harrington Family History of Ohio and Nova Scotia – November 2016

 

Author and Publisher:  The author, Richard E. Harrington, is the son of Ira Edward and Audra Lavada Young-Harrington; all were born in Ohio and lived in Pickaway County, Ohio most of their lives. Except for short periods of time when he worked elsewhere, Ira, who was born in Pickaway County, spent his life there. Several other members of the Harrington and extended family provided valuable input for this book.

 

Copyright:  Under U.S. copyright law, the author of any copyrightable material is automatically granted a permanent copyright. For this book the copyright became effective on 15 November 2016. All rights are reserved.

 

The computer program, “Family Tree Maker,” was used for data storage and organization during the research and writing phases of this work. The Family Tree Maker book-writing feature was also used to help organize parts of this book.  While most of the material used in this book was gathered by personal research, credit is due to Ancestry.com for making available resources such as online U.S. Federal Census and other documents that otherwise would have involved considerable travel and research.

 

Richard E. Harrington

9517 Mount Vernon Landing

Alexandria, Virginia, USA

22309-3222

 

                  Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

             iii

 

 

 

 

 

 

PREFACE

 

The story of our Harrington family begins almost entirely in several countries of Western Europe. This conclusion which can be based on the results of genealogical family research data is also supported by analysis of the author’s DNA. So it is not surprising to find deep German and English roots in our parade of ancestors.

The Irish surname of Harrington was a relatively recent addition to the family dating back to the early 1800s when the immigrant, Thomas Harrington, married into the English family of Webb and Rushton. The author’s father, Ira E. Harrington, was proud of his Irish heritage and frequently bragged of being nicknamed “Irishman.” Ironically, he was far more German than Irish. His Valentine-grandfather and Bolinger-grandmother were almost pure German having been born from lines of German speaking immigrants. His mother was similarly German also deriving from German speaking settlers in the Hocking Valley in Ohio. Ira’s claim to an Irish background came through his father, William Alvin Harrington, whose father was half Irish and half English. Unfortunately, Ira knew very little about his lineage and one major piece of his limited data, in retrospect, was incorrect. He claimed that his grandmother-Pence was half Dutch and half English based on family lore that they were “Dutch-English.” In reality, they were Deutsch, for German, with probably a little English from his grandmother-Lockwood. I am glad that Ira never learned the truth of his lineage because being Irish was a source of pride and so important to him.

The author’s German linage was further reinforced by my mother’s line that was about half German and half English. The results of all the ethnic mixing which is so typical of citizens of the United States can be found in the author’s DNA chart on page 540 of this book. What is a little surprising is the relatively large (16%) Scandinavian component as compared with the much smaller (6%) Irish component. Ireland was repeatedly invaded and partly settled by the Vikings over its history. The large Scandinavian component could suggest that our Irish line, known to us as being from the Harrington family line, could have been more Viking than Irish. This 6% Irish as compared with 16% Scandinavian further undermines Ira’s claim to an Irish lineage. But, I suspect that Ira would have been equally proud to learn that he carried a significant fraction of Viking blood.

As might be expected, the ethnic blending continues in the descendants of these ancestors, to a point that it becomes very difficult to predict their ethnicity. One of the advantages of a DNA analysis is that it provides a direct measure of the mix, obviating the need to try to predict it from ancestral data.

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

iv

 

 

 

 

 

          HOW THIS BOOK IS ORGANIZED

 

This book is primarily designed to tell the story of the Harrington family that lives in Ohio, USA and Nova Scotia, Canada. Hopefully, it also captures some of the drama, success and failures of the Harrington and related families.

The book has three major sections. The first section is a narrative-based “Story” of about 98 pages that begins with an overview of some of the main events in our ancestral history. This story also includes a spot-light on many of the members of the family whom the author either knew personally or had information provided by others. It also includes some information and stories that could be deduced from historical documents and records. In all these cases, an effort has been made to identify the source and in no instances has any of the material been fictionalized.

The second section of this book is a collection of Records, Data, and Notes that provide details on each family member. This section is the product of extensive research collected over about 20-years from many sources such as private communications; county, state and federal records; documents such as letters and private photograph collections.

The third section of this book is an extensive Photo Album of over 200-pages containing nearly 1,000 photos. An attempt was made to provide photos of as many family members as possible. The album has its own page numbering system and index that are located at the end of the book. Click on the Album Index in the in the Table of contents (TOC) on the next page below (Page vi) (or, click here), then click on the highlighted page number to see a photo of the person.

A number of features are also included in the book in support of its three major sections. One of these is an overall index for the book that is found at the end of the Records, Data and Notes section on page 544. In addition, there is an independent index for the photo album located at the end of the album. This Album Index is cross-referenced to the Story and the Records, Data and Notes sections of the book. Also, located at key points in the Story and the Records, Data and Notes are references to individuals found in the Album. These are identified by the blue color-coded symbol, “Photos in Album, Pages:”  followed by the page-numbers within the album on which the picture can be found. Finally, a Table of Contents found on pages iv-viii helps the reader locate and navigate all of the major parts of the book and the supporting sections, therein. Note that the indices of the Story and the Records, Data and Notes in the book that follows as well as the Album are organized two ways. Each index is presented as page-number sequence and as an alphabetical index.

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

v

 

 

 

Table of Contents

Section 1,     Story - Sorted by page number – below

 

Section 1,     Story – Sorted alphabetically by first or given-name – see page ix-x

Click here to go to the Album Index

 

Title Page

i

Acknowledgement and Dedication

ii

Preface

iv

Organization of this Book

v

Table of Contents (this page)

vi-x

Section 1 -     Story

 

 

 

Story of the Harrington Family

1

Relationship of Ancestral Family Lines

2

Role of DNA in Unwinding our Harrington Story

4

Leavenworth, Kansas DNA Matches

6

Significance of Second DNA Match to Our Harrington

7

Valentine Family

9

Drum Ancestors

10

John Adam Drumm Family Murders

10

Saga of Mary Jane Valentine

13

Harrington Line in Nova Scotia

17

Pence Family

17

Descendants of Our Ohio Harrington Line

21

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

William Alvin Harrington

21

Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington

23

Nellie Mae Harrington

24

Charles Raymond “Ray” Harrington

25

Ruth Imo Harrington-Umphonour

26

George William Purcell

28

Nancy Jean Purcell-Howard

28

Roger Carlton Pennell

30

Viola “Olie” Grace Harrington-Eblin

31

William Allen Eblin

31

George William Eblin

34

Leonard Leroy Eblin, Sr.

35

Leonard Leroy Eblin, Jr.

36

Tonja Renee Eblin

36

Karen Sue Eblin

36

Esther Mae Eblin-Greene

37

John Edward Greene, Sr.

38

John Edward Greene, Jr.

38

Richard Allen Greene

40

Roy Edward Eblin

41

Ira Edward Harrington

41

Dortha Ellen Moore-Keplar

60

 

vi

 

 

 

June Lucille Harrington-Walters

61

Robert Paul Franklin, Jr.

62

Vivian “Lil” Radford-Harrington

62

Audra Lavada Young-Harrington

63

Richard Edward Harrington

63

Daniel Edward Harrington

66

Gregory Phillip Harrington

67

Matthew Sterling Harrington

68

Pamela Anne Harrington-Schwartz

68

Margaret “Peggy” Elaine Harrington-Poole

69

Eryn Leigh Poole

70

Morgan Kendall Poole

71

Neil William Harrington

71

Margaret Jadwiga Stasikowski-Harrington

72

Kyle Ira Stasikowski Harrington

73

William Young Harrington, Sr.

73

Betty Joan Griffith-Harrington

77

Candice Kay Harrington

79

Phillis Ann Logan-Marriott

80

Angela Lynn Harrington

80

William Young Harrington, Jr.

81

Patricia “Pat” Sue Harrington-Reynolds

82

Charles Richard Hutchinson, Jr.

84

Cheryl Ann Huttchinson

84

Craig Patrick Hutchinson

85

Roy William Harrington

85

Martha Kathryn Payne

86

Easter Marie Harrington-Thompson

86

Ward Emittt Thompson

87

Raymond Alvin Thompson

89

Robert Eugene Thompson

89

Catherine “Kate” Marie Thompson Benzin

89

Emmitt Russell Thompson

90

Norma Jean Thompson-Binkley

91

James Richard Thompson

91

Lewis “Lou” Josiah Harrington

91

Thelma Gertrude Allen

93

Donna Lee Harrington-Hunt

93

Paul Eugene Hunt

93

Jack Lewis Harrington

95

Phyllis Joann Boring-Harrington

95

Jan Gordon (partner – never married)

95

Margaret Ann Littell-Harrington

96

Kathleen Charolette Lytle-Harrington

96

Marvin Frederick “Fred” Harrington

96

 

vii

 

 

Section 2 -       Records, Data, and Notes

 

 

 

Epilogue

97

Harrington Coat of Arms

98

Records, Data, and Notes

98

Pedigree Chart of the Harrington Line

101

Outline Descendant report of the Harrington Line

122

Genealogy report (data and notes) of the Harrington Line

124

Outline Descendant report of the Webb Line

252

Genealogy report (data and notes) of the Webb Line

253

Outline Descendant report of the Rushton Line

262

Genealogy report (data and notes) of the Rushton Line

263

Outline Descendant report of the Valentine Line

273

Genealogy report (data and notes) of the Valentine Line

276

Outline Descendant report of the Drum Line

342

Genealogy report (data and notes) of the Drum Line

344

Outline Descendant report of the Bohlender Line

353

Genealogy report (data and notes) of the Bohlender Line

354

Outline Descendant report of the Pence Line

395

Genealogy report (data and notes) of the Pence Line

413

Outline Descendant report of the Lockwood Line

456

Genealogy report (data and notes) of the Lockwood Line

457

Outline Descendant report: William Alvin Harrington

461

Descendant Chart of our Harrington Line

472

Mygatt History of Harrington Family

536

Mary Bolinger Wife of Levi J. Valentine

538

What became of Thomas Harrington?

540

About the Author

542

Index of Sections 1 and 2

544

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Section 3Album

 

After

Page-558

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Album -  Click here to go to the Album Index, then on the highlighted page number to see the photo of the person

 

Album

Page-205

 

Click here to go to the Album Index

 

viii

 

 

 

Section 1,       Story – Sorted alphabetically by first or given-name

 

Story of the Harrington Family

1

Relationship of Ancestral Family Lines

2

Role of DNA in Unwinding our Harrington Story

4

Leavenworth, Kansas DNA Matches

6

Significance of Second DNA Match to Our Harrington

7

Valentine Family

9

Drum Ancestors

10

John Adam Drumm Family Murders

10

Saga of Mary Jane Valentine

13

Harrington Line in Nova Scotia

17

Pence Family

17

Descendants of Our Ohio Harrington Line

21

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Angela Lynn Harrington

80

Audra Lavada Young-Harrington

63

Betty Joan Griffith-Harrington

77

Candice Kay Harrington

79

Catherine “Kate” Marie Thompson Benzin

89

Charles Raymond “Ray” Harrington

25

Charles Richard Hutchinson, Jr.

84

Cheryl Ann Huttchinson

84

Craig Patrick Hutchinson

85

Daniel Edward Harrington

66

Donna Lee Harrington-Hunt

93

Dortha Ellen Moore-Keplar

60

Easter Marie Harrington-Thompson

86

Emmitt Russell Thompson

90

Eryn Leigh Poole

70

Esther Mae Eblin-Greene

37

George William Eblin

34

George William Purcell

28

Gregory Philip Harrington

67

Ira Edward Harrington

41

Jack Lewis Harrington

95

James Richard Thompson

91

Jan Gordon (partner – never married)

95

John Edward Greene, Jr.

38

John Edward Greene, Sr.

38

June Lucille Harrington-Walters

61

Karen Sue Eblin

36

Kathleen Charolette Lytle-Harrington

96

Kyle Ira Stasikowski Harrington

73

 

ix

 

 

Leonard Leroy Eblin, Jr.

36

Leonard Leroy Eblin, Sr.

35

Lewis “Lou” Josiah Harrington

91

Margaret “Peggy” Elaine Harrington-Poole

69

Margaret Ann Littell-Harrington

96

Margaret Jadwiga Stasikowski-Harrington

72

Martha Kathryn Payne

86

Marvin Frederick “Fred” Harrington

96

Matthew Sterling Harrington

66

Morgan Kendall Poole

71

Nancy Jean Purcell-Howard

28

Neil William Harrington

71

Nellie Mae Harrington

24

Norma Jean Thompson-Binkley

91

Pamela Anne Harrington-Schwartz

68

Patricia “Pat” Sue Harrington-Reynolds

82

Paul Eugene Hunt

93

Phillis Ann Logan-Marriott

80

Phyllis Joann Boring-Harrington

95

Raymond Alvin Thompson

89

Richard Allen Greene

40

Richard Edward Harrington

63

Robert Eugene Thompson

89

Robert Paul Franklin, Jr.

62

Roger Carlton Pennell

30

Roy Edward Eblin

41

Roy William Harrington

85

Ruth Imo Harrington-Umphonour

26

Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington

23

Thelma Gertrude Allen

93

Tonja Renee Eblin

36

Viola “Olie” Grace Harrington-Eblin

31

Vivian “Lil” Radford-Harrington

62

Ward Emittt Thompson

87

William Allen Eblin

31

William Alvin Harrington

21

William Young Harrington, Jr.

81

William Young Harrington, Sr.

73

 

x

 

 

 

 

Story of the Harrington Family

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Hello relatives and friends. I would like to tell you what I have learned about our large Harrington and Related families. The “Story” that follows includes both our ancestors and descendants. I hope you find our Harrington Family Story interesting.

 

In July of 2016, on my way home to Alexandria, Virginia from Ohio, I was listening to the local Public Broadcasting System (PBS) radio station when an author, Jenny Hollowell, read one of her recent creations; a poem titled, “The History of Everything, Including You.” In the first four paragraphs of her poem she succinctly describes about 14-billion years of history, to arrive at where this book begins. This abstract poem speaks of a period in which there are no records and hints at how insignificant our human history is compared to the history of the Universe; a history for which we can only guess. The next 4-paragraphs are those of Jenny Hollowell from her poem, “The History of Everything, Including You.”.

 

“First there was god, or gods, or nothing. Then synthesis, space, the expansion, explosions, implosions, particles, objects, combustion, and fusion. Out of the chaos came order, stars were born and shone and died. Planets rolled across their galaxies on invisible ellipses and the elements combined and became.

 

Life evolved or was created. Cells trembled, and divided, and gasped and found dry land. Soon they grew legs, and fins, and hands, and antenna, and mouths, and ears, and wings, and eyes. Eyes that opened wide to take all of it in, the creeping, growing, soaring, swimming, crawling, stampeding universe.

Eyes opened and closed and opened again, we called it blinking. Above us shone a star that we called the sun. And we called the ground the earth. So we named everything including ourselves. We were man and woman and when we got lonely we figured out a way to make more of us. We called it sex, and most people enjoyed it. We fell in love. We talked about god and banged stones together, made sparks and called them fire, we got warmer and the food got better.

 

We got married, we had some children, they cried, and crawled, and grew. One dissected flowers, sometimes eating the petals. Another liked to chase squirrels. We fought wars over money, and honor, and women. We starved ourselves, we hired prostitutes, we purified our water. We compromised, decorated, and became esoteric. One of us stopped breathing and turned blue. Then others. First we covered them with leaves and then we buried them in the ground. We remembered them. We forgot them. We aged.”

 

This brings us to the era and purpose of this book. This “Harrington Family” book is a search for our Harrington family line and its history and the several historical family lines from which they sprang. The “focus” of a family history book such as this is the family where all of the ancestral lines converge to a single person and from which all of the descending progeny derives. The focus of this book is my grandfather, William Alvin Harrington (1866-1951) and my grandmother, Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington (1872-1948).

 


 


1


 

 

The book begins with the pedigree of William Alvin Harrington and his wife, Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington. The pedigree of these two ancestors is best captured as the pedigree of one of their children. I have chosen the pedigree of my father, Ira E. Harrington (1899-1983). The story finishes with the ever growing population of William Alvin Harrington and Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington descendants. At the pedigree level, eight family lines are explored. At the descendent levels, every branch for which data for individuals could be found has been included. Many other family lines have contributed to our family history, leaving many more to be explored by future researchers.

 

The Harrington surname is actually a fairly recent addition to our family. Great, great grandfather Thomas Harrington appeared on the scene from Ireland in about 1841, 175-years ago. This date which is well documented is fairly recent compared to the oldest ancestor in our Drum (Dromm) line, Nickel Dromm, who was born over 400-years ago.

Ahh, but I get ahead of my story. You see, I am not a professional story teller. By profession I am an engineer. So let me start by calling your attention to the family tree chart below. This is a picture that displays some of the major, continuous family lines that make up our Harrington family. Each of the eight family lines was selected for research because it connects directly to one of my great grandparents. At the right side of this chart you will find my father, Ira Harrington, the son of the focus of this book, and me, the author of this book. On the left side of this chart, which is going back in time, are the names of the ancestral families we will explore. These are the ancestral lines that made the stories that follow, possible. The reader can return to this chart at any time if additional orientation is needed.

 

 

 

Click here to view Harrington Ancestral Family Chart

 


 

 

 

 

 

Click here to go to the Table of Contents

 

Click here to go to Page #1 of the Book Index

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

2

 

 


 

 

Let’s begin with two ancestral lines, the Webb and Rushton families, who preceded the arrival of our ancestor, Thomas Harrington, to North America by about 150-years.

In the year 1700 the colonies of England, France and Spain in the Americas were still being defined and settled. The major colonies and population on the continent were English. Only 11 of the 13 colonies that later revolted from England were in existence. The colonies of the different countries were at war with each other and some were allied with the Indian tribes that lived in the areas they occupied. It was not the best of time to be an American, but then, except for the Indians, there were no Americans. These pioneers, including both the Rushton and Webb families were colonial citizens of England and subjects of the King of England who originally settled in what is now the United States.

 

In about 1700 the Rushton family lived in the colony of New York. The Webb family lived in Connecticut. As years passed, both families became aware of the unrest that was beginning to stir among citizens of the colonies toward the authority of the British Crown. However, the main concern for their security was from attacks by non-English colonies such as the French to their north and the threat of Indian attack. It would be another 50 years and another generation in each family before the threat of cessation became real; a threat that no doubt troubled both families. Both families were comfortable being English subjects and were English Loyalists. By the 1760s and 1770s, as the 1776 date of the Declaration of Independence approached, both families were among many who moved to Nova Scotia rather than join the fight against England.

 

Both families settled in Westchester Township, Cumberland County, Nova Scotia not far from where the village of Parrsboro is now located. The move to Nova Scotia reduced much of the civil strife caused by American rebels agitating for independence from England. This strife included the rustling of their livestock to be sold to the British and other injustices. Their move was not the end of hostilities, however. American vigilante vessels continued to prey on Nova Scotia commerce and even raided coastal villages in Nova Scotia. The northern lands around Minas Bay where the Rushton and Webb families had settled were more secure because they were more difficult for the vigilantes to reach. This may have been a factor in the selection of many of the British Loyalists’ new homes.

 

Two generations after immigrating to Westchester Township, Jane Sarah Rushton (1784-1869) and Samuel James Webb (1785-1828) who were neighbors married in October 1802 bringing our two ancestral families together. They became the parents of Mary Webb who married the Irish blacksmith, Thomas Harrington (his date of birth and death are unknown). Thus, our Irish Harrington line was linked to the English Rushton and Webb family lines. Outline Descendent lists of the Webb and Rushton families can be found on pages 252 and 262, respectively.

 

Thomas and Mary Webb-Harrington, my 2nd great grandparents, had three sons; Harris D. Harrington (1842-1916), Charles William Harrington (1844-1904), and John Webb Harrington (1846- ?). Their middle son, Charles William Harrington, will be the ancestor that we will closely follow in this story, although, all of the available data for the other two sons are included in this book. Ironically, we lose track of Thomas Harrington after 1846. Carla J. Summer’s voluminous family tree of the Rushton family gives the date of marriage of Tomas and Mary Webb Harrington as 27 Oct 1841. No records are available that provide Thomas’ age. However, a record of Thomas’ final days and death may have been found. Thomas Harrington and his sons are included on the Outline Descendent lists of the Rushton and Webb on pages 252 and 262.

 


 


3


 

 

 

At this point, I need to tell you how we came to know about our two ancestors, Thomas and his son, Charles William Harrington and Mary Webb’s ancestral line.

 

 

The Role of DNA in Unwinding Our Harrington Story

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

When I began the research of our Harrington line, I immediately encountered a genealogical “brick wall.” I had started my research in the mid-1990s after all of my Harrington ancestors had died so I was unable to interview any Harrington uncles or aunts. As it turned out, it probably would not have been useful if I had. Fortunately, years earlier, my dad, Ira Harrington, had told me about a few clues that had been passed from his grandmother, Sarah Jane Valentine, relating to his grandfather. The clues were as follows: 1) the name of the father of her Sarah Jane’s son, William Alvin Harrington, was Charles William Harrington. 2) Charles was of Irish descent and 3) had been born in Nova Scotia, Canada. 4) Charles had arrived in Kansas, USA on a cattle boat and 5) had given their son his middle name, William. Ira’s main message, however, was that except for the clues from his grandmother, nothing else was known about his grandfather.

 

My search for the Harrington line began in the mid-1990s and, as my father had told me, I could find no information that would help me identify his grandfather, Charles William Harrington. So after satisfying myself that Ira was right about the chances of success in finding Charles William Harrington, I turned my attention to researching the Harrington line from my grandfather, William Alvin Harrington, to the present. I also researched the Valentine family line of which Sarah Jane Valentine, Ira’s grandmother and partner of Charles William Harrington, was a member. The Valentine family research led me back to Charles William Harrington and his visit to Kansas in 1965. So, in 2012 I made a trip to Kansas where my grandfather, William Alvin Harrington, was conceived and born. After 2-weeks of extensive and thorough research, I found no significant new leads to Charles William Harrington.

 

It was not until I had my DNA analyzed by Ancestry-DNA that my quest began to bear fruit. Ancestry-DNA is a branch of the organization, Ancestry.com, the genealogical research arm of the Mormon Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. My first clue came in an e-mail from Ancestry-DNA advising me of a DNA match with another Ancestry-member named Linda McNeil. Linda e-mailed me that she did not know the source of our DNA match but since my name was Harrington, she speculated that it might be from the several Harrington members in her family tree from Nova Scotia. Subsequent research on her suggestion persuaded me that the Harrington’s in her family tree could be the source of the DNA match. I made a trip to Nova Scotia with my wife in the summer of 2013 to further research this possibility. In Parrsboro, Nova Scotia, we found a wealth of Harrington information and descendants. Confirmation of the clues that had been passed down from Sarah Jane Valentine seemed to point to Charles William Harrington being my long-sought-after great grandfather. We found records that identified Charles’s father as Thomas Harrington and his mother as Mary Webb. We also found a detailed family tree of the Webb family. We gathered as much information on the Nova Scotia Harrington line as possible and met with many of the descendants of Charles who are living there. We even visited the graves of Charles, his Nova Scotia wife, Caroline Couch Willigar and many of his descendants.

 


 


4


 

 

I have called this DNA match, my “Nova Scotia DNA match”; a term that is used later in this story to distinguish it from a second Harrington or Herington match that I call my “Leavenworth, Kansas DNA match.” In spite of our apparent success, however, our trip to Nova Scotia did not yield information that would prove, beyond a doubt, that Charles William Harrington was my correct great grandfather. While it seemed highly likely that he was, it was still possible that the DNA match could have been with another related surname such as Webb or Rushton.

 

On 16 November 2014, I received another e-mail from Ancestry-DNA announcing their new “DNA Circles” project. This feature of their service involves identifying Ancestry-members whose DNA and/or family tree, show a match with a common ancestor. The name given to such a Circle is the name of the common ancestor of the Circle members. Within days, Ancestry-DNA identified two Circles that were in my Nova Scotia family line. They were Jane Sarah Rushton (1784-1869) and Samuel James Webb (1785-1828) the parents of Mary Webb-Harrington, wife of Thomas Harrington. These Webb and Rushton Circles confirmed the possibility that my DNA match with Linda McNeil could be from another related surname, since Linda also shares the Webb and Rushton ancestors with me. Further, DNA results from any of the living Nova Scotian descendants whom we had met on our trip to Nova Scotia would be similarly compromised since they also share the Webb and Rushton DNA. The only way to prove my Harrington linkage with Charles William and his father, Thomas Harrington, would be to find a DNA match with another Harrington descendant who was independent of the Webb and Rushton family. Finding such a match would seem to be highly unlikely, but it happened.

 

In January of 2016, my Ancestry-DNA account showed a new Circle that had been named the “Eliza Anne Herington Circle.” This DNA match was with a person who was known by the pseudonym “J.M.” and was administered by Sharon Ann Balts-Stauffer. The “J.M.” DNA match was identified as being a possible 2nd - 3rd cousin and the confidence level was rated by Ancestry-DNA as “Extremely High.” The J.M. pseudonym turned out to be Jennie Marie Mygatt (1919-living), daughter of James Franklin “Frank” Mygatt (1868-1956). Sharon Ann Balts-Stauffer is the daughter-in-law of Jennie Marie Mygatt. Sharon’s husband, Donald "Don" Stauffer is the son of Jennie Marie Mygatt and as might be expected, Donald "Don" Stauffer’s DNA also matches mine. James Franklin “Frank” Mygatt’s mother was Eliza Anna Herington (1835-1895), daughter of Charles Herington (about 1807-about 1840), an immigrant to America. Charles Herington (about 1807-about 1840) was the son of a fisherman known only as “Dutch” Charley Harrington.

 

Let me interrupt this story to add a couple of clarifications. First, as was typical in documents of our ancestors’, names such as Harrington were frequently spelled in different ways. Harrington can be found spelled as Harrington, Harington, Herington, Herrington and probably other ways that I have not yet encountered. Multiple variations are frequently found in a single document. This is probably done deliberately, to assure that the author intended the same name/person to be understood regardless of the spelling variant used. The Mygatt document is an example in which Harrington is spelled using a number of variants.

 

The second point of clarification is a caution to the reader about the two names; Anna Eliza Herington and Eliza Ann Herington. Anna Eliza Herington was the name of the wife of the immigrant, Charles Herington who was the son of a fisherman known only as “Dutch” Charley Harrington. Eliza Ann Herington was Anna Eliza Herington’s daughter who, in the Mygatt document, was claimed to be born in America. I know that you, dear reader, would figure this out, but the similarity in names can make some of the

 


 


5


 

 

following text, a bit tricky. I finally learned to simply use the first name of each woman; namely, Anna and Eliza, and that seemed to fix the problem.

 

So, back to the story of the second Harrington DNA match. Sharon Balts-Stauffer made me aware of and provided a copy of a family history document authored by James Franklin “Frank” Mygatt (1868-1956). Sharon Balts-Stauffer believes the document was transcribed by Frank Mygatt’s neice, Mary Going Kelso, in Tulsa, Oklahoma in the period 1953-1956. By the way, Mary Going Kelso was another of the people with whom my DNA matched. The full text of this document by James Franklin “Frank” Mygatt (1868-1956) can be found in its entry in this book on page 536 and should be read and understood as the basis of conclusions that follow.

 

This Mygatt document seems to support the argument that two related ancestors of our Harrington family may have come to the new world about the same time and that one, Thomas Harrington immigrated to Nova Scotia while the other, Charles Harrington (about 1807-about 1840), initially located in western New York state on Lake Erie. If there were two Harrington brothers or cousins in America, it is likely that they would have known about the other’s presence and communicated it to family members. The most important evidence, of course, is that the DNA matches from each scenario are with my DNA, the author of this book, Richard E. Harrington (1931-living).

 

As noted earlier I have called my DNA matches with descendants of Charles Herington (about 1807-about 1840), my “Leavenworth, Kansas DNA matches” to distinguish them from the Nova Scotia DNA match with Linda McNeil.

 

 

The Leavenworth, Kansas DNA Matches Story

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

The story of the Harrington family in America according to the James Franklin “Frank” Mygatt (1868-1956) document, hereafter referred to as the Mygatt document, is as follows:

 

“Dutch” Charley was a fisherman from Holland. This may be true but other data argue that the family may have originated from Ireland. Either point of origin is possible since under the heel of English rule, Ireland, in the late 1700s and early 1800s, was in a desperate economic condition. Holland had developed a successful, world-class fishing fleet and enjoyed a thriving fishing industry. Ireland, on the other hand, did not begin to promote their fishing industry until the early 1800s. So, it is likely that Irish fisherman would have looked to the established Holland fishing industry as a more profitable place to apply their trade.

 

Whether the early Harrington clan was from Holland or Ireland is of little importance to our story. It is clear that they were accomplished seamen. The Mygatt document has Charles Herington, Jr. (about 1807- about 1840), son of “Dutch” Charley Harrington, going to sea in his teens and soon establishing himself as a knowledgeable seaman. He allied himself with the fur trading industry in the new world and, in the early 1800s, made several crossings of the Atlantic Ocean between Europe and the Americas. His work was almost certainly as a sailor, which was what he had been trained to do. Since he was saving his money to move his wife, Anna E. Herington to America, it seems obvious that he was not paying for his several Atlantic Ocean crossings. It also seems clear that his alliance with the fur trading industry was probably as a sailor in the industry’s fleet of ships that crossed the Atlantic regularly, transporting furs from the new world to their main markets in Europe. At that time, the fur trading industry was the most profitable

 


 


6


 

 

and best paying employer in the world.

 

According to the Mygatt document, Charles Herington, Jr. moved with his wife, Anna Eliza Coopper-Herington and her brother, John Coopper, to America, landing at Hoboken, New Jersey on 5 March 1835. At this time Charles Herington, Jr. and his wife, Anna E.

Coopper-Herington had a 3-year old son, Charles Herington, 3rd. Within a few days of their arrival in Hoboken, they added a daughter, Eliza Ann Harrington (9 Feb 1835 - 1 Jan 1895).

 

[Note the24-day difference between the date of birth of Eliza Ann, 9 February 1835, and the date arrival of the family in New Jersy, 5 March 1835. The Mygatt document states that Eliza was born the day following their arrival in America. It could suggest that she was born aboard ship and her parents declared her born the day after their arrival so that she would be an American citizen.]

 

Charles Herington, Jr., his wife, Anna E. Coopper-Herington, their two children, and Anna’s brother, John Coopper settled in western New York on the Great Lakes. Charles Herington, Jr. continued to work for the fur trading industry. At this point the Mygatt document states that Charles Herington, Jr. was killed by Indians in northwest Wisconsin. The Mygatt document also says that sometime in the 1840s, Anna Eliza Coopper-Harington and John Coopper moved to Milwaukee, and settled in Oshkosh, Wisconsin where they lived for several years. [This move was likely made before Charles was killed by the Indians.] Then in 1849 or early 1850s Anna E. Coopper-Harington & John Cooper moved to Leavenworth, Kansas. The Mygatt document does not mention Anna E. Coopper-Herington and John Cooper again. This could indicate that they stayed in the Leavenworth, Kansas area or that their future travels simply were not considered important to the Mygatt story.

 

The Mygatt document continues to track Eliza Ann Harrington (9 Feb 1835 - 1 Jan 1895) through 2-marriages and to Leavenworth, Kansas between about 1861 and 1865, as the wife of James G. Mygatt. James G. Mygatt was in the Army in the Civil War and was stationed at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas. After retirement from the Army, Eliza A. Harrington-Mygatt and James G. Mygatt moved to Clay County, Kansas, a distance of about 120 miles west of Leavenworth, Kansas and close to Fort Riley, Kansas. It was from Eliza Ann Harrington-Mygatt, the daughter of the immigrant, Charles Herington, Jr., that the Harrington DNA was passed on to several descendants, including me, that now register the DNA matches among us.

 

 

Significance of a Second DNA Match to Our Harrington Family

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Keep in mind that we are dealing with two separate sources of Harrington DNA. The first Harrington DNA match is from the descendants of Charles William Harrington in Nova Scotia. This is the source that I have called the “Nova Scotia DNA match.” The second source is the DNA of the Herington line that originated from “Dutch” Herington, whom we have just discussed and is detailed in the Mygatt document. This DNA was channeled through Charles Herington, Jr. to his daughter, Eliza Ann Harrington (9 Feb 1835 - 1 Jan 1895), and on to several Ancestry-DNA members, including me. This is the source that I have called the “Leavenworth, Kansas DNA match.” These are clearly two independent sources of Harrington DNA that match my own DNA.

 

At the time of this writing, I have two independent Harrington DNA matches from widely separated geographical sources. Now, let’s look at the Nova Scotia Harrington

 


 


7


 

 

DNA and its possible connection with the Harrington DNA from families who descended from the Leavenworth, Kansas match in the paragraphs above. Our Thomas Harrington first appears in the Nova Scotia records in 1841 when he married Mary Webb (1810-after 1871). He appears later in the records of the births of his three sons; Harris D. Harrington in 1842, Charles William Harrington in 1844 and John Webb Harrington in 1846. Thomas’ name appears in miscellaneous records of his descendants but not in a way that establishes his presence. For example, he is identified on marriage license of his children. Thomas sort of breezes onto the scene in 1841 and disappears sometime after the birth of his sons; after 1846. No records have been found of Thomas’ birth or his arrival in Nova Scotia other than a note on his marriage license to Mary Webb that he was from County Cork, Ireland. Yet, today we find strong DNA matches with both the Nova Scotia and Leavenworth, Kansas Harrington’s. How could this be?

 

At least three possibilities come to mind. The first is that the DNA data are wrong or misleading. I reject this possibility on the basis that there are far too many DNA matches in both locations (Kansas and Nova Scotia) and too many match-ups of information such as the clues from Sarah Jane Valentine and subsequent data found in my Nova Scotia trip that match the clues.

 

A second and more probable possibility is that Thomas Harrington had at least one more Harrington relative in America. That relative would likely have been a brother or cousin and he appears to have been Charles Herington, Jr., son of “Dutch” Charles in the Mygatt document.

 

A third possibility is that Charles Herington, Jr. and Thomas Harrington was the same person. This could be possible since Charles Herington, Jr. supposedly was killed by Indians in the 1840. The Mygatt documents states that sometime in the 1840s, the wife of Charles Herington, Jr. and her brother, John Cooper moved to Oshkosh, Wisconsin and in 1849 or early 1850s moved to Leavenworth, Kansas. It is possible the story that Frank Mygatt knew about his grandfather, Charles Herington, Jr., having been killed by the Indians, could have been a cover-story to hide the separation of Charles and Anna Herington. Charles Herington, Jr. could have later changed his given name to Thomas and married to Mary Webb. The timing of such a scenario fits. On 27 October, 1841, Thomas Harrington married Mary Webb. Thomas Harrington and Mary Webb may have met in Nova Scotia on one of his many trips while working for the fur trading company. But, this version seems a little far-fetched and there is no data to support it. In the end the likelihood that two closely related Harrington siblings or cousins account for the two separate sources of Harrington DNA matches and seems more probable.

 

It doesn’t really matter to our Harrington story, whether Charles Herington, Jr., son of “Dutch” Herington, and Thomas Harrington, parent of Charles William Harrington was the same person or that they were brothers or cousins. Of course it would be nice to know. But the DNA matches prove that at the very least, both were related to me, the author of this book. The DNA matches of several Charles Herington, Jr. descendants with my DNA are fortuitous because they are free of any known prior connection with the Webb or Rushton families in Nova Scotia. So, these matches with my DNA resolve the issue of whether the DNA matches with the Nova Scotia descendants of Thomas Harrington were true matches with my Harrington line or were simply matches with the Webb and Rushton parents of Thomas Harrington’s wife, Mary Webb. It isn’t even important that we know which DNA resulted in the Nova Scotia matches, since Thomas and Mary Webb are known to have been married and known to have been the parents of Charles William Harrington. Most likely both family’s DNA are involved in the match.

 


 


8


 

Our Valentine Family

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

The bridge between our Nova Scotian ancestors of the Harrington, Webb and Rushton families and the descending Ohio Harrington clan was my great grandmother, Sarah Jane Valentine. The Valentine line is quite possibly the next most significant line in our Harrington story. Our Valentine line in America began with the German immigrant, Johan George Valentine (1715-1783), my 5th great grandfather. George was born in Mutterstadt, (near Ludwigshaften), Palatinate, Germany. He sailed for America as a young man of 34-years, arriving in Philadelphia in September 1749. He married Margaretha Matthis in 1752. In August 1755 George’s son, Johan Henry Valentine (1755-1838), my 4th great grandfather was born. George eventually established his final homestead in Maryland where he died and is buried on his Maryland estate.

Farming is a very labor-intensive occupation. So farmers with large families, especially those with male family members, had an advantage in terms of building wealth. It also had a major down-side in terms of how to manage the inheritance of the parent’s farm. Families with a large number of children were faced with the problem of subdividing the farm into smaller acreages that were no longer as profitable and sometimes too small to support a new family. An alternate extreme was to will the farm to one child and leave the others on their own to find a farm to support their new families. While other options were available for dividing inheritances equitably, the results nearly always resulted in the children, many of whom had significantly contributed to the family wealth and property being divided, receiving a reduced share. One of the results of this practice was to cause families to move to new, unoccupied land. In the early years of the United States, that meant moving West. This also gave rise to the saying attributed to Horace Greeley in 1865, “Go west, young man, go west and grow up with the country.” George Valentine (1715-1783) apparently handled this problem by giving each of his sons a quarter of his farm. George’s son, Henry Valentine (1755-1838), handled it by selling his farm in 1829 to two of his four sons, Joseph Valentine (1795-1863) and Joshua Valentine (1798-1870).

 

Henry Valentine (1755-1838), the second son of his immigrant father, George Valentine, was my 4th great grandfather. At the age of 22 he was a drummer in the Revolutionary War’s 37th Battalion, 4th Company of the Maryland Militia. He married Elizabeth Barbara Friess on 21 Sep 1779 and soon started his family of at least 5 girls and 4 boys. All 5 girls were born before the first boy was born. In 1807 he moved to Pickaway County, Ohio where he died 21 October 1838 at the home of his son, Joshua, my 3rd great grandfather. Henry is buried in the Zion Church Cemetery in Washington Township, Pickaway County, Ohio.

 

Joshua Valentine (1798-1870) remained on the farm he had bought from his father, Henry Valentine (1755-1838), for the remainder of his life. On 29 Jul 1817 he married Margaret Drum (1799-1867), with whom he had at least 9 children; 6 males and 3 females. Joshua and Margaret’s third child was Levi J. Valentine (1824-1893), the father of Sarah Jane Valentine who was the mother of William Alvin Harrington (1866-1951), the patriarch of our Ohio Harrington clan. The only photograph of Sarah Jane Valentine-Anderson is on page 2 in the Album at the end of this book. In this picture Sarah Jane is the oldest of 4-generations.

 


 

 


9


Our Drum Ancestors

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

We will return to the Valentine story on page 13, but let me interrupt their story briefly to relate an important story about our Drum ancestors. An Outline Descendant list of this family can be found on page 342. Incidentally, the Drum name is a good example of a name that has experienced many variations in spelling over the years. It can be found spelled Trumm, Trum, Trump, Dromm, Drom, Drumm and Drum in the historical literature; sometimes with two or more spellings in the same document.

The Drum family had plenty of excitement of its own. The family line was from Germany. Our immigrant ancestor to America was Johan Adam Drumm who was born 9 December 1705. He married Maria Gertraud Bier on 22 Jan 1733 in Ulmet, Bayern, Germany. Four years later they emigrated to America and arrived in Philadelphia, PA on 29 August 1737 aboard a ship named the “Samuel.” Johan Adam Drumm was murdered by Indians in his home on 22 June 1757. The details of this murder can be found as a newspaper article prepared from a military report of the event.

 

The story that follows is of the Johan Adam Drumm family as written by Lewis W. Donar and edited by Brendan D. Strasser. It appeared in the newsletter of the Albany Township Historical Society, Spring 1998.

 

THE JOHAN ADAM DRUMM FAMILY MURDERS

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Johan Adam Drumm, son of Johan Christian and Anna Elisabeth (Doll) Drumm, was born and raised in Ulmet, Germany, a town in the Palatinate, known as the Pfalz. His exact birth date is unknown, but his christening took place on 9 December 1705 in Ulmet. On 22 January 1733 he was married to Gertraud (Maria Gertrude) Bier, daughter of Peter and Ann Catharine Bier of Ulmet. John Adam and Gertraud became the parents of a son, Johan Christian, born in Ulmet and christened on 17 April 1735, and of whom nothing more is known. He does not appear on ship immigration records and in 1775 documents concerning ownership of the deceased Adam's Albany Township land. George Drumm, Christian's brother, is listed as Adam's sole living heir.

 

At age 31, Johan Adam Drumm and his wife, Gertraud, arrived in the New World aboard the ship "Samuel", on 29 August 1737. (Johan Christian Doll and Johan Peter Doll were also on board, but any relationship to the mother of Johan Adam has not yet been established.) On the following day, 30 August, Adam appeared at the courthouse in Philadelphia, Pa., to sign the necessary qualification papers, one being the swearing of allegiance to the King of England, George II, and the other a pledge to abide by the laws of the province of Pennsylvania. Being able to write, he signed both by his own hand.

 

Adam established himself as a land owner in Albany Township, Berks County, Pa., by warrant dated 20 January 1736 for a tract containing 205 acres. In the year 1738, a son, George, was born; his exact birth date is unknown. On 4 November, 1741, it is noted on a draft of a tract of land drawn in favor of Andreas Hagenbuch that Adam Drum was already, in possession of the neighboring tract. The Drumm tract adjoined the Hagenbuch tract on the northwest, between it and the tree line of the Blue Mountain.

 


 

 


10


 

 

 

Keeping this in mind, we turn now to another tract of land eight-tenths of a mile farther to the West. This tract is identified on a draft of "The great road of Catawissey to Philadelphia" drawn in February 1752, along which is noted the course and distance of a short stretch of this road, East, 43 perches [about 710 feet], "Along the land of Adam Trum." Evidence exists that at some time between 1741 and 1752, Adam sold his initial tract to Frantz and Martin Bailey and took residence on his second purchase. At a much later time, the first purchase was in the possession of Mr. Clifford Lutz, the second the farm of Mr. Oskar Dietrich. It must be assumed that the Drumm family was living on this second plantation when the following events occurred.

 

It was evidently a hot Wednesday afternoon with thunderstorms threatening. At that time of day the family quite probably was gathered for the evening meal when suddenly two things took place almost simultaneously. A thunderstorm of major proportion broke over the countryside, and the Drumm family was brutally attacked by Indians. The date was 22 June 1757.

 

In a letter written on 25 June 1757 to David Schulrz of Hanover Township, Berks County, Pa., James Reed of Reading, Pa., gives the following account of this attack:

 

"Last night Jacob Levan came to see me, and showed me a letter of the 22d inst. From Lieutenant Engle by which he advised Mr. Levan of the murder of one Adam Trump (an alternate spelling of "Drumm) in Allemangel, by Indians that evening, and that they had taken Trump's wife and his son, a lad of nineteen years old, prisoners; but the woman escaped, though, upon her flying, she was closely pursued by one of the Indians (of which there were seven), that he threw his tomahawk at her, and cut her badly ill the neck, but 'tis hoped not dangerously. This murder happened in as great a thunderstorm as has happened for twenty years past: which extended itself over a great part of this and Northampton Counties--for I found much mischief done, as I came from Easton, Northampton County, to this place, the length of fifty two miles, the day before yesterday, and which I hear has broken down the dams of seven forges, and six gristmills, on Maxatany creek, chiefly in this county; the rest in Philadelphia County. I almost forgot to mention (but am so hurried just now, 'tis no wonder) that the Indians, after scalping Adam Trump, left a knife, and a halpert, or spear, fixed to a pole in his body."

 

Adam Trump was dead, his wife was badly wounded and his son, George, was a captive of the Indians who having stolen, a quantity of liquor out of the house, moved westward and arrived at a hill (today known as Hawk Mountain). The consumption of liquor was having its effect on the Indians, for they began to make much noise and dance around in the road. As they ascended the hill, things were in such a state that at an opportune time, George made his escape by running down the other side of the hill. [This writer is familiar with this stretch of road in its unimproved state and can appreciate the effort made by George in descending this water-soaked ground road in the dark of night; having descended the mountain, he immediately had the Schuylkill river to cross and then a great deal of travel in a very hilly countryside to get to his destination at Fort Lebanon.]

 

Captain Jacob Morgan, the commander of Fort Lebanon, which was located several miles west from where George Drumm made his escape, wrote in his daily journal for 24 June 1757: "Yesterday morning about 8 of the clock, the son of one Adam Drumm, (whom the Indians had killed the night before in Allemingle [sic] and took his son

 

 

 


11


 

 

 

captive) found an opportunity to make his escape and came to this Fort. He informed me that the Indians (8 in number) had got a quantity of liquor out of his father's house and came to a hill about 7 miles from this Fort, where they got to dancing, and made themselves drunk he took the opportunity and escaped to the Fort. An Indian followed him near a mile and a half whom our men tracked; so as soon as the young man came I sent out a party to the place where the man left them, but when they came there they only found an old pair of mogasins and a deer skin whom they had left, but the Indians were fled; they tract't them as far as they could but night coming, were obligated to return home. I have this day sent out a party to intercept them in the way to the gap of the second mountain. (where Schuylkill [this should read: Swatara Creek] comes through) being the place which I found they often retreat back; the men will range about 2 days."

 

George returned to his home and continued operation of the plantation; however, nothing further has been learned about his mother. On 16 October 1757, we find that George Trumm and Elisabeth Hem, single, witness the baptism of Elisabeth Scherff, daughter of Christoph and Christina Scherff, four years before the erection in 1760-61 of the first New Bethel (or Corner) Church in Albany Township.

 

Sometime in late 1759, George married Maria Catharina Strasser, daughter of Johann Nicolaus and Maria Catharine Strasser of Albany Township; also in 1759, we find George on the Albany Township tax list.

 

On the 17 July 1760, George Trumm and Maria Catharina witnessed the baptism of Maria Catharina Schwenck, daughter of Hans Nicolaus and Maria Barbara Schwenck. Also in 1760, during the construction of the New Bethel Church, George contributed 1 pound in cash money, 13 days of hand labor, and 3 days of hauling with a team of horses. George and Catharina's first child was born on 22 August 1760 and was baptized 5 weeks later on 18 September 1760, with the name of Johann Henrich. Elisabeth Strasser was one of the sponsors, though as Elisabeth was the name of both Catharine's mother and one of her sisters, which one served as sponsor is unknown.

 

Other children were Anna Maria, born 13 July 1763; Maria Catharina, born 19 March 1766; Eva Barbara, born 26 September 1767; Johan George, born 6 April 1773 Johannes, born 11 June 1778; and Charles born 1780.

 

The Drum family is unique in our family history for two reasons. First, a descendant of Adam Drum’s brother, Johann Simon Drum (8 Sep 1689 - ?), emigrated south from Pennsylvania and settled in Graysville, Monroe County, Ohio, the county of birth and the home for the first 22 years of my mother, Audra L. Young’s (1907-1990), life. Audra was not related to the Drum line but her father, William E. Young, did business with the Drum family at their store in Woodsfield, Ohio. An irony of the Drum family’s presence in Woodsfield is that Audra would one day marry into and become part of our Harrington family. This is a family relationship that she never knew. Second, the son

 


 


12

 

 


 

 

of Adam Drum who was murdered in 1757 by the Indians, George Adam Drum, was taken prisoner by the Indians but managed to escape. George’s granddaughter, Margaret Drum (1799-1867) subsequently married Joshua Valentine in Pickaway County, Ohio, and became the parent of Levi J. Valentine, father of Sarah Jane Valentine (1848-1933) and his 21 other children. Levi had 12 children with his first wife, Mary Bolinger, and 10 with his second wife, Emily Jane Walker. Sarah Jane Valentine was the partner in Kansas of, Charles William Harrington, - the two were my great grandparents. With that, we have completed the introduction of the six major family lines leading up to my grandfather, William Alvin Harrington. At this point let’s follow Sarah Jane Valentine to her meeting with Charles William Harrington in Kansas.

 

 

 

The Saga of Sarah Jane Valentine

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

We resume the story of Sarah Jane Valentine that we left briefly on page 9 for the introduction of the Drum family line and Margaret Drum, Sarah Jane Valentine’s grandmother. Joshua and Margaret Drum-Valentine’s had nine children; six were male. Sarah Jane Valentine’s parents were Levi J. Valentine (1824-1893), the son of Joshua and Margaret Drum-Valentine, and Mary Bolinger (about 1825-1867), Levi’s wife from the Benjamin and Elizabeth Leist-Bolinger family. The Valentine and Bolinger families were neighboring farmers in Washington Township, Pickaway County, Ohio. In those days of limited transportation almost all of the non-city dwellers were farmers or farm laborers and it was common that a mate would be selected from a family that lived nearby. That is how Levi J. Valentine and Mary Bolinger met and were married on 31 Jul 1845. Sarah Jane Valentine was born to Levi J. and Mary Bolinger-Valentine on 28 June 1848 as the 3rd child and first girl in their family that would eventually number 12 children.

 

In 1850 the U.S. Federal Census enumerated the young family on land that Levi had bought from his father-in-law, Benjamin Bolinger, in Adam Twp., Seneca County, Ohio. For Sarah Jane Valentine this would be the first move of many that would take her 18-years and across 5 states into Brown County, Kansas Territory and finally back to Pickaway County, Ohio. The Levi Valentine family would leave Pickaway County Ohio with 3 children and arrive in Kansas with 8 children, two being a pair of twins. An Outline Descendant list of the Valentine family can be found on page 276.

 

Levi and his family may have lived on the Seneca County, Ohio property for two or three years. But by 1854 they had moved on to Pike County, Illinois where four more of their children were born: George W., on 26 Feb. 1854; Almira about 1856; and twins Sylvanus and Sylvester on 5 Nov. 1857. In about 1858 the Valentine family made their move to Brown County, Kansas. At this point, national events began to play a major role in their lives. Kansas was still a Territory in 1860 moving toward statehood in January

 

1861. New states like Kansas entering the United States had the option of choosing if they would be a slave-state or free-state. With the Civil War at hand, the outside pressure from neighboring states such as Missouri was mounting for Kansas to elect to become a slave-state. Only 2 years earlier, John Brown, the abolitionist, had conducted armed insurrection in the Kansas Territory in an effort to overthrow slavery in the United States. Although John Brown had moved east with his insurrection, his legacy of killings continued, causing Kansas to become known as Bleeding Kansas. In the early 1860s the Kansas territory that the Valentine family had selected as their new home was politically an unstable territory going through troubled times.


 

13

 

 

 

Ironically, Kansas was also a major producer of food products during the Civil War. Kansas was the end of many of the cattle drives that provided food for the Union Army. Early in the 1860s the Union Army had cleared the Mississippi and Missouri rivers of Confederate control and they were being used as major Union shipping routes during the Civil War. With most of the Union Navy engaged in military operations against the South, much of the food and undoubtedly other materials were being transported by ships of foreign registry. This was likely why ships from Nova Scotia were operating on the Mississippi and Missouri Rivers that provided the opportunity for Charles William Harrington to visit Kansas on a cattle boat. Also, as previously noted on pages 6 and 7, Charles probably knew that he had two related families, Anna Eliza and Eliza Ann Harrington living in the Fort Leavenworth, Kansas area.

 

Sarah Jane Valentine had turned 17-years old the summer of 1865. It is likely that she had left her parents’ family to go to the community near Fort Leavenworth where there were plenty of jobs for pay and a more active social life . This seems to be a reasonable speculation considering that she became pregnant by Charles William Harrington (1844-1904) that year.

Such an event would seem unlikely if she were still living in Brown County, Kansas, which was far from the river where Charles, a sailor, would have been working. Years later, Sarah Jane told her son, William Alvin Harrington, that he had been born in Kickapoo, Kansas. The town of Kickapoo, Kansas was located about 2-miles north of Fort Leavenworth near the Missouri River. The town derives its name from the Kickapoo Indian tribe that in 2016 still has a reservation a few miles from Fort Leavenworth. Mary Bolinger-Valentine, Sarah Jane’s mother, became pregnant with her 12th and last child about a month before Sarah Jane’s son, William Alvin Harrington, was born. Sarah Jane’s mother, Mary Bolinger-Valentine, died in 1867 quite possibly as a consequence of child birth.

 

We can only guess at the events surrounding this tumultuous period for the Valentine family. The next event on the family time-line was the 21 May 1868 marriage of Sarah Jane’s father to Emily Jane Walker. In 1868 Emily was a young woman of about 28-years old, 15-years younger than Sarah Jane’s mother and 8-years older than Sarah Jane. Emily had been with the Valentine family since before 1860 but after 1850. Her role may have been to help Sarah Jane’s mother, Mary Bolinger-Valentine, care for the large and ever-growing Valentine family. Levi and Emily Jane Walker-Valentine’s first child, in their family of 10 children, was Henry C. Valentine (1868-1882). He was born in Liberty Township, Clay County, Missouri. This indicates that within a very few months following the death of his wife, Mary Bolinger-Valentine, Levi remarried and moved a few miles east, across the Missouri River, from Kansas to Missouri.

 

The details about what really happened in the Levi Valentine family in Kansas in the years following the Civil War are lost to history. The events in Kansas that followed the birth of Sarah Jane Valentine’s son, William Alvin Harrington (10 June 1866), the birth of her sister, Nora Ellen Valentine (22 February 1867), the death of Sarah Jane’s mother, Mary Bolinger (probably shortly after 22 February 1867) and events in Ohio that included the deaths of both grandmothers, Joshua’s wife, Margaret Drum-Valentine (12 Feb 1867) and Benjamin Bolinger’s wife, Elizabeth Leist-Bolinger (1 Feb 1868) must have been shattering to the orderly structure of all of the families involved. Levi was left with these losses and a house-full of children ranging from ages 20, Sarah Jane Valentine, to less than a year old, Nora Ellen Valentine. It appears however, that Levi’s guidance

 


 


14

 

 


 

 

was there to try to optimize the situation. My guess is that Levi may have suggested to Sarah Jane the possibility of her returning to Pickaway County, Ohio with her son, William Alvin Harrington, her new sister, Nora Ellen Valentine, and possibly her younger brother, George Valentine who was about 13 years old. Levi most likely would have contacted his father, Joshua Valentine, to explore the idea with him. Joshua apparently agreed because in the Federal Census of 1870 we find Sarah Valentine keeping house for William H. Anderson who had been reared by her grandparents, Joshua and Margaret Drum-Valentine. Joshua Valentine died on 1 June 1870 and the census for the area that included Joshua’s, Ben Bolinger’s, and William Anderson’s farms was enumerated on 3 June 1870, about the time of Joshua’s funeral.

 

Sarah Jane Valentine and her charges returned to Pickaway County, Ohio sometime between about March 1867 and late 1869. Considering the age of her son, William Alvin Harrington who was only 1-year old in the summer 1867, and her baby sister, Nora Ellen Valentine, who was only 2 or 3-months old, she most likely would have made the trip in the Summer of 1868 or, more likely, 1869. She would have likely traveled by train as the head of her group of four and could have lodged with her grandfather, Joshua Valentine. Her grandmother, Margaret Drum-Valentine, had died on 12 Feb 1867, just 10 days before her granddaughter, Nora Ellen Valentine, was born in Kansas.

 

By 1870, Sarah Jane Valentine was enumerated in the house of William H. Anderson that was near her grandfather, Joshua Valentine’s house. She probably arrived in time for Joshua Valentine to meet his great grandson, William Alvin Harrington; his granddaughter, Nora Ellen Valentine; and grandson, George W. Valentine. Joshua died 1 June 1870 at the age of 71-years.

 

William H. Anderson has been a very visible character in the Valentine saga but he has also been very hard for me to trace. He was born 17 March 1937 and first appears in the records in the household of Sara Jane Valentine’s grandparents, Joshua and Margaret Drum-Valentine, in the 1850 Federal Census for Pickaway County, Ohio. He may have been enumerated in Joshua and Margaret’s household in the 1840 census when he would have been 3-years old, but since that census only names the head of the household and the number the other household members, we cannot know for sure. Nevertheless, he is definitely named in the 1850 and 1860 censes as a member of Joshua’s household. As noted above, William Anderson, age 32, was enumerated in the 1870 Federal Census as the head of his own household that included Sarah Jane Valentine, age 22, and David Stout age 14. William Anderson’s enumeration in the 1870 U.S. Federal Census immediately follows that of Joshua Valentine.

 

I have speculated that William H. Anderson was the son of Elizabeth Valentine (1820-1889), daughter of Joshua and Margaret Drum-Valentine and an unknown Anderson. This speculation is based only on circumstantial evidence; there is no direct data to support it. Several Anderson families lived nearby, according to the 1830 Federal census, who could have fathered William in June of 1836 when Elizabeth Valentine was 16-years old. I have not been able to find any birth or parental records for William except for the fact that he was reared by Joshua Valentine from a young age. There are no records to suggest that William had been previously married. Also, in his will, William included Samuel Ressler, the son of Elizabeth Valentine. If this speculation is correct, William Anderson and Sarah Jane Valentine would have been 1st cousins. This could explain why a Pickaway County, Ohio application for a marriage license dated 9 October 1869 that bore the names of Sarah Jane Herrington and William H. Anderson was never used.

 


 

 


15

 

 

 

 


This date, 9 October 1869, could have been about the time that Sarah Jane might have come from Kansas to Pickaway County, Ohio but earlier in the summer. It could also explain why the actual marriage of William H. Anderson and Sarah Jane Valentine took place in Kenton, Kenton County, Kentucky on 4 November 1872, 3-years after the 9 October 1869 application was issued and after the death of their grandfather, Joshua Valentine.

William H. Anderson and Sarah Jane Valentine-Anderson never had children of their own. Sarah Jane reared her son, William Alvin Harrington, her sister, Nora E. Valentine, and her brother, George W. L. Valentine in the household of William H. Anderson. William Harrington, Nora E. Valentine, and George W. Valentine were 14, 13, and 26 years old respectively at the time of the 1880 Federal census. Additional details are available about the life of Sarah Jane Valentine Anderson in the notes for Sarah Jane Valentine in this book on page 313.

 

Nora E. Valentine married Charles P. Ramsey on 31 Dec 1889 in Pickaway County, Ohio when she was 22-years old. Sometime over the next 10 years, Nora and Charles Ramsey moved to Kansas near where several of Nora Valentine’s siblings remained. Charles died in 1924 in Independence, Missouri at the age of 60-years. Nora continued to live in Independence until her death in February of 1949 at the age of 82-years. She apparently never remarried and had no children.

 

George Washington L. Valentine married Sarah "Sallie" Elizabeth Stroop on 9 Jan 1881 in Pickaway County, Ohio. George and Sarah Valentine, also, returned to Kansas. Sallie died in 1903 and George died in 1932. The couple are known to have had at least 3 children. Their names are unknown.

William “Bill” Alvin Harrington grew up on his step-father, William H. Anderson’s farm in Washington Township, Pickaway County, Ohio. On 2 November 1890 Bill Harrington married Sarah Elizabeth Pence, daughter of Josiah and Sarah Jane Lockwood-Pence from Hocking County, Ohio. An Outline Descendant list of the Pence family can be found on page 395. Nine children including my father, Ira Edward Harrington, were born to my grandparents. Each of these children is described in the text of this book in some detail. All are deceased. Five of the nine children of William and Sarah Elizabeth Pence Harrington had a total of 19 offspring. Only one of the 19, Richard E. Harrington, the author of this book is still living.

 

Sarah Jane’s husband, William H. Anderson, was born 17 March 1837 and died 4 October 1906. William was 35-years and 8-months old when he and Sarah Jane Valentine married on 4 November 1872. Sarah Jane was 24-years and 5-months old, making William 11-years and 3-months her senior. In September (estimated), 1906, Sarah Jane and William Anderson went to Independence, Missouri where they visited with Sarah's sister, Nora E.

 

Valentine Ramsey. While there, on October 4, 1906, William H. Anderson died suddenly. He was 69-years and 7-months old. His body was embalmed in Independence, MO and transported back to Ohio. He arrived on Saturday evening and funeral services were held Sunday morning. He was buried at St. Paul's Church in Washington Township, Pickaway County, Ohio.

 

One of the 19 descendants of William Alvin Harrington was Ira Harrington’s first daughter and my half-sister, June Lucille Harrington. June was 2-weeks short of her 13th birthday when her great grandmother, Sarah Jane Valentine-Anderson, died on 15 May 1933. June had just completed the 7th grade of middle school and remembered Sarah Jane Valentine-Anderson well. June described Sarah Jane as a feisty little lady who was financially well off and traveled frequently, visiting members of her Valentine family in Kansas and her son in Circleville, Ohio. Census records indicate that after the death of her husband, William H. Anderson, on 4 October 1906, Sarah Jane continued to make

 


 


16

 

 

 

 


Circleville, Ohio her permanent home. Sometime before the 1930 Federal Census, Sarah Jane liquidated her Circleville assets which she donated to the Circleville, Ward 3, Home and Hospital on West Ohio Street, Circleville Township, Pickaway County, Ohio in exchange for her board and keep for the remainder of her life. She died just a month before her 85th birthday, apparently suffering from some degree of dementia. Her only son, William Alvin Harrington, would have been 67-years old at the time of her death. He also died at age 85-years old, just 2-months older than his mother. Sarah Jane Valentine-Anderson, our Pioneer great grandmother, is buried beside her husband of 34-years, William H. Anderson, in the Saint Pauls Evangelical Church Cemetery, Pickaway County, Ohio.

 

 

 

The Harrington Line in Nova Scotia

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Meanwhile in 1865 or 1866 Charles William Harrington returned to Nova Scotia, quite possibly on the same cattle boat on which he arrived in Kansas. On 23 Feb 1867 in Parrsboro, Nova Scotia, Charles William married Caroline Couch Willigar. Ironically, Charles and Caroline’s wedding date was one day after Sarah Jane Valentine’s mother gave birth to her 12th child, Nora Ellen Valentine. His marriage to Caroline Couch Willigar was 8-months after the birth of William Alvin Harrington to Sarah Jane Valentine.

Charles was a seaman his entire career. The few records that we have marking his mariner status, began with his trip to Kansas in 1865 where he met Sarah Jane Valentine and initiated our Ohio Harrington family. Records exist of his children’s marriages that show him as a seaman, sailor or mariner. The 1880 U.S. Federal Census reported that Charles William Harrington was being incarcerated in the Deer Island facility at Boston, Massachusetts for an unnamed offense. Charles would have been 35 years old at that time and was still listed as a sailor. It was not until sometime before the marriage of his daughter, Edith Harrington, to Mayford Phinney on 27 August 1903 that Charles became a Sea Captain. He died in 1904 so he did not enjoy his new rank for long.

 

Over the 24-years of Charles and Caroline’s marriage they had 11 children who in turn begat at least 41 grandchildren. All of the 11 children of Charles and Caroline and most of their 41 grandchildren were deceased by 2016, the year this book was published. Charles William Harrington died on 20 August 1904 at the fairly young age of 60-years. His wife, Caroline, lived another 21-years to the age of 75-years. An Outline Descendant list of the Charles William Harrington family can be found on page 122.

 

In the summer of 2013 my wife, Margaret Stasikowski, and I went to Nova Scotia in search of our Harrington family and their descendants. There we met many of the descendants of the 41 grandchildren of Charles and Caroline Harrington. Photos and information regarding some of these cousins are included in the album at the back of this book. We plan a return trip to Nova Scotia to expand our knowledge of our Harrington kin there and meet many more descendants of the Harrington clan. This is an ongoing project, however, that may require an update to this book in the future.

Pence Family

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

 


 


17

 

 

 


The last, but not the least of the 8 family lines of ancestors included in this book is the Pence family. There are many more than 8 family lines of ancestors that make up our Harrington family, of course. The number is certainly dozens, if not hundreds. But because of the way our European culture names people, the maiden name of the maternal member of a family frequently becomes lost to history within a couple, or so, generations. This is the main reason that family surnames of male member of the family, like Harrington, Valentine, Pence, etc. can be traced over many generations but maiden names frequently and all too easily become lost.

The first record that I have found of the Pence family in the Hocking Valley appears in a book titled “Hocking Valley, Ohio - together with sketches of its cities, villages and townships, educational, religious, civil, military, and political history, portraits of prominent persons, and biographies of representative citizens” [Wow! What a title!] published by the Chicago:

 

Inter-State Publishing Co., 1883. On page 814 of this volume, Christian Westenhaver, a resident of Maryland, is identified as the first permanent settler in what was to become Hocking and Vinton Counties. “Mr. Westenhaver settled on his place in March, 1798, and he was followed the next two months by John Pence and Conrad Brian, brothers-in-law, locating their families in a log cabin … John Pence took … eighty acres, since known as Braggtown …” Ohio did not become a state until 1803 and Hocking County, Ohio was established in 1818 so the Pence family line was among the pioneers that helped tame and settle what would eventually become what is now known as Ohio.

 

According to the book titled, “Hocking Valley, Ohio” [the one with the paragraph-long title] and the research of Richard Allen Pence (1932-2009), a self-proclaimed genealogist of his Pence ancestry, the Pence family had arrived in Hocking County, Ohio in the waning years of the 1790s. The early years of the 1800s saw new families move into the area that soon claimed the available real estate. Richard Allen Pence traced our Hocking County line back to Hans Martin Bentz (1631-1726). Of interest to me is the observation that Hans Martin was born exactly 300-years before my own birth year.

 

Beginning with Hans Martin Bentz, the Pence descendants continue as listed below. The first two in the list, Hans Martin and Johannes Bentz, did not immigrate to America but were born and died in Germany.

1.         Hans Martin Bentz (1631-1726) and wife, Helene Margarethe Kern (1644-1688)

 

2.         Johannes Bentz (1675-1746) and wife, Susannah ? (1680-1748)

 

3.         Johann Georg Bentz (1697-1778) and his wife, Anna Barbara Bullinger (1698- ?)

 

4.         Jacob Johann Ludwig Pence (1727-1778) and his wife, Barbara (unknown)

 

5.         George Frederic (Bens) Pence (1752-1835 and his wife, Mary (unknown surname)

 

6.         George Frederick Pence (1775-1840) and his wife, Mary Harp (1785-1840)

 

7.         Peter Pence (1816-1912) and his wife, Sarah Ann Hart (1814- ?)

 

8.         Josiah Pence (1846-1912) and his wife, Sarah Jane Lockwood (1850-1926)

 

9.         Sarah Elizabeth Pence (1872-1948) and her husband, William Alvin Harrington (1866-1951) For the record it should be noted that the identification of ancestors 1 thru 5 above come

from the data of Richard Allen Pence whose work has proven fairly reliable. I have researched and confirmed the data for ancestors 6 through 9, however. Additional information provided by Richard Allen Pence includes the following:

Johann Georg Bentz (number 3 in the above list), his wife and at least four of his sons, Ludwig or Lewis, Jacob, Adam, and Henry, emigrated from Germany arriving in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania on 15 September 1749 aboard the ship Phoenix. Our lineage continues through their son, Jacob Johann Ludwig Pence (1727-1778), who was born in

 


 


18

 

 

 

 


Germany before 14 December 1727, his date of baptism. Jacob received a grant of land of 262 acres from Lord Fairfax on 20 August 1866 near the Little Hawksbill Creek in Shenandoah County, Virginia which is now Page County. Jacob married Barbara (unknown surname) and had at least nine children, one of whom was our ancestor, George Frederic (Bens) Pence (1752-1835). George Frederic (Bens) Pence and his wife, Mary (unknown surname) were the parents of George Frederick Pence (1775-1840), my 3rd great grandfather.

 

Richard Allen Pence’s research was conducted in the late 1900s, a couple of decades before my own, when genealogical data was much more difficult to access. Richard Allen Pence observed that other members of the Pence family also arrived in the Hocking Valley area in the late 1790s. He states, “FREDERICK PENCE, possible brother to John, was in what is now Hocking County, Ohio in 1800 according to a county history. He perhaps is the Frederick Pence who married Mary Harp (or Hart) 1 Jun 1804 in Fairfield County, Ohio. John and Frederick Pence paid taxes in Berne Twp, Fairfield Co in 1806, and a Jacob Pence was a taxpayer in Greenfield Township, Fairfield County in 1806.” I have been able to confirm that George Frederick Pence (1775-1840) was my 3rd great grandfather, which appears to support Richard Allen Pence’s conclusion above.

 

Our Pence family lineage continues with Frederick Pence (1775-1840), also identified as George Frederick Pence, and his descendants. Frederick and his wife, Mary Harp (1785-1840), whom he had married on 1 June 1804 in Franklin County, Ohio, had at least 7 children: Martin, born in 1806; John, born in 1809; George, born about 1810; Peter born about 1816; (George)

 

Washington, born 20 July 1818; Elizabeth “Betsy,” born 21 April 1819; and Martha, born 1824. All of these children were born in Ohio.

Martin Pence (1806-1876) appears to have been, at least, a part-time farmer. By 1833, Martin, then 27 years old, began a career in the buying and selling of real estate – an early realtor without all the middle-men and big organizations of today’s real estate industry. By 1837 he had sold over a dozen properties, most of them within Washington Township, Hocking County, where he lived. His primary access to property that he offered for sale was “cancelled” or defaulted purchases from the Federal and State Land Offices. This was likely land that had been granted to military personnel who had fought in one of the early American wars but decided not to struggle with the hilly land found in the Hocking Valley.

 

In 1837 Martin’s younger brother and our ancestor, Peter Pence (1816-1912), then 21 years of age, entered the real estate business. These two sons of Frederick Pence, Martin and Peter, sold dozens of properties during their career. During this period they frequently involved other members of their family. An example was Josiah Pence (1846-1912), son of Peter Pence, both members of our Pence family line. On 13 December 1883, Josiah Pence purchased property from a citizen. A day later, on 14 December 1883, he re-sold the same property to his father, Peter Pence. This kind of transaction was repeated between other members of the Pence family with some frequency.

 

This process of buying cancelled or defaulted properties from the Federal and State Land Office was perfectly legal and above-board. It indicates that these Pence realtors had access to money enough to invest in the property. All of the sales may not have been harmonious, however. A record in Hocking County dated 24 Apr 1851 stated: "At my instance, an attachment was this day issued by Samuel Sultz, a justice of the peace of Washington Twp., Hocking County, Ohio, against the property and effects of Martin

 


 


19

 

 

 

 


Pence, an absconding debtor. Dated this 12th day of April A.D. 1851. Thomas Lytle." In 1850 Martin and his family were already in Jefferson Twp, Wells County, Indiana. They were also there in 1860, but enumerated under the name Pentz. They were in Bushnell Twp., Montcalm County, Michigan, in 1860.

 

Hocking County is a beautiful but hilly and somewhat hostile area. It is in the line that the pre-historic glacier of about 12,000 years ago, advanced before it stalled and melted. It lies south of Fairfield County and east of Pickaway County which are both flat, fertile farm lands, planed-off by the advancing glacier. Because of its hilly and rolling terrain, crop farming in Hocking County is difficult. Most farms were subsistence farms. Lumbering may have been an attraction to the earliest settlers but once the timber had been cut and lacking any other industry, most inhabitants could only subsistence-farm or move to more productive areas. Over a period of almost 100-years and 3 or 4 generations, “move” is what our Pence family chose to do.

 

The families of Peter Pence (my 2nd great grandfather) and his son Josiah Pence (my great grandfather) moved to Circleville, Ohio around the turn of the 20th century. Ohio Route #56 is almost a direct connecting route from Circleville to the area where these Pence families lived in Hocking County, Ohio, a distance of about 25 to 30 miles. It is not clear who moved first. Birth records of William Alvin Harrington’s children indicate that he had initially settled in Hocking County after his marriage to Sarah Elizabeth Pence on 2 November 1890. The birth place of their first two children is not known. But, the birthplace of their third child, Ruth Imo Harrington, on 27 July 1895 was Hocking County. Their 4th through 8th children were born in Pickaway County, Ohio. Census records show that the Josiah Pence and William Harrington families were in Circleville in the year 1900. Peter Pence’s death record indicates that he died in Circleville in 1912. In 1900 Josiah and Peter Pence would have been 54, and 84-years old, respectively.

 

Peter Pence’s families were not the only Pence families to abandon Hocking County at the turn of the century. Several of the families of Peter Pence’s brother, John Pence, also left Hocking County about the same time with most of them moving to Circleville, Ohio. The result was a virtual flood of Pence immigrants into Circleville in the opening years of the 20th century. One-hundred years later, the 2001 Circleville telephone book still recorded 8-Pence names. This probably means that there were about 16 direct Pence descendant families still living in Circleville, Ohio, if we assume that the Pence females were equal in number to the males. Many of the descendants of these Circleville-Pence families migrated to Columbus, Ohio over the years; many went elsewhere. One of the DNA matches to my DNA analysis was Rita Pence, a resident of Columbus, Ohio, with whom I have collaborated in my Pence-genealogy research.

 

A half-second Pence-cousin, once removed, named Emma Mae Pence-Hill was tragically removed from the Circleville-Pence population when on 9 October 1967 she was shot and killed by her husband, William Allen Hill. Emma Mae Pence had eight children with her murdering husband. After her death, her children who had not reached the age of personal accountability were made wards of the State of Ohio. Her husband was convicted and sentenced to prison for life.

 

Sarah Elizabeth Pence, daughter of Josiah and Sarah Jane Lockwood-Pence, was the author’s grandmother. Lizzie, as she preferred to be called, was born in Hocking County, Ohio on 29 April 1872 and moved to Pickaway County, Ohio after she married William Alvin Harrington on 02 Nov 1890. She died in Circleville, Ohio on 19 January 1948. Lizzie is further detailed with her husband on the pages below.


 

20


 

Descendants of Our Ohio Harrington Line

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

The section that follows begins with the couple whom we have identified as our focus couple, my grandparents, William Alvin and Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington. It then addresses all the known descendants of that couple who owe their origins to their Ohio, USA branch. Being part of the Ohio branch of Harrington descendants, I am most familiar with those relatives. I have tried to make this section as complete as possible in terms of including all known members of William and Sarah Elizabeth Harrington descendants. Unfortunately, there are some whom I did not know. As a result, the details about these people are uneven in comparison to those I knew well. In particular, I regret the brief discussion of many of the very recent additions. My hope is that some family historians will craft books of their own to supplement this offering.

 

So, let’s begin with the couple whom we have identified as our focus couple, William Alvin and Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington. Where it appears that people have been skipped, it is most likely because I had no information about them.

 

William Alvin Harrington (10 June 1866 - 24 Jul 1951)                            Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

William (Bill) Alvin Harrington was the son of Sarah Jane Valentine and Charles William Herrington. The earlier spellings of the Harrington surname included Herington, Herrington and all three are found in the historical records. Bill Alvin's children used "Harrington," so, that is the spelling that will be used here.

Little is known of Bill Alvin Harrington's youth and early family life. He claimed that he was born in Kickapoo, Kansas, a claim that almost certainly would have been based on information that he received from his mother. But the period between his birth on 10 June 1866 and the 1880 Federal Census when he appears as a 14-year-old son in the William H. and Sarah Jane Valentine-Anderson household of his mother is a blank. His whereabouts during this period can be assumed from the whereabouts of his mother, Sarah Jane Valentine, beginning on page 15.

 

It is not known whether Bill Harrington finished high school. It is doubtful that he did although he was literate in reading, writing and arithmetic. It was common practice in American farming families of the period that children would drop out of school after their 6th or 8th grade of school to work on the farm. This is likely what William Alvin Harrington did. However, the 1880 U.S. Federal Census shows him still in school. So, he at least went as far as the 8th grade. At the age of 24 years Bill married Sarah Elizabeth Pence on November 2, 1890 in

 

Hocking County, Ohio. Eleven months and a few days later, Bill and Lizzie had their first of nine children. The baby was named Nellie Mae Harrington and would be the first of 4-girls and 5-boys. All 9-children lived to adulthood and except for Easter Marie Harrington-Thompson who died at the age of 28, all lived relatively long lives.

 

Bill and Lizzie's children, as adults, enjoyed each other's company and would get together fairly frequently to play cards, share meals, cook sweetcorn, make ice cream, drink beer, and tell stories of their life experiences. Grandpa Bill was a frequent participant in these get-togethers. He always came by himself - Lizzie never joined in except when someone visited her house. Bill did not contribute much to the story-telling but was a frequent subject of some of the stories. His children agreed that he was a

 


 


21

 

 

 


no-nonsense, authoritarian parent and was quite capable of backing up his authority with corporal punishment, if needed. Each of his progeny had tales to tell of his discipline. My father, Ira, once told of coaxing his dad into sparing with him using boxing gloves. Ira was of an age that he was pretty sure that he could whip his dad in a boxing match. During the course of the match, Ira landed a solid blow on his dad's nose. The result was that it made his dad angry and he was going to take off the gloves and give Ira a good thrashing. But the boxing gloves were laced-on and he could not use his hand to grab and hold Ira. His solution was to put his gloved hand between his knees and rip the glove off tearing the boxing gloves and breaking the lacings in the process. While his dad was freeing himself of the gloves, Ira climbed the fence and escaped. Bill recovered from his sore nose and hot temper and reestablished his composure before Ira could return home.

 

Throughout his life, Bill would collect his weekly pay and on his way home from work, go to the store and buy the groceries. Lizzie seldom went to the store or handled money. One can speculate that there was some conversation with his wife as to what to buy, but he otherwise controlled the menu for the table.

Bill Alvin Harrington was a laborer. Census records list him as initially being a farmer, farm laborer, and general laborer. He worked in construction, poured and finished concrete, built fences, worked at the canning factory, worked on truck farms and about anything that would earn a few dollars. He was a hard worker giving full value for his pay. He finished his career as a janitor, laborer and handy man working many years for the Ohio Electric Power and Lighting Company just south of Columbus, Ohio. He finally retired at the age of 72 with a pension from that Company. The Ohio Electric Power and Lighting Company is still an operating plant of the American Electric Power Company (AEP).

 

Bill was well liked by all who knew him. Unlike his wife who was usually secluded and largely antisocial, Bill was forthcoming and pleasant. He loved to play cards and would seldom pass up a game. He liked to gamble at cards but never for high stakes. Usually he played for a nickel or dime; a quarter a hand was about his limit.

John Greene, Jr. son of John and Esther Mae Eblin-Greene and Grandpa Bill's great grandson recalls: "When we lived on the south end of Frankin County in old Marion Township from 1941 to 1949 grandfather Bill Harrington would come to visit us. He would ride the Greyhound bus from Circleville to the south side of Columbus. He would then walk the short distance from High Street to our house (about a 1/4 mile). That weekend there wasn't much sleeping. It was an all-night poker party. I remember his pointer finger had a heavy deformed finger nail, and he would thump it on the table when he wanted to make a point. When he came, he always brought along his bottle of Four Roses."

 

Bill Harrington’s deformed fingernail was on the index finger of his right hand. It was the result of an auto-accident. He was driving a model-A Ford and bumped into the back of a similar vehicle. Neither car was damaged but the front-bumper of Bill's car went over the back-bumper of the other car. He got hold of the bumper of his car and raised it a little and it slid off. The tip of his finger was between the sliding bumpers and it sheared off the end of his finger. It just cut off the tip leaving the 'root' of the nail so that it continued to grow but as a thick, deformed nail that he kept well-trimmed to look a bit like a talon of a bird.

 

Grandpa Bill Harrington lived about a dozen years after he retired at the age of 72. At 72 he was pretty well worn out but made good use of his retired years.

 


 


22

 

 

 


He liked to fish and, of course, play cards. The 1940 Federal Census enumerated Bill and his wife, Lizzie, living with their son, Roy and Kathryn Payne-Harrington. After Lizzie moved out of their home, Bill continued to make his residence with his son, Roy and Kathryn Harrington, who lived on Main Street on the far-east side of Circleville. He no longer drove a car. One of his remaining pleasures was to walk the full length of Main Street to the far-west side of Circleville - a distance of about a mile. The attraction on West Main Street was a little bar named "Mary's." It was run by the owner whose name was Mary. Weather-permitting, Grandpa Bill would make the walk once a day. At Mary's he was well known. He knew and liked all the patrons - it was a comfortable, fun place to be and he felt at home. Moreover, Mary was a good friend and although she was a couple of decades younger than Bill, she gave him a lot of attention calling him her 'boyfriend' and other endearing names. Bill enjoyed the attention. Undoubtedly, it was attention that he had not received for a long, long time at home, if ever. It filled a need of being liked and needed. Bill, at the age of about 80-years, misread Mary's interest and decided to propose marriage to her. He bought her a nice engagement ring and prepared to make his 2nd proposal of marriage in his life. As his plan matured, he took some of his children into his confidence. Their vision and advice was more conservative than Bill's had become and they advised him against his plan. Being the stubborn old cuss that he was, he did not take their advice and proceeded with his proposal. The discussions with his kids and their advice, however, probably helped soften the blow when Mary rejected his proposal of marriage. Bill continued his daily walk, though. Perhaps he found the beer was as important as Mary.

 

Grandpa Bill returned from his daily walk about 3:00 p.m. on July 24, 1951. He always took his supper with Roy and Kathryn and would usually help Kathryn prepare it if he could. On this day, he told Kathryn that he was not feeling good and thought he would lie down on his bed and rest a little. When Kathryn went to call him for dinner she found him dead. At the age of 85, Grandpa Bill had finally worn out.

 

William Alvin Harrington never owned his own home. He always rented and was therefore relatively mobile. In the course of his life he moved many times remaining in the same house just a few years.

The author’s mother, Audra L. Young Harrington, frequently remarked how much she liked her father-in-law, Bill Alvin Harrington. Audra first met her future father-in-law when he was about 62-years old. Audra was taken aback by the brash, boisterous, and unpolished nature of some of his children, but, in contrast the man she knew as her father-in-law, Bill Harrington, was a soft-spoken, real gentleman. The author, Audra’s son, first remembers his grandfather a decade or so later and confirms Audra’s description of him.

 

Sarah Elizabeth Pence (29 Apr 1872 - 19 Jan 1948)                                           Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Sarah Elizabeth Pence apparently did not prefer to be called by her first name, Sarah. In almost every record where she could control her preferred name such as the U.S. Federal Census records, she went by her middle name, Elizabeth, or more commonly Lizzie or Eliza. This could have been a preference developed in childhood to avoid conflicting with her mother whose name was Sarah Jane Lockwood-Pence.

 

Lizzie was a nice but private person who did not socialize much with others. She rarely hosted events in her home, even with members of her own family. She was very much the opposite of her husband, Bill Harrington, who was social and friendly. During her entire life, except for the last 3 or 4-years, Lizzie had the burden of caring for

 


 


23

 

 

 


children. As her own children left the nest it was almost immediately filled by grandchildren. Lizzie spent her entire life in a hand-to-mouth economic environment that was near poverty which also probably discouraged her socially. Yet, she was kind. I recall visiting her at Christmas time and she always gave her grandchildren a white paper bag of hard-tack candy and an orange. I recall spending the night at her house while our parents went to a late night social event. She pushed two comfortable chairs together to make a bed for my brother, Bill, who was about 3-years old, while I slept on a couch. Bill was not ready to go to bed but Lizzie insisted telling him that if he didn’t be good, the Boogy Man would get him. Unconvinced, Bill retorted that the Boogy Man would get her which made Lizzie smile. Years later, my half-sister, June Lucille Harrington, who was being reared by her grandparents remarked, that was one of the few times that she ever saw our grandmother smile.

 

Lizzie was fairly religious and belonged to one of the more liberal Christian churches in Circleville that included some physical participation by the congregation in their services such as shouting and occasional marching about if the spirit struck them. Toward the end of her life, she asserted that she saw snakes crawling around the chair where her husband sat. About 3-years before she died, she moved out from her home and rented a place of her own. She died on 19 January 1948 and was buried in Hitler Cemetery located about 3-miles from Circleville.

 

Nellie Mae Harrington (1892-1975)                                                     Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ William Ottis Zwicker (1884-1946)

 

Nellie Mae Harrington (1891-1975) was the first child to William “Bill” Alvin and Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington. Her marriage application states that she was born in Circleville Ohio. Nell was a hard, independent lady with fixed ideas that favored her and sometimes offended others. In many ways she had a similar personality to her mother, Lizzie, except that it was more aggressive. Being the oldest child in a family that grew rapidly, she had a major role in raising her younger siblings. A family story was told that involved her younger brother, Ira, my father. When she was about 12 years old, her mother was working as a gleaner in a bean or pea field. Nellie was charged with keeping an eye on her siblings and possibly also helping with the gleaning. Ira was approaching 2-years old and wondered onto the nearby rail road track that bounded one side of the field. He was rescued from being run over by a brakeman who made his way to the cow-catcher and snatching him a second before the train hit him. This was one of the “near miss” events for Ira that would have drastically changed the nature of this book. Nellie escaped the family early and married young. Her marriage ended in divorce and there is no evidence that I could find that she ever married again.

 

Family lore was that Nellie Mae Harrington never married. She was referred to as the old-maid of the family. But, from the Pickaway County, Ohio, Marriage Book number 14, page 459 – I found a marriage on 20 November 1909 of Nellie Mae Harrington, born 14 October 1891 in Circleville, Pickaway County, Ohio, to, William Ottis Zwicker, born 22 February 1884 in Circleville, Pickaway County, Ohio. Their marriage was performed by D.H. Jemison, pastor of the M.E. Church, in Circleville, Ohio. Nellie Mae Harrington’s gave her residence as Circleville, Pickaway County, Ohio. Her occupation was left blank. Her father was William Harrington and her mother was Sarah Pence. William Ottis Zwicker’s residence was Circleville, Ohio. His occupation was carpet weaver. His father was George Zwicker and his mother was Fannie Francis.

 


 


24

 

 

 


Both William and Nellie claimed that they had not been previously married.

 

My earliest recollection of Nell was when she was about 55-years old. She was a woman of average build, perhaps 5’-6” tall, slim, weighing perhaps 120 pounds, red thinning hair, and almost always well dressed. She was independent and somewhat arrogant. In retrospect she may have suffered from an inferiority or insecurity complex that she tried to hide.

Nellie lived and worked in Columbus, Ohio for much of her life. Early-on she lived with one or more of her siblings who had also moved to Columbus to work. By the time I knew her, she visited other members of the family, infrequently. When she did, she made clear that she did not like children, an impression that no-doubt colored my opinion of her, even yet, since I was a child when most of my memories of her were formed.

 

Most of the stories told about Nellie usually reflect her controlling and frequently disagreeable personality. In about the 1960s, her younger brother, Roy William Harrington, divorced his wife, Kathryn and moved into his own apartment in Circleville. Nell moved into his apartment with his permission. Shortly after moving-in, she took charge of the apartment which included re-arranged Roy’s furniture to her liking. This was typical of Nell but was not an arrangement that Roy could approve. Roy soon asked her to leave.

 

The latter years of her life were spent in Circleville, the town of her birth. There she was a resident in an assisted living facility and later a nursing home not far from where Ira’s son and my brother, William “Bill” Young Harrington, lived. Bill’s wife had baked a pie and had their son, also named William “Billy” Young Harrington, Jr., deliver a piece to Nellie. Nellie accepted the offering without a “Thank You.” Instead, she sent the message back to Bill, “Next time don’t send your brat. Bring it yourself.” Perhaps the message got garbled by the carrier, but it was typical of Nellie.

 

Charles Ray Harrington (1893-1966)                                                 Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+                 Florence Prichard Still-born child

+                 Bertha (Betty) Arbelle Kimmerling (1891-?)

 

+                 Esther Spetnagle

 

+                 Grace Harlor

 

Charles Raymond (Ray) Harrington (1893-1966) was the second child and the oldest son of William (Bill) Alvin and Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington. He was short, about 5’-5” and when I knew him at about age 53 he was bald except for a rim of remaining hair. He was a little over-weight; perhaps 220-230 pounds. Ray was one of only three children of Bill and Lizzie Harrington who owned real estate property. The other two children to own real estate were my father, Ira, and his youngest brother, Fred Harrington. I recall visiting Ray with my dad, Ira, once when Ray lived in Canal Winchester, Ohio. He lived in a cute single-story house with a well-manicured lawn. I believe that by then his wife was Grace Harlor, a school teacher. Grace would have been Ray’s 4th wife. Ray had no living children. His 1st wife, Florence Prichard, had a stillborn child, the only child that Ray was known to have sired.

 

From the Pickaway County, Ohio, Marriage Book number 15, page 415 – I found a Marriage on 25 November 1914 of Charles Ray Harrington, born 17 September 1892 in Pickaway County, Ohio, to, Bertha A. Kemmerling, born 6 December 1891 in Ashville, Pickaway County, Ohio. Their marriage was performed by Rev. P.E.

 


 


25

 

 

 


Wright, Ashville, Ohio; no church affiliation was given. Bertha A. Kemmerling’s residence was Ashville, Pickaway County, Ohio. Her occupation was Telephone Operator. Her father was William Kemmerling and her mother was Ella Cupper. Charles Ray Harrington’s residence was Circleville, Ohio. His occupation was laborer. His father was William Harrington and his mother was Lizzie Pence. Both Charles and Bertha claimed that they had not been previously married.

Ray had only a limited education, perhaps 8th grade, and had chosen to go into the automobile maintenance business as a mechanic working at a garage. Unlike most of his Harrington siblings, Ray apparently discovered early in life that cultivating manners and some culture would get him ahead in life faster than the loud, boisterous personality of some of his younger siblings. As he grew older, his personality began to pay off in his career. He moved from the dirty-fingernail work of the mechanic to the parts department and eventually to a mid-level management position. Ray even passed the gentleman-test of my mother, Audra L. Young-Harrington, who had a good feel for such things and generally did not like the manners of some of the Harrington family.

 

Ray liked his beer. However, I have never seen him drunk or boisterous. Ira told me the story of going somewhere with Ray in Ira’s 1920-ish model Ford. Ira was driving. Ray was his passenger. Both had been drinking and Ray had fixed himself a mixed drink for the road. Ray was holding his drink by the upper lip of the glass but between his knees and as they drove along, Ray went to sleep. They drove for several miles over rough roads with Ray holding his drink near the top of the glass suspending the weight of the glass below his fingers. His hand formed a gimbal that minimized the movement of the glass and contents so it did not spill a drop. Upon arriving at their destination, Ira stopped the car while Ray slept on. Ira called to Ray that they had arrived, upon which Ray awoke, startled and jumped; spilling the full contents of the drink in his lap.

 

Ray lived to be 72–years old. He died on 16 Mar 1966, just 3-months and 4-days short of the 100th birthday of his father. Ray was married to Grace Harlor when he died. He is buried in Union Grove Cemetery Canal Winchester, Franklin County, Ohio.

 

Ruth Imo Harrington (27 Jul 1895- 17 Sep 1965)                                      Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+                 George Henry Purcell (25 Dec 1892- 06 Feb 1968)

                        George William Purcell (07 Apr 1912- 31 Jul 2002)

Nancy Jean Purcell (15 Jul 1939 – living)

 

+                 Hurshel Scott Heeter (28 Jul 1896- 28 Feb 1932)

 

+                 Carlton Pearl Pennell (07 Jun 1892- 01 Mar 1951)

                        Roger Carlton Pennell (02 Mar 1930- 10 Dec 1981)

John Carlton Pennell (1949- ?)

Deborah Jo Pennell (06 Oct 1950- ?)

Norma J. Pennell (27 Dec 1952- ?)

David E. Pennell (26 Dec 1957- ?)

Ruth Ann Pennell (30 Apr 1964- ?)

William Pennell (unknown-- ?)

+                 Sterling Umphenour (Aug 1898-Dec 1976)

 


 

 

 


26

 

 

 


Ruth Imo Harrington (1895-1965) was the third sibling in Bill and Lizzie Pence-Harrington’s family. She was the opposite from her sister Nellie. She was short, personable, congenial, slightly plump but a good figure for her age. She was a people-person and judging from her looks when I first knew her at about age 45-years, she must have been a beautiful younger woman. She had a good work ethic and was working as a housekeeper for a family when she was 15-years old.

Ruth first married George Henry Purcell (1892-1968) on 5 December 1911 and had her oldest son, George William Purcell, who became a local radio star. On the Marriage License Application for George H. Purcell and Ruth Harrington, Ruth gave Hocking Co. Ohio as her place of birth. I was able to confirm Hocking County, Ohio as her place of birth from the birth record book in the Hocking County.

 

Her second marriage to Hurshel Scott Heeter dated 3 February 1918 lasted only a few years – perhaps about 3-years. She was still married to Heeter on January 1920 when the U.S. Federal Census was taken. This census showed that Hurshel Heeter was a farm laborer who had a 7-year old son. By 1922, Ruth was living in Columbus, Ohio sharing an apartment with her siblings, Nellie and Ira Harrington. Interestingly, on the Marriage License Application for Hurshel S. Heeter and Ruth Harrington-Purcell (03 Feb 1918), Ruth gave Vinton Co. Ohio as her place of birth. However, the Hocking County birth records confirm that her birth was in Hocking County. It is not so important that she gave her place of birth as Hocking County on her first marriage application and Vinton County on her second marriage application since these are neighboring counties. It is important that her place of birth was confirmed as Hocking County because it helps date when her parents moved from the Hocking Valley to Pickaway County, Ohio because their next child, Viola Grace Harrington was born in Pickaway County on 29 Aug 1897. So they must have moved between 1895 and 1897. I have chosen to date the move about 1896.

 

Ruth’s third marriage was to Carlton Pennell on 05 Apr 1924 with whom she had her second and last son, Roger Carlton Pennell. Carlton was 2-years and 10-months Ruth’s senior. He was a plumber who owned his own plumbing company. Ruth assisted with the management of the company’s accounts. His company was one of the many businesses that failed during the Great Depression.

 

In early 1932, in the depths of the Great Depression, Ruth and her family, and Ira and his new wife, Audra Young Harrington and their new son, Richard Harrington, headed for Florida. Their plan was to build a fishing boat, fish, and sell their catch to the food market. They figured that the food market would somehow be immune from the national depression that gripped the economy. Their plan worked reasonably well except for being able to sell their catch to the food market. They soon discovered that the price being paid for fish was so low that it would not pay for the price of fuel for their fishing boat.

 

Concern over the economics of the venture was soon overtaken by the sudden death of Easter Marie Harrington-Thompson on 25 July 1932. This was an unexpected shock to Ira and Ruth since Easter was their baby sister. The Ira Harrington family drove back to Ohio for Easter’s funeral in a marathon, non-stop except to refuel, run of 21-hours. Following the funeral, the Ira Harrington family remained in Ohio. Ruth and Carlton’s marriage ended after 26-years with the death of Carlton who succumbed to cancer on 01 March of 1951.

 

After 10-years as a widow, Ruth's fourth and final marriage was to Sterling Umphenour in 1961, a retired Army Officer listed as a Lieutenant.

 


 

 


27

 

 

 


Their marriage lasted four and a half years and was ended by Ruth’s death at the age of 70-years on 17 September 1965. She is buried in Alexandria National Cemetery, Louisiana.

 

George William Purcell (07 Apr 1912 - 31 Jul 2002)                                 Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

George William Pence was the son of George Henry Purcell (25 Dec 1892 - 06 Feb 1968) and Ruth Imo Harrington-Purcell who had married on 05 Dec 1911 in Circleville, Ohio. George William Purcell's daughter, Nancy Jean Purcell-Griffin-Howard, wrote that George rode a freight train to California when he was in his teens. He was part of the Carlton, Ruth and Rodger Pennell family who moved to Florida in early 1932 to start an aborted fishing business. Later, (sometime after 1932) he started singing on the radio in Columbus, Ohio. This was about the same time that Bing Crosby began his radio career. As a singer, George went from 1-night-a-week appearances to full week appearances. Nancy wrote that he was a handsome, curly haired singer with a big ego. George also became a champion heavy weight boxer in Columbus, Ohio. George married Wilma Ann Maurer (12 Sep 1912 - 21 Nov 1997) on 09 Jun 1934 and their daughter, Nancy Jean Purcell was born on 15 Jul 1939. Later, he became a master plumber and had his own plumbing shop.

 

On 5 January 1942, Nancy's grandfather, Ferdinand Maurer (10 Mar 1872 - 05 Jan 1942), died and her family moved to Dover, Ohio to take care of her grandmother and the farm. They remained on the family farm until Nancy's grandmother, Pearl Florence Hawk-Maurer died on 27 August 1949. George had been a heavy smoker and quit but suffered from bronchitis every winter. After Pearl's death, the family moved to Phoenix, Arizona for her father’s health. Their stayed in Phoenix was about 2-years before they moved on to El Cajon, California where George became head of maintenance for the 11th Naval District. Wilma played piano for Sunday School at the Seventh Day Adventist Church where George became head Deacon. George and Wilma lived in El Cajon, California until they both died.

 

Although I had lived with George and his family for a few months in Florida, during the formation of the fishing business during the depression, I was too young to remember him. I visited and talked with George Purcell on 5 May 2000. His wife, Wilma, had died two and a half earlier. He was 88 years old and lived by himself in a trailer court. He seemed to be very sharp, although he had a little difficulty remembering the names of the Pence family. He verified information provided by June Harrington-Franklin-Walters that one of Grandma, Sarah Elizabeth Pence Harrington's, brothers lived in Valporaso, Indiana. A couple of years later, George passed away on 31 Jul 2002.

 

Nancy Jean Purcell (15 Jul 1939 - living)                                                   Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Larry Lee Griffin (27 Apr 1936 - 16 Apr 2004)

Rebecca Lee Griffin (27 Jan 1959 – living) +

Rob ? Dahlan (? - ?) deceased

Krista Jean Dahlan (23 Jan 1989 – living) (twin*)

 

+ Joshua David Martinez (7 Nov 1986 – living)

 

Kierra Jean Martinez (21 June 2010 – living)

Khloe Ann Martinez (6 Oct 2011 – living)

Griffin Howard Martinez (25 Feb 2016

 


 


28

 

 

 


Candice Deserah Dahlan (23 Jan 1989 – living) (twin*)

 

+ Damien Baldrich (? - ?)

 

Lillian Belle Baldrich (24 Aug 2006 – living)

+ Garret Eugene Maxwell (7 Nov 1986 – living)

Jackson Rae Maxwell (20 Sep 2010 – living)

 

Deserah Louise Maxwell (15 Apr 2016 – living) +

Thomas Scott Neal (? - ?)

Thomas Nathan Neal (29 July 1986 – living)

Melissa ? (29 July 1984 – living)

Alyssa Nicole Cook (19 Nov 2000 - living)

 

Thomas James Neal (25 Aug 2013 - living)

 

Emilee Elizabeth Neal (25 Dec 2014 - living)

James William Griffin (29 Jul 1961 – living)

+ Mary Elizabeth Tompkins (? – living)

 

Seth Micheal Tompkins (7 June 1989 – living)

 

+ Zoey Isabel ? (4 Feb 1994 - living)

 

Sterling Micheal Tompkins (15 Mar 2012 – living)

Melony Louise Tompkins (? – living)

William “Billy” Charles Tompkins (? – living)

+ Andrea "Drea" ? ? (24 Sept 1982 – living)

 

Kimber Elise Tompkins (10 Sept 2013 – living)

Barrett William Tompkins (04 May 2015 – living)

Christopher James Griffin (? – living)

Anthony “Tony” James Lee Griffin (? – living)

Rachel Jean Griffin (08 May 1961 – living)

 

+                 David ? Haston (13 April 1956 – living)

 

+                 Benjamin Martin Howard (22 Jul 1930 - living)

 

Nancy Jean Purcell was the only child of George and Wilma Ann Maurer-Purcell. In high school, Nancy was a model for a store. By about 1951 she had moved to California with her parents. On 05 Oct 1957 at the age of 18-years and 4-months Nancy married Larry Lee Griffin, a policeman. The couple had three children and grandchildren as listed above. Nancy’s children were Rebecca (Becky) Lee Griffin-Neal, an X-ray technician; James William Griffin, a nurse; and Rachel Jean Griffin, a payroll clerk. Jim located in Idaho north of Lake Coeur d'Alene. Rachel never had children.

 

Nancy earned her master’s degree and was an elementary school teacher for 27 years. She was active in her United Methodist Church. She sang in the First Methodist Church choirs for 10 years.

On 28 Dec 1985 Nancy married Benjamin Martin Howard (22 Jul 1930 - living), her current husband. Ben served in the U.S. Navy in the Korean War - 1950. He has two master’s degrees; one in Education and one in Industrial Technology. He worked overseas for General Atomics for the peaceful use of atomic energy. He also acted in Hollywood for a year. Ben completed his varied career by teaching high school for 30-years. Nancy and Ben have traveled to Europe 9 times. They cruised to Mexico and Hawaii with friends. On their 21st anniversary they took a 3-week cruise to Florida, Portugal, Bermuda, Ireland, France and London, England.

 


 


29

 

 

 


They travel to visit their descendants, see new great grandchildren and attend weddings.

 

Roger Carlton Pennell (02 Mar 1930 - 10 Dec 1981)                                 Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Bonnie Louise Chrysler (11 July 1929 – 02 June 1992)

John Carlton Pennell (20 Jan 1949 – unknown)

+ Kathleen Edith McHarry (1947 - unknown)

Roger Carlton Pennell (1975 - unknown)

+ Wetonia Ann Boehringer (21 Mar 1976 - unk)

Madison Grace Pennell (2000-living)

Guage Carlton Pennell (2003-living)

Mathew J. Pennell (1977 - unknown)

 

Deborah Jo Pennell (06 Oct 1950 – unknown)

Norma J. Pennell (27 Dec 1952 – unknown)

   + David T. Gibson (about 1950-?)

 

+ unknown spouse (unknown-?)

 

+ Michael A. Eisel (about 1951-?)

 

Minor Child (no further information)

David E. Pennell (26 Dec 1957 – unknown)

+ Belinda R. Angles (unknown- ?)

 

Ruth Ann Pennell (30 Apr 1964 – unknown)

 

William Pennell (unknown- ?)

 

+ Pat (unknown- ?)

 

Roger Carlton Pennell was the only child in the family of Ruth Imo Harrington-Purcell-Pennell. He was Ruth’s second child, the first being George William Purcell. Roger was about 1-year and 10 months old when the Carlton Pennell and Ira Harrington families went to Florida to start a fishing business as a hedge to the worsening Great Depression of the late 1920s and 1930s. That effort was short-lived due to the death of Ira and Ruth’s sister, Easter Marie Harrington-Thompson on 25 July 1932. After Easter’s funeral, with Ira’s wife, Audra Lavada Young-Harrington, pregnant with my brother, William Young Harrington, both families went their separate ways. I saw the Carlton and Ruth Pennell family only sporadically over the following years on family visits. After Roger and I graduated from high school, I saw them not at all.

 

I recall one visit by the Pennell family to our house in about 1946 that could well be the last time I saw Roger. At that time I was the proud owner of a single-cylinder, Maytag gasoline engine that had been the power source for my mother’s washing machine before we had electricity. Roger wanted the motor and I wanted the crystal-set radio that he had. We traded and were both happy.

 

On 9 July 1948 Roger enlisted in the Army and was released a year later on 18 Oct 1949. Roger married Bonnie Louise Chrysler (11 Jul 1929 - 02 Jun 1992) of Columbus, Ohio about 1948 and had 6 children over the next 14 years. Roger became a welder and lived in Columbus, Ohio most of his life. He eventually moved to near Lancaster, Ohio. On 10 Dec 1981 he died of a stroke at the Mount Carmel East Hospital in Columbus, Ohio. Roger’s cousin, June Harrington-Franklin-Walters, related the following story of Roger’s death: "Roger came home from work one day [09 December 1981] and asked his wife how long it would be before supper. She told him, "Oh, about an hour."

 


 


30

 

 

 


He said he thought he would take a nap and laid down on the couch. His wife came to wake him for supper and found him unconscious. He died of a stroke." [The records indicate that Roger had a stroke on 9 December 1981 and died the next day, 10 December 1981, in Mt. Carmel East Hospital, Columbus.]

 

From the obituary of Roger Carlton Pennell, I have a complete listing of his children. His children and a couple of his grandchildren are listed above. However, I have been unable to find any of Roger and Bonnie’s children or get any more information about his family.

 

Viola “Olie” Grace Harrington (29 Aug 1897-12 Feb 1996)                      Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ William Allen Eblin (17 Apr 1894-02 Sep 1948)

 

George William Eblin (08 Apr 1914-06 Dec 1980)

 

Leonard Leroy Eblin (08 May 1915-03 May 2002)

 

Esther Mae Eblin (17 Apr 1917-02 May 2001)

 

Roy Edward Eblin (13 May 1919-26 Jun 1981)

 

Viola “Olie” Grace Harrington was the fourth of William (Bill) Alvin and Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington’s children. She was born on 29 August 1897 and went by her nickname, Olie. Olie holds the record in the Harrington family for having lived so long. She was 98 and one-half years old when she died on 12 February 1996. I did not know Olie or her husband, William Allen Eblin. Of her children, I only met Leonard once in his barber shop in the 1970s and interviewed him for this book in the late 1990s. I also interviewed Olie’s daughter, Esther Mae Eblin-Greene, in the late 1990s.

 

I recall my dad, Ira Harrington, taking my brother, William “Bill” Young Harrington, and me, Richard “Dick” Edward Harrington, to the Circleville Ice Plant to buy ice, in the mid-1930s. On the way, we stopped to visit his sister, Olie Harrington-Eblin, at her home. Bill and Olie Harrington-Eblin lived on the road approaching the ice house that was located close to and west of Circleville, Ohio. It was a short visit. About all that I remember of the visit was that there were several older children at their house who, in retrospect, were probably Olie and Bill Eblin’s children listed above.

 

Olie (Viola Grace) Harrington-Eblin and Bill (William Allen) Eblin divorced a few years before Bill’s death in 1948. Olie lived another 48-years. She was an accomplished cook working at the Weaver and Wells Restaurant, Pickaway Arms and for the Pickaway County school system. Her last few years were spent in a nursing home. She had lost her cognitive abilities prior to her death.

 

William Allen Eblin (17 Apr 1894 - 02 Sep 1948)                               Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

The grandparents of William “Bill” Allen Eblin were Lewis William Eblin (10 Jul 1836-11 Aug 1883) and Nancy Terry (Mar 1826-1901). They were farmers living in Meigs County, Ohio. Lewis William Eblin died in Meigs County. Nancy Terry eventually moved to Circleville, Ohio and lived with her son, Martin Eblin and her daughter, Lizzie Anna Eblin, until her death in 1901. Lizzie Anna Eblin (Dec 1876- 07 Mar 1948), who went by Anna Eblin was born in Meigs County, Ohio, and was the mother of William “Bill” Allen Eblin. The father of William A. Eblin is not clear. A story attributed to Bill was that he was the illegitimate son of a Civil War veteran. Since Anna Eblin

 


 


31

 

 

 


had no husband when Bill was born on 17 April 1894, she gave him her maiden name. It is not clear where Bill Eblin was born. His mother, Anna Eblen, was in Circleville before 20 September 1894 when she married Samuel Hessinger, which was 5-months after Bill’s birth so Bill was likely born in Circleville and Samuel Hessinger could have been his father. Samuel was definitely not a Civil War veteran, however, since he was born between 1863 and 1874. At the time of Bill’s birth in 1894 there were several Eblin and Hessinger families living in Circleville, Ohio. Samuel and Anna Eblin-Hessinger divorced and on 3 November 1902 when her son, Bill Eblin was 8-years and 6-months old, Anna married Thomas Thomas (Thomas Thomas is not a typo) who had been a boarder in the home of her brother, Martin Eblin, and his family since before 1900. Bill Eblin appears on the 1900 Federal Census as “William Eblin.” On the 1910 Federal Census, he appears as “William Thomas.” Bill’s WWI registration card and 1920 Federal Census lists him as William “Bill” Allen Eblin.

 

Bill Eblin’s mother, Anna, and her husband, Thomas, were both heavy in their latter years. Today they would probably be considered obese.

Bill Eblin had a half-brother, George H. “Fats” Thomas (Abt. 1907 – unknown) who was the son of his mother and her second husband, Thomas Thomas. George’s nickname, Fats, came naturally to him because of his weight. Bill’s grandson, John Edward Greene, Jr. remembered him as follows: “I remember seeing Fats Thomas and was amazed at his size. While visiting my grandfather I was shown the bed that Fats slept on and the sofa that he used to sit on. I saw the Pontiac that he drove around Circleville. The rear seat had been removed and the front seat was moved to the rear as far as it would go to allow his large body to drive the car. I was told of his five legged pig that he charged people to look at for some income. The only other job that I know of he ever had was as bartender for the Eagles Club on east Main street. The only other thing that I can remember and I have tried to forget was the odor of the Thomas home. They were all rather large people and I don't think they took bathing real seriously. I do remember walking around their backyard. They had some poultry and other animals in their back yard for use on the table.

 

I remember Fats Thomas’ weight of around 500 pounds and when he passed I was told that an extra-large casket had to be purchased for him. Everyone in Circleville seemed to know him in earlier times.”

John continued, “I had a newspaper delivery route for the old Columbus Citizen when I was about 10 years old [about 1945 and John lived in Marion Township near Columbus, Ohio]. One afternoon after the newspaper truck delivered my bundle of papers for me to deliver and I had cut the wire that held the bundle together on the front page of the Citizen was a picture of two young women, each standing in each leg of a huge pair of pants. I was surprised to read that the pants belonged to Fats Thomas of Circleville Ohio. The paper had featured Fats pants on the front of their paper.”

 

William “Bill” Allen Eblin and Viola “Olie” Grace Harrington married about 1913. By the time the 1920 Federal Census was taken, all of their four children were born and Bill was working at the Circleville Strawboard Co. as a machine tender. The Strawboard Company made a course paper from wheat-straw. The company was later bought by the Containers Corporation of America. Bill was always a good provider. By 1930 he had secured a position with the Circleville Ice Plant where he worked most of the rest of his life. Being the era before the powered refrigerators became a required household-appliance, Bill managed the distribution of ice to the city of Circleville, the

 


 


32

 

 

 


transportation, and railroad industry. The Circleville Ice Plant also provided jobs for Bill’s sons who ran ice delivery routes.

 

Bill and Ole divorced a few years before Bill’s death. Bill liked his beer and in the early summer of 1948, just a few months before he died, he was playing the slot-machines in the Eagles Lodge in Circleville. He became angry with the machines and pulled them over on himself, breaking both his legs. Bill’s grandson, John Edward Greene, Jr. recalls going with his mother to visit Bill Eblin after his accident with the slot-machines. He was living with Thomas and Anna Eblin-Thomas at the time. He never fully recovered from the effects of that incident. Bill died on 02 September 1948.

 

John Edward Greene, Jr., my 1st cousin, once removed, was much closer to the Bill and Olie’s family since John’s mother, Esther Mae Eblin-Greene, was their daughter. John shared some of his memories of them. I include some of his stories here since they serve to better describe that part of the family. John wrote, “I remember going to the Eblin household at the Circleville Ice plant. My father and all of the Eblin clan worked at the ice plant. My father worked in maintenance there and all of my mother’s family worked delivering ice or in some capacity there. I remember at a very young age going with Roy [Esther and Bill Eblin’s youngest son] up to the barn where the horses were kept and him bringing the horses from the barn and harnessing them to the ice wagons. I once went with Roy to the train station on South Court Street to deliver ice to the refrigerator cars and to the passenger trains. Also I remember my grandfather Bill and the family at butchering time in the fall. I remember their killing the hogs with an old .22 caliber pistol that they had and the discussion among the family about where to shoot the hogs for a quick kill. I really enjoyed that time at the Eblins. Grandma Olie fixed pork and cracklings for us to eat after making lard. I stayed with the Eblins overnight a few times and remember the big breakfasts that Grandma Eblin fixed every morning on her wood burning stove. They had no running water inside, but used a pitcher pump inside on the sink in cold weather. Outside was another pump used in the summer time. I looked forward to Saturday night at the Eblins. I sat with the family and we listened to the Grand old opry on their radio. Then I went to sleep in their unheated bedroom. Lots of other stories come to mind when I think of the visits to the Ice plant home. I remember the summer kitchen where there was a kerosene stove used for cooking. The wood stove, I was told, was much too hot for cooking in the summer.

 

I remember the tumultuous situation between my grandparents and their eventual breakup and divorce. Alcohol was a major cause of trouble in the Eblin household. All but Leonard misused alcohol.

Alcohol was eventually the demise of Roy. After the war and his discharge from the Army, Roy married and later divorced his wife June. June is still alive [as of, 2011] and lives in Chillicothe Ohio. She married a deputy sheriff and is a widow now. Roy developed cirrhosis and passed some time ago after a marriage and having a child. Roy worked for Hill Distributing company as a sales-truck driver for several years with access to large amounts of alcohol. I remember Roy as a short tempered alcoholic who drank Wiedemann beer from sunrise to sunset every day of his life. While driving his truck he would have a case of beer available to him constantly. I was constantly concerned about his driving and drinking and was amazed that he didn't kill someone with his truck driving around the city of Columbus. George was also encumbered with the bane of alcoholism. When not drinking, he had a wonderful personality, but alcohol drove him over the edge.

 


 

 


33

 

 

 


I remember staying with the Eblins [Bill and Olie] when they owned the Cozy Corner bar on old Rt. 23 south of Circleville. The bar was more trouble and the end of their marriage.”

I don't remember exactly when Grandma Olie Eblin moved in with us, but she stayed for some time. Her next move was to the home for the aged at Alum Crest on Alum creek drive where she spent the rest of her life.”

 

George William Eblin (08 Apr 1914 - 06 Dec 1980)                                   Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

George was the first son of Bill and Olie Eblin. I have very little information about George who was my 1st cousin. I recall hearing my parents describe him as personable, but unable to “hold his liquor.” George was thought to be somewhat mentally challenged. He apparently had a serious problem when he got drunk. George was sentenced to prison a couple of times. John Edward Greene, Jr., George’s nephew, recalls that he was in the Ohio State Penitentiary for about a year in 1944 or 1945. I do not know the exact crime on which he was sentenced. But he went crazy when he was drunk. Both John Greene, Jr., and my parents told me of an incident that happened in Chicago, Illinois in which he got drunk and broke the window of a butcher shop to get at sausage that was hanging there. When the police arrived, he was sitting on the curb in front of the butcher shop eating sausage.

 

George’s nephew, John Edward Greene, Jr. described him this way. George Eblin, when not drinking was a perfect example of kindness and good will. He would do anything to help out the family. George for years exhibited what I would call mental problems. As far as I know he never hurt anyone physically.

George was a hobo and traveled the country on freight trains. One day he would show up at my parent’s home, looking gaunt and dirty. Mom would feed him and offer him a bed and shower. He would work around the house painting or whatever mom and dad wanted done. He was like an angel with broken wings. Then, suddenly, when he was back in good physical shape he would vanish in the middle of the night with a toothbrush and a bar of soap. He would usually know where the cash was stored in my parent’s home and I always thought mom intentionally would let him know that there was some cash there for him. This happened so many times.

 

George was also a hopeless alcoholic. Cheap wine was his weakness. When he was drinking I was always afraid that he would hurt me, my brother, or mom and dad. One Christmas he was so drunk that he tore up our home and fell into the Christmas tree. My brother and I cowered upstairs fearing the worst and heard the commotion and turmoil going on downstairs. It was almost more than I could take. This was just one instance of trouble that George would bring to our lives.

 

One of his favorite places to drink was " Eberts" tavern at the corner of south High street and Frank road. Someone there offended him and he managed to make it home while in a drunken state. My father kept a 16 gauge Remington pump gun in the stairway leading to our up stairs. George was so drunk he could barely walk. He pushed the shotgun down into his pants leg and started down the street headed to Eberts tavern. He said he was going to take care of someone there.

 

I panicked and decided it was time to stop him. I called the constable of Marion Township. I knew the constable and went to school with his two sons. He intervened and brought George and the shotgun home. If this happened today, George would have probably been shot and killed. Back then [in] the community where I lived, this act would not have been a big deal.

 


 


34

 

 

 


 

George was in the service for a while and was discharged because he had flat feet - a medical discharge, I guess. He worked at Columbus Packing Co. and at Columbus Rendering Co.

George married a prostitute whom he met at a bar that was at the corner of South High Street and Hanford Ave in Columbus, Ohio. I don’t remember the name of George’s wife. Grandma Eblin was living with us at the time. He brought his new wife to our home to live. I remember them sitting at our kitchen table and Grandma Eblin lecturing them. It was kind of funny in a way. The marriage did not last long. George's wife returned to her life as a prostitute. It wasn't long before she was thrown from a speeding car by a group of men she had taken up with at her tavern hangout.

 

George's next adventure was his marriage to a woman named Louise. She had several children and they were dirt poor. George and Louise had one child and I think it was a boy. They lived in a shanty built of soda signs and scraps of wood.

I don't know exactly why George was sentenced to prison. I do remember my mother and I going to the Ohio Penitentiary to visit him and take him some personal items and tobacco. [John

believes this may have been about 1944-1945.] He chewed tobacco.

 

I remember his death and going to the funeral home. He was dressed as he lived – in a white shirt and denim pants. I am not sure, but he may be buried in Greenlawn Cemetery in Columbus.” [George’s records indicate he is buried at Obetz Cemetery, Obetz, Franklin County, Ohio]

 

Leonard Leroy Eblin, Sr. (08 May 1915 - 03 May 2002)                           Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Ruth Kathryn Eccard (07 Apr 1918 - 24 Aug 2001)

Leonard LeRoy Eblin, Jr. (27 Mar 1944 – living)

+ Virginia Mae Owens (22 Nov 1944 – living)

Tonja Renee Eblin (22 Sep 1964 - before Aug 2005)

Aaron Travis Eblin (23 Aug 1965 – living)

+ Deborah K Cook (1944 – living)

 

+ Connie S Litsey (11 Jun 1948 – living)

Karen Sue Eblin (20 Feb 1951 – living)

+ David Eugene Reichelderfer (20 Jun 1951- ?)

+ Ronald Lee Gaines (28 Oct 1938 - 1997)

 

Julie Nicole Gaines (22 Jan 1972 – living)

 

Ronna Sue Gaines (27 May 1973 – living)

 

Leslie Lee Gaines (25 Jun 1974 – living)

 

Brian Michael Gaines (21 Sep 1975 – living)

 

 

+ Rodric "Ric" Greider (15 Aug 1949 – living)

 

I may have met Leonard Leroy Eblin when I was a child but did not remember him. I met him again when I went to his barber shop for a haircut in the late 1950s. My last contact with him was in his home in 1995 when he was 81-years old and I was interviewing him as part of this genealogy project. Leonard and his wife Ruth Kathryn Eccard-Eblin had a lovely home in the north side of Circleville, living the good life of retired professionals. Ruth was a retired school teacher. Leonard impressed me as a very serious, intelligent person who was firmly in control of his life.

 


 


35

 

 

 


 

In his mid-to-late teens he worked with his father, Bill Eblin, at the Circleville Ice Plant and eventually had his own ice delivery route that involved driving a horse-drawn delivery wagon around Circleville. Leonard was married only once on 14 October 1941 to Miss Ruth Eccard following his enlistment in the Army on 27 March 1941. They married in the Lutheran Church in Circleville with George L. Troutman presiding. Leonard was a medic in the Army during WWII. Leonard initially served under General George Patton in the Africa Campaign of WWII. He was sent to Ireland for about a year and then to Europe. He was in the second wave of D-day arriving on 7 June 1944, one day after the initial invasion on 6 June 1944. He was released from military service on 11 August 1945 as a Sargent.

 

Leonard and Ruth Eccard-Eblin had two children. Their oldest was Leonard LeRoy Eblin, Jr. who was probably born in Circleville, Ohio. Leonard, Jr. was married 3-times. His three wives and two children are listed above. I did not know Leonard Eblin, Jr. or his wives or descendants. However, I had a fairly extensive e-mail exchange with his daughter, Tonja Renee Eblin, that covered the last 4-years of her life.

 

Leonard Leroy Eblin, Jr. (27 Mar 1944 – living)                               Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Virginia Mae Owens (22 Nov 1944 – living)

Tonja Renee Eblin (22 Sep 1964 – 4 July 2005)

Aaron Travis Eblin (23 Aug 1965 – living)

+ Deborah K Cook (1944 – living)

 

+ Connie S Litsey (11 Jun 1948 – living)

 

 Leonard Leroy Eblin, Jr. began his career as a system analyst. He moved to Florida in the mid-1980 where he still lives. In Florida he worked for the Baptist Hospital for a while but is now retired. Leonard had no military service. Leonard had two children, Tonja Renee and Aaron Travis Eblin. Tonja died 4 July 2005 and Aaron now lives in California with his wife and three children.

 

Tonja Renee Eblin (22 Sep 1964 - 04 Jul 2005) 

 

During my interview in 1995 with my 1st cousin, Leonard Leroy Eblin, Sr., Tonja’s grandfather, he told me that Tonja suffered from a congenital disease that rendered her an invalid. In our subsequent e-mails Tonja referred to her condition apparently thinking that I knew about it. When I finally asked her about it via e-mail on February 9, 2002, she referred me, to an excellent web site that described in detail the condition of Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva (FOP). I had never heard of it. The web site, http://www.ifopa.org/fopbook/index.htm, is an excellent reference. In short, it is a very rare and painful condition in which the body forms extra bone material inside muscles, tendons, ligaments, and other connective tissue that blocks the function of these body-parts and joints. There have only been a few hundred cases of this affliction known in the world. Tonja was strong in her position that she did not want to be viewed as a laboratory specimen and subject to research that she felt would be futile. Tonja died on 4 July 2005. She would have been 41-years old on 22 September 2005.

 

                                                                                        Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 


 

 


36

 

Karen Sue Eblin (20 Feb 1951 – living)

 


+ David Eugene Reichelderfer (20 Jun 1951 - ?)

 

+ Ronald Lee Gaines (28 Oct 1938 - 1997)

 


Julie Nicole Gaines (22 Jan 1972 – living)

 

+  Ronald Schwind (unknown-unknown)

Ronna Sue Gaines (27 May 1973 – living)

+ Steven Thomas (unknown-unknown)

Kylan Gaines (25 Jan 1992-living)

Elijah Redmond (3 Jan 2001-unknown)

Leslie Lee Gaines (25 Jun 1974 – living)

+ Brian Maynard (unknown-unknown)

 

Ashley Wittenmeier (20 Oct 1992-living)

 

Grace Maynard (02 Sep 2002-living)

 

Hunter Maynard (11 Apr 2008-living)

 

Brian Michael Gaines (21 Sep 1975 – living)

 

+ Rheanna ?

 

Colin Michael Gaines (27 Feb 2002-living)

+ Michele Pettigrew (unknown-unknown)

Cameron Michael Gaines (06 Jun 2013-living)

Benjamin Tucker Gaines (25 Apr 2014-living)

+ Rodric "Ric" Greider (15 Aug 1949 – living)

 

Karen Sue Eblin completed her schooling through high school in Circleville, Ohio graduating in 1969. In 1997 she received her degree in nursing from the Columbus State University in Columbus, Ohio. She is now a practicing RN.

 

Esther Mae Eblin (17 Apr 1917 - 02 May 2001)                                         Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ John Edward Greene, Sr. (22 Feb 1914 – 05 Oct 1994)

John Edward Greene, Jr. (31 Aug 1935 – living)

+  Carol Anna Summers (16 Dec 1936 – living)

 

Richard Allen Greene (01 Jul 1938 – living)

 

+  Mary George Lloyd (07 May 1938 - 02 Sep 2012)

 

Esther Mae Eblin was the 3rd child and the only female in the family of Bill and Olie Harrington-Eblin. She was born and grew to adulthood in Circleville, Ohio. She met and married her husband John Edward Greene, Sr. on 26 Aug 1934 at the age of 17-years and 4-months old. One year and 5-days later she had the first of two children, John Edward Greene, Jr. Three years and 2-months later she added her second son, Richard Allen Greene, to complete her family. John Greene, Sr. and Esther lived in Circleville for several years. During about 1938 and 1939 of that period, John worked at the Circleville Ice Plant. From the job at the ice plant, John became a pipe-fitter in Circleville. But, his wages were so low that he applied and got a job at Fort Hayes as a high-pressure steam engineer. John moved his family from Circleville, Ohio to Columbus, Ohio in 1941 to be closer to his work. At the time of this move, Esther was 23-years old and her husband, John was 26-years old. He was later transferred to the Army Depot in Columbus from which he eventually retired. In 1949 the family moved to 1632 Moler Road, Columbus. John and Esther bought an acre of land at that address and John built a two-car,

 


 


37

 

 

 


concrete block garage that the family equipped with a bathroom and kitchen and moved into for 3 or 4-years. When John, Jr. and Carol Summers-Greene married in 1953, they moved into the garage area and John, Sr. and Esther moved into the new house that John, Sr. had constructed. A few years later, John, Jr. and Carol built their own 3-bedroom house with an attached garage.

 

John Edward Greene, Sr. (22 Feb 1914 – 05 Oct 1994)                             Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

John Edward Greene, Sr. was the second son of Denny and Hazel Ora-Green both of Circleville, Ohio. Historical records suggest that it was probably Hazel Ora-Greene-Peters who changed the spelling of the Green family name to Greene. This conclusion is based on the appearance of the Greene spelling of her children’s name in the 1930 US Federal Census that was taken about 9-years following her first husband, Denny Green’s death in 1921. Her oldest son, Reynold Green, retained the spelling, Green, of his father’s name.

 

John Edward Greene, Sr. was 7-years old when his father died so he was reared by his mother, Hazel, and her second husband, Stanley B. Peters, whom she married 15 February 1922. Hazel had no children with Stanley Peters. On 26 Aug 1934 John Greene, Sr. married my 1st cousin, Esther Mae Eblin, daughter of Bill and Olie Harrington-Eblin. Esther was 17 and John was 21 years old when they married. John Greene, Sr. started his career working at the Circleville Ice Plant with his grandfather, Bill Eblin. He soon became a plumber in Circleville, then in Columbus, Ohio. Within a few short years he took a position with the Army Depot in Columbus, Ohio from which he eventually retired. John Edward Greene, Sr. died at his home in Pickerington, Ohio on 05 Oct 1994 at the age of 80-years.

 

John Edward Greene, Jr. (31 Aug 1935 – living)                                       Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Carol Anna Summers (16 Dec 1936 – living)

William Allen Greene (25 July 1954 – living)

+ Cathy Barnette (06 July 1956 – living)

Michael Todd Greene (22 Aug 1955 – 4 Mar 1956)

Larry Edward Greene (08 May 1957 – 10 Jun 1957)

James Charles Greene (14 Nov 1959 – living)

 

+ Arlinda Del Craig (1960 – living)

Deanna Mae Greene (17 Nov ‘63 – living)

+ Johnny Jerald Hammel (29 Sept 1961 – living)

David Allen Greene (30 Oct 1964 – 23 Aug 1984)

 

John Edward Greene, Jr. was born 31 August 1935 in Circleville, Ohio, the son of John Edward Greene, Sr. and my 1st cousin, Esther Mae Eblin-Greene who were also both born in Circleville, Ohio. Like most families who lived through the Great Depression, the Eblin-Greene family was very poor. John’s birth was described as a hard birth for both John and his mother. John was born with a double hernia that required that he wear a truss from the age of 2 to 9 years old, when he had corrective surgery. His early physical issues and the corrective truss had a profound effect on John’s early years. He was unable to do the physical things a normal child could do. Bullying by his fellow students left emotional scars that took years to heal.

 

John Edward Greene, Jr. moved with his family to Columbus, Ohio in 1941 when he was about 6-years old. After spending his first year in a Columbus school, his family

 


 

 


38

 

 

 


moved to Marion Township where he enrolled in Fornof grade school. Bulling continued at school. John graduated from Hamilton Township high school in 1953 having received his full education in the Franklin County, Ohio school system. He married his high school sweetheart, Carol Anna Summers, on 22 August 1953 just 9-days before he turned 18-years old. Carol who had been born in Columbus was 16-years and 8-months old. The young couple began housekeeping in a garage-home recently vacated by John’s parents and started their family a year later with the birth of their first son, William Allen Greene, on 25 July 1954.

 

John Greene, Jr., went to work for Western Electric in the year 1958. He completed the Western Electric Tool-and-Dye apprenticeship program, got his journeyman’s card while still living in his father’s garage-apartment and became an employee in the Western Electric Tool and Dye Department. Armed with a solid job and some savings, John and Carol bought a 1.5 acre lot in Plain Township, Franklin County, Ohio and set about to construct their new home. With the help of his father and some hired home-building experts, he built a pre-fabricated home. John did most of the electrical wiring, installed and finished the hardwood floors, hung all of the doors, and did all of the painting. Finally, the job was finished.

 

John and Carol Anna’s family eventually numbered 6-children. Tragically, only half of them survived to adulthood. Their second and third sons died within their first year of life and their youngest son, David Allen Greene, was electrocuted at the age of 19-years while working on a construction job.

John had a full 35-year career with Western Electric, retiring in 1992.

 

Carol Anna Summers-Greene worked for 5 1/2 years for Plain Township Schools in New Albany, Ohio. She retired with disability from the State of Ohio, Bureau of Workers Compensation after 18 years of service.

John and his wife, Carol Anna, were avid motorcycle buffs, taking many road trips and seeing much of the USA. One such trip was to the Upper Peninsula of Michigan where they fell in love with the area. They sold their motorcycle, bought property and built a house where they lived for about 12-years. While there, John suffered a stroke that limited his mobility for a while. Because of the remoteness of the location and because medical facilities were sparse, they decided to move back to central Ohio. In 2004, they moved to Johnstown, Ohio near Columbus.

 

John Edward Greene, Jr. was a major resource for the contemporary members of the Eblin family, in the writing of this book, for which I am most grateful. One over-arching observation made by John repeats itself several times throughout his contributions: Alcohol was a problem in the Eblin family. All of the Eblins suffered from alcoholism. My grandparents divorced and fought like cats and dogs. Bill Eblin died as a result of being drunk and pulling slot machines onto his legs and breaking them. Roy drank a terrible amount and lost his liver function. George died young. Leonard was the only one who was able to drink in a sensible manner. My mother suffered with the same problem and made me and my brother's life miserable at times. My father would have a couple of beers now and then, but never was consumed with alcohol. As you probably know, both of my parents died as a result of lung cancer from cigarettes that they used most of their lives.”

 

John Edward Greene, Jr. and his younger brother, Richard Allen Greene, were the only two children of their parents, John Edward Greene, Sr. and his wife, Esther May Eblin-Greene. In 2014 through 2016, the author of this book, Richard Harrington, helped organize and publish a nearly 400-page family history of the Summers and Greene

 


 


39

 

 

 


family titled, “The Summers-Greene Family Tree.” That book had been initiated by Carol Anna Summers-Greene with the help of her nephew, John Paul Rea, who together had collected considerable information on Carol Anna’s family line. “The Summers-Greene Family Tree” provides considerably more detail of their branch of our Greene family and even more extensive history of Carol Anna Summer’s family. Copies of “The Summers-Greene Family Tree” book can be found in the library of the Pickaway County Historical and Genealogical Society in Circleville, Ohio.

 

Richard Allen Greene (01 Jul 1938 – living)                                              Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Mary George Lloyd (07 May 1938 - 02 Sep 2012)

John LeRoy Greene (07 Jan 1961 – living)

+ Catherine Ann Schultz (17 May 1960 – living)

 

Allison Rose Greene (30 Aug 1986 – living)

 

Senneth Cheyenne Greene (23 Jan 1990 - living)

 

+ Josh Smith

 

Richard Allen Greene, Jr. (11 Dec 1962 – living)

 

+ Amee L. Rush (12 Aug 1968 - living)

 

Shawntae Amanda Greene (12 Feb 1991 - living)

 

+ (partner) Mason Truman

 

Scotlyn Truman

 

Brittany Lynn Greene (15 Aug 1993 - living)

 

+ Alison Lynn Brower (15 Mar 1976 - living)

 

Carson Olivia Greene (29 Jan 2004 - living)

 

From an e-mail from Richard Greene dated June 13, 2001, "I go by Rich mostly. When I worked at AT&T a lot of the people there called me Dick, but family and friends call me Rich."

 

Rich Greene took his entire 12-years of schooling in the Franklin County School System graduating in the spring of 1956. He started college in the fall of 1956 at The Ohio State University with the intention of pursuing a career in Chemical Engineering. After one quarter he realized he did not want to invest an additional 4-years in intensive schooling and dropped out of OSU to consider his options. Rich married Mary George Lloyd on 9 August 1979 in Columbus, Ohio. He went to work for Western Electric and rose in the ranks of the company from maintenance, through design engineer, through senior engineer, and finally became acting Chief of the Design Department. He retired from Western Electric as senior engineer and Acting Chief of the Design Department in 1989. Upon retirement Rich started his own company which he called, “Greene Engineering Design.” Uncomfortable with all of the administrative issues of running a company, he closed his business after about 2-years to go to work with Resinoid Engineering Corporation which was owned by a friend and competitor. Richard retired again in the year 2000 from Resinoid Engineering Corporation after working there for about 8-years.

 

Also from Rich’s June 13, 2001 email: “Why I am in Frazeysburg? I lived in Pickerington 35 or so years, and had always planned to get out... perhaps a small farm, and somehow ended up here. [Rich and Mary moved from Pickerington to their present home on Thanksgiving Day in 1995.] I took early retirement from AT&T, did not like retirement, so had my own business for a little bit, then went to work for a company in Newark, and this location is

 


 


40

 

 


handy to Newark. Rich Greene" P.S. We actually are in Fallsburg, but post office is Frazeysburg, OH.”

 

Roy Edward Eblin (13 May 1919 - 26 Jun 1981)                                                Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Dorothy June Carr (unknown-?)

 

+ Becky (unknown- ?)

 

Terry Eblin (31 Jul 1958-?)

 

Roy Edward Eblin was the youngest child of William “Bill” and Olie Harrington-Eblin. He was born in Circleville, Ohio. He grew up in his parent’s house located near the Circleville Ice Plant where his father worked. When he was 21-years old, he had an ice delivery route. In WWII, Roy enlisted in the U.S. Army on 13 August 1942 and was released on 22 September 1945. He served as an aircraft mechanic in the Pacific Theater. According to Carol Anna Summers-Greene, Roy E. Eblin lived most of his adult life in Columbus, Ohio except for his time in the military (enlistment date: 13 August 1942 – release date: 22 Sep 1945). He first married Dorothy June Carr. John Greene, Jr. wrote, “His wonderful wife June could not live under the stress and rudeness that Roy displayed while under the demon of alcohol. Even when not drinking, he was a stick of dynamite just waiting to explode.” Roy and June divorced. “Roy married again to a woman named Becky and they had a daughter named Terry. Roy developed cirrhosis of the liver from the alcohol consumption and died a very painful death.” Roy died in Columbus, Ohio on 26 June 1981 at the age of 62-years and 1-month. He was buried in Forest Cemetery in Circleville, Ohio.

 

Ira Edward Harrington (28 Aug 1899 - 23 Nov 1983)                                       Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Dortha Ellen Moore (21 Jul 1901 - 01 Oct 1997)

 

June Lucille Harrington (1 June 1920 - 28 Apr 2003)

 

+ Vivian “Lil” Redford (15 Jan 1900 - Aug 1975)

 

+ Audra Lavada Young (24 Jan 1907 - 8 Apr 1990)

 

Richard Edward Harrington (23 December 1931 – living)

 

William Young Harrington (17 Jun 1963 - 23 Feb 1986)

 

Patricia Sue Harrington (20 Jun 1936 - 28 Apr 2013)

 

It is true that we can never fully know our parents. When we enter the family, our parent’s life is already about 20% to 30% over. Our grandparents' lives are already about 50% to 60% complete. Our earliest concept of family is therefore made up of, us kids, middle-aged people, old people, and, if there are great grandparents still living, very, very old people. Each of these groups of people have their own characteristics, their own history, life spans and their own attitudes and impacts on our own life. If asked to describe any of these individuals, the only real description we can give must be within the limits of our own experience with them. Our description, however, would likely include historical events that have been told to us by these individuals or by others. This we all take for granted and seldom even think about how much we know and don’t know about our closest kin until we attempt to describe an ancestor, a contemporary or a progeny. A result is a time-based myopia that is one source of bias in a descriptive genealogy such as this.

 


 


41

 

 

 


In my own immediate family, the earliest recollection of my parents began about 1936-1937. My dad, Ira Edward Harrington, was about 38-years of age; my mother, Audra Lavada Young Harrington, was about 30-years old. Both sets of grandparents were still living and in their 40s and 50s. Audra’s mother, Ola Hodge was 49-years old. One great grandparent who was still living, Mary Jane Whitacre-Hodge, was in her mid-70s. So almost everything I describe in this book that preceded 1938 had to be derived from records and stories that were told to me.

I am about to tell you of my father, Ira Edward Harrington, a guy whom I should know very well. But, some of the most exciting parts of his life happened before I was born. We are fortunate that among his many attributes, Ira was a good story teller. Maybe his telling of his life-stories was motivated by the knowledge that he would never write his own biography and he used the role of a bard to communicate his history. Like a bard he repeated his stories with very little variation, many times during the period we lived together.

 

In the spring of 1977 my daughter, Pamela Anne Harrington, was in college and had been given an assignment to write a paper. She decided to interview her grandfather, Ira, for some of his many stories, as the basis for her academic paper. She recorded the interview and transcribed several of his stories just as he had told them. I recognized most of the stories as almost exact versions that Ira had told many times to his children and others. These include the stories of his first 40-years that began shortly after his birth in 1899. Several of these stories have been repeated in this book just as Ira told them, retaining Ira's unique vernacular. The stories that were transcribed from the recorded audio in the exact vernacular used by Ira, are identified in this book with an asterisk (*) and enclosed with quotation marks for easy identification of the source. An attempt has been made to arrange the stories in chronological order. Where I had information that would help date a story, it was placed in that location in the chronological series. Several of the stories, however, do not yield to a specific year. In those cases, they have been located in the series where they appear to most likely fit.

 

For me, these stories are an important part of this book. Collectively, they tell the story of the life of a very special guy.

 

1902

 

This story is the first story that I can recall of the very early life of my father, Ira Harrington. I consider it a very important story in our family history because, but for a fraction of a second, Ira and all of his descendants would not be here and this book would not have been written. Also, as I assembled this book, I came to recognize several such near-misses that could have had similar results. For this reason, this story also appears in the discussion of my Aunt Nellie Mae Harrington.

 

When Nellie Mae Harrington was about 12 years old, her mother was working as a gleaner in a bean field that was bordered on one side by railroad tracks. Nellie was charged with keeping an eye on her then 4-siblings and possibly also helping with the gleaning. Ira was about 2-years old and probably bored and wondered onto the nearby rail road track. Perhaps amazed by the on-coming train that was approaching with its whistle screaming, and coming too rapidly to stop, Ira stood transfixed on the track. He was rescued from being run over by a brakeman who made his way to the cow-catcher and snatching him a second before the train would have run him over. I shudder at the thought of what my history and the history of our family would be if that brakeman had failed to connect with Ira as he did.

 


 


42

 

 

 


 

1910

 

Nellie Mae Harrington married William Ottis Zwicker on 20 November 1909 so was not enumerated with her parent’s family in the U.S. Federal Census of 1910. However, the 1910 Federal Census provides the most complete listing of my dad’s family, with Nellie Mae Harrington missing.

 

From the Federal Census of 1910 for Circleville Township, Lancaster Pike, Pickaway Co., Ohio, enumerated 26 April 1910

 

Harrington, William, Head, age 44, born in Kansas (father born in Wisconsin), occupation: Concret (sic) worker, sidewalks;

Ella Harrington, wife, age 37, born in Ohio;

 

Chas. Wm. Harrington, son, age 17, born in Ohio, occupation: laborer, farm;

 

 Ruth I. Harrington, dau., age 15, born in Ohio, occupation: working out, (private family);

 Viola Harrington, dau., age 13, born in Ohio;

 Anna (sic - Ira) E. Harrington, dau., age 11, born in Ohio;

 Roy Wm. Harrington, son., age 9, born in Ohio;

       Easter M. Harrington, dau., age 6, born in Ohio; Lewis Harrington, son., age 4, born in Ohio;

       Fred Harrington, son., age 11-mo., born in Ohio

 

1912

 

Many of the freight trains that hauled coal from Kentucky and southern Ohio came through Circleville, Ohio from south to north. These trains used steam powered locomotive engines that burned coal in their boilers to convert water into steam. Periodically they needed to replace the water used during their trip. There was a water tower located about 2-miles south of Circleville where the steam engines stopped to replenish their water supply. Being long heavy coal trains, they took several miles to get back up to speed for their continuing trip. Also, there was a curve in the railroad tracks that caused the trains to navigate around Circleville rather than going through the heart of town.

 

When Ira was a boy, he and several other boys would walk along the railroad tracks toward the water tower. They would board the slow moving train and as it approached the south end of Circleville where they lived and they would kick lumps of coal off the coal cars. Later they would pick up the coal in sacks and take it home for fuel.

This operation was pretty successful. The railroad was aware that they were doing it and would sometimes have railroad-detectives posted to try to catch them. On one occasion, one of Ira's friends put a lump of coal in their stove and it blew up. It had been drilled and a dynamite cap had been placed in the hole. This was done by the railroad-detectives as a deterrent to stealing coal.

 

1915

 

* Ira's stories began, "Before I ever went to Florida or California, either one, we used to catch a train here in Circleville and go to Portsmouth, Ohio and back, just like that. Just for fun, when I was 15 years old. If my folks knew that I rode a train when I was 15, I'd a had nothing to sit on!"

 


 


43

 

 


 

1916

 

*                  "Chet Workman and I pert' near growed up together. Once when we was about 16 years old, we were down here below town about - oh, a mile - and we were in a woods. Well, we come to a rail fence that was around a cemetery, and beyond the cemetary was bluegrass, so we figured on goin' up through there. So I throwed my leg over the fence, to climb over and Chet; I'll never forget, there were sheep in the cemetery, and he got one leg over the fence and the sheep started to get up. Now they don't get up like a cow. When they get up, they raise up on all fours. I don't know how they do it, I never watched them. But they just raise up. We were about 30 feet away from them and I had my lantern, and he seen 'em. I didn't see 'em myself 'til they raised up, and when they raised up they pert' near scared Chet to death. He thought they were ghosts!"

 

*                  "I was up to see Chet day before yesterday. He's been a life-long friend. Tried and true. We run around together about all our lives. We still run around together. He's 74.

 

*                  "He's a guy that, I don't care where you're at, what you're doin', or who you're with, he keeps you laughin' all the time. Just naturally comical. It all had no importance, nothin' didn't mean anything, yet we had a lot of fun. Fishin' together, huntin' together, running' around together, went with girls together.

*                  "One of the funniest things that I can remember, he set me up a date one time, with a girl that we knew. That was the horse and buggy days, so I rented a horse and buggy and went and picked her up. We went for a mile and a half or two miles, and I turned around and went straight back 'cause she stunk. She looked clean enough, and was a nice enough lookin' girl, but she had that damn odor about her when you don't take a bath. Her name was Claire Meyers. It's funny how I can remember things back there and I can't remember something somebody told me yesterday. Oh, I've had a lot of fun in my time."

 

1916-1917

 

* "When I was about 16 or 17, this guy I knew had a big ol' upstairs, and they'd have prizefighting up there. He'd give me five dollars to fight."

 

1917

 

Ira grew to manhood as the Industrial Revolution was in full swing. Prohibition had become the law of the land in 1920 and the world was hurdling toward World War I. Ira had no formal career training and the hard manual-labor of his father was looking less and less appealing to him. What he did find interesting was the rapidly evolving automobile and motorized transportation industry. No doubt this was further inspired by his older brother, Ray. Ray was 6-years Ira’s senior who had launched a career as an automobile mechanic and was progressing rapidly with the burgeoning industry. Ira described his passage into the automotive business this way.

 

* "My first mechanical experience was, I bought a motorcycle and I tinkered and worked 'til I knew it, and I understood how a motorcycle and a gasoline engine operates. Then I was working for a contractor here in town [Circleville, Ohio], and I had experience with small gas engines, so I worked for him and I took care of his cement mixers

 


 


44

 

 

 


and their drive engines."

 

1918

 

As Ira became older, he began to travel farther from home in search of work. His main mode of travel was hopping freight trains. It was upon returning from such a job, when he was about 18 years old, that he was on his way back from Hog Island. He had been shoveling sand for a Navy Yard. Hog Island is at the mouth of the Delaware River and he was coming back by way of train. Because he hadn't eaten in about three days, he was forced to do something that he had never done before - ask for food. He finally decided to approach a woman's house to ask for a hand-out.

 

* "There was a picket fence about three feet tall, and I was comin' back from Hog Island. I went and asked her for something to eat. She said 'Well, wait a minute.' So I waited. And I heard a dog's toenails hittin' the linoleum, so I took off running' and she opened the door and a big ol' dog gets out and took to running' me out the yard and down the street.

I went on down the street and here was a boy about nine years old. I'll never forget this, I was really hungry. I hadn't had much to eat in three days, and here come this boy out of this house. He had a great big slice of homemade bread, all piled with butter and jelly, and he wouldn't stand still and he wouldn't come close enough. I was going to take it away from 'im. I says 'Hey boy, come here!' but he wouldn't come. It's kind of funny now, but it wasn't funny then, when you're hungry, with no money, and miles and miles from home."

 

"I never begged anything in my life. I just couldn't beg. It just wasn't in me. I was walkin' down the railroad track about that same time and I saw this piece of bread layin' in the middle of the tracks. I looked at it and passed on. I was really hungry. I must have walked, oh, maybe a mile, and I thought, 'Oh hell. Some conductor or something throwed that off the train. It wouldn't be poisoned.' And I walked clear back, and I looked at it and I just couldn't pick it up. I never got nothing to eat until I hooked up with a fellow by the name of Brown. I'll never forget him. He was a “muleskinner,” he drove mules. I run into him and we got to talkin' and he says 'You look hungry.' 'I am hungry.' I says, 'I haven't eaten for three days.' Well, we got to a little town and he went out to get me something to eat and he sat down and ate three breakfasts. They'd take him in and sit him down and give him something to eat, and they'd never give him something to bring back to me. He finally run on to a woman. She was a middle aged lady, and she gave him two big slices of bread. One covered with butter and one covered with apple butter. That was the best I ever ate. You get real hungry and take a piece of plain bread, and it will taste like cake."

 

1918

 

On September 12, 1918, Ira registered for WWI draft at Circleville, Ohio. C. E. Stout signed the registration card. Ira gave as his profession, Linesman for the Citizen Telephone Co., Place of employment: N. Court St. Circleville, Pickaway Co., Ohio. He gave as his permanent contact point: Elizabeth Sarah Harrington , address: 6076 Mound St , Circleville, Pickaway, Ohio. He also gave this same address as his own address. He gave his date of birth as Aug 28, 1898 and his age as 20.

 


 

 

 


45

 

 

 


1919

 

I recall Ira telling this story about camping on an island that had formed in the Scioto River, west of his hometown, Circleville, Ohio. Flood waters had carved a new but shallow course that isolated a small piece of land from the river bank creating the island. Ira and a friend pitched a tent on the island and lived a life of Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn for part of a year. They lived off the land by hunting, fishing and eating young corn from a neighbor’s field. One day they had prepared a large skillet of corn that they cut from the cob and fried over an open fire. It was still early so they decided to run their trot-lines before eating. The weather had been dry and the river level was low. When they returned, they found that a herd of cattle had waded across the shallow stream that isolated their island and helped themselves to the nice warm skillet of sweet corn, licking the skillet clean. Supper was late that evening since it was necessary to clean the camp site, wash the soiled dishes and prepare a new skillet of corn. This camping adventure ran well into the winter, as the story goes. As the winter came on, they banked the outside of their tent with folder from a farmer's corn field that provided a good insulation from the weather. It was so well insulated that they were able to warm the tent from the heat of a lantern.

 

In telling this story, Ira indicated that it was “me and another guy” who were on this camping expedition. He never mentioned the name of the other guy. I have often wondered if the other guy might have been Dortha Ellen Moore with whom he had his first child, June Lucille Harrington, on 1 June 1920. As Ira’s son, I recognize that this would fall in the category of things that was none of my business – but, I have often wondered.

 

1919

 

Ira became the proud owner of an Indian motorcycle. In the years that included 1919 there were only a few paved roads and these did not include the gravel roads that served most rural residents and farms. On one occasion, Ira was riding on a gravel road with a passenger seated behind him. As he approached a place in the road where a ditch had been cut across to install a tile and refilled leaving a bump, Ira, jokingly told his passenger, said that the road was out ahead and he should jump off. The passenger jumped off throwing the motorcycle out of control. Ira rode the vehicle off the road and into a fence row where he broke-off three fence posts. Ira was knocked unconscious. He remained in a coma for 8-days before waking up. This was one of Ira's near-death events that had a happy ending and, by extension, made possible the writing of this book.

 

1920

 

On 1 June 1920 Ira's first child, June Lucille Harrington, was born. June's mother was Dortha Ellen Moore. Information regarding this event is sparse and research has yielded little. Dortha abandoned June to her father, Ira Harrington. Unable to provide June with a home and without the experience or resources to care for a child, June lived with and was reared by her grandparents, Bill and Lizzie Harrington, until she graduated from high school. I have looked through the marriage license records in Fairfield, Pickaway, Ross and Franklin Counties, and more recently, Ancestry.com, for a record or Ira's marriage to Dortha Moore. I found none. I have come to the conclusion that Ira and June’s mother, Dortha Moore, probably were never married.

 


 


46

 

 

 


 

1922

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira E. Herrington; Residence year 1922; Address 417 E. Main, Columbus, OH; occupation: Auto Mech; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1922 [living with Nell and Ruth (both waitress) at 417 E. Main]

 

1923

 

On 14 July 1923 Ira Edward Harrington and Vivian (Lil) Radford married.

 

1924

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira E. Harrington; Residence year 1924; Address 678 Mohawk Av, Columbus, OH; occupation: Auto Mech, McClure-Nesbitt Motor Co.; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1924

 

1924

 

Ira and Vivian went to Florida by way of a Model-T Ford when he was 24 years old. This trip lasted at least 2-years since Vivian and Ira Harrington are registered in the Tampa, Florida City Directory in 1926 residing at 31 9th Ave, Tampa, Florida.

 

1924-1926

 

* "In Tampa Florida, some boy, I don't remember his name, was crookeder than hell, and he said I held him up! His older brother owned two or three filling stations, and three times he robbed that filling station. He would go and stay there while his brother went out to lunch or something, and three times he had a 'hold up' while his brother was out to lunch. One of 'em was right next to the shop where I worked, and he said that I held him up. They took me in for questioning, and I stayed overnight in jail. There was all kind of proof that I wasn't no ways near there at that time. He said that I had on a gray suit of clothes, and I didn't own one. I had a brown suit and a white suit. In fact, I was down at the Latin American Club. I had all kinds of alibis."

 

 

1924-1926

 

* "Once, on the corner of 9th Avenue and Maryland, in Florida, I stopped in a store. While there, I heard what sounded like a car backfiring. I went out and there was this guy that shot a nigger. This guy wanted me to swear and I wasn't even there. I was in a drugstore, and while I was in the drugstore, he shot 'im. And I went out, and the nigger was lyin' there bleedin' and that guy kicked a half a brick over to the side of the nigger and he wanted me to say I saw it and that the nigger was goin' to hit him with the brick. I said I don't want a damn thing to do with it. I didn't see it and I don't want nothin' to do with it; got in the company car and just went on about my business."

 

U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989 about Vivian Harrington

 

Name: Vivian Harrington

 

Gender: Female

 

Residence Year: 1926

 

Street address: 1031 9th Av

 


 


47

 

 


Residence Place: Tampa, Florida, USA

 

Spouse: Ira Harrington [vocation: mechanic]

 

Publication Title: Tampa, Florida, City Directory, 1926

 

1927

 

Ira ran over a little girl with his auto breaking both of her legs. He was exiting an alley in Columbus, Ohio where he lived and she ran across the alley from the obscured front of a building in front of his car. No charges were filed against Ira. He paid for the little girl’s medical treatment and visited her while she was in the hospital.

 

1929

 

Pam wrote, "When Ira was 29 years old, my grandfather took another trip. This went to California with his brother Lou. They took another Model-T Ford and set out for more adventures - which they found. They had a few problems with the Ford, though. In Arizona, the top of the car caught fire because of the wood support rubbing against the metal hood. Because they were in the desert, there wasn't any water to put it out with. How it was finally quenched will have to be passed down from generation-to-generation by word of mouth. After this happened they wrecked the Ford, and since they were low on money, instead of paying to have it fixed, they sold it, and came back by way of a train. Not the conventional way, mind you, they hopped freight trains. This wasn't a new form of transportation to them, although the experiences they had were.

 

1929?

 

*   "Another time, comin' back from Calfornia, I got to Texas, Sante Fe, and this railroad detective was puttin' everybody off the train, to keep 'em from ridin' and this detective caught up with me. I wasn't on the train, 'cause the train had stopped, and you better get off the train and get hidin' while you were stopped. So I got off the train and this detective caught me. He talked to me a little bit, I wasn't really a bum, see, I had some money and was dressed pretty good, so he talked to me a little bit. I told him where I was from and everything and he said, 'I believe you.' Then he said, you see that straight embankment down there? There's a road that goes across that and the train has to go upgrade. Now you start walkin', and when the train pulls out you get on it and get in the box car and shut the door.' So I did. There was another feller in there, a young guy from Texas, so I got in there and here was this guy. He was about, oh, I'd say 20 years old, but he was great big. Well I told him that the man said that if we keep the door shut, we could go on through. Well, we come to another town and made a stop, for somethin' and when we started to pull out, these two spicks got on, Mexicans. They were maybe between 20 and 25, they pulled in the rope and jumped in. So, that was pretty wild country through there. After we got out a piece, they throwed the door wide open and one sat on one side and one sat on the other. I tried to tell 'em that the man said that if we'd shut the door we could ride. They'd say 'no speak.' They didn't know English too well, and in order to get to ride, I insisted that they get back and shut the door. Well, they didn't like that and one pulled out a switchblade about six inches long and started to clean his fingernails.

 

So I got the other guy to come back to the other side of the car, and I sat down and he sat down along side of me. I asked him where he was goin' and everything, and he told me, but anyhow, I said 'We got to get rid of them if we want to ride this train clear through.

 


 


48

 

 


 

"'What'd ya want to do?', he says,

 

'"Well, we can talk to 'em a little bit, and you get on one side and I'll get on the other . . .' "When the train got to rollin' real good, we just put our foot in their backs and kicked

 

them onto the ground. They just rolled like balls! For the next two days I bought papers whenever we stopped in a town, to see if there was any account of them. I never heard anything. I don't think they were hurt, just a little scratched up.

 

1929?

 

* "Lou and I got separated on the way back, in Alburquerque, New Mexico. I didn't know where he was, but I knew he was on his way home. This was in Joliet, Illinois. I was ridin' on top of the merchandise in a box car, and we pulled in to Joliet. Well, I had to get off the train, so when it come to a stop, I looked both ways, and here come guys with lanterns, that was after dark, and here come a guy walkin' over top. They was lookin' for guys like me. And there was only one thing for me to do, make a dash for it. And I did. There was an old cabin set back off the railroad and I just went around that ol' cabin, it was all overgrown with weeds, kind of swampy down there, there was burdock and grass. I just made a dive around that house and went back in there quite a ways, crawlin' in the grass and big ol' burdock. They stomped all around me with their flashlights, they saw me run that way, and here they come with flashlights. One guy pert' near stepped on me. They give up, and I figured that was a pretty good place to spend the night, so I just stayed there. The next morning, shortly after daylight I woke up. I didn't dare to go back on them rails, because they'd be watchin' for me, so I started the other way, and come up to a big stone wall. I crawled up it, and looked right down in the back of a prison. I was out side of the prison. I went out to the trough where they watered the mules and washed my face and hands. There was a great big guard there and he come over and talked to me. He asked me where I was headed for and I told him. He said, 'Do you know where you're at?'

 

"I said, 'No.'

 

"You're in Joliet, Illinois. You're in the penitentiary. You're in the yard!' "I said, That's rough, ain't it?'

"I don't know whether to open that gate there and put you over in the penitentiary yard or let you go.'

"'Well,' I said, 'I haven't committed no crime, and I haven't offended you have I?' "'No.'

"'Well, then, I can't see no sense in putting me over in the prison yard.' "'Well, " he says, 'I guess I can't either."

"The prison gate where I went out was about a quarter of a mile out towards the street. He walked out to the gate with me. We just got out the gate and here come the city patrol. They didn't have cruisers then, they all walked on foot. We stood there and talked a little bit, and he said, 'Here's a guy that wandered in the back end this morning here. I'm going to turn him over to you.'

 

"The policeman asked, 'What did he do?' "'Oh, I don't know what he's done.' "They was kiddin' me, you see.

"So the patrolman said, 'Well we're pretty well filled up down there, I think I'll let 'im go.'

 


 


49

 

 

So he told me where a hobo jungle was. A hobo jungle is where a bunch of hobos concentrate and cook and sleep and tell lies. Before I got there I went to a bakery and got some sweet rolls and, oh, a little ham I guess. There were ten or twelve guys there, with a big ol' lard can over a fire cookin', and I had this stuff to eat, and here comes another'n, says 'what you got?' and I give it to 'im and he tears the bread all up and tossed it in there and took the balony or whatever it was, cut it up and throws it in the can. They call it scumgullion. Everybody ate some. I had a little money, $60 or $70 and I was afraid to go to sleep, or stay there after dark 'cause those guys would cut your throat for a dime. So about an hour before dark I walked out through the jungle to a hill. I knew the steepness of the grade would slow the train down, so I sat down there in the grass agin' a tree and went to sleep until I heard a train whistle."

 

1929?

 

* "In New Mexico I stopped once and got some ham and eggs. The girl there was baitin' me or something, I don't know. She told the railroad detective to watch me." (He was referring to the waitress.) "He was a nasty ol' guy. Three days before that he had shot a 15 year old boy in the back. I went out and stayed away from the railroad until dark. When it got dark I knew that nobody could see which direction I was goin' or anything, but I had to walk out about a mile away from that town, then circle back to get to the railroad. That's when the guy got me. There was a light in the station, and I could see 'im bobbin' back and forth in that light comin' in my direction, so I got off the railroad, back onto the highway, He tried to get me back on the railroad so that he could arrest me. He pulled a gun and told me to get back down on the tracks. I said, 'If you're the kind of man that would shoot another man for nothin', than you go ahead.'

 

"He said, 'Where are you from?' "Ohio', I told him.

"Well, you're going to learn something, 'cause down here, we shoot first and investigate later.'

 

 

"Well, you go ahead and shoot, 'cause I ain't gettin' down on no damn railroad. I'm up here on a public highway, and it ain't any of your business.'

"I watched him out of sight, and started walkin' on the highway. I figured that the highway would come back to the railroad somehow 'cause it was kind of curving towards the railroad, I must have walked a mile, and sure enough it did. The road went under the railroad, so I got up against the buttress there, and later, it was just breakin' day when a train come along. Goodbye! I was gone.

 

 

1930

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira Harrington; Residence year 1930; Address 1159 E. Fulton, Columbus, OH; occupation: Mech; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1930

 

From the 1930 Federal Census for Columbus, Ward 4, Block 203, Franklin County, Ohio; Fulton Street; enumerated 4 April 1930 [all members of this house were born in Ohio; both of Katherine Loos parents were born in Germany; father: Alsace-Lorraine; mother: Bavaria, Germany]

 


 


50

 

 

 


Katherine Loos, head, age 58, occupation: none

 

William Loos, son, age 38, occupation: city Salesman, machine Wipers

 

Marjorie Loos, dau., age 13

 

Jean Loos, dau, age 12

 

Isabelle Loos, dau., age 6

 

Robert Loos, son, age 4

 

Ira Harington, lodger, age 30, occupation: none

 

1930

 

While lead-mechanic at a garage in Columbus, Ohio (it could have been the McClure-Nesbitt Motor Co.) Ira was asked to start an old Dussenberg automobile that had been taken in on trade. The Dussenberg was an American-made luxury automobile made in Des Moines, Iowa between 1917-1937. Although several mechanics had worked on it, it would not start. Ira was too busy to get to it for several weeks. Finally Ira told Jimmie, the garage handyman, to pull the car out on the floor. It had a magneto spark source. Ira dropped the pan so he could see the position of the pistons and synchronized the spark with the firing order of the cylinders. He put the pan back on and had Jimmie put oil in it and give it a crank. It fired on the first pull and ran well.

 

Another ‘Ira’ story was about a customer who bought a new car. He was Italian and spoke only broken English. He was particularly careful with it and drove it very slowly. He would not use the high speed gear on the car. One day he brought the car in for repairs having been hit on the side in an intersection. Ira told him that he was hit because he was driving too slow. Ira pointed out that if he were going faster, he would have been well out of the intersection by the time the other car came along. The customer speeded up. Sometime later, he brought his car in again. Again it was hit in an intersection. He was furious with Ira. He complained that if he had not been driving faster, he would not have been even close to the intersection when the other car was there.

 

1931

 

On 24 February 1931, Ira E. Harrington and Audra Lavada Young Hines married in the Trinity Lutheran church in Circleville. They had met in Columbus, Ohio where Ira and Audra were each renting rooms from the sister of Audra's brother-in-law. Audra had lost her husband, Lawrence Hines, about 2-years before and was enrolled in a beautician school. Ira was working as a mechanic at a new-car dealership near by. Soon after their marriage, they moved to a shared facilities with the family of Ira's older sister, Carlton and Ruth Imo Harrington Pennell. The Great Depression was raging and the Country's economic system was on the rocks. Richard E. Harrington, the author of this book, was born on 23 December 1931 in St. Frances Hospital in Columbus, Ohio.

 

1931

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira E. Harrington (Audrey L.); Residence year 1931; Address 1288 E. Engler, Columbus, OH; occupation: Mech, McClure-Nesbitt Motor Co.; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1931 [Ruth I. & Carlton P. Pennell are also listed at this 1288 E. Engler address]

 


 


51

 

 

 


 

1932

 

Audra L. Harrington, Ira E. Harrington, with their new son, Richard E. Harrington; and Ruth I. Harrington-Pennell, Carlton P. Pennell, with their sons, Roger Pennell, and George W. Purcell, went to Miami, Florida in early 1932 where they constructed a boat and began a commercial fishing business. The new business was financed with money that Audra had from a life insurance policy from her departed husband, Lawrence Hines. The venture was cut short and they all returned to Circleville, Ohio about July 26, 1932 to attend the funeral of Easter Marie Harrington-Ward, youngest sister of Ira and Ruth. They did not go back to Florida.

 

1933

 

Ira told a story about him and a friend going gigging for frogs. They had finished gigging and returned to the friends Model-A Ford when they discovered that were being pursued by the game warden. Ira had a Model-A Ford just like the friend's car in which they were being chased. They outran the game warden and Ira was dropped off at his home. His friend drove on just seconds ahead of the game warden arriving at Ira's house. Ira ran into the house, closed the door and waited in the dark, looking out the window. The game warden drove up, felt the radiator of Ira's car and found it cold. The game warden drove away.

 

1934

 

In about 1934 Ira and Audra decided to buy a house with a little acreage in the country near Circleville, Ohio. The Great Depression was in full control of the National economy and work was hard to find and uncertain. Property with a little acreage would provide shelter and land to raise sufficient food to provide for the family. They had no money to buy their dream, however, and decided to borrow it from Audra's father, Will Young. Upon request, Audra's father took a shoe box from under his bed full of government bonds that he had bought from income from oil wells on his property. He removed enough bonds for the $600 loan, cashed them and provided the money.

 

1936

 

In 1936 the Great Depression still gripped the Nation. Ira was working at about any job he could find. At the suggestion of a friend, Carl Dutro, he agreed to try selling Watkins Products. This involved using his own car and peddling the Watkins-brand of products house-to-house. The product line was very large and included some staple foods, Watkins Liniment, Watkins Salve, Watkins Salt and Pepper, brushes, sponges, soap, and many more products. Sales were on commission. As a promotion, the Watkins agency gave away song books and other paper products. Ira was never a good salesman and hated the job. He soon decided that he wasn't making any money at it and stopped.

 

1937

 

Shortly after giving up on selling Watkins Products, Ira and his youngest brother, Fred Harrington, who was 9-years his junior, went into the hog-butchering business. They would go the stock market and buy one or more pigs. Ira had a trailer that he used for hauling pigs and all of the equipment for butchering. Ira and Fred would kill the pig, scald it, scrape off the hair, butcher it and prepare the meat for sale. Audra helped with the preparation and wrapping of the meat products. Ira and Fred would then peddle it around

 


 


52

 

 

 


the country side and sell it. It was a lot of work -- butchering is no easy job. Uncle Fred had no investment in the business except for his labor. He was a good peddler, however, and outsold Ira. The business went on the rocks when Ira discovered that Fred was making sales and keeping the money. Fred also went back to customers who had bought on credit, collected the outstanding credit and kept the money.

 

1938

 

With the election of Franklin D. Roosevelt, several programs were undertaken to try to pull the country out of the depression. One was the Works Progress Administration (WPA). This was largely a make-work program that did public work on a wide range of infrastructure, cultural and art activities. One such activity was the repair and painting of bridges. Ira applied to and was hired by the WPA. His job was to help paint bridges. He didn't particularly like the work but it was a job. Before long he became a specialist at painting the reflective stripes on bridges. He worked for the WPA until he could find a job more to his liking.

 

From the 1940 Federal Census for Pickaway Township, Pickaway County, Ohio; Dresbach road through county line enumerated 19 April 1940 by Fred Dudleson [all members of household born in Ohio]

Ira Harrington, head, age 40, occupation: mechanic, auto mechanic

Audra Harrington, wife, age 32

Richard Harrington, son, age 8

 

William Harrington, son, age 7

Patricia Sue Harrington, dau., age 3

 

1940

 

This potentially lethal accident occurred on the return trip home from a visit to Audra's parents, Will and Ole Young. Ira was driving his Model-A Ford sedan. Ira's father, William “Bill” Alvin Harrington, was along for the visit. It had been raining and the road was wet. As we crested a small hill and were descending on the other side, Ira applied his breaks and the car went into a spin. It slid making a complete 360 degree spin but remaining on the paved road and came to a stop pointed in the same direction that we had been traveling. Not much was said at the time of the event. Later both Audra and Ira commented that their passenger, Ira's dad - Bill Harrington, who was riding in the front seat between them, turned as white as a sheet. The Harrington kids, myself included, were riding in the back seat, fully enjoying the maneuver.

 

1941

 

With World War II raging, American Industry was gearing up for maximum war materials production. The draft had syphoned much of the man-power needed for the building of the war machine and its operation. The older men and the women of the Nation had to fill in the gap left by the military. Ira joined the operation by helping construct new manufacturing plants in Marion and Ravenna, Ohio. This required that he rent a room for over-night during the work-week and commute home for the weekend.

 


 


53

 

 

1943

Ira Harrington was in the hospital with pneumonia in the spring of 1943. This date is fixed by June coming from Indianapolis for a visit and was pregnant with her only son, Bobbie Franklin. Ira had been painting the eve-spouts on the farm-house while standing on a ladder that reached to the 2nd story. He was using an aluminized, oil-based paint to protect the iron-based eves. Ira complained of the harsh smell of the paint solvent. Whether the solvent was exacerbating an existing condition or was causing it, was unclear. Whatever the case, the condition soon turned into pneumonia. Ira was never one to take more than home-remedies but he eventually agreed to seek medical help. He went to Dr. Black who was an old physician who practiced in Circleville. Dr. Black prescribed two placebos; a sugar pill and a charcoal pill. Ira did not benefit from either and soon became delirious and uncontrollable. At the insistence of his wife, Audra, the doctor was changed to Dr. Vemont Kerns who immediately put Ira in the Berger Hospital and on antibiotics. After 2 or 3 very troublesome days and nights during which a neighbor, Roy Strawser, stayed throughout the night to keep Ira in bed and under control, he began to improve. This turned out to be another of several near-death experiences for Ira. Ira had been expected to die from this pneumonia. Had he died, this book would have a significantly different ending.

 

1946

 

Ira was the union steward when he worked for the Containers Corporation of America. This role pitted him against management, a role that he enjoyed. He told a story of saving a guy's job, who was nicknamed Shorty, that the management wanted to fire. Ira said that he probably should have been fired, but it was his job to keep it from happening.

 

1947

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira Harrington; Residence year 1947; Address RD 1, Circleville, OH; phone: 1922; occupation: emp Container Corp; Publication title: Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1947

 

1948

 

In 1948 Ira decided to start his own business in the form of a welding shop. His work at the Containers Corporation of America had given him ample experience welding and plenty of opportunity at equipment and metal construction to qualify for the work. His wife, Audra, however, was quite concerned that he may not be qualified to manage the finances and administrative part of the business. She volunteered to help provide administrative assistance and support. Ira opened his business that he named "Harrington's Welding" in a moderate sized, all wooden, two story building that he bought on Western Avenue near the corner of Mound Street in Circleville, Ohio. The business thrived until he retired in 1960. It was strictly a one-man shop that would not have supported more than one family. His clients were largely farmers in the area for which he did miscellaneous welding, re-shoeing or re-laying of plow points, building farm wagons, etc. He did a small amount of welding and repair on automotive equipment. A circus company regularly wintered at the Pickaway Fair Grounds which kept him busy during the winter months building and repairing their equipment. Ira bought the large, three-story, red brick house and lot on which the shop was located. He sold the property in the country and moved into the first floor of the red brick making his commute to his welding shop the short walk of about 70-feet thru the back yard to the shop.

 


 


54

 

 

 


 

1949

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira E, Harrington (Audra L); Residence year 1949; Address RD 1, Circleville, OH; phone: 1922; (Harrington's Wldg Shop); Publication title: Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1949

 

1949

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: (Ira E, Harrington) 216(r) W Mound; year 1949; phone: 139; Publication title: Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1949 [second 1949 City Directory entry.]

 

1950

 

Ira and Audra's oldest son, R.E. Harrington, left home in the autumn of 1949 to begin college at The Ohio State University. Ira built a motor scooter for Dick to travel to classes. In 1952 Ira bought a new 1952 Ford sedan and gave Dick the old 1936 family Plymouth.

In 1950 with the help of his youngest son, William "Bill" Young Harrington, Ira started construction on a small two bedroom house on the empty lot beside the large red brick house. He and Audra moved into the new house where they lived the remainder of their lives. Ira converted the large house into three apartments that he rented. The third floor apartment was usually empty because it had no toilet facilities. However, even that space was occasionally rented as a sleeping room to a single renter. Rent from the red brick along with social security was Ira and Audra's main source of income in their retirement. Audra resumed working as a beautician after Ira's retirement, more out of boredom than need. With the children gone, Ira and Audra slowly prospered and their lives included travel and more recreational activities.

 

1952

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira E. Harrington; Spouse: Audra L. Harrington; Residence year 1952; Address: Circleville, OH; occupation: Wldg (welding); Publication title: Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1952

 

1955

 

Ira vowed that he would retire at the age of 60. His plan was to build a power-boat that he would take to Florida and fish. He bought plans with patterns for the components to construct a 26-foot long, 8-foot beam, power boat. During periods of slack business, he built his boat in his welding shop. It was equipped with a converted 8-cylinder, Lincoln automobile engine and transmission.

 

1959

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira E. Harrington (Audrey); Residence year 1959; Address: 216 W. Mound, Circleville, OH; Publication title: Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1959

 


 

 


55

 

 

1960


Ira retired from the welding shop at age 60. He sold most of his equipment to a local Circleville, Ohio competitor who had recently opened his own shop. Ira kept his service truck to pull his newly completed boat. In the summer of 1960 he headed for Venice, Florida. He bought a mobile home near Venice and launched his boat. Venice is on the western coast of Florida about 90 miles south of St. Petersburg. A year or two before Ira arrived in Florida, a periodic event of the Red Tide occurred which sickens and kills many of the fish in the Gulf of Mexico unlucky enough to be in its path. The result is a cessation of fishing for from a few months to a few years.

 

1961

 

Audra rented their furnished house in Circleville to two school teachers and joined Ira at Venice, Florida.

 

1962

 

By the summer of 1962, Ira and Audra tired of Venice, Florida and decided to go back home to Circleville, Ohio. On their return trip to Ohio they stopped for a visit with the author, R.E. Harrington, who was living and working in Pensacola, Florida. During that visit, Ira gave Dick the boat that they had left in Venice. Dick moved the boat to a marina in Pensacola within about a month. In 1963 the marina caught fire and burned all of the boats, including the un-insured boat that Ira had built.

 

1965

 

After retiring at about age of 60, Ira became bored. He built himself a small light weight fishing boats. A friend who saw it wanted to buy it, so he sold it. He built another for himself and again sold it to a friend. Before long, he was taking orders for his boats. He made and sold perhaps a dozen boats. The project helped him get over his retirement boredom but it, also, soon became boring. He made one more boat which he kept.

 

1972

 

About 1972, Ira, his oldest son, Dick, and Dick's two sons, Daniel and Gregory went to Canada on a camping and fishing vacation.

 

1974

 

Ira vowed that he would never fly. His claim was that if he were ever killed by an airplane, it would have to fall on him. In the early 1970s, his oldest son, R.E. Harrington, was working in Washington, D.C. Ira and Audra wanted to visit but did not want to drive. Ira finely relented and took a plane to and from Washington, D.C.

 

1980

 

Ira's health began failing with obvious signs of dementia. He was diagnosed as having insufficient oxygen to the brain because of decreased blood flow to that area, brought on by hardening of the arteries. His doctors said that it was likely a product of life-long smoking.

 


 

 


56

 

 

1983


Ira died 24 November 1983.

 

From the Ohio, Deaths, 1908-1932, 1938-1944, & 1958-2007

NAME:

Ira E Harrington

 

BIRTH DATE:

1899

 

BIRTH PLACE:

Ohio,

 

GENDER:

Male

 

 

RACE:

White

 

 

RESIDENCE PLACE:

Circleville, Pickaway, Ohio, United States

DEATH DATE:

23 Nov 1983

HOSPITAL OF DEATH:

Home

DEATH LACE:

Circleville, Pickaway, Ohio, USA

CERTIFICATE:

085377

 

AGE AT DEATH:

84

 

CERTIFIER: Physician

 

SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER:  288-01-4159

 

MARITAL STATUS:Married

 

Mr. Ira Harrington obituary:

 

Mr. Ira E. Harrington, 84, 212 W. Mound St. died this morning at 3 a.m. at his residence. Born August 28, 1899, in Circleville, he was the son of William A. and Elizabeth Pence-Harrington.

He was the retired owner of Harrington Welding Shop.

 

He was preceded in death by four brothers and three sisters.

 

Survivors include his wife, Audra Young Harrington; two sons, Richard E. Harrington of Washington, D. C., and William Harrington of Circleville; two daughters, Patricia Reynolds of Circleville and Mrs. Martin (June) Walters of Washington (state of Washington); 13 grandchildren and five great-grandchildren; one sister, Ola Eblin of Columbus.

Graveside memorial services will be held Friday at 2:30 PM in Forrest Cemetery (Circleville, OH) with Pastor John Mittermaier officiating. Memorial contributions may be made to Trinity Lutheran Church.

Ira was cremated and his ashes are buried at the site of his and his wife's tombstone in Forest Cemetery, Circleville, Ohio. When Ira's daughter, Patricia Sue Harrington Hutchinson Reynolds died on 28 Apr 2013, she was buried in the grave of her father. Ira's urn of ashes were removed and reburied in the same grave at her request.

 

Such is the chronology of the life of Ira Edward Harrington as best it could be described from public records, stories related by Ira about himself, and from the author's memory. So, who then was Ira Edward Harrington? Was he a complex or simple man? Was he wise or irresponsible? The following are the author's personal assessment. As you read the following conclusions, keep in mind the opening paragraphs. “It is true that we can never fully know our parents.” Also, keep in mind that it is very difficult - almost impossible - for one to assess a member of the family without significant bias. But, I will try to be objective.

 

Ira was a smart yet average man. Some terms that come to mind that apply to Ira, to varying degrees, include: macho, confident, independent, proud, honest,

 


 


57

 

 

 


courageous, hard-working, mechanically inclined, intelligent, prejudice, self-centered, loyal, a limited formal education and a temper. He enjoyed hunting, fishing, dogs, hard work, mechanical challenges, his family, close friends, coon hunting, and complements. His taste in foods was limited to basic foods. He did not like fancy dishes, wine, mixed drinks, sandwich meats, carrots, or any wild meats such as wild rabbit, squirrel, groundhog, etc.

As with most people, I suspect, it is likely that the experiences of Ira in his parental family were among the most important factors in forming who Ira E. Harrington would be throughout his life. Some of the main factors include the period in history when he lived, the size of his parental family, the poverty of the family, the competition within the family, the role-models of the extended family, the education level of his parents and himself, the priority of education by his parents, and more. Many of these factors can be overcome or reoriented in later life. In Ira's case some were, some were not.

 

The lack of education of both of Ira's parents would have been a major factor in his upbringing. It kept the family in poverty throughout Ira's formative years. Life was hard. There was barely enough to eat and wear. Competition within the family was keen. Etiquette and manners were subordinate to needs.

A family trait within the members of Ira Harrington and his siblings was competition with other siblings. This competition manifested itself in several ways. One was an apparent need to brag about one's own accomplishments and the need to minimize achievements of other siblings. While the siblings seemed to enjoy getting together, each sibling seemed to display a need to brag about their own accomplishments. It could bring about a boisterous level of discussion and give the impression that each sibling was selfish and considered their own story to be the most important in the gathering. In the case of Ira, this attitude carried over into the home. Perhaps this observation is only an impression of a child-member of the Ira Harrington family. But it was clear that Ira was always right, always the decision-maker and disciplinarian, always the person who controlled all aspects of the family. In reality, this was probably more a reflection of how things were in his parent's home. It probably also reflected the fact that while 'dad was the law,’ there was not much law. It was more an environment in which the kids ran wild and free, without much guidance.

 

Another manifestation of being self-centered was that almost all family activities involved things that interested Ira. Ira was an outdoors man. Only bad weather and darkness kept him inside. Family entertainment included hunting, fishing, and occasional camping trips. He liked to work and always had a project in progress or in mind. He was talented, cleaver, and good at almost everything he undertook. He took great pleasure in his accomplishments. He was helpful to neighbors since it provided an opportunity to demonstrate his ability to analyze a problem and demonstrate his ability to solve it. He would frequently brag about accomplishments that he experienced on his job. This talent served Ira well when he had his own welding business.

 

Ira took great pride in his ability to provide for himself and his family with almost all of their material needs. It appeared to be the sense of accomplishment that drove him. He had a need, a desire and a drive to be a harvester. With the help of his wife and family, he raised most of his own family's food. He was almost totally independent of the supermarket. The small four acre subsistence farm provided most of the family needs. He hunted and fished for food. He kept honey bees; planted, harvested and preserved a full range of vegetables; raised and butchered his own meat; kept a milk cow; and more. He also hunted and trapped for pelts for extra money. He made his own electricity

 


 


58

 

 

 


with a home-made wind-charger that he built. He cut his own wood for fuel. He expanded his house with used blocks and reclaimed lumber. He dug his own well, piped the water into the kitchen where it was pumped with a hand pump into a concrete sink that he built. He built his own house. He did most of this by himself, without help other than members of his immediate family.

Ira had a deep dislike for politicians and people in authority. He viewed politicians of any level to be one of the main sources of problems that the Country faced. His dislike of constraints extended to many of the laws and regulations he encountered. He was persuaded in his views by the observation that he was born and lived much of his life without many of the laws and regulations and felt that things ran well. He could never acknowledge that the rise in population might need regulations and rules to more smoothly govern the interaction and conduct of people. He saw all such laws and regulations that inhabited his freedom only as they applied to him. This was likely a manifestation of his early up-bringing.

 

Ira believed in God and religion but distrusted organized religion. He used to say that he could go into the woods, away from people and be closer to God than in any church. He viewed the church, any church, as a human manipulation of religion for profit.

On most subjects, Ira had thought long and hard and had developed his own views and theories of his world. If they differed for others, he was willing to argue for them but seldom was he willing to modify them. He had great confidence and faith in himself and believed that he had an equal or better chance of being right as someone else. He was an island of confidence and would quickly agree that his views might differ but never agree that he was wrong.

 

Ira was a product of a dying - perhaps now dead - survival culture. A culture when neighbor helped neighbor without expecting pay or immediate return of the favor. He grew up in a time when trading was common and payment in services and products one had to offer were acceptable. Dad paid doctor bills with produce from the garden -- he didn't have the money. He worked nights at the Containers Corporation of America and would get out of bed during the day to repair a neighbor’s tractor. They in turn would plow his garden or give him straw if he needed it. People seemed to trust that in the longer run things would even out - no one would take or get an advantage. Agreements didn't have to be detailed to the letter. Later in his life this resulted in a number of misunderstandings and disagreements. An example of such a contract was when he agreed to buy used concrete block from a nearby church that was dismantling a block wall. Ira's understanding of the agreement was that he could buy only the block that he needed for the agreed-upon price. The church elder's understanding was that he would buy all of the block and haul away that which he did not need. On another occasion he bought hay from a farmer for cow feed. When the hay was delivered, it was a beautiful, high-grade, alfalfa hay that came at a price that was 2 to 3 times more expensive than he expected. Still another time, Ira agreed to clear-cut wood on a neighbor's farm for the wood. Well into the job, the neighbor asked Ira for his half of the wood; a part of the agreement that had not been discussed. Fortunately, this kind of misunderstanding did not happen often.

 

Ira could be very judgmental. He had a dislike for certain "kinds" of people including sissies, homosexuals, cowards, effeminate men, and liars. He distrusted politicians, lawyers, preachers, high-pressure salesmen and saleswomen, advertisers, the wealthy, and people whom he thought were grossly overpaid for the work they do, such as sports figures, movie stars, business executives, etc.

 


 


59

 

 

 


 

Love was a difficult emotion for Ira. Love seemed to collide with his sense of macho and masculinity that he valued. He considered the outward expression of love as effeminate and even sissy. Yet, he clearly loved his wife, Audra, and his family. He could not apply the term to his siblings or parents, but, he "liked" them. I never heard Ira tell his wife that he loved her, although I’m sure that he did. He never told his children he love them and seldom would cuddle with them. It was a word and emotion that was somehow connected to his image of a sissy. It was important that his sons not be sissies. Being a sissy meant that you didn't cry. And, you didn't yield to non-masculine emotions like hugging or showing affection.

 

But Ira had all those emotions. He just couldn't expose them. He clearly was proud of his children. He would eagerly acknowledge or even raise the subject of certain attributes in his kids that he admired such as talent on the basketball court, track and other sports, honors won in school, going to college, Patty's attractiveness, and more. He had fear for our safety or having had a near injury -- he would sometimes hide his feelings with scolding or anger. In later years after I had left home, he was clearly glad to see me return. Perhaps the closest he ever came to showing affection was in an admonition at the end of a visit, "Don't stay away so long."

 

Yet in spite of Ira's hard exterior and the taboo of ever appearing to be a sissy, we had some wonderful times. They mostly involved doing things together. More times than not it was some work-related event; sometimes it involved hunting or fishing or visiting the Old-Mans-Cave or visiting grandma and grandpa Harrington or Young.

When it came to love, Ira had all the emotions of any well-adjusted man. He just couldn't express them. He could not allow himself to even try.

Ira was 5-feet, 8-inches tall. He weighed 175 pounds all of his adult life with little variation. He had a full head of hair throughout his life that over time went from a brown/red to snow white. He always considered himself a red-head. He always claimed Irish as his ethnicity. Ira was seldom sick during his life. He periodically suffered from a strained back that at times made him bedfast. His two most serious bouts with ill health were: 1) In about 1919 he was in an 8-day coma from head injuries suffered in a motorcycle accident, and 2) In 1943 he had a serious bout with pneumonia. As he approached the end of his life, around 1980, he began suffering from dementia. Over a period of about 3 years he was reduced to a condition similar to a new-born baby. He died in his sleep at home. Ira Edward Harrington was cremated and buried in Forest Cemetery in Circleville, Ohio

 

Dortha Ellen Moore (21 Jul 1901- 01 Oct 1997)                                                 Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

The first partner of my father, Ira Harrington, for whom we have a record was Dortha Ellen Moore. Dortha Moore was the mother of my half-sister, June Lucille Harrington (1 Jun 1920- 28 Apr 2003). No record of a marriage between Ira and Dortha has been found. Dortha was the daughter of a carpenter, John William Moore (1859-1947) and his wife, Nettie Marlina Rowland-Moore (1870-1956) who lived in Tarlton, Ohio. Dortha Moore was the third child and the first girl in a family of four boys and two girls. The Moore family-line had been in Tarlton, Ohio for at least 3-generations before Dortha was born. In the 1910 Federal Census, Dortha was listed as being 8-years old and the entire family was intact. By 1920 it appears that Dortha’s parental family had broken up. Dortha’s father was remarried and was living with his son in the family of his new wife, Laura. Dortha’s two younger brothers were in the children’s home in eastern Lancaster, Ohio. In 1930, three members of the Moore family were enumerated with Nettie

 


 


60

 

 

 


Marlina Moore listed as the head of the family. Dortha does not appear with her parental family again. However, in the year 1919 she would have been with Ira Harrington since she got pregnant about September of 1919 with her and Ira’s daughter, June Lucille Harrington.

 

Dortha eventually abandoned her daughter, June Harrington, and went on with her life. Her daughter, June Harrington, was reared by her grandparents, Bill and Lizzie Pence-Harrington in Circleville, Ohio. After her father, Ira Harrington, married Vivian Radford, The couple moved to Florida taking June with them. Dortha married 4-times, counting her relationship with Ira Harrington as a marriage, which it probably was not. Her second relationship (probably her first real marriage) was with Acy Clemon Keplar with whom she had two more children, Ross Edward Kepler (5 Feb 1924 - 21 Dec 1984) and Lewis Calvin Kepler (15 Dec 1925 - 19 Jul 1959). Both brothers married and had military service. Ross divorced from his wife, Dorothy Ellen Tipton on 5 Aug 1963. At the time of their divorce, they had 3 minor children. One of their sons was Lewis Edward Keplar who married Diane Rose Tucker. The names of their other children are unknown to me. Lewis was married to Ellen C. (maiden name unknown). According to his death certificate, Lewis was in the military [U.S. Navy] in WWII and the Korean War. Lewis C. Keplar died 19 July 1959 in Methodist Hospital, Gary, Indiana of Bulbar Poliomyelitis (polio). He was 33 years old. His address at the time of his death was 4428 Marquette St. East Gary, Indiana, USA. He was buried 21 July 1959 at Ridge Lawn Cemetery, Gary Indiana.

 

Dortha apparently married a third time to an unknown person. Her fourth and final marriage was to Charles Milar. The date of their marriage is unknown. Charles Milar died in 1961. Dortha died on 1 October 1997 at the ripe old age of 96-years.

 

June Lucille Harrington (1 June 1920 - 28 Apr 2003)                                        Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Robert Paul Franklin, Sr. (27 May 1921 - 22 Nov 1997)

Robert Paul Franklin, Jr. (9 Aug 1943 - living)

 + Thelma Jean Hillmer (14 Feb 1944 – living)

Scott Alan Franklin (26 Aug 1965 – living)

+ Kelly Hollshew (unknown-living)

Amanda Nicole Franklin (26 Apr 1999-living)

Julie Marie Franklin (10 Nov 1967 - living)

+ David Patrick Moraine (05 May 1965 – living)

Benjamin Paul Moraine (21 May 1988-living)

+ Courtney Church (unknown- ?)

Savannah Kay Moraine (21 Oct 2009-living)

 

Tanner Stone Moraine (02 Jan 2014-living)

 

Corey Scott Moraine (02 May 1991-living)

 

Megan Melissa Moraine (02 Mar 1999-living)

Bailey Marie Moraine (26 Apr 2001-living)

+ Martin Luther Walters, Jr. (14 Jun 1920 - 11 May 1992)

 

June Harrington was the daughter of Ira E. Harrington and Dortha Ellen Moore. She “picked” her own first name by being born on the first day of June. Her young parents, Ira and Dortha, were unable to care for her so June was reared by her paternal grandparents, Bill and Lizzie Harrington, until she graduated from Circleville High School in 1938. Almost immediately after graduation, she moved to Columbus, Ohio where she worked for a few years. On 8 Aug 1942, she married Robert “Bob” Paul

 


 


61

 

 


Franklin (27 May 1921 - 22 Nov 1997) who was soon to become a soldier in WWII. One year and one day after their first marriage anniversary, June gave birth to her only child. They named him after his father, Robert “Bobby” Paul Franklin, Jr.

June and Bob’s marriage failed in early 1950 resulting in divorce. June raised her son as a single mother in Columbus, Ohio. She held several mid-level jobs that included secretary and apartment building manager. After about 25-years, on 16 December 1979, June married Martin “Marty” Luther Walters. She and Marty had been in the same class in Circleville High School and were both in their Junior Class Play in 1937. They lived several years in the state of Washington where Marty worked for a contractor at the Columbia River Facility of the Department of Energy dealing with the disposal of radioactive waste from the construction of the U.S. atomic bombs. They next lived to Meadview, Arizona where they had moved to be in a low-humidity climate to accommodate June’s worsening asthma. Marty died of cancer on 11 May 1992 in the Desert Springs Hospital, Las Vegas, Nevada. After Marty’s death, June moved to Henderson, Nevada to be closer to medical facilities.

 

June died on 28 Apr 2003 at her home in Henderson, Nevada. She was one month shy of being 83-years old.

 

Robert Paul Franklin, Jr. (09 Aug 1943 - living)                                       Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Robert Paul Franklin, Jr. was born at the Berger Hospital in Circleville, Ohio just 19 days before the birthday of his great grandfather, Ira Harrington, who was 40-years his senior. His mother, June Lucille Harrington-Franklin, had just turned 23-years old.

On 23 Jan 1965 Robert married Thelma Jean Hillmer in Columbus, Ohio and began his family of two children. Scott Alan Franklin was born on 26 Aug 1965 and Julie Marie Franklin was born on 10 Nov 1967. Scott married Kelly Hollshew on 1 Nov 1998 and the couple added Amanda Nicole Franklin 26 Apr 1999. Julie married David Patrick Moraine on 8 Dec 1987 and had four children: Benjamin Paul Moraine born 21 May 1988, Corey Scott Moraine born 2 May 1991, Megan Melissa Moraine born 2 Mar 1999 and Bailey Marie Moraine born 26 Apr 2001. Of these four, only Benjamin has expanded the line – so far. Benjamin married Courtney J.

 

Church on 10 Oct 2008 in Wichita, Texas and had two children: Savannah Kay Moraine born 21 Oct 2009 and Tanner Stone Moraine born 02 Jan 2014.

Robert Franklin, Jr. recognized the emerging role of communication technology and started his own business in the field. About a year and a half later, in 1984, he took a partner, William E. Tittel. Business was good and he eventually sold his share in the business and is now enjoying retirement.

 

Vivian (Lil) Radford (15 Jan 1900 – Aug 1975)                                          Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Ira Edward Harrington married Vivian U. Radford on 14 Jul 1923. Both Vivian and Ira had been involved in a romantic relationship once before. Ira had a daughter, June Lucille Harrington, with Dortha Ellen Moore. There is no evidence that Ira and Dortha ever married. In July 1923 June was just over 3-years old and was living with Ira’s parents. Vivian had married Frank O. Lenhart before 1920 but apparently had no children. Sometime after their wedding, Ira and Vivian took June Lucille Harrington to Florida

 


 


62

 

 

 


where they spent about 3-years. Part, if not all of that time, was spent in Tampa, Florida where Ira worked as an automotive mechanic. A city directory for the year 1926 shows Ira and Vivian still in Tampa. But by 1930 Vivian was back in Columbus living with her parents.

 

Audra Lavada Young (24 Jan 1907 - 8 Apr 1990)               Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Audra’s first husband of only 9-months, Lawrence William Hines (17 Aug 1904 - 27 May 1929), died on 27 May 1929 of a heart ailment. Audra used part of Lawrence’s life insurance money to enroll in a beautician school in Columbus, Ohio. She had taken a room in the home of the sister of her brother-in-law, Freda Mary Weber-Landefeld. From there she would commuted by streetcar to-and-from her school. Freda Landefeld’s husband, Alfred J. Landefeld, had recently died on 11 Aug 1926 of consumption and Freda was renting rooms in her home to make ends meet. Freda had two children, Loretta Freda and Leverne Alfred Landefeld.

 

Ira had returned to Columbus, Ohio from Tampa, Florida, probably before 1930. He was enumerated in the 1930 U.S. Federal Census on 4 April 1930 as a lodger in the home of a family named Loos. But, sometime after April 1930 he also rented a room from Freda Landefeld. That is where my father and mother met. Ira Edward Harrington and my mother, Audra Lavada Young-Hines, married in Circleville, Ohio on 24 Feb 1931. I was their first child born 23 December 1931.

 

I have not included further details about my mother, Audra Lavada Young-Hines-Harrington, in this book because I have written a separate book on that family line. Instead, I have gone directly to the branches of Ira and Audra’s children and progeny.

 

Richard Edward Harrington (23 December 1931 – living) [The author of this book]

 

+ Lois Anne Wolfe (3 October 1931 - living)                       Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Daniel Edward Harrington (15 Jan 1955 – living)

Gregory Phillip Harrington (26 Jun 1957 - living)

Pamela Anne Harrington (20 Jun 1958 - living)

Margaret “Peggy” Elaine Harrington (09 May 1960 - living)

Neil William Harrington (17 Jun 1963 - living)

+ Margaret Jadwiga Stasikowski (31 March 1948 - living)

        Kyle Ira Stasikowski Harrington (28 January – living)

 

Richard "Dick" Edward Harrington, the first child born to Ira Edward and Audra Lavada Young Harrington was born 23 December 1931 in Grant Hospital, Columbus, Ohio. The Nation was in the grip of the Great Depression and the majority of the western world's citizens were impacted in one way or other. For the Ira and Audra Harrington family, it meant a move from Ohio to Miami, Florida where the Ira Harrington family and his sister, Ruth Pennell’s, family decided to start their own business catching and selling fish. About two months after Dick was born, the families drove to Florida, built a fishing boat and went into business. Audra found the move not to her liking and spent most of her time caring for Dick in their new environment. While the new business was a success up to the point of catching fish, there was almost no market for the product. By June of 1932 it became obvious that the business was not making enough money to support the two families.

 

On 26 July 1932 Ira and Ruth received word that their baby sister, Easter Marie Harrington-Thompson, had died suddenly and unexpectedly the previous day.

 


 

 


63

 

 

 


Immediately the Ira Harrington family set off in their Model-A Ford on a marathon, non-stop (except to buy fuel) 21-hour drive from Miami, Florida to Circleville, Ohio to attend Easter's funeral. Heartbroken and exhausted, they arrived in time for the funeral. The Ira Harrington family never returned to Miami. And so began the life of their first child, Richard E. Harrington.

On 10 March 1933, within 8-months of the return of the Ira Harrington family to Circleville, Ohio a second son was born, William Young Harrington. The economy was still grim and Ira's job was barely breaking even. Ira and Audra decided to avoid the expense of rent by buying a 4-acre plot of land with a run-down brick house on it. They borrowed the total purchase price of the property, $600, from Audra's parents who were farmers in Monroe County, Ohio. The house provided a rent-free home while the land was sufficient to provide most of their food from a large garden and sufficient pasture for a cow and some pigs. Ira continued to work for a meager wage at the Straw Board, a paper plant in Circleville, and supplemented the table by hunting and fishing, both avocations which he loved.

 

The 4-acre farm proved to be Dick's home for the next 13 years while he attended school from 1st through 12th grades at Pickaway Township School. In 1949 after graduating from high school and working the summer in his father's welding shop, Dick entered a 5-year, college of Chemical Engineering program at The Ohio State University in Columbus, Ohio.

College was never a priority in the Harrington family. In fact, it was never seriously considered by any family members including Dick. Both the Ira Harrington and Audra Young families descended from a long line of farmers where college was not considered necessary or even beneficial. Being on the cusp of recovery from the Great Depression, college was not economically possible. Dick describes his path through college as an anomaly - almost an accident. He gives his high school principal, Mr. John Hardin, all the credit for his going to college. As graduation from high school approached, John Hardin asked Dick what he was planning to do after graduation. Dick had no idea so John Hardin asked if he ever considered going to college. He gave Dick an Ohio State University course catalog and suggested he peruse it calling attention to the courses in chemical engineering, an area where Dick had shown an interest in high school. Unknown to Dick, John Hardin applied for a scholarship for him at The Ohio State University. During the summer following high school graduation, John took Dick to the University to register. John worked with the registrar's office to secure a work-for-room situation with one of the professors at OSU.

 

Dick was not strongly motivated to go to college. While the idea was enticing, it was foreign. With no other option other than working for his father in his welding shop business, Dick decided to try a quarter - maybe a year - studying engineering classes with the idea that even one year of college might help land a job as a draftsman. And so college began with the understanding that any further progress would require that he earn enough money to pay for his own tuition, room and board.

 

Being still 17-years old when he graduated from high school and entered college, Dick was still too young for the draft that was in effect from the World War II military effort. By the following year, after turning 18-years old, the draft was a real threat to interrupt completion of college. Dick joined the Naval Reserves during his first year at The Ohio State University and in early 1950 signed up for the US Naval Reserve Officer's Training (NROTC) program. This program required summer training at Newport, Road Island's Narragansett Naval Training Center following the first year of college and a final training session the year before graduation. Protection from the draft during college

 


 


64

 

 

 


years, however, was assured. Upon completion of a degree as a Chemical Engineer, the contract required going onto active duty for 2-years.

 

In the sophomore year of the 5-year Chemical Engineering program, Dick re-met a lovely young lady, Lois Anne Wolfe, through her first cousin, Ronald Luther List. Lois was going to college at Ohio University in Athens, Ohio. It was a re-meeting because Lois and Dick had both gone to Pickaway Twp. School together, in the 1st-through-3rd grades. Lois was studying to become a teacher at Ohio University in Athens, Ohio. They dated for well over a year and married on 25 September 1952. That year Lois changed schools from Ohio University in Athens, Ohio to The Ohio State University in Columbus, Ohio where she finished her degree in elementary teaching. The next year she taught 2nd grade in the Westerville school system. Dick worked at Varo Engineering Corp., a small civil engineering firm in Columbus, Ohio as a draftsman until he graduated in the Autumn quarter of 1954. Dick was the first college graduate in his Harrington family and to his knowledge, the second in his extended family. His first cousin, Wayne Edward Weber graduated a year earlier than Dick with a degree in accounting. Since undertaking this genealogy research, other relatives have been found to have graduated from college, but in subsequent years. On 15 January 1955 Dick and Lois's first son, Daniel Edward Harrington, was born at the Ohio State University Hospital.

 

Dick's first job was in Pensacola, Florida with the Chemstrand Corporation, a large plant that made nylon for every conceivable end-use ranging from women's nylon hose to heavy-duty truck tires and parachutes. It was a permanent job but one to be soon interrupted to satisfy the terms of the NROTC program. In June of 1955 Dick reported to Pearl Harbor, Hawaii for duty aboard the USS Current, ARS-22. Lois and Daniel soon moved to Pearl Harbor where they lived in housing on a section of the base for Naval Officers. Dick lived with his family when his ship was in Pearl Harbor but he was at sea about a third of the time. With a long deployment to the Arctic Ocean coming up for the USS Current ARS-22, Lois and Dan returned to Ohio where Gregory Philip Harrington was born on 26 June 1957. Following a 27-month tour of duty (May 1955 - August 1957), Dick and his family returned to Pensacola, Florida where they lived for the next 6-years. While there, Pamela Ann Harrington was born in Pensacola on 20 June 1958, Margaret (Peggy) Elaine Harrington was born on 9 May 1960 and Neil William Harrington was born on 17 June 1963.

 

In December of 1963, bored with life in Pensacola and being away from the extended family in Ohio, Dick accepted a job in Cincinnati, Ohio with the US Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (HEW) as a research engineer with the newly formed research organization that later became the research arm of the newly formed U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). For the next 18-years the family lived in several locations including Durham, N.C., Washington, D.C., back to Cincinnati, OH, and Ann Arbor, MI. In 1981 Dick changed agencies of the US Government to the U.S. Department of Energy that had recently been formed in 1977. He initially went to work as Deputy Director of the Morgantown Energy Technology Center (METC) in Morgantown, West Virginia. Two years later in 1983 he again returned to Washington, D.C. as Deputy Assistant Secretary for Fossil Fuels. After 4-years he retired from the government to start his own consulting business. Dick finally retired permanently about 1992.

 

Dick and Margaret (Margo) Stasikowski met when they worked in the US EPA. They married on 31 May 1991.

 


 


65

 

 

 


 

Since 1992 Dick has been working on family genealogy. He has written and published 5 genealogy books of family groups within his family. These include an initial book on his mother’s Jung/Young family, a genealogy of the Jackson family, a genealogy of his first wife’s Wolfe family and one on the Summers-Greene family. This Harrington book is number 5.

 

Daniel Edward Harrington (15 January 1955 – living)

+ Sharon Louise Desjardins (15 Nov 1953 - living)    

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

Daniel Edward Harrington was born 15 January 1955 in the Ohio State University Hospital in Columbus, OH. It was a relatively easy birth his mother, Lois Wolfe-Harrington, would later say. As her labor began, Dick drove Lois to the OSU Hospital just a few blocks from their rented home. The hospital staff, anticipating a long labor, urged Dick to go home. An hour later, Dick received a phone call reporting that he was the father of a healthy baby boy. Such was the beginning of Daniel Edward Harrington son to Lois Ann Wolfe Harrington, an elementary school teacher, and Richard (Dick) Edward Harrington, a newly graduated student in chemical engineering from The Ohio State University.

 

Within a few weeks, Daniel and his mother joined Dick in Pensacola, FL where Dick had taken his first job as a newly graduated chemical engineer. It was a short stay in Pensacola since Dick would soon be ordered to report aboard a U.S. Naval ship in June 1955. Dan and Lois lived with his grandparents, Russell and Mary Wolfe, for a few months while Dick's ship was on maneuvers in the Arctic Ocean. Lois and Dan then sailed from a naval base on the west coast of California to Pearl Harbor, Oahu, Hawaii, the home base of Dick's ship. They lived in officers' quarters on base at Pearl Harbor, Oahu, Hawaii. Daniel was 3-years old when he, his parents, and his new baby brother, Gregory Philip Harrington, returned to Pensacola, Florida. Dan completed kindergarten and first grade in Pensacola, transferring in mid-year of the second grade to a school in Cincinnati, OH where the family had moved in December of 1963. Dan's schooling was interrupted three more times before he graduated from Fort Hunt High School, Alexandria, VA in 1973. He enjoyed scouting and family camping trips while growing up.

 

College was never a strong priority in the Harrington household. It was encouraged by both his college-graduate parents but because of the modest income and the relatively large family, college would have to be earned by the student. Dan was motivated to go to college and registered at Old Dominion University in Norfolk, Virginia. He worked as a house painter over one summer to get enough money for tuition, room, board and buy a car. During one school year he worked as a pizza delivery-man to pay the bills. Once when he was making a delivery to a ship in the U.S. Navy shipyard, he left his car at the gangway to the quarter-deck of the ship to deliver the pizza. When he returned, his car was gone. The stolen car was recovered three days later with 100 additional miles on the odometer, money and wallet still in the glove compartment, and pizzas still in the delivery oven. Presumably some sailors had "borrowed" his car for a round trip to Virginia Beach about 50 miles away.

 

In addition to one year as a pizza delivery-man, he also worked as a wrecker driver, attendant, grease monkey and shift supervisor for a garage near the university.

Dan worked his way through college at Old Dominion University earning a BS in Environmental Health in 1978 and a Masters in Business Administration in 2006 from Averett University. His first job was at the Newport News Shipbuilding in Norfolk, VA where he spent his entire working career of 38 years. Starting as field industrial

 


 


66

 

 


hygienist, Dan was promoted to health and safety supervisor and health and safety manager. He attained professional certification from the American Board of Industrial Hygiene as Certified Industrial Hygienist in comprehensive practice. He married Sharon Louise Desjardins in 1982. He and Sharon never had children but they had lots of cats – maximum, four at one time.

Dan's hobbies included music and playing the guitar and recording songs. He loved fishing, traveling and technical stuff. He was a computer expert, strong in the application of most of the operating systems and programs.

Dan and Sharon lived in the Tidewater area of Virginia for all of their adult lives. As of this writing they plan to build a new home and retire on the James River near Smithfield, Virginia.

 

Gregory Phillip Harrington (26 Jun 1957 - living)                                                                    Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Sandra “Sandy” Redd Harrington (03 May 1952 - living)

Matthew Sterling Harrington (27 Apr 1983 - living)

                         + Branwen I. Hardebeck-Durso (11 Mar ? - living)

                                 Juniper Sarah Harrington (06 May 2013-living)

                         + Griffin Harrington

+ Leah Mancuso (06 Dec 1962 - living)

 

Gregory Phillip Harrington was born on 26 Jun 1957 in Berger Hospital in Circleville, OH. His mother, Lois Ann Wolfe-Harrington, had returned with her older son, Daniel Edward Harrington, from Hawaii a few weeks earlier. Gregory's father, Richard "Dick" Edward Harrington, was somewhere on the Pacific Ocean on active duty with the U.S. Navy and would soon be released from active duty to resume their civilian life in Pensacola, Florida. Gregory was baptized on 18 August 1957 at Trinity Lutheran Church in Circleville, Ohio.

Greg started to school in Pensacola but his first year was interrupted when the family moved to Cincinnati, OH in December 1963. Like his siblings, he experienced several additional disruptions to his schooling which included schools near Raleigh, N.C. and Alexandria, VA. Greg graduated from Fort Hunt School, Alexandria, VA in 1975.

 

College was never a strong priority in the Harrington household. It was encouraged by both his college-graduate parents but because of the modest income and the relatively large family, college would have to be earned by the student. Gregory was a very good high school student and worked his way through college at the College of William and Mary in Williamsburg, VA where he graduated in 1979 with a High Honors degree in chemistry. He continued his education at the Medical College of Virginia (MCV) at Richmond, VA. While in medical school at MCV, he met and married Sandra Cornelia Redd who was working as a receptionist at a medical doctor's office. On 27 April 1983 Sandra and Gregory had their only child, Matthew Sterling Harrington. Gregory focused his graduate work toward Interventional Radiology and upon completion of his schooling and internship, he practiced as a Interventional Radiologist in the Boston, Massachusetts area.

 

Dr. Gregory and Sandy Redd Harrington divorced about 2009. Gregory married Leah Mancuso on 3 July 2010 and continues to work in Boston, Massachusetts.

 


 

 


67

 

 

 


Matthew Sterling Harrington (27 Apr 1983 - living)                                                                                                                                            Click here to return to the Table of Contents                                             

+ Branwen I. Hardebeck-Durso (11 Mar ? - living)

Juniper Sarah Harrington (06 May 2013 - living)

Griffin Harrington (about 15 September 2016 – living)

 

Matthew Sterling Harrington was born 27 April 1983 in Newport News, Virginia. He graduated in a science program and worked for Bell Laboratories for several years. Matthew married Branwen I. Hardebeck-Durso on 18 Oct 2008 in Las Vegas, Nevada. As of 2016, the couple has two children: Juniper Sarah Harrington born 6 May 2013 and Griffin Harrington born about 15 September 2016, both born in Oregon.

 

Pamela Anne Harrington (20 Jun 1958 - living)                                                 Click here to return to the Table of Contents

+ John Edward Schwartz (06 Jan 1959 - living)

 

Richard James Schultz (14 Jun 1987 - living)

 

Robert John Schultz (14 Mar 1991 - living)

 

Jacquelyn Michelle Schwartz (19 Aug 1993 – living)

 

Pamela Anne Harrington was born in Baptist Hospital in Pensacola, Florida on 20 Jun 1958 to Richard Edward and Lois Anne Wolfe- Harrington. She lived in Pensacola until shortly after her 5th birthday when she moved with her parents to Cincinnati, Ohio where she began her schooling. Like her siblings, her schooling was interrupted as the family moved from Cincinnati, OH; to Raleigh, NC; to Washington, DC; back to Cincinnati, OH and finally to Ann Arbor, MI as her father's job with the U.S. Government changed locations.

Pam graduated from Mount Vernon High School in Alexandria, VA in 1976 after attending school at Fort Hunt from 1972-1974 in the same city. Upon graduation from high school, she went to Miami University near Dayton, Ohio from 1976-78. Pamela interrupted her college career in 1978 to spend 10-months in Scotland with a group called “Youth With a Mission (YWAM).” Upon returning from Scotland she transferred to Concordia University in Michigan because her family had moved to Ann Arbor, MI during her absence. Pamela received an Associate degree from Concordia in 1980 and dropped out of college when she married John "Jack" Edward Schwartz on 08 Aug 1981 whom she had met at Concordia University.

 

Pamela worked for nearly 6-years following her marriage before she and Jack began their family. On 14 Jun 1987 their first child, Richard James Schwartz was born. Their second child, Robert John Schwartz, was born on 14 Mar 1991 and their third child, Jacquelyn Michelle Schwartz, was born on 19 August 1993 completing the John and Pamela Harrington-Schwartz family.

 

As her children grew and left the family, Pamela resumed her college career earning an undergraduate degree in Business Administration and Leadership in August 2009 from Concordia University in Michigan. She went on to earn a Master's degree in Organizational Leadership and Administration in May 2011. Pamela had been employed by Concordia University as she earned her undergraduate and Master's degrees. After earning her degrees, she was retained by Concordia University and became Director of Student Success and Retention. In 2014 she relocated to Gloucester, VA and became Administrative Assistant at Virginia Commonwealth University in the department of Family Medicine and Population Health located in Richmond, VA.

 


 


68

 

 

 


In mid-November of 2002, Pamela’s oldest son, Richard James Schwartz, experienced an event that could have well cost him his life. He was scheduled to go to Porcupine Mountines, Michigan on a first deer-hunting trip with his dad, Jack. He ended up not going on the trip because he was not feeling well. He began complaining about pains in his shoulder on Saturday, thinking he may have pulled a muscle. A trip to the doctor’s ended with a diagnosis of a collapsed left lung. Upon closer examination, it was discovered that both lungs were collapsing. Had Rick made the trip, he could have easily died. Rick survived the experience but not before going through a very painful series of treatments that included inserting tubes into his chest for the removal of air outside of his lungs and for administering tetracycline, an irritant used to force his lungs to adhere to his chest cavity walls to allow the lungs to function properly. The treatment was terrible, and successful.

 

Rick (he has gone by Rick, Richard, and Rich), who is 6-foot, 3-inches, met and married a lovely young lady named Alaine Michelle Reichle Schwartz who is about 4-foot, 10-inches. At their wedding, Rick danced with his new bride while on his knees which made them about nose-to-nose. Rick went to Concordia University, Ann Arbor, Michigan and dropped out with only a couple of courses to go for his degree. His wife, Alaine, also went to Concordia University, Ann Arbor, Michigan and got her degree in Family Life. She is now a “Youth Pastor” in Wisconsin, serving 4 separate congregations.

 

Pamela’s second son, Robert John Schwartz, apparently got an extra serving of his mother’s extraverted genes. He went to Concordia University, Chicago where he got a degree in Kinesiology. He too married a lovely young lady named Lyndsey Nicole Garlich whom he met at college. Lyndsey also has a degree in Kinesiology.

Pamela’s daughter, Jacquelyn “Jacqui” Michelle Schwartz, got her degree in Public Relations and Journalism from Concordia, Nebraska. At the time of this writing, Jacqui is still single and working in Minneapolis, Minnesota.

Pamela and Jack divorced in 2015.

 

Margaret Elaine “Peggy” Harrington (09 May 1960 - living)                          Click here to return to the Table of Contents

+ Michael Clark Poole (06 Jun 1958 - living)

 

Eryn Leigh Poole (25 May 1982 - living)

 

+ David Michael Pluim (21 Dec 1981 - living)

 

Tyler Styron Pluim (30 Sep 1998 - living)

 

Tobin Kendall Pluim (11 Dec 2012 - living)

 

Sophia Marie Joy Pluim (26 Aug 2015 – living)

Morgan Kendall Poole (20 May 1985 - living)

+ Michael Gatsky (partner) (unknown - living)

 

Elliott Dmitri Poole-Boguch (07 Sep 2004 - living)

 

+ Joshua Max Boguch (12 Mar 1985 - living)

Malcolm Ari Boguch (06 Jul 2015 - living)

Emily Yan Li Poole (20 Sep 1998 - living)

 

Margaret (Peggy) Elaine Harrington was born 09 May 1960 in Pensacola, FL to Richard Edward and Lois Ann Wolfe-Harrington. She lived in Pensacola 3-1/2 years, then moved with her parents to Cincinnati, Ohio where she began her schooling. Like her siblings, her schooling was interrupted as the family moved from Cincinnati, OH to

 


 


69

 

 

 


Raleigh, NC; to Washington, DC; back to Cincinnati, OH and finally to Ann Arbor, MI as her father's job with the U.S. Government changed locations. Peggy graduated from Dexter High School in Dexter, Michigan in 1978. She went to Sienna Heights College for about one semester, then moved to Ann Arbor where she worked for J.C. Penney for a while, then moved on to a job at a Total gas station. Her first car was a VW Karmann Ghia. At the age of 20-years she met and married Michael Clark Poole on 24 May 1980.

 

Peg and Mike moved to Newport News, VA in March of 1981, then to Gloucester, Virginia in 1983 where they bought their first house and started their family. Their first daughter, Eryn Leigh Poole, was born 25 May 1982. On 20 May 1984 their second daughter, Morgan Kendall Poole, was born. While Morgan was the last biological family member, she was not the last family member. On 29 July 1999 Mike and Peggy traveled to China and adopted a beautiful little girl, Emily Yan Li Poole, from a State orphanage. At that time, China was enforcing a one-child rule for its citizens. Combined with the cultural preference for sons, Emily had been abandoned on the steps of a government building. She was in good health and less than a year old. No records exist regarding her parents or her age other than her given name, Yan Li. Emily was quickly integrated into the Mike Poole family and soon earned a favorite position among her adopted parents and two older sisters, Eryn and Morgan. The family soon gave Emily her first name and kept her Chinese names as her middle name. They made their best-estimate of Emily Yan Li Poole’s date of birthday as 20 September 1998. They now celebrate both her "birthday" of 20 September and a "Gotcha" day of 29 July.

 

As the family grew older, Peggy resumed her education by attending Thomas Nelson Community College where she earned an Associate degree in nursing in May 1990. She sat for her board-exams and became a Registered Nurse the same year. Armed with her RN, Peggy worked in Med-surgery, Telemetry, and Critical Care at Riverside Walter Reed Hospital in Gloucester, VA for several years. In 1995 she worked in Riverside Walter Reed Home Health where she became supervisor for about 7-years of a staff of over 20 home-health care nurses. She continued her advanced studies at the Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU) and earned her Bachelors of Science in Nursing in December 2012. In 2014 she returned to college full-time at VCU, while retaining her job at Riverside Walter Reed as a part-time home-health nurse. At VCU she studied to get her master’s degree in the area of Acute Care Nurse Practitioner (ACNP). Upon graduation in May 2015 sit for and passed her ACNP boards. Peggy was subsequently employed as a full time Acute Care Nurse Practitioner at Riverside Walter Reed in Gloucester, VA.

 

On 29 November, Peggy was promoted to a position of hospitalist at Riverside Walter Reed in Gloucester. VA. As a hospitalist she was a permanent staff member of the hospital and with another nurse with a similar position, provided full time staff coverage for the hospital as Nurse Practitioner.

 

Eryn Leigh Poole (25 May 1982 - living)                                                    Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ David Michael Pluim (21 Dec 1981 - living)

 

Tyler Styron Pluim (30 Sep 1998 - living)

Tobin Kendall Pluim (11 Dec 2012 - living)

Sophia Marie Joy Pluim (26 Aug 2015 – living)

 


 

 


70


 

 

 

Eryn Leigh Pool is the oldest of Michael Clark and Margaret “Peggy” Elaine Harrington-Poole's three children; all three are girls. Eryn was born 25 May 1982 at Mary Immaculate Hospital in Newport News, VA. She graduated from Gloucester High School in the year 2000. In 2000 she started college at Christopher Newport University and graduated in 2004 with a Bachelor of Arts (BA) in English. Subsequently, she parlayed her BA in English into a teaching certificate. On 11 May 2002 Eryn and David Michael Pluim married at the Union Baptist Church in Bena, VA.

 

David was born 21 Dec 1981 in Grants Pass, Oregon to Thomas Arthur and Rosalea Myrna Adams Pluim. He too graduated from Gloucester High School in the year 2000. He went to college at the College of William and Mary and in 2004 graduated with a Bachelor of Science degree in Applied Mathematics, Operations Research.

On July 2009 Eryn and David adopted Tyler Styron Pluim who was born on 30 Sep 1998. The Pluim family celebrates his "Gotcha Day" on July 4th. Eryn and David’s second adopted child is Tobin Kendall Pluim. By prior arrangement that preceded Tobin’s conception, they adopted Tobin Kendall Pluim who was born to Eryn's sister, Morgan Kendall Poole, on 11 December 2012 at St Mary's Hospital in Richmond, VA.

 

At the date of publication of this book, David and Eryn Pluim are in the process of making their third adoption. Her name is Sophia Marie Joy Pluim born 26 Aug 2015.

 

Morgan Kendall Poole (20 May 1985 - living)                                                           Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Michael Gatsky (partner) (unknown - living)

 

Elliott Dmitri Poole-Boguch (07 Sep 2004 - living)

 

+ Joshua Max Boguch (12 Mar 1985 - living)

 

Malcolm Ari Boguch (06 Jul 2015 - living)

 

Morgan Kendall Poole is the younger daughter of Michael Clark and Margaret Elaine "Peggy" Poole. She was born 20 May 1985 in the Mary Immaculate Hospital in Newport News, VA. In 2003 she graduated from Gloucester High School. In early 2004 she became pregnant and on 7 Sep 2004 delivered her first son, Elliott Dmitri Poole. Subsequent to Elliott's birth, Morgan elected to serve as surrogate mother for two in-vitro propagated births. She attended Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU) then switched to Riverside School of Professional Nursing graduating in 2008 as a Registered Nurse. Morgan elected to again become a surrogate mother on behalf of her sister, Eryn. A son, Tobin Kendall Poole was born on 11 Dec 2012 at St. Mary's Hospital in Richmond, Virginia from a combination of Morgan's egg and sperm from a sperm-bank. Tobin is being reared by Morgan's sister, Eryn, and Eryn’s husband David as their second adopted son. Morgan considers Tobin to be Eryn and David's son and her nephew. She said, "I know they plan on telling him (Tobin) his story, but I just consider him to be my nephew."

 

Morgan married Dr. Joshua Max Boguch on 26 May 2013. They married in Virginia in Shenandoah National Park along the Skyline Drive. On 6 July 2015 their son, Malcolm Ari Boguch-Poole, was born at Meriter Hospital, Madison, Wisconsin. Josh adopted Elliott Poole on 14 September 2016 changing his name to Elliott Dmitri Boguch.

 

                                                                                Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 


 

 


71

 

 

 


Neil William Harrington (17 Jun 1963 - living) 

+ Donna Louise Morgan (26 Oct 1960 – living)

 

+ Jana Marlene Fenneken (19 Aug 1971 - living)

 

Neil William Harrington, the youngest of 5-children of Richard E. and Lois Anne Wolfe Harrington, was born 17 Jun 1963 in Pensacola, Florida.

 

Neil graduated from Dexter High School in 1981 and started college the same year. This initial college career was short-lived. He got a role in the outdoor staging of the play, "Tecumseh," in Ohio. About the same time he became involved with the Ohio Army National Guard. His college career resumed in the late 1980’s and has continued since. His vocational accomplishments include:

 

- St. Philip’s College: Certificate of Completion - Vocational Nursing - August 1990

 

- The Ohio State University: Bachelor of Science in Agriculture - March 1994

 

- Columbus State Community College: Associate of Applied Science in Nursing Technology - December 1996.

- DeVry University: Associate of Applied Science in Health Information Technology – February 2010.

- University of Cincinnati: Bachelor of Science in Health Information Management

 

Administration – early 2016

 

Some of his other activities include:

 

- U.S. Army Commendation Medal - July 1991.

 

- Ohio Army National Guard - Honorably Discharged with the rank of Sargent October 1993.

- He was baptized by the Pastor of New Life Assembly of God, in Circleville, Ohio in

 

March 2014.

 

On 12 Sept 1998, Neil married Donna Louise Morgan Lindner. They divorced in about 2013. On 7 September 2014 Neil married Jana Fenneken and resides in Circleville, Ohio.

 

+ Margaret Jadwiga Stasikowski (31 March 1948 - living)                                                               Click here to return to the Table of Contents

Kyle Ira Stasikowski Harrington (28 Jan 1986 - living)

 

Margaret Jadwiga Stasikowski was born in Ruda Slaska, Poland on 31 March 1948. At that time, Poland was under the near-dictatorial control of the Union of Soviet Social Republics (now Russia) and its Communist Government. Margaret’s parents, Saturnin

 

Jerzy and Jadwiga Agata Wrzesinska-Stasikowski had survived the brutal Nazi-Germany regime and occupation after World War II. Life in Poland was difficult. The family left for the United States in 1964 with some help of Margaret’s uncle who had come to the United States in 1923. Within 2-years she had learned English, graduated from high school, and was headed to college at The Ohio State University. Margaret graduated from Ohio State

 

in 1969 with a Bachelor of Science degree in Psychology and again in 1971 with a Bachelor of Science degree in Russian. She earned her Master of Science in Environmental Science and Industrial Hygiene from the University of Cincinnati in 1973.

Margaret worked briefly for the Oil, Chemical and Atomic Workers Union in Denver, Colorado, then went on to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in 1974. It was there that I met Margaret working in the same EPA Office of Research and Development in Washington, D.C. Margaret was fluent in English, Polish, and Russian

 


 


72

 

 

 


and had some knowledge of French, and Spanish. Since much of my work involved interaction with engineers and scientists from several of these countries, Margaret’s linguistic and environmental technical knowledge almost assured that our paths would cross.

 

Margaret worked at the EPA for over 30-years retiring in October 2004 as Director of the Health Effects Division, Office of Pesticides Program. Before retiring Margaret started to work on her Master’s Degree in School Counseling at George Washington University and graduated in 2005. Margaret worked as a school counselor until 2012. Six months later she joined College Access Fairfax a non-profit organization where she assumed a position of Director Project Discovery Program, a program designed to help students with career exploration and planning for post-high school education. . She is currently Chair of the Board for Project Discovery. In 2013 she also became an active Master Gardener in the County of Fairfax.

 

Kyle Ira Stasikowski Harrington​(28 Jan 1986 - living)                                                                     Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Kyle Ira Stasikowski Harrington was born to Richard Edward Harrington and Margaret Jadwiga Stasikowski on 28 Jan 1986. Kyle was a bright independent child who loved to learn new things. He started school at the Aquinas Montessori School in Alexandria, VA at the age of 2 ½ -years. The Montessori approach to learning suited his personality well. At age 5 he started to attend the class of 1st, 2nd and 3rd graders (in Montessori school students move at their own pace), thus “skipping” what in a traditional school is called kindergarten. Kyle continued at Aquinas through 7th grade. The year that Kyle was in 7th grade was the only year that the 7th grade was offered at Aquinas Montessori school. During 7th grade, Dick Harrington, his Dad, found a new profession. That year he taught Algebra, Chemistry and Physics at the school. From Aquinas, Kyle went to Burgundy Farm Country Day School for one year before entering Mount Vernon High School. He selected the International Baccalaureate Diploma program, graduating in 2003. Continuing with an independent learner track, Kyle selected Hampshire College

 

in Amherst, Massachusetts in the fall of 2003. He graduated in 2007 with a Bachelor of Arts in Computer Science and Artificial Life. Kyle was accepted for a fellowship program at Brandeis University Graduate School of Computer Science, where he earned his Master of Arts and PhD in Computer Science with specialization in Quantitative Biology. He was a Postdoctoral Fellow in the Pathology Dept. of Harvard Medical School for two years.

 

Kyle is an Assistant Professor at the University of Idaho, Virtual Technology and Design beginning with the 2016 Autumn Semester.

 

William Young Harrington, Sr. (17 Jun 1963 - 23 Feb 1986)                                                            Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+                 Betty Joan Griffith (3 Oct 1932 - 12 Jan 1962)

 

Candice Kay Harrington (30 Dec 1951 - living)

 

+                 Phillis Ann Logan (9 Apr 1944 – living)

 

Angela "Angie" Lynn Harrington (9 Nov 1963 - living)

 

William Young Harrington, Jr. (3 Nov 1965 - living)

 

William "Bill" Young Harrington was born 10 March 1933 at home in a house on East Mound Street in Circleville, Ohio rented by his parents. Fifteen months and

 


 

 


73

 

 

 


17-days earlier, Bill's older brother, Dick, had been born on 23 December 1931 in Columbus, Ohio. Both births came in the depth of the Great Depression when unemployment was high and money was scarce. Shortly after Dick's birth, his parents joined forces with the family of Aunt Ruth Imo Harrington-Pennell and using money that Audra Young-Harrington, Dick and Bill's mother, had collected from an insurance policy upon the death of her first husband, both families headed for Miami, Florida. Their plan was to build a fishing boat and go into the business of catching and selling fish for a living. The boat was built and the fishing business begun. They caught fish but because of the high competition from other fishermen, they made little money. In June of 1932, Audra became pregnant with William (Bill) Young Harrington. A month later, Ira and Ruth's baby sister, Easter Marie Harrington Thompson, died near Circleville, Ohio. Ira, Audra and Dick immediately drove from Miami, Florida to Circleville, Ohio, non-stop to attend the funeral. They never returned to Florida and the fishing business. Audra's money was exhausted. Instead, they remained in Circleville, Ohio where Bill was born 8-months later.

 

As a baby, Bill was small and required more care and attention than had Dick. Nevertheless, Bill developed without incident remaining somewhat slight for his age. He was a "toe-head" with his hair remaining almost white throughout his early years. Initially, his mother felt the need to be more protective of Bill, in part, because of his slight physical size and his tendency to have more colds and a need for more attention. As he developed, he grew stronger and healthier and the need for extra care diminished. During his early formative years Bill developed a keenly independent and competitive spirit that served him well the rest of his life. The younger of the two brothers Bill was in strong competition with his older brother. He was constantly driven to be equal to or better than his older brother in nearly everything. Bill never accepted his younger age or smaller size as a reason for not being able to do whatever Dick could do, so the competition continued throughout their childhood. This spirit of competition was the root cause of many quarrels.

 

One of the attributes that Bill honed was avoiding his 'share' of work. Bill was not lazy. Rather, it was part of the competition. There was always work to do around the small subsistence farm such as working in the garden, hoeing corn, picking wild blackberries, cleaning the animal shed, watering and feeding the livestock, spreading animal manure on the garden, shoveling snow, etc., etc. These tasks were usually assigned by their dad, Ira, as a collective effort; "You boys clean the cow shed today." Bill was very intelligent and cleaver and used these attributes to his advantage. Bill discovered early-on that he could shirk his share of the work, knowing that failure to complete the task would bring collective criticism or even punishment and that Dick would pick up the slack rather than risk the punishment.

 

In June of 1936 Patricia (Patty) Sue Harrington was born. After an uncertain beginning in which she almost starved from lack of adequate nutrition, Patty developed into a beautiful little toe-head who quickly learned to be competitive with her older brothers and was usually successful in keeping them on the defensive. Bill was better able to cope with this new challenge, perhaps because of his own earlier experience.

 

Within the Ira and Audra Harrington family there was never pressure to prepare the children for a vocation or skills that might be useful to make a living as an adult. In retrospect, this was probably because that was the way it was in the families of both Ira and Audra and their parents before them. The children of these families simply grew up with complete choice of how they would make it through their lives. Morals were taught and education was prized as the only guidelines. In this environment, Bill may have

 


 


74

 

 

 


been better prepared by his childhood experiences than his siblings. Through his intellect, cunning and practice of maximizing his situation with a minimum of effort, he better understood how to compete in an adult world than most. He was well liked and while he used his experience and talents to his benefit, he was smart enough to not exploit people. He was an expert at "reading" people and successfully interacting with them. He was a hard worker at things he liked or needed to do and was generally successful at any of his undertakings.

 

As an adult Bill became fiercely independent. He was well built, fearless and protective. He was not a bully and did not go around picking fights but would not run from a fight. If he encountered a person or event that he thought might constitute an affront, he would likely interpret it as an affront and seek justice. His daughter, Candice, recalls such an event in which "... the family was traveling in their car on Lancaster Pike when a car going the opposite direction, blasted by with the horn blaring. This infuriated Bill so he drove "like a bat out of hell", turned around, and hunted for the guy - cussing all the way. He overtook the car and tore open his car door. He was going to beat up this guy. Mother (Betty) was crying and begging Dad (Bill) not to do it. We waited for the fight to start but all we saw was Dad popping the hood and stuck his head under the hood. Dad then returned to the car and explained the offender's horn was stuck and Dad helped him fix it."

 

On another occasion Bill was driving in Circleville when he was passed by a car load of young men who were being rowdy and shouting at people as they passed. The guy in the passenger seat shouted something nasty as he passed Bill and called him a name and gave him 'the finger.' Bill fell in behind the offending car with his car and followed them at a close distance. Within a couple of intersections, both cars were stopped by a red light. Bill alighted from his car, walked up to the driver side of the car ahead, reached through the open window and seized the driver by the shirt collar and pulled him until his head was almost outside the car window. Bill proceeded to slap the driver's face several times. Throughout his slapping, the driver protested that it was not he who called Bill the name, but his passenger. Bill responded that he was the driver and was responsible for the actions of his passengers. Bill returned to his car and proceeded on his way after the traffic light changed.

 

Bill's earliest memories were formed during a time when the Nation was recovering from a deep depression. Ira and Audra had purchased a small farm (about 4 acres) and engaged in subsistence farming which consisted of raising a large garden, having a milk cow, raising chickens for eggs and meat and keeping a couple of hogs for meat. Audra canned fruit and vegetables and Ira smoked meat for winter. Ira hunted rabbits, squirrels and ground-hogs as game meat. The family never lacked for good food. Bill was indoctrinated into a frugal life style that included 'living off the land' as much as possible. As an adult he pursued a similar life-style with his own family even though he always held a good job and embracing the role of a "gatherer" was not necessary. By then, however, it was a sport. He took pride in and enjoyed being able to harvest the many fruits of wild nature like picking wild greens, mushrooms, game, dandelions, berries, wild fruits, turtles, fish, etc. There is little doubt that he could have cared for his family without the convenience of grocery stores or other commercial resources if it became necessary. He took pride in laying-food-by for winter or possible times of need.

 

Bill enjoyed having fun. He liked fishing, hunting, camping - activities that frequently yielded game and vegetables that he froze for later consumption. When someone

 


 


75

 

 

 


came by for a visit, Bill could usually impress them with a fare of frog-legs, turtle soup, venison, or other exotic dish. On one occasion, his sister, Pat, and her second husband, Harry Reynolds, came by for a visit. Bill had recently dug a quantity of horseradish roots that he made into one of his favorite condiments; ground, fresh, horseradish. Harry liked horseradish, too, and during his visit, ate a lot of it. Harry became sick and almost died. Apparently, Bill had mistakenly include a root of the poisonous polk-berry plant in his concoction. Harry was the only person to suffer from the experience, however.

 

William was talented at many things. His curiosity and technical abilities led him to fearlessly tackle about any task that caught his fancy. He was a good candidate for almost any career he might choose. However, committing the time and drudgery of getting an advanced education was not an option he would consider. He was impatient to grow up and taste the adventures of adult life. On April 1951, he married early at the age of 18-years and 1-month to Betty Joan Griffith, a co-worker at Kroger's grocery store in Circleville, Ohio where Bill was Produce Manager. In the early years of his marriage he worked as an automotive mechanic for the local Chevrolet garage. He later went to work for DuPont at their recently constructed Mylar plant near Circleville where he became proficient as a welder and mill wright. He constructed his own, up-scale home in the Jefferson-Addition south of Circleville. His life and the life of his family was on a sharp rise when suddenly his wife, Betty, died on 12 January 1962 from a lung ailment leaving Bill with his 10-year old daughter, Candice Kay Harrington, to care for.

 

After a period of 14-months without his mate, Bill re-married on 11 March 1963, one day after his birthday, to Phillis Ann Logan who was born 9 April 1944. Phillis brought her 2½-year old daughter from a previous marriage, Brenda Sue Cave, into the family. Soon two more children were born; Angie Lynn Harrington born 9 November 1964 and William Young Harrington Jr. born 3 November 1965. Bill and Phillis began a program of buying distressed properties, fixing them up and renting them. Bill left DuPont in the late 1960s to go to work for a company that installed machinery under contract. This new job capitalized on his experience as a mill-wright and caused him to travel to job sites with some frequency.

 

Bill's daughter Candice, recalls, "One November (1980) Dad butchered 7 hogs in the backyard at our house in Jefferson Addition, just south of Circleville, Ohio. Jefferson-Addition was an up-scale residential community of new houses on half-acre lots. Bill shot the hogs and gutted them in the back yard. Of course the neighbors were upset. Dad placed a sawhorse in the front yard with a sign saying, "Trespassers will be shot on sight". There was a gun placed nearby. In a short time, a deputy sheriff showed up at the house. Dad and the deputy talked, the gun was removed, and the butchering continued according to plan. The meat was distributed among the members of the project. Bill smoked the hams and other cuts of meat in a 'smoke-house' that he constructed in the corner of his garage."

 

He was a risk taker but was careful not to over extend himself. He enjoyed the excitement and challenge of competing and that included competing with the law. He usually remained within arguably legal bounds but enjoyed pushing-the-envelope. This included things like speed laws, wild game laws, trespassing, making or buying moonshine, engaging in physical altercations when he considered it necessary, and more. He considered such things as the legal season for hunting to be secondary if he wanted to go hunting. He would carefully weigh the risk of getting caught as part of any decision to do whatever he was planning. Like his dad, Ira, he liked to gig frogs and fish which he

 


 


76

 

 

 


would do even though there was no legal season for doing so. His first cousin, Gary Jackson, liked to tell the story about the time Gary's parents and their children came to Circleville for a visit. Gary was 10-years younger than Bill and the year was about 1963. Bill had a new, white, large-finned DeSota that he wanted to show-off to Gary. So they went for a ride and returned to Circleville about dusk. Bill was driving and was over the speed limit when he entered Circleville. Within a few blocks after entering town, he came to the attention of a policeman who sounded his siren and took chase. Bill decided to outrun the police and began making some evasive maneuvers down streets and alleys that he knew well. He finally pulled in behind a hedge and stopped, commanding Gary to get down on the floor and stay there until he told him he could get up. Gary, being about 20-years old at the time, obeyed although he did not know why it was important for him to be out of sight. After a few minutes, he was given the all-clear and they resumed their trip home. Bill had successfully out-run and out-maneuvered the policeman. While Bill was not an outlaw, he loved the thrill of living on the edge.

Sometime after 1963, Bill took possession of the "Continental Club" on the northern side of Circleville. It was a highly popular night club with a full liquor license. I used to enjoy coming to Circleville from Cincinnati and working the bar for Bill for free. He had a good crew of waitresses and appeared to have a large clientele. The seating space was a bit too small as were the prices of drinks. After a couple of years, Bill gave up the bar because it was not profitable. That was Bill's only venture into the bar business.

 

In the early 1980s Bill was diagnosed with lymphoma-cancer. He underwent multiple surgeries to remove sections of his small intestines and endured long periods of radiation treatment. He eventually succumbed to the disease on 23 Feb 1986. He was laid to rest in the Harrison Township Cemetery, about a mile south of South Bloomfield, Pickaway County, Ohio.

 

Betty Joan Griffith (3 Oct 1932 - 12 Jan 1962)                                                           Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Candice Kay Harrington (30 Dec 1951 - living)

 

On 10 March 1950, William “Bill” Young Harrington, the future husband of Betty Joan Griffith, turned 17-years old. He was a Junior at Pickaway Township School and would be for another couple of months. He had bought his first automobile, a 1932 Chevrolet sedan, for $50 from a neighbor, Neil Rhoads, who was his 6th cousin, although neither cousin ever knew of the relationship which was discovered decades later through family research done to prepare for the writing of this book. Bill also applied for a job and was hired by the small Kroger grocery store in Circleville. This provided him with a source of income that enabled his transition from a high school kid into early adulthood. Typical of most 17-year-old, almost-men, Bill was on top of his world! At Kroger’s store, Bill progressed rapidly from basic market-store maintenance to manager of the produce department.

 

Also working at Kroger’s was Betty Joan Griffith, a cute young lady from Amanda, Ohio who was about 7-months Bill’s senior. Betty and Bill soon became friends - very good friends. They began dating and in March 1951, Betty became pregnant. By then, Betty had become a frequent visitor at the Harrington house at 214 W. Mound Street in Circleville, Ohio. Bill’s parents had sold their 4-acre farm and bought the large red brick house on the corner of West Mound Street and Western Avenue. Betty’s pregnancy shook Bill’s young, adult life. He decided that he was not ready for marriage and fatherhood and began searching for alternatives. He decided to run – to join the Navy and

 


 


77

 

 

 


 ignore his responsibility for his unplanned adult life. Early April 1951 found Bill on a bus headed for San Diego where he planned to enlist in the U.S. Navy. He had chosen San Diego as his place of enlistment to try to assure that his basic training would be in that area as opposed to the Great Lakes, Illinois boot camp which would have been where he would have been assigned if he had enlisted in Columbus, Ohio. Fate again intervened in Bill’s plans. On the bus-ride toward San Diego, he found a seat beside a Chief Naval Officer who was highly decorated and sported several gold chevrons on his sleeve signifying a long career of good conduct. During the course of their ride the Chief engaged Bill in conversation and learned of his plans. The Chief, being much older and wiser than Bill, advised him that his plan was flawed and explained several reasons why. The Chief strongly suggested that Bill go back to Ohio and marry Betty and make his wife and child a home. He explained to Bill that in so doing he could avoid serious legal and financial problems and if he still wished to join the Navy, he could still do so. Bill abandoned his trip to San Diego at about the half-way point and took the next bus back to Circleville. Bill and Betty eloped and were married in Indiana in late April 1951. Their daughter, Candice Kay Harrington, was born on 30 December 1951.

 

Betty was the youngest daughter in a large family of Griffiths who lived near Amanda, Ohio. She had one younger sibling named James “Jimmy” William Griffith. Her father, Martin Emerson Griffith (14 Oct 1891 - 30 Jul 1966) was a farmer who was both religious and a hard disciplinarian. In the mid-1950s his house burned. By then most, if not all, of his children had left home and started their own families. Martin called a family meeting following the loss of his home and announced that he expected his children to build their mother and him a new home and that they should figure out a way to assume the cost of the construction. This story came to me via his son-in-law, Bill Harrington, who felt that Martin’s expectations were too high and that Betty and Bill were not able to afford the cost. I am unaware of the outcome of this tragedy but I don’t believe that Betty and Bill bore any of the financial burden for the replacement.

 

Betty proved to be an admirable wife for Bill over the next 11-years. She was smart, kind and gentle. She was an avid, capable worker and a good mother. Everyone liked Betty. Their life was back on track and Betty and Bill made significant progress over the next few years. Their finances flourished and they built a lovely new home in the Jefferson subdivision south of Circleville. They began buying distressed property, repairing and renting it. Betty took a job with the local General Electric plant that manufactured an array of electrical products from incandescent light bulbs to television screens. She didn’t like the work but it helped pay the bills. Betty and Bill were back in control of their lives again.

 

Betty had a couple of apparently minor health issues. She was afflicted with a bowel condition that required that she take laxatives daily to function properly. She had also developed a serious smoking and coffee habit. Betty was seldom without a cup of coffee and a cigarette in her hand.

On 13 January 1962 I responded to a knock on the door at my home in Pensacola, Florida to find two members of the Sheriff’s Office standing there. They brought the news that I should call my parents in Ohio about a death in the immediate family. The family member was my brother’s wife, Betty Joan Griffith-Harrington. I learned later that Betty had become ill while at work at the GE plant. She was taken to Berger Hospital in Circleville, Ohio suffering from a serious respiratory problem that was diagnosed as a rare form of Staphylococcus. She was placed in an oxygen-tent and died 3-days later on 12 Jan 1962. Betty was buried in Forest Cemetery, Circleville, Ohio.

 


 


78


 

 

Candice Kay Harrington (30 Dec 1951 - living)                                                                                Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Gediliah Alexander Dresbach, Jr. (12 Apr 1951 - living)

 

Todd Robert Dresbach-Featheringham (28 Feb 1971 - living)

 

+ Tracy Asher (25 May 1976 – living)

 

Morgan Elizabeth Featheringham (16 Aug 1995-living)

+ Elizabeth Ann Hackler (17 Apr 1979 – living)

Kyle Raymond Featheringham (07 Oct 1997-living)

 

Kassidy Arden Featheringham (10 Nov 1999-living)

Christopher Michael Dresbach (20 Jun 1972 – living)

Gediliah Alexander (Andy) Dresbach (23 May 1975 – living)

Elizabeth Ann Dresbach (09 Oct 1976 – living)

+ Wesley Holbrook (unknown-living)

 

Laura Elizabeth Holbrook-Dresbach (23 Feb 1994-living)

 

+ Jerry Clark (unknown-living)

 

Adeline Joy Clark (03 Feb 2016-living)

 

+ Jerry Elwood Tipton (14 Mar 1976 – living)

 

Dylan Isiah Tipton (25 Jul 1997-living)

 

+ Taylor Certain (Dec 1997-living)

 

Isabell Ann Tipton (26 Nov 2014-living)

 Leah Jane Tipton (06 May 2001-living)

+ Thomas R Karshner (about 1948 - unknown)

 

+ Lester “Les” Ray Miller (20 Dec 1942 - 15 Jan 1998)

 

Candice “Candy” Kay Harrington had just turned 11 years old and was in the 5th grade when her mother, Betty Joan Griffith-Harrington, died. In retrospect, it is clear that her mother, Betty, was the glue binding their family together. With her passing Bill Harrington, now 29-years old, drifted back to the independent life he had pursued before their marriage. More destructive, however, was that Candice had lost the most important moral beacon in her life. Her grandmother tried to fill the vacancy but her mother, her role-model, was gone, never to be replaced. Candy’s father, Bill, remarried to Phillis Ann Logan-Cave on 11 March 1963, 15-months after Betty’s death. Candy was 12-years and 3-months old when her father remarried. Phillis was under 20-years old, just 6-years and 8-months older than Candy. Phillis was an outsider to Candy’s family who, in addition to purporting to replace Candy’s mother, also brought her own 2-year, 5-month old daughter, Brenda Sue Cave, into the home. Eight months after Phillis and Bill’s wedding, a new baby, Angela Lynn Harrington, was born.

 

While this kind of turbulent sequence of events is not unknown within a family, it is fortunately not common. For Candy, however, it must have been traumatic. In the period of about 1-year, at the critical age of her early teens, she lost her mother, lost much of the guidance of her father, lost her place as the only child and “apple of her parent’s eye,” to become subject to what must have seemed to Candy to be a proverbial “wicked” step-mother. For Candy, Phillis who was very young and near Candy’s own age, could not be respected or accepted as a replacement for her mother. In less than another year, Phyllis’s second child was born relegating Candy to nearly that of a boarder

 


 


79

 

 

 

in her own home. Many kids rebel in their mid-to-late teens. Usually these are rebellions based on gaining their own independence. In Candy’s case she must have felt rejected by her family and found the “street” a welcoming venue.

 

Candy became pregnant with her first child, Todd, about May 1970 at age 19-years. Todd was born 28 February 1971. Candy put Todd up for adoption. He was adopted and became Todd Robert Featheringham.

She married Junior (Gedilah Alexander) Dresbach 6-months later, on 7 August 1971 and Mike was born on 20 June 1972. Candy and Junior divorced 14 December 1973. Candy joined the U.S. Navy. About 6-months after their divorce, Candy re-married Junior Dresbach on 28 May 1974. They remained married for 6-years during which time her son, Andy, was born on 23 May 1975 and daughter, Beth, was born on 9 October 1976. Candy and Junior divorced again on 8 May 1980.

Candy then married Tom R. Karshner on 4 July 1980. They divorced on 9 November 1981.

 

Candy then married Lester “Les” Ray Miller on 9 July 1983 and they divorced 6 October 1989. They remarried on 13 September 1996 and Les died of cancer on 15 January 1998.

 

+ Phyllis Ann Logan (9 Apr 1944 – living)                                                                          Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Angela "Angie" Lynn Harrington (9 Nov 1963 - living)

William Young Harrington, Jr. (3 Nov 1965 - living)

 

After the death of his first wife, Betty Joan Griffith, on 12 January 1962, Bill Harrington remarried to Phyllis Ann Logan-Cave on 11 Mar 1963. Phyllis brought her young daughter Brenda Sue Cave, age 2-years, 4-months, into the family. Within a few years, Bill and Phyllis embarked on a program of buying distressed properties in the Circleville, Ohio area which they renovated and rented to recover the purchase and maintenance cost. At the time of Bill’s death in 1986, they owned several properties. Nine months after Bill’s death, Phyllis remarried to Robert Bruce Marriott, a truck driver. They married in Franklin County, Ohio. Phyllis sold the investment properties that she had bought with Bill Harrington.

 

Angela "Angie" Lynn Harrington (9 Nov 1963 - living)                                                   Click here to return to the Table of Contents

+ James Keith Beglin, Jr. (11 Aug 1963 – living)

 

Raeanne Lynea Beglin (21 Jan 1985 – living)

 

+ Jewel Songo (07 Jun 1983 – living)

Jacob Keith Beglin (25 Jul 1986 – living)

+ Ginny Kesselring (20 Sept 1987 - living)

 

Jacob Carter Beglin (09 Aug 2010-living)

 

Ella Marie Beglin (08 Jul 2012-living)

 

Martha Bethany Beglin (09 Oct 1990 – living)

 

+ Jeff Brown (18 Mar 1989 – living)

 

Zachary Logan Brown (18 Nov 2009-living)

 

Kree Elizabeth Brown (18 Sep 2013-living)

Rachael Elizabeth Beglin (04 Feb 1993 – living)

+ Allen Rae Demint II (23 Jun 1992 – living)

 

Harley Rae Lynn Demint (18 Jun 2013-living)

 


 


80

 

 

 


Chloe Elizabeth Ann Demint (05 May 2016-living)

 

Samuel Robert Beglin (29 Aug 1995 – living)

 

Sarah Kathryn Beglin (04 Jan 1998 – living)

 

Timothy William Beglin (23 Dec 1999 – living)

 

Emma Joy Beglin (29 Oct 2001 – living)

 

Angela Lynn Harrington, the daughter of William Young and Phillis Ann Logan-Harrington, started school at Pickaway Elementary in 1970. Her junior-high years, 1976-1978, were spent at McDowell Exchange School and her high school years at Logan Elm High School, 1978-1982, where she was in the Honor Society. In 1983 she went to Hocking College from which she graduated in 1984 with an associate degree in Science of Nursing, LPN. After passing her nursing exams she became a Registered Nurse. Angie continued her studies at Ohio University where she is pursuing her education and will graduate in 2017 with a Bachelor’s of Science in Nursing. Her specialties include Progressive Care Certified Nurse (PCCN) and Pediatric Trauma Nurse – ACLS, PALS. Angie currently works at the Nationwide Children’s Hospital in the Emergency Department.

 

On 30 June 1983 Angie married James Keith Beglin, Jr., her high school sweetheart. James had completed his elementary school years at the Laurelville Elementary School, then, followed the same route through junior-high and high school as Angela. James was 1-year ahead of Angela, however, graduating in 1981. He went into the U.S. Army in 1982 and spent his entire tour of duty in Washington State at Fort Lewis. James currently works at Diamond Innovations making synthetic diamonds.

 

Angie and James started their family in 1984 with their first child, Raeanne Lynea Beglin, who was born on 21 January 1985. Over the next 16-years their family has grown to the 8-children listed above.

 

William Young Harrington, Jr. (3 Nov 1965 - living)                                                       Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Elizabeth Helen Greenlee (03 May 1970 – living)

Kayla Beth Harrington (26 Dec 1990 – living)

Rebecca Ann Harrington (12 Aug 1992 – living)

+ Andrew Randal Karst (21 Dec 1989 – living)

 

Adia Elizabeth Karst (26 Mar 2012-living)

 

Gavin Andrew Karst (28 Sep 2014-living)

 

+ Paige Pack (06 Jul 1967 – living)

 

Jarred William Harrington (28 Sept 2001 - living)

 

William “Bill” Young Harrington, Sr.’s lymphoma-cancer was diagnosed at an advanced stage. His first surgery followed shortly after the diagnosis and was in turn followed almost immediately with radiation treatments. At the time of his diagnosis, Bill was constructing a new garage at the rear of his home in Circleville. His work on that project was cut short and he never recovered enough to finish the job. Bill and Phyllis’ daughter, Angie, had married and left home 3-years earlier. Bill’s wife, Phyllis, remarried less than 10-months following Bill’s death. Although Bill Jr. had turned 20-years old, he found it difficult to accept his new step-father, Robert Bruce Marriott, as a substitute of his dead father. The polarity reached a climax in a fist-fight in which his older and stronger step-father thoroughly beat Bill Harrington, Jr. This was clearly an event that could never have happened if Bill, Sr. were there to defend his son. After a short period William “Bill” Young Harrington, Jr.’s became owner of his parent’s house. William “Bill” Young Harrington, Jr. completed the construction of the garage that his father had begun.

 

On 16 Jun 1990 Bill, Jr. married Elizabeth Helen Greenlee and the couple had two daughters, Kayla Beth Harrington born 26 Dec 1990 and Rebecca Ann Harrington

 


 

 


81

 

 

 


born 12 Aug 1992. Bill and Elizabeth Helen Greenlee-Harrington divorced on 22 April 1997 and shared custody of their daughters.

 

Rebecca Ann Harrington married Andrew Randal Karst on 12 July 2012. The couple had their first child, Adia Elizabeth Karst, on 26 Mar 2012. Their second child, Gavin Andrew Karst, was born 28 Sep 2014.

 

Patricia Sue Harrington (20 Jun 1936 - 28 Apr 2013)                                Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Charles Richard Hutchinson (11 Sep 1933 - 30 May 2013)

Charles “Chuck” Richard Hutchinson (3 Sep 1954 - living)

Cheryl Ann Hutchinson (27 Sep 1955 - living)

Craig Patrick Hutchinson (26 Apr 1957 - living)

 

In her last will and testament, Audra Lavada Young Harrington left her small house and lot at 212 West Mound Street, Circleville, Ohio to her only daughter, Patricia Sue Harrington-Hutchinson-Reynolds. Audra explained to her only other living progeny, Richard Edward Harrington, that the reason for this decision was to assure that Patty would always have a home.

 

Audra was always concerned about her daughter's welfare. It was the reason that Audra remained in Circleville, Ohio following her husband, Ira Edward Harrington's, death on November 23, 1983. She had wanted to move back to Monroe County, Ohio, the county of her birth, but chose to remain in Circleville because of her concern for Patty Sue, as she always called her, and Patty's daughter, Cheryl Hutchinson.

 

Patricia Sue Harrington had been born at home in the small brick farm house, 3 miles east of Circleville, Ohio on June 20, 1936. It was a relatively easy birth attended by Dr. Montgomery from Circleville. The family was poor and subsequent follow-up visits to the doctor occurred only in cases of emergency. Audra tried to nurse Patty but before long it became clear that she was not getting enough nourishment. Patty nearly starved before this diagnosis was made and she was switched to a blend of diluted evaporated milk and Karo syrup. After the change of diet she thrived.

 

As Patty grew she became a beautiful child with long blond hair that hung in golden curls. As the youngest and only girl in the family, she was both spoiled and the target of child-level torment from her two older brothers. Patty was combative, however, and soon learned to use tools to help her level the playing field. She took to screaming loud and long when things did not go her way. She would bite her wrist until she left tooth-marks knowing that the extreme of self-inflicted violence would cause her mother to become alarmed and that the action would precipitate criticism on her siblings.

 

Perhaps some of these early childhood actions were signals of things to come. As Patty grew to school age she exhibited new characteristics. She was a below-average performing student. She shunned her school work and the few chores that she was assigned. Her choice of friends was usually from the bottom of her class. Her attitude toward others and life in general became more critical, negative and paranoid.

 

Patricia never finished high school. At the age 17 and a half years, she became pregnant with her first child and on 13 February 1954 she married her future child's father, Charles Richard Hutchinson in Richmond, Indiana. Patty became a mother the following September with all the responsibilities of parenthood. Two more children soon followed.

 


 


82

 

 

 


all the responsibilities of parenthood. Two more children soon followed.

 

Mentally, Pat never developed much further. Her ambition appeared stalled. Her paranoia seemed to deepen. She appeared to choose to live in a household of disarray and dirt rather than exert the energy to organize and clean. Her marriage failed and she found herself with the task of rearing 3 children. Patricia Sue and Charles Richard Hutchinson divorced on 2 July 1969. Audra helped as much as she could by making cloths for Patty and her children, giving her money, making loans to Patty that were never repaid, giving her food, etc. Since such support was an extension of the early care Patty had received as a child, it appeared that Pat expected it and seldom if ever expressed appreciation for the assistance.

 

Eventually, Pat was forced to find work as an aid in a healthcare centers. During this period she also learned how to access public welfare services. At the age of 38-years, while working as a nursing aid, she met and married Harry Reynolds, a crude and abusive retired truck driver who was 28-years her senior. They married on 19 November 1974. This marriage lasted only 3 or 4 years but, it served to temporarily get Patty off welfare. Harry Reynolds died on 12 April 1993.

 

By the time her second marriage dissolved, Pat with the assistance of Audra, was able to access welfare sufficiently to maintain her lifestyle without working. Her daughter, Cheryl Ann Hutchinson, qualified for Supplemental Security Income (SSI) and Pat was able to draw Social Security.

Within a couple of weeks following Audra's death on April 8, 1900, Pat Hutchinson and her daughter, Cheryl Ann Hutchinson moved into Audra's vacated house at 212 W. Mound Street, Circleville, Ohio. With no rent to pay, more money became available. Pat and Cheryl became increasingly obese due to an increasingly sedate life style and the consumption of copious quantities of soft drinks and fast-food. Pat developed an increasingly independent attitude that manifest as hostility toward neighbors and increased her paranoia. Her mood became darker and her views became more negative. Her health began to fail likely accelerated by the continued poor diet and the copious consumption of soft drinks.

 

Over the 10 years following her mother's death, the only known maintenance to the house on 212 W. Mound Street was the addition of a chain-link fence around the property. In the early years of the new century the author and Pat's son, Craig Hutchinson undertook major maintenance of the house to keep it in a livable condition.

Both of her sons, Chuck and Craig, had left Pat's home at the earliest opportunity. Cheryl, the middle child of the 3-children, had a speech deficit that she never overcame, but she had an unusual memory and ability with dates and numbers. She never fully matured and adopted a life style that emulated her mother’s. Pat was psychologically abusive to Cheryl, a situation that worsened as Pat became less able to care for herself and depended more on Cheryl. Finally, a critical point was reached and Cheryl became explosive and physical. Cheryl was removed from the home to live by herself by the community social service. Pat and Cheryl overcame their conflict and Cheryl visited her mother at Pat’s home. They never lived together again, however.

 

Patricia continued to deteriorate physically and mentally until she could no longer care for herself. Her son, Craig, took her into his home where she stayed until her death on April 28, 2013. Patricia’s first husband, Charles Richard “Dick” Hutchinson developed Alzheimer’s and died 30 May 2013, a month after Patricia’s death.

Patty Sue Harrington was hard to love and she seemed to like it that way. But, we loved her, anyway. To my knowledge, Patricia never received psychiatric attention

 


 


83

 

 

 


or treatment, a service that might have altered her life for the better. I recall our half-sister, June Louise Harrington, once speculating that Patricia’s problem might have been related to a problem with her birth. Patty had been delivered at home by Dr. Montgomery, the family physician. Alternately, June speculated, it might have been related to the short period of under nourishment that she experienced shortly after her birth. I tend to discount both of these speculations, but we will never know.

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

Charles Richard Hutchinson, Jr. (3 Sep 1954 - living)

+ Barbara Jean Beaver (2 Jun 1956 - living)

 

Lindsey Audrea Hutchinson (21 Jan 1981 – living)

 

+ Douglas Scott Yors (16 Oct 1974 – living)

Estella Audrea Yors (12 Jan 2013-living)

Eli Jackson Yors (27 Feb 2014-living)

Andrea Michelle Hutchinson (27 Aug 1982 – living)

+ Philip Steven Cranfill (19 May 1980 – living)

Philip Andrew “Drew” Cranfill (22 Sep 2002-living)

 

Zoe Audrea Cranfill (31 Aug 2003-living)

 

Addyson Mae “Addy” Cranfill (23 Apr 2010-living)

 

Charles Richard Hutchinson, Jr., born 1954, went by the nickname, Chuck. His father, also, Charles Richard Hutchinson, born in 1933, used his middle name and went by the nickname, Dick. I recall Chuck as a bright, capable young man who, like many kids of his age and generation, considered himself more intelligent, capable, and ready to out-smart the more mundane members of their world. His youth and minimally functional home life probably contributed to his inflated self-esteem. He seemed to enjoy pushing the limits of legality and by about 1974 found himself in minor conflicts with the law. His final involvement found him sentenced to a 1-year residency in an Ohio Correctional Institution at Lancaster, Ohio. As viewed through the lens of history, the sentence had at least two positive outcomes. First, it gave Chuck time to mature in a secure and disciplined environment in which he could reevaluate his priorities in life. Second, he was given an unexpected and unwarranted gift of a stranger deciding that she would communicate with him, essentially as a pen-pal. The stranger eventually became his wife, Barbara “Barb” Jean Beaver-Hutchinson.

 

Barb became a nurse and deserves major credit for the movement of her family into an economic and social level above that from which her husband, Chuck, had known. The couple had two lovely daughters for whom they provided both a higher education and opportunities for their own families. Their oldest daughter, Lindsey Audrea Hutchinson, became a lawyer while Andrea “Ande” became an accountant. Both married and have lovely families.

 

Cheryl Ann Hutchinson (27 Sep 1955 - living)                                                           Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Cheryl Ann Hutchinson graduated from Circleville High School in May 1973. She lived with her mother nearly full time until about the year 2000. After graduation, Cheryl held several odd jobs such as with Mason’s Furniture in Circleville, the Work Shelter in Circleville and a similar organization in Dexter, Michigan while staying with Dick Harrington’s family in the late1970s. Cheryl never married.

 


 


84


 

 

Craig Patrick Hutchinson (26 Apr 1957 - living)                                                       Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Kimberly "Kim" Martin (28 Sep 1962 - living)

 

Marylynn Christine Hutchinson (18 Apr 1987 - living)

 

+ Christopher Metcalf (31 Dec 1980-living)

 

Gracelynn Metcalf (23 Jul 2011-living)

Ellie Metcalf (07 Dec 2012-living)

+ Frank Mann (unknown-living)

 

Jacob Mann (11 March 2016)

 

Tabatha Ann Hutchinson (22 Oct 1988 – living)

 

Carson Lloyd Freasure ( 21 September 2008 – living)

 

Lillie Ann Fields (20 October 2012 – living)

 

Cloe Mayfield (13 May 2016 – living)

 

Upon graduation from high school in Circleville, Ohio, Craig Patrick Hutchinson joined the U.S. Army and was stationed in Texas, USA. While in the Army, he bought a motorcycle that he rode home after his release from service. He married Kimberly “Kim” Martin about 1987. The couple had two lovely daughters, Marylynn Christine and Tabatha Ann Hutchinson. Both daughters now have their own families.

 

Roy William Harrington (14 Aug 1902 - 02 Jul 1975)                                               Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Martha Kathryn Payne (11 Feb 1906 - 01 Jul 1993)

Norma Jean Thompson (daughter of Easter Marie

Harrington-Thompson, 23 Jun 1930 - 22 Feb 1994)

 

On his 31 May 1924 marriage license application to the lovely Martha Kathryn Payne (she went by Kathryn), Roy William Harrington gave his occupation as a truck drive. Sometime over the next 6-years he became a lineman for the Electric Light Company. Roy worked throughout his life for the same company and became a supervisor for their Circleville operation. He retired from the same company sometime after 1959. By then, he was divorced from Kathryn Payne-Harrington. He retired to a cottage by the Muskingum River in or near Stockport, Morgan County, Ohio where he lived with a woman named Mae - I don't know her surname. They did not marry. Roy died while living at this location.

 

Roy was a steady worker with a good work-ethic and was a good provider. He had no children of his own. However when Easter Marie Harrington Thompson died on 25 July 1932, Roy and his wife, Kathryn, took Easter's 2-year, 1-month old daughter, Norma Jean Thompson and raised her until she married Richard Gale Binkley in about 1946. The 1940 U.S. Federal Census indicates that Roy and Kathryn also had Roy's parents and nephew, Jack Harrington in their household. Roy's parents lived with him for most of the decade of the 1940s with his mother moving out in about 1946 and his father continuing to live with him until he died on 24 July 1951.

 

Like most of his siblings, Roy loved to fish and he was renowned within the family for his fishing cabin that he built on Darby Creek a few miles west of Circleville. It was a 2-room cabin with one bedroom that held 4-beds and a kitchen-sitting room combination. There was also an attached storage shed that had been built after the cabin

 


 


85

 

 

 


was completed. The cabin was located in a completely wooded area that provided summer shade, about 50-yards up a slight rise from Darby Creek. In good weather there could be someone vacationing there, and almost every weekend there would be several members of Harrington families enjoying the facility. It was the meeting place for Harrington’s for many years.

Within the family, Roy had a unique talent for "calling square dances." He was known for miles around as an excellent caller and was frequently solicited to call regularly scheduled square dances which were popular in the 1940s and 1950s. He also called for special events such as dances held by lodges and sometimes schools. I danced to many square dances that he called. It was an excellent way to exercise and have fun.

 

The Harrington clan of Circleville, Ohio liked their beer and mixed drinks. If practice-makes-perfect in drinking, that could be why all of the family who shared Harrington-DNA, that I knew, drank but seldom got drunk - tipsy, sometimes, but never drunk. There was always beer at Roy's fishing cabin and most family functions. This contributed to the vocal-volume of the more boisterous family members.

 

Roy may have been one of the champions of the family in his beer consumption. Most of this reputation was made toward the end of his life, however. I was told that after he retired he would replenish his beer supply on Saturday by returning seven 24-empty-bottle cases and taking home 7-full cases of beer. Eventually, the alcohol burden on his aging body took its toll. Roy died of sclerosis of the liver on 2 Jul 1975 at the age of 73-years. He left his cottage on the Muskingum River and other possessions to his house-partner, Mae, who sold them and moved to southern Ohio. She too died within about a year after Roy's death.

 

Roy William Harrington had no biological children of his own.

 

Martha Kathryn Payne (11 Feb 1906 - 01 Jul 1993)                                                  Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Martha Kathryn Payne-Harrington went by her middle name, Kathryn. She was born on 11 February 1906 in Ross County, Ohio, the daughter of a farm laborer. She was a beautiful young lady when she was married on 31 May 1924 to Roy William Harrington as can be seen on page 2 in the album. Kathryn was attractive throughout her life. She was a good friend of my mother, Audra Harrington. Kathryn and Roy took Easter’s 2-year old daughter, Norma Jean Thompson, when Easter died on 25 July 1932 and raised her as their own. They did not adopt Norma Jean, however. Norma Jean Thompson’s biographical sketch is on page 91. Kathryn loved to dance and accompanied her husband to most of the square-dances that he called. She became heavier as she aged, probably from lack of exercise. Kathryn and Roy Harrington separated but I never found a divorce document. After their separation Kathryn became the partner of Roy’s younger brother, Fred Harrington. They never married but lived together until Fred died of cancer on 26 Sep 1975. Kathryn died on 1 July 1993 at the age of 87-years old.

 

Easter Marie Harrington (31 Mar 1904 - 25 Jul 1932)                                              Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Ward Emitt Thompson (04 Apr 1897 - 06 Jan 1977)

 

Raymond Alvin Thompson (31 Jan 1923 - 30 Apr 1988)

 

Robert Eugene Thompson (25 May 1924 - 13 Dec 1987)

 

Russell Emmitt Thompson (30 Dec. 1925 -18 June 1997)

 

Norma Jean Thompson (23 June 1930 - 15 Feb. 1994)

 

James Richard Thompson (19 Mar. 1932 - 12 May 2006)

 


 

 


86

 

 


 

Easter Marie Harrington was born 31 Mar 1904 in Pickaway County, Ohio, the youngest daughter of Bill and Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington. She was only 16-years old when, on 28 Oct 1920 she married Ward Emmitt Thompson a 23-year old farm boy from Hocking County, Ohio. Ward was 7-years Easter’s senior with limited education. Easter bore her first son at the age of 18 and had 4 more children by her 28th birthday. It was the year 1932 and the Great Depression was in full swing. Ward Thompson, had only a laborer’s job as a farm-hand and was already hard pressed to feed and care for his wife and 5 children. By mid-July, Easter had confirmed that she was again pregnant with her 6th child. At the time of her death, Easter’s youngest child, James Richard Thompson, was only 4-months old. Easter died on 25 Jul 1932, four months after her 28th birthday, from a botched attempted abortion. The informant given on Easter’s death certificate was her husband, W. E. Thompson, whose address was Groveport, Ohio.

 

When Easter died on 25 Jul 1932, my parents, Ira and Audra Harrington, and the Ruth Harrington-Pennell family were in Miami, Florida. I was only 7-months old and as a result I never knew Easter. My parents packed a few things and drove non-stop for 21-hours back to Circleville, Ohio to Easter’s funeral. They did not returned to Florida for another 25-years.

 

Easter Marie Harrington Thompson is buried beside her husband, Ward Thompson, in Hitler-Ludwig Cemetery about 3 miles east of Circleville, Ohio.

 

Ward Emitt Thompson (04 Apr 1897 - 06 Jan 1977)                                                  Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Ward Emit Thompson was the middle child in a family of 9-children. He was born 4 April 1897 in Perry Township, Hocking County, Ohio to Joseph F. and Mary Jane Davis-Thompson. Like many young people of Ward’s generation, he quit school with only an 8th grade education to enter the work force. Like his father, Joe Thompson, Ward probably hired out as a farm hand which would be his profession for the rest of his life. On 3 September 1918, at the age of 18-years, Ward enlisted in the U.S. Army to fight in World War I. However, on 11 November 1918 World War I ended and Ward was Honorably Discharged on 15 December 1918. His total service time in the U.S. Army was 3-months and 12 days. Unlike many other men who fought in that terrible war, Ward was one lucky soldier. Twenty-two months following his release from the Army, Ward married Easter Marie Harrington on 28 October 1920. The first child for whom we find a record of birth was Raymond Alvin Thompson who was born on 31 January 1923, 3-years and 3-months following Ward and Easter’s marriage. Over the next 9-years, four more children were born, all my 1st cousins.

 

On 25 July 1932 Ward’s wife, Easter Marie Harrington-Thompson died. She had given birth to her youngest son, James Richard Thompson, just 4-months earlier on 19 March 1932. By late June or early July, she had discovered that she was pregnant again which would have made her next child just a year younger than James Richard Thompson. Barely able to support their existing family, Easter decided to try an abortion. Perhaps this was not her first abortion, but it cost her life on 25 July 1932. With the loss of his wife, Ward’s family fractured. He was forced to place his two youngest children with other families to foster.

 

The months following Easter’s death would have been extremely difficult for Ward. Even with the placement in foster homes of his two youngest children, Norma Jean and James Richard, he was still left with three minor children to care for: Raymond Alvin, 10-years and 6-months; Robert Eugene, 8-years and 2-months; and Russell Emmitt, 6-years and 7-months old.

 

Eight years later on the date of the 1940 U.S. Federal census, found on page 219 of this book, Ward was married to a woman named Hazel who was about 14-years his junior. His family in the 1940 Federal Census included his three sons from Easter Harrington and a new child named Mary Thompson who was 10-years old. Hazel turned out to be Hazel Marie Ogan-Shirkey-Peters-Thompson. Eight years earlier, at the time of Easter’s death, Hazel would have been 21-years and 2-months old. She had married Beman Shirkey when she was 16-years old and in 1930 she had two children, Russell Shirkey who was 1-year and 4-months old and Mary L. Shirkey, who was 2-months old. Sometime between 1930 and 1936 Hazel

 


 


87

 

 

 


divorced Beman Shirkey and married George Peters. The marriage to Peters did not last because on 14 November 1936 she married Ward Thompson, giving her married name on the marriage application with Ward, as Hazel Marie Peters.

 

It is tempting to speculate that the events in the lives of Ward Thompson and Hazel Marie Ogen-Shirkey-Peters may have conspired to solve both of their problems. Hazel may have divorced or otherwise separated from George Peters about the same time that Ward was in need of someone to care for his three minor sons. The arrangement may have been so successful that it led to the marriage of Hazel and Ward on 14 November 1936. Ward and Hazel had their youngest child, David M. Thompson about 1938. I have not been able to find data about David Thompson except for a note that appears in the 1976 obituary of his mother, Hazel, that places him in Williamsport, Ohio. A second note found in the 1977 obituary of his father, Ward, places David in Millersport, Ohio near or at the address of his half-sister, Mary L. Shirkey-French’s. The marriage of Ward and Hazel’s survived 40 years until the death of Hazel on 4 October 1976 at the age of 65. Ward lived only 3-months longer, dying on 6 January 1977 at the age of 79-years. Ward is buried beside his first wife, Easter Marie Harrington-Thompson, in Hitler-Ludwig cemetery about 2-miles east of Circleville, Ohio.

 

I pursued the story of what happened to Ward Thompson after Easter Marie Harrington-Thompson’s death primarily to see if, his children, my 1st cousins, had acquired any half-siblings from Ward’s 2nd wife, Hazel. By then I was working with the granddaughter of Ward Thompson and Easter Marie Harrington-Thompson, Kate Marie Benzin, and decided to pursue the two new names, Hazel and Mary Thompson from the 1940 U.S. Federal census for their possible relationship to Kate. The result of my search answered the question about whether there were additional half-siblings to my five 1st cousins. It also lead to identifying yet another “small world” event of the kind that seems to pop-up with some frequency in the area of genealogy research. Here is what I found:

 

Hazel Marie Ogen was the daughter of Fred and Mary J. Chandler-Ogan. The Ogan family had been in Ross County, Ohio (Ross is the county just south of Pickaway County) for about 3-generations and like most people in Ross County, they were farmers. Hazel Marie Ogan was born 1 June 1911, likely in Ross County, Ohio. She married Beaman (or Beman) L. Shirkey on 25 June 1927 in Circleville, Pickaway County, Ohio. She was 16-years old and Beman was about 18-years old on the date of their marriage. The 1930 Federal Census enumerated Hazel at age 19 with her two children: Russell Shirkey, and Mary L. Shirkey. In the 1940 Federal Census, Russell is enumerated in the household of his grandfather, Fred Ogan, as Russell Ogan. Interestingly, the 1930 census enumeration showed Hazel to be living just 5-houses away from her parent’s house. Hazel and Beman Shirkey lived on Wolfe Road in Pickaway County, Ohio while Fred Ogan lived on Logan Elm Road about a mile away.

 

I found a marriage record in the Pickaway County Marriage Book #21 (1936-1937), page 52 that contained a marriage application for Ward E. Thomson to Marie Peters who were married on 14 November 1936 by Emil S. Toensmeier, Minister of the Gospel, Circleville, Ohio. Ward E. Thompson gave his age as 37 years on the 4th of April 1936. His residence was Circleville, Ohio. His place of birth was Hocking County, Ohio. He was a laborer. His father was Joseph Thompson and his mother was Mary Jane Davis. He was listed as a widower. Marie Peters gave her age as 25 years on the 1st of June 1936. Her address was RFD, Kingston, Ohio. Her occupation was Housework. Her father was Fred Ogan and her mother was Mary Chandler. She stated that she had been married once before and her married name was Mrs. George Peters. So, it appears that between 1930 and 1936, Hazel Ogen-Shirkey may have divorced Beman Shirkey, and married and divorced George Peters, before marrying Ward Emitt Thompson on 14 November 1936. I can only speculate that she may have forgotten about the 1930 Federal Census, or her marriage to George Peters may have been annulled and she did not count it as a 2nd marriage. However, she brought her young 10-year old daughter named Mary L. (Shirkey or Peters) to her marriage with Ward E. Thompson.

 

The reason for calling this a “small world” event is the following: I went to the Pickaway Township School from the 1st through the 12th grades. I recall that there was a student in the grade ahead of me who was named Russell Ogan. I recall Russell as a nice enough guy, and I think he was smart. This was the same Russell Ogan who was born to Hazel Marie Ogan-Shirkey and was being reared by his grandfather, Fred Ogan.

 

 


 


88

 

 

 


 

Another personal but unrelated note from my 3rd grade at Pickaway Township School is that the class included three kids named Wolfe. Two were twins, Ned and Ted Wolfe. The third was Lois Anne Wolfe, a 2nd cousin of Ned and Ted. The Wolfe Road where the Ogan family lived had been named after the great grandfather of these Wolfe students. Lois moved to Kingston, Ohio in Ross County at the end of the 3rd grade. I did not see her again until we were in college in 1951. I married her in 1952 and she is the mother of 5 of my 6 children.

 

Raymond Alvin Thompson (31 Jan. 1923 - 30 Apr. 1988)                                          Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Raymond Alvin Thompson was the first-born child to Ward and Easter Thompson. We know very little about Raymond Thompson except for what can be derived from his public records. His sister, Norma Jean Thompson, who was reared by Roy William and Kathern Payne-Harrington, knew essentially nothing about him. The 1940 U.S. Federal Census record shows Raymond Alvin, age 17, and his two brothers, Robert Eugene, age 15, and Russell Emmitt Thompson, age 14, still living with their father, Ward Emitt Thompson, who by then had married Hazel Marie Ogan-Thompson. Raymond’s personal records indicate that he and his wife lived most of their lives in Corpus Christi, Texas where he died at the age of 65-years. The Corpus Christi, Texas city directories list him as a truck driver for at least two trucking companies. Raymond and his wife, Millie Faye Carren-Thompson may have had children but at the time of this writing, there are no records to establish propagation.

 

Robert Eugene Thompson (25 May 1924 - 13 December 1987)                                 Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Catherine Almeda Clark (05 Jan 1926 – living)

 

Catherine Marie Thompson-Benzin (2 December 1944 – living)

 

+ Clara Marie Nisley (24 May 1931 - 26 Feb 1984)

 

Debra Thompson (abt 1951 - ?)

 

Ward Keith (Scooter) Thompson (14 Aug 1956 - 01 Nov 2011)

 

Kenny L Thompson (abt. 1958 - 01 Jan 2014)

 

Kimberly Michelle Thompson (Dec 1958 - 09 Feb 1959)

Robert E. Thompson (? - ?)

Richard E. Thompson (? - ?)

 

+ Evelyn (surname unknown) (? - ?)

 

Ward and Easter Harrington-Thompson’s second child was Robert Eugene Thompson. He was born less than 16-months after his older brother, Raymond, was born. Robert was 8-years and 2-months old when his mother died. After Easter’s death the two youngest children of the family were placed with relatives to be reared. Robert and his two brothers, Raymond and Russell remained with their father, Ward Thompson.

 

Robert Eugene Thompson’s story is primarily derived from the literature. The exception is that through DNA analyses, I made contact with his daughter. So, the remainder of Robert’s story is better told through the eyes of his daughter, Catherine Marie Thompson-Benzin.

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

Catherine “Kate” Marie Thompson-Benzin (2 December 1944-living)

 

In about March of the year 2016, Ancestry.com sent me the results of a person named Kate Marie Benzin who had her DNA analyzed and was found to be a predicted 1st or 2nd cousin match to me. I e-mailed Kate using the e-mail program provided by Ancestry.com. I received a reply from Kate in which she said that she thought we might be related as 1st cousins, once removed. So, we began an e-mail discussion and discovered that Kate M. Benzin is the daughter of Robert Eugene Thompson who was the

 


 


89

 

 

 


second son of my Aunt Easter Marie Harrington-Thompson. Kate was able to fill in much of the story of Robert Thompson but knew very little about his siblings. She confirmed that on 1 December 1941, six days before Japan’s attacked on Pearl Harbor, at the age of 17-years and 6-months, her father had enlisted in the U.S. Navy. He was sent to the Great Lakes Training Camp for indoctrination and training – better known to Naval personnel as “boot-camp.” That was where Robert met Catherine Almeda Clark whom he married on 16 December 1943 and with whom he had a daughter on 2 December 1944 that they named Catherine Marie Thompson; Kate Marie for short. Upon completing boot-camp the family moved to San Diego where they lived for a while in the San Diego Navy Housing facilities. Before long, Robert was shipped-out aboard a ship that was engaged in fighting the Japanese who occupied Indonesia.

 

Kate and her mom moved back to the Chicago area where the Clark family had lived for about 3-generations. When the war was over and Robert was released from the Navy on 26 May 1943, one year and eight months after the surrender of Japan that ended WW-II in the Pacific, he returned to his family in the Chicago area. They bought a small property south of Chicago and Robert built a house. Apparently, things did not go well for the couple and within a year or so, when Kate was about 4-years old, her parents separated. Kate and her mom continued to live in their house and Robert returned to Ohio, near Columbus, Ohio where his parents and younger siblings lived. Kate's mom began dating after the separation and within about 4 or 5 years when she wanted to marry John Louis Benzin she pushed for a divorce from Robert. John Louis Benzin who was of German descent adopted Kate after his marriage to her mother in September 1953 when Kate was about 9-years old. This accounts for Kate having Benzin as her surname.

 

Kate became a school teacher and taught for a few years. One day she got an offer to teach "computer-operation" to a group in Indonesia. It was a 3-month job that she took, largely for the trip and the experience. She liked Indonesia and made it her new home. In Indonesia she took a job as a tour guide leading tours, first, to the northeastern USA, then expanding to Europe and ending up leading tours in Russia. She set up a branch of the company for which she was working in Indonesia. She is now retired from the tour-guide business and spends her time writing books and providing website consultation. She has written 7 or 8-books which are available on Amazon.com under her name, Kate Benzin. I watched a video on U-tube that she made about her experience when the volcano, Mount Merapi, on the side of which she has a home, erupted in 2010.

 

From about the age of 4-years, Kate had not seen her biological father until they met again on her 40th birthday on 2 December 1984. Robert looked her up and came to see her on one of her visits to her mother's family in Chicago. Even at the age of 40-years, Kate said her mother tried to discourage her from meeting her biological father. Kate bypassed her mother and conferred with her grandmother for information about her father who confirmed that he was a nice man and supported her decision to meet with him. Kate said that she found him to be a very nice and warm person. In 1955 Robert remarried to Clara Marie Nisley with whom he had seven children. He lived in Lancaster and Baltimore, Fairfield County, Ohio and worked in the aircraft parts industry. He died on 13 Dec 1987 at his home in Baltimore, Ohio and is buried at Floral Hills Memory Gardens, Lancaster, Fairfield County, Ohio.

 

Emmitt Russell Thompson (30 Dec. 1925 - 18 June 1997)                                                 Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

The third child of Ward and Easter Harrington-Thompson’s was Emmitt Russell Thompson, who was born in the village of Millford Center, Union County, Ohio. As with his older two siblings, he was born in rapid succession, just under 18-months from the birth of his next-older brother, Robert Eugene Thompson. Our knowledge of the life of Emmitt is limited. He enlisted in the U.S. Navy on 10 April 1943 at the age of 17-years and 7-months. He was released from the Navy on 17 February 1947. Records show that his U.S. Social Security Number was issued in California, but it could have been issued when he was in the U.S. Navy. From a conversation with Emmitt’s sister, Norma Jean Thompson-Binkley, I was told that Emmitt lived in Texas. According to Norma Jean, Emmitt had met and married a woman in Texas, possibly of Mexican descent.

 


 


90

 

 

 


Two U.S. Public Records Indices, one for the year 1996, one year before his death – the other undated, show his address to be PO Box 2123, Bandera, TX, 78003-2123 and 11042 Ctn Wd, Bandera, TX, 78003, respectively. Bandera is located in east-central Bandera County. It is 47 miles (76 km) northwest of downtown San Antonio, on the Medina River.

 

Norma Jean Thompson (23 June 1930 - 15 Feb. 1994)               Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Richard Gale Binkley (15 Sep 1924 - 19 Mar 2012)

 

Patrick Eugene Binkley (25 Jul 1948 - ?)

 

+ Marylin Minton (unknown - ?))

 

Derek Binkley (11 March 1976 - ?)

 

Christa Ann Binkley (20 Jun 1952 - ?)

 

+ Howard Lee McKenzie (unknown - ?)

 

Kristen Lee-Ann McKenzie (23 Jun 1984 - ?)

 

Matthew Scott Binkley (12 Jul 1957 - living)

 

Norma Jean Thompson was the only child of Ward and Easter Harrington-Thompson that I (Richard E. Harrington) really knew. Norma Jean was 18-months, to-the-day, older than me. When her mother, Easter Marie Harrington-Thompson, died on 25 July 1932, Norma Jean was 2-years and 32-days old. With Easter’s death, the family of Ward and Easter Thompson fractured. Ward’s vocation was as a farm-laborer with little or no job security and made barely enough income to feed his family. Norma Jean and her baby brother, James Richard Thompson, aged 4-months, were placed with other families for rearing. Norma Jean was raised by her Uncle Roy William and Aunt Kathryn Payne-Harrington in Circleville, Ohio who were unable to have a child of their own. My family, Ira E. Harrington and the Roy W. Harrington family lived less than 5-miles apart and socialized to a modest degree which brought me in contact with Norma Jean on many occasions throughout our childhood. Norma Jean was a bright, capable student. She was reared as the only child in her uncle’s family and being slightly older than my siblings and me she frequently exhibited a bit of a leadership role. She was a Circleville High School cheerleader. She married Richard Gale Binkley about 1947 and had three children. The family lived in Circleville, Ohio until after 1959 when they moved to Florence, South Carolina where Richard started a new job. Sometime before 1990, Richard Gale and Norma Jean Thompson-Binkley divorced and Norma Jean moved back to Ohio. She lived with her foster mother, Martha Kathryn Payne-Harrington, for a while and later moved to Tarlton, Ohio. She was in poor health when she lived in Tarlton and died on 22 Feb 1994.

 

James Richard Thompson (19 Mar. 1932 - 12 May 2006)                                          Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

James Richard Thompson must have been one confused kid. He was 4-months old when his mother, Easter Marie Harrington-Thompson died and he was passed to the Flowers family to be reared. It appears from the few records that I have for him that he used the surname, Flowers, for much of his life. Even on the Ohio record of his death on 12 May 2006, his “Father’s surname” is given as Flowers. His Social Security Application and Claims Index, 1936-2007, however, lists him as James Richard Thompson and Flowers.

 

Lewis Josiah Harrington (21 Mar 1906 -12 Oct 1969)                                               Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Thelma Gertrude Allen (4 Sep 1908 - 01 Apr 1936)

 

Wanda Lou Harrington (15 January 1925 - 27 April 1929)

Ruby Elizabeth Harrington (16 February 1930 - 18 March 1930)

Donna Lee Harrington (9 October 1931 - 19 December 2012)

+ Paul Eugene Hunt (04 Oct 1932 - 26 Aug 2011)

Mary Lynn Hunt (08 Jan 1953 – living)

 


 


91

 

 

 


+ Ronald Dauer (12 Aug 1950 – living)

        Sandra Dannette Dauer (20 Jan 1973 – living)

 

Patricia Dawn Dauer (21 Jun 1974 – living)

Jaysun David Dauer (07 Feb 1977 – living)

Cynthia Kay Hunt (10 Aug 1954 - Jun 2000 (cancer)

 

+ Ernest Alfred Villiers (8 May 1953 - 23 Jan 2007)

Ernest Alfred Villiers III (07 Feb 1974 – living)

James Henry Villiers (10 Nov 1983 – living)    

Vicky Sue Hunt (30 Sep 1955 – living)

+ Michael L. Miller (08 Sep 1956 - living)

Daniel Forrest Miller (10 Oct 1975 – living)

Amy Elizabeth Miller (07 Jul 1978 - living)

Paul Dennis Hunt (14 Nov 1956 – living)

 

+                 Jennie L. Climer (abt 1961 - ?)

 

+                 Sandra J. Cline (abt 1965 - ?)

 

One child name unknown

 

Thelma De-Ann Hunt (29 Sep 1958 – living)

+ John Danford King (17 Oct 1955 - living)

April Dawn King (14 Apr 1978 – living)

 

John Danford King III (30 Jun 1980 – living)

 

Paul Ellsworth King (01 Mar 1982 – living)

Amanda Lynne King (01 Aug 1983 – living)

Jack Lewis Harrington (21 August 1933 - 30 March 2014)

 

+ Phyllis Joann Boring (abt 1934 - ?)

 

Gregory Lewis Myers (17 Feb 1957 – living)

 

+ Margaret Ann Littell (15 Jun 1942 – deceased)

 

Pamela Kay Harrington (28 Nov 1962 - ?)

Michael Ray Harrington (29 Oct 1964 - ?)

Tamra Lynn Harrington (4 Aug 1966 - ?)

+ Kathleen Charolette Lytle (29 Dec 1931 - Aug 2000)

 

Nine step-children

 

+                 Nora Huffman (unknown )

+                 Marcella Effig (unknown )

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

We learn about Lewis Josiah Harrington (he went by Lou) for the first time as a young man traveling with his older brother, Ira Harrington, by hopping freight trains. At the age of 18, the 1924 Columbus City Directory finds him working as a driver. Lou was blind in one eye as long as I knew him beginning about 1935. I recall one of my very early lessons in etiquette when as a small child, I ask him how he became blind, only to later discover from my mother, that it was not an appropriate question. But, I was young and recall that he told me he had gotten a cinder in his eye. My mother later told me that he had lost his eye as a result of having contracted a venereal disease. I never learned if that was a correct diagnosis.

 

On 15 Dec 1928, at the age of 22, Lou married Thelma G. Allen. At that time, Lou worked as a farm laborer and lived in Circleville, Ohio. Lou and Thelma lost their first two children shortly after each was born. Then, on 01 Apr 1936 Lou’s wife, Thelma, died suddenly while hanging out cloths on a line to dry. By then Lou and Thelma

 


 


92

 

 

 


had two more children, Donna Lee Harrington born 9 October 1931 and Jack Lewis Harrington born 21 August 1933, making them similar in age to Ira and Audra Harrington's first two children, Dick and Bill. I knew both Donna and Jack reasonably well since they lived in Circleville, Ohio and we had occasional contact with them. In the 1990s I interviewed both of them for this book. Neither of Lou's children had any significant recall of their mother. They both expressed deep love for their father; expressions that I believe were very sincere. Donna told me about anxiously waiting for their dad to come home from work and going through his lunch box to see if he left any sandwiches for them. She said he frequently would have a jelly sandwich left over from his lunch. In a different interview with Jack, he described how his dad had died in his arms, a very emotional experience for him.

 

I was touched by both Donna and Jack's tender recalls of their father. Yet, my memory of Lou was that he was not around for them very much. Lou did not have his children with him during his subsequent marriages. Donna lived with her maternal grandparents for several years while Jack lived alternately with his paternal grandparents, then, with Roy and Kathryn Harrington. In their advanced teen-years both were living with their paternal grandparents. My father, Ira, became concerned about seeing both Donna and Jack on the street at night and the inability of their grandparents to control them. Ira initiated steps for both Donna Lee and Jack to go to the children's home. Their father, Lou, did not participate in the process or offer to take his children. Lou's response was to become angry with Ira for a time, but that faded. In retrospect, it was a good move for everyone. Both Jack and Donna became good, useful citizens and enjoyed productive lives.

 

Lou's two subsequent marriages failed but he eventually got and kept a good job with a manufacturing company in Columbus, Ohio that allowed him to retire comfortably. For the last several years of his life, he stopped drinking and smoking.

Lewis Josiah Harrington died at the age of 63-years on 12 Oct 1969 in Columbus, Ohio.

 

+ Thelma Gertrude Allen (4 Sep 1908 - 01 Apr 1936)                                                Click here to return to the Table of Contents

Donna Lee Harrington (9 October 1931 - 19 December 2012)

Jack Lewis Harrington (21 August 1933 - 30 March 2014)

 

 

Thelma Gertrude Allen, the first wife of Lewis Josiah Harrington, was born to Cliff Allen and Cora M. Calvert on 4 September 1908. She died 1 April 1936 at the age of 27-years and 5-months old. I was only 4-years and 4-months old when Thelma died, but I remember visiting my grandparent’s home and seeing Thelma in her casket as she lay in state in their living room. It must have made quite an impression on me to have remembered that event. Thelma would have been the first dead person that I had experienced. My mother, Audra L. Harrington, would have been a little over 6-months pregnant with my sister, Patricia Sue Harrington, at the time of Thelma’s death, although that is not part of my memory. I recall that many years later, my mother told me that Thelma died while she was hanging up cloths on a cloths-line in her back yard. A neighbor saw her laying on the ground and found her dead.

 

Donna Lee Harrington (9 October 1931 - 19 December 2012)   Click here to return to the Table of Contents

+ Paul Eugene Hunt (04 Oct 1932 - 26 Aug 2011)

 

Mary Lynn Hunt (08 Jan 1953 – deceased)

+ Ronald Dauer (12 Aug 1950 – living)

 


 


93

 

 

 


Sandra Dannette Dauer (20 Jan 1973 – living)

 

Patricia Dawn Dauer (21 Jun 1974 – living)

Jaysun David Dauer (07 Feb 1977 – living)

Cynthia Kay Hunt (10 Aug 1954 - Jun 2000 (cancer)

 

+ Ernest Alfred Villiers (8 May 1953 - 23 Jan 2007)

Ernest Alfred Villiers III (07 Feb 1974 – living)

James Henry Villiers (10 Nov 1983 – living)

Vicky Sue Hunt (30 Sep 1955 – living)

+ Michael L. Miller (08 Sep 1956 - living)

Daniel Forrest Miller (10 Oct 1975 – living)

Amy Elizabeth Miller (07 Jul 1978 - living)

Paul Dennis Hunt (14 Nov 1956 – living)

 

+                 Jennie L. Climer (abt 1961 - ?)

 

+                 Sandra J. Cline (abt 1965 - ?)

 

One child name unknown

 

Thelma De-Ann Hunt (29 Sep 1958 – living)

 

+ John Danford King (17 Oct 1955 - living)

April Dawn King (14 Apr 1978 – deceased)

John Danford King III (30 Jun 1980 – living)

 

Paul Ellsworth King (01 Mar 1982 – living)

Amanda Lynne King (01 Aug 1983 – living)

+ Douglas Moore

 

Donna Lee Harrington was my 1st cousin born to Lewis Josiah and Thelma Gertrude Allen-Harrington on 9 October 1931. Donna was my senior by 2-months and 2-weeks. I recall that as a child she was shy. She had been the 3rd child of Lou and Thelma, but the 1st child to live – both of her two older sisters died before they were 4-months old.

 

Donna was just 4-years and 6-months old when her mother died. Neither she nor her brother, Jack, had any memory of their mother. With Thelma’s death, their father, Lou Harrington was left to care for his two young children, a job that he was ill equipped to do. Easter Harrington-Thompson’s death just 4-years earlier had consumed the capacity for the extended family to absorb Donna and Jack and it fell to their grandparents to provide temporary shelter for Donna and Jack. Looking back, it was the beginning of their turbulent childhood in which both children were shifted among families that included their grandparents, their uncle and aunt, Roy and Kathryn, and eventually the Pickaway County Children’s Home. The Home became the only option that remained and was the result of my father, Ira Harrington, taking the lead with County authorities to have them placed in the County Facility. They entered the Children’s Home when Donna was 15-years old. By then, their father, Lou Harrington, had abandoned all responsibility for them and both children were staying with separate aging grandparents who were rapidly losing any control over them. Their father, Lou, became furious with his brother, Ira, for his role in having them placed in the Children’s home, but he offered no alternative nor accepted any responsibility for their care. Within a few years, however, Lou got over his irritation and resumed a normal family relationship with the family.

 

Donna developed into a fine young lady and her childhood experience ended well. In the Children’s Home she was reunited with her brother, Jack, which provided an opportunity to both help oversee his care and make her own experience more comfortable. Her years in the Children’s Home assisting with the care of other children who were there, taught her responsibility, empathy, and life lessons that served her well in her later life. All-in-all, Donna’s time in the Children’s Home was just what she needed at that period in her life.

 


 


94

 

 

 


Donna married Paul Eugene Hunt, a local Circleville, Ohio boy, when she was about 21 years old. Paul was one year younger and a good match for Donna. They both shared an even and low-key personalities that made them compatible. Paul was a truck driver for his entire career, driving for a single trucking company. Donna and Paul were married 59-years, their marriage being interrupted only by the death of Paul at the age of 78-years on 26 August 2011. I visited Donna in the Arbors of Delaware Nursing and Rehab center in Delaware, Ohio in October of 2012. She died 2-months later on 19 December 2012.

 

 

Jack Lewis Harrington (21 August 1933 - 30 March 2014)               Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ Phyllis Joann Boring (abt 1934 - ?)

 

Gregory Lewis Myers (17 Feb 1957 – living)

 

+ Jan Gordon (partner – never married)

 

Sonya Marie Harrington-Gordon

 

+ Margaret Ann Littell (15 Jun 1942 – deceased)

 

Pamela Kay Harrington (28 Nov 1962 - ?)

Michael Ray Harrington (29 Oct 1964 - ?)

Tamra Lynn Harrington (4 Aug 1966 - ?)

+ Kathleen Charolette Lytle-Harrington (29 Dec 1931 - Aug 2000)

 

Jack Lewis Harrington was the second and last child born to Lewis Josiah and Thelma Gertrude Allen-Harrington. Jack was only 2-years and 7-months when his mother died. Jack’s childhood mirrored that of his sister, Donna Lee Harrington, except that they were frequently separated by living with different relatives. Jack and Donna were again reunited when they stayed in the Pickaway County Children’s Home. See the entry above for Donna Lee Harrington for additional details.

 

+ Phyllis Joann Boring (abt 1934 - ?)                                                  Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Gregory Lewis Myers (17 Feb 1957 – living)

 

Jack was married three times and had a child with a fourth woman whom he never married.. He first married Phyllis Joann Boring in the mid-1950s with whom he had one son, Gregory Lewis Harrington, born 17 Feb 1957. Jack and Phyllis separated about 1959 with his wife taking Gregory. Phyllis remarried on 18 June 1960 to Franklin D. Myers in Ventura, California. Franklin Myers adopted Gregory changing his surname to Myers. I recall Jack telling me in a note that he wrote in his Christmas card sometime in the late 1990s that his son, Gregory had called him by telephone and they had talked for several minutes. Jack was elated by that call.

 

+ Jan Gordon (partner – never married)                                               Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Sonya Marie Harrington-Gordon

 

Jack then fathered a baby with Jan (unknown maiden name) that they named Sonja Marie Harrington. That affair broke up with Jan keeping baby Sonja. Jan’s mother took Sonja for a while. Jan later married Ronnie Gordon and the couple took Sonja into their new family. Ronnie Gorden then adopted Sonja changing her name to Sonja Marie

 



Harrington-Gordon.

95

 

 

 


+ Margaret Ann Littell (15 Jun 1942 – deceased)                              Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

Pamela Kay Harrington (28 Nov 1962 - ?)

Michael Ray Harrington (29 Oct 1964 - ?)

Tamra Lynn Harrington (4 Aug 1966 - ?)

 

On 09 Jun 1962, Jack married Margaret Ann Littell in Columbus, Ohio. Margaret was born on 15 Jun 1942 and was over 10-years younger than Jack. This marriage lasted 12-years and 4-months. Their divorce was final on 18 October 1974. Three children were born to this union. At the time of this writing, I have not been able to locate any of his children.

 

+ Kathleen Charolette Lytle (29 Dec 1931 - Aug 2000)    Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

On 10 March 1987, Jack married Kathleen C. Onesko. Jack and Kathleen were both 55-years old. Kathleen had 9-children from three previous marriages but she and Jack had no children together. The names and dates of birth of Kathleen’s children are available in the “Records, Data, and Notes” section of this book on page 409. Kathleen was a heavy smoker. She died in Aug 2000 of lung cancer, just a couple of years after my last visit with them on South High Street in Columbus, Ohio.

 

Marvin Frederick Harrington (17 May 1909 - 26 Sep 1975)    Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

+ (unknown wife former marriage claimed on his marriage application to Florence Moore)

 

+ (unknown partner Fred claimed that in England he bore his only child)

 

+ Florence Moore (27 Dec 1902 - ?)

 

+ Stella Marie Lambert (15 Jan 1900 - 27 Apr 1962)

 

+ Martha Kathryn Payne (11 Feb 1906 - 01 Jul 1993) (Partner: Kathryn and Fred never married)

 

Marvin Frederick Harrington was the eighth and last child of William Alvin and Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington. He went by the nickname, Fred, of his middle name, Frederick and used M. as his middle initial. He was in the U.S. Army in WW II in England & Europe. June L. Harrington believed that Fred had a child while in England. Also, Fred once asked of me, after learning that I had made a trip to England, "Did you see any kids over there that looked like me?" so who knows. Other than that “hint” Fred had no other known children that he claimed.

Like several of the immediate Harrington family, Fred had several spouses; four that I know about. Fred’s first wife is known only by his claim on the marriage license application for his second marriage to Florence Moore of having been married once before. From the Pickaway County, Ohio, Marriage Book number 18, page 542 - Marriage on 9 July 1930 of Fred Harrington, age 21, born 17 May 1909 in Circleville, Pickaway County, Ohio, to, Florence Moore, age 28, born 27 December 1902 in Friemon, West Virginia. Their marriage was performed by E.A. Brown, Circleville, Ohio. Fred Harrington’s residence was Circleville, Pickaway County, Ohio. His occupation was Ice-man (likely another of the ice delivery jobs provided by his Uncle Bill Allen Eblin). On Fred’s marriage application, his father was William Harrington and her mother was Elizabeth Pence. Florence Moore’s residence was Circleville, Ohio. Florence’s occupation was clerk. Her father was Graham Moore and her mother was Elpha Roy. Fred declared that he had been married once before. Florence did not declare regarding a previous marriage – it was left blank. Fred’s marriage to Florence lasted 11-years. His wife divorced him while he was in the Army during WW-II.

 


 


96

 

 

 


Fred Harrington was the youngest of Ira Harrington's siblings. He was a colorful character, extraverted, and inclined to pursue short-cuts in life as opposed to embracing a serious career. I first remember Uncle Fred when he and my father, Ira Harrington, went into the swine butchering business in the mid-to-late 1930s. Fred was in his mid-20s and unemployed. He was physically able to be a good partner for the arduous work of butchering. He proved to be an unreliable partner for that enterprise, however, by collecting money from sales of the pork products and keeping it. That eventually caused the business venture to go out of business.

 

Later when Fred returned from WWII in about 1945 he brought two air-rifles back for my brother, Bill, and me. He had been a cook in the Army and was associated with other administrative-type tasks such as collecting arms from the surrendered German Army and German Citizens.

Upon returning from World War II in Germany, Fred remarried. From the Pickaway County, Ohio, Marriage Book - Marriage on 3 May 1946 of Fred Harrington, age 38, born 17 May 1909 in Circleville, Pickaway County, Ohio, to, Stella Marie Lambert, age 46, born February 1900 in Vermont. Fred’s father was William Harrington and his mother was Elizabeth Pence. Stella Marie Lambert’s father was Andrew Lambert and her mother was Emma, surname unknown. This marriage lasted 16-years and was terminated by Stella’s death on 27 Apr 1962. Stella is buried in Hitler Cemetery in Pickaway County, Ohio.

 

Fred liked his liquor and good food. Not surprisingly, his vocation became that of bartender of a small neighborhood local bar on South Pickaway Street in Circleville, Ohio named "Shifty's." Being a relatively small bar, Fred was the only employee. The proprietor of Shifty's lived in Columbus, Ohio and left the management of the bar to Fred. Fred apparently managed the establishment well since he worked there for many years - perhaps approaching 20-years. Consistent with Fred's character and background as a cook, it wasn't long before he began roasting good cuts of meat and providing a few side dishes to supply his customers with food, for a price. The model for his venture may have been that of the pubs that he had experienced during his military tenure in England. The side-business of food at Shifty's served to make the bar more attractive to customers and was a side-business that would have little accountability to the proprietor. At the time of the writing of this book in 2016, Shifty’s is still in business in Circleville, Ohio.

 

After Stella Marie Lambert's death, Fred took Kathryn Payne-Harrington, the ex-wife of his older brother, Roy Harrington, as his partner. They did not marry, however, they lived together until Fred’s death.

Fred died 26 September 1975 of cancer. He was buried 30 September 1975 at Spring Bank Cemetery, Ross Co. Ohio on Rt. 104. He had no known children; only the possible child that he claimed who might be living in England.

 

Epilogue

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

This brings to a close the Story section of this book. It began by telling you everyone and everything that the author, Richard E. Harrington, knew or was able to find out through research about as many of the members of the eight ancestral families. These eight ancestral lines have introduced hundreds of ancestors. Most of them were not previously known to us. The “Focus Couple” of these families has been William Alvin and Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington, my father’s parents. Each of the children of

 


 


97

 

 

 


William and Sarah Harrington served as the spring-board for the 350+ descendants of William Alvin Harrington’s family. In all, thousands of us are related. Our journey has covered a time span of about 400-years. Nevertheless, we have discovered and discussed only a fraction of the people to whom we owe our existence.

 

In our society we are indebted to the early church and to the efforts of tax collectors of governments for the invention of how we structure our names. The system that was invented is based on a philosophy of male domination within the family. Women assume the surname of the man upon marriage and children who are born take their father’s surname. Unfortunately, the result is the early loss of the identity of most female surnames that is so important to understanding the full structure of a family. Nearly every generation of each surname-based family tree loses an important family name and a full family tree.

 

The advent of DNA analyses is helping to eliminate some of the limitations that we find that results from the way we name and record people. Also, with the advent of computerized record storage and records management it is likely that the ability to document and track people will continue to improve making genealogy research more reliable, less difficult and time consuming. DNA science is still in its infancy and promises even more advantages for the future.

 

It is my hope that this book will find new authors in the future who will take the challenge of digging deeper into the family history and expand on the many families that have yet to be explored. And, of course, there is always the need for family scribes to continue to record the progeny yet to come and keep the family history current.

 

Harrington Coat of Arms

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

 

The Harrington Crest or Coat of Arms that appears throughout this book is purely for decoration. While it is purported to be an actual Harrington crest, it is not known to be a crest of our Harrington family. I seriously doubt that our Harrington immigrants to the North American continent had need for, or perhaps even knew of a family crest.

 

Records, Data, and Notes

 

This is the second part of the book following the “Story of the Harrington Family” in Ohio and Nova Scotia. It is a selected, structured data-dump from the Family Tree Maker that I have used to store and organize my data and information for this book. It includes relevant records, data and notes on many of the individuals in the Harrington and related families. The next few paragraphs are here as a guide to the information in this section. You can skip reading them if you like – you can get much of the same information by looking at the Table of Contents (TOC) on pages iv-viii, but you will have to figure it out for yourself.

 

Most of this material has been gathered through personnel research over the past 25 or so years. It represents most of what I, the author, know or have discovered about our Harrington and related families. As noted in the Preface of this book, much credit is due to Ancestry.com, of which I am a member, for making many of the historical record sources readily available, obviating a lot of travel and burdensome searching through federal, state and county files that requires significant time and expense. Even with the help of Ancestry.com, however, considerable private research was required.

 


 


98

 

 

 


A partial list of these ancestral lines follows. This list of 23 ancestral lines includes all of the lines in my database for which there are 2 or more known consecutive generations. Ancestral lines that have been researched in detail and presented in this “Records, Data, and Notes” section are identified with an asterisk, (*).

 

Bentz/Pence - Hans Martin Bentz *

 

Bier - Peter Bier (abt 1680)

 

Bohlender - John Jacob Bohlender (abt 1700) *

 

Bullinger - Jacob Bullinger (abt 1675)

 

Coon - Hanness Coon (1695)

 

Dromm/Drum - Nickel Dromm (1591) *

 

Friess - Johann Michael Friess (abt 1740)

 

Hall - Reinhard Renniger Hall (abt 1675)

 

Haynlyn - Michael Haynlyn (abt 1680)

 

Herrington/Harrington - Dutch Charlie Herrington (abt 1780) *

 

Hoyt - Nathan Hoyt (1691)

 

Jung - Johann Jacob Jung (abt 1650)

 

Leist - Andrew Leist - Jr. (1782)

 

Lockwood - Joshua Lockwood *

 

Matthis - Claus Matthis (abt 1650)

 

Morr - Andew Morr (abt 1700)

 

Nied - Jurg Nied (1690)

 

Rushton - John Rushton (abt 1695) *

 

Strasser - Johann Nicholas Strasser (abt 1715)

 

Valentine - John Valentine (1666) *

 

Walkowicz - John Walkowicz (abt 1785)

 

Webb - Jonathan Webb (12 Apr 1675) *

 

Weber - Mathes Weber (abt 1650)

 

This “Records, Data, and Notes” part of the book can be viewed as a data base for most of the book. The sources and proof-of-data used in the book can be found in this section. Readers of the first part of this book, the “Story of the Harrington Family,” who may be interested in additional material on specific individuals should consult the entry for that person in this “Records, Data, and Notes” part of the book since additional material and detail may be found there.

Most of the data in the “Records, Data, and Notes” are presented in three formats. The first is a Pedigree Chart of the “Focus Couple” found on page 101. It is similar in construction to the chart titled “Relationship of Ancestral Family Lines leading to the Harrington Family” found on page 2 at the front of the book. It is presented first in this section to provide the reader with a detailed map of the several ancestral lines that converge to the Harrington “Focus Couple,” William Alvin and Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington. It is also an index, of sorts, for several of the ancestral lines that have been researched in some detail.

 

Pages 122 thru 457 are follow-ons to the Pedigree chart on pages 101 thru 121. Each ancestral line found on the Pedigree chart is further detailed in two documents. The first is an Outline Descendant Report that lists all known members of that ancestral line along with data such as dates and places of birth and death, and their relationship

 


 


99

 

 

 


to other members of their family. The second is a Descendant Report that contains considerably more data and notes on each of the family members.

 

In this “Harrington Family” book our primary attention is on the Harrington line. That is why all of the ancestral lines eventually converge on the Harrington line and why the “Focus Couple” was chosen to be William Alvin and Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington. For this reason we have followed each known ancestral line, forward in time, until it converges with another line that leads us closer to our Harrington family. For example: (To better follow the example that follows, you may want to refer to the Pedigree chart on page 101 in this section, or, to the chart titled, “Relationship of Ancestral Family Lines leading to the Harrington Family” found on page 2.) Our Drum family line runs from the oldest ancestor, Nickel Dromm, born 1627, toward the future, until it intersects the Valentine line with the marriage of Margaret Drum, born 1799, to Joshua Valentine, born 1796. At this point of intersection, we drop the Drum line and continue to follow the Valentine line until it intersects the Harrington line with the partnership of Sarah Jane Valentine, born 1848, to Charles William Harrington, born 1844. At this intersection we discontinue following the Valentine line in favor of following the Harrington line.

 

This principle for following our ancestral lines, also applies to data found on the Outline Descendant Report charts and the Descendant Report on the pages below.

At the end of this “Records, Data, and Notes” section of the book, beginning on page 461, the data shifts from our ancestral families to the descendants of the “Focus Couple.” These include all of the family members beginning with the children of the “Focus Couple” and proceeding forward in time to the date of publication of this book. A chart of the descendants of the Focus Couple, William Alvin and Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington begins on page 461. This is followed by an Outline Descendant Report of all of their descendants on page 472.

 

R.E. Harrington 15 November 2016

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


100


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


101


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


102


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


103


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


104


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


105


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


106


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


107


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


108


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


109


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


110


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


111


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


112


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


113


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


114


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


115


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


116


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


117


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


118


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


119


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


120


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


121


 

 

 

 

 

Outline Descendant Report for possibly "Dutch" Harrington

 


1 possibly "Dutch" Harrington + "Mother" Harrington

...2 Charles Harrington b: Abt. 1805 ; Notice: read the notes associated with this Charles Harrington entry., d: Unknown

 

+ Eliza Ann Cooper b: 1807

 

......3 Eliza Anna Herrington b: 09 Feb 1835, d: 01 Jan 1895 in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, Oklahoma, USA

 

+  James German Mygatt b: Abt. 1823, m: 1859 in Denver, Denver, Colorado, USA, d: Mar 1870 ; died of consumption

 

.........4 James Franklin "Frank" Mygatt b: 06 Sep 1868 in Clay County, Kansas, USA, d: 13 Aug 1956 in Tulsa, Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA

 

+Ethel Minnie Braker b: 13 Apr 1886 in Malvern, Mills County, Iowa, USA, m: 16 Aug 1908 in Marquette, McPherson, Kansas, United States, d: 26 Apr 1957 in Independence, Macon, Missouri

 

.........4 Susan Coon Mygatt

 

+ Charles Albert Going

 

+ Charles Calvin Covey b: 1825, d: 1856

 

.........4 Eva Monira Covey b: 26 Oct 1853 in Wisconsin, USA, d: 21 Mar 1925 + Robert Litle Shirley

 

.........4 Minnie Julie Covey b: Jan 1854, d: 16 Apr 1916 + Frank L. Turner

 

...2 Thomas Harrington b: Abt. 1813 in County Cork, Ireland

 

+Mary Webb b: 19 Nov 1810 in Nova Scotia, Canada, m: 27 Oct 1841 in Nova Scotia, Canada, d: Aft. 1871

 

......3 Harris D. Harrington b: 1842 in Nova Scotia, d: 1916

 

......3 Charles William Harrington b: 20 Aug 1844 in Wallace, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 20 Aug 1904 in West Bay, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada; Black Rock Cemetry, West Bay, Cumberland, Nova Scotia

+ Sarah Jane Valentine b: 28 Jun 1848 in Washington Township, Pickaway County, Ohio, d: 15 May 1933 in Home Hospital, 4 Ward; buried in St. Paul United Methodist Church, near Circleville, Ohio

 

.........4 William Alvin Harrington b: 10 Jun 1866 in Kansas, d: 24 Jul 1951 in at the home of his son, Roy William Harrington, in Circleville, Ohio; buried in Hitler Cemetery near Circleville, Ohio

 

+Sarah Elizabeth Pence b: 29 Apr 1872 in Benton Twp., Hocking County, Ohio, m: 02 Nov 1890 in Hocking County, Ohio; by James Milhon, V Dr. M, d: 19 Jan 1948 in Circleville, Ohio, Pickaway County, Ohio; buried in Hitler Cemetery near Circleville, Ohio

+ Caroline Couch Willigar b: 27 Feb 1849 in Black Rock, Cumberland County, Nova Scotia, m: 23 Feb 1867 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 08 Oct 1924 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

.........4 Florence May Harrington b: 29 Jan 1869 in Mill Village, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 20 Apr 1905

 

+John Patrick Harrington b: 10 Apr 1873 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada, m: 26 May 1896 in Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

.........4 Thomas Stewart Harrington b: 25 Dec 1870 in Black Rock, Cumberland County, Nova Scotia

 

+Annie Edna Messom b: 03 Feb 1880 in Kentville, Kings County, Nova Scotia, Canada, m: 03 Feb 1900 in Kentville, Kings, Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 29 May 1903

 

+Amey Withrow d: 1908

 

+Paulina (Lina) Rushton b: 14 Jun 1888 in Great Village, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada, m: 27 Jun 1908 in Truro, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 18 Apr 1922 in a house fire

 

.........4 John William Harrington b: 25 Dec 1872 in Port Greville, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 15 Sep 1917 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada; died of Consumption

 

.........4 Harris Harrington b: 04 Jul 1874 in Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 15 Oct 1925

 


 

 


122


+ Emily Rita Willigar b: 08 Mar 1894 in West Bay, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, m: 02 Mar 1916 in Oxford, NS

 

.........4 Mary Jane Harrington b: 25 Mar 1876 in Five Islands, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 21 Mar 1943 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada; Buried in St. George's Cemetery, Parrsboro, NS

 

+Harvey David Henwood b: 18 Apr 1878 in Nova Scotia, Canada, m: 18 Aug 1902, d: 19 Nov 1962 in Nova Scotia, Canada

 

.........4 Freeman Harrington b: 22 May 1877 in Five Islands, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 30 Jul 1965 in Parrsboro, Cumberland Co., Nova Scotia, Canada

 

+Sarah Alice Couch b: 02 Apr 1888 in West Bay, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, m: 20 Dec 1905 in Parrsboro, Cumberland Co., Nova Scotia, Canada; Baptist, d: 16 Sep 1946 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

.........4 Banford Harrington b: 04 Mar 1880 in Nova Scotia, Canada, d: Mar 1921

 

.........4 Ann E. Harrington b: 07 Feb 1882 in Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 1917

 

.........4 Edith Mabel Harrington b: 15 Jan 1884 in Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 10 Feb 1955 in Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

+Mayford Phinney b: 02 Apr 1884 in Black Rock, Cumberland Co, Nova Scotia, Canada, m: 27 Aug 1903 in Parrsboro, Cumberland Co., Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 08 Feb 1943 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

.........4 Bessie Maud Harrington b: 1885

 

.........4 Howard Joseph Harrington b: 20 Mar 1891 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 02 Nov 1960 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada; Alternative dod = 24 Nov 1960

 

+Mary Emily Anderson b: Abt. 1892, m: 11 Nov 1912 in Truro, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada; RC

 

+Rae Laurine Melvin b: Abt. 1908, m: 29 Mar 1934

 

......3 John Webb Harrington b: 26 May 1846 in Granville, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

+ Nancy Anne Embree b: 24 Mar 1843 in Greewnville, Nova Scotia, Canada, m: 26 May 1866 in River Philip, Cumberland Co, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

.........4 Wilbert Barry Embree b: 03 Jan 1863

 

.........4 Mary Alice Harrington b: 07 Feb 1867 in Gray's Road, Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

+Silas Purdy Mills b: 12 Jul 1865 in Nova Scotia, m: 25 Nov 1887 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

.........4 Alexander McPhee Harrington b: 18 Mar 1871 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

+Elizabeth J. Nelson b: 1872 in Nova Scotia, Canada, m: 28 Oct 1890 in Truro, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

+Rachel Bentcliff b: 1873 in Truro, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada, m: 27 Apr 1896 in Truro, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

+Sarah Ann Hennessy m: 22 Dec 1897 in Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

.........4 John Patrick Harrington b: 10 Apr 1873 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

+Florence May Harrington b: 29 Jan 1869 in Mill Village, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada, m: 26 May 1896 in Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada, d: 20 Apr 1905

 

.........4 Ellen Louisa Harrington b: 31 May 1875 in Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

.........4 Lucy L. Harrington b: 08 May 1878 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

.........4 Marguerite May Harrington b: Abt. 1879 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

.........4 Charles Warren Harrington b: 28 Mar 1882 in Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

+Nellie Farrell b: 28 Jul 1882 in Newfoundland, m: 13 Mar 1901 in Springhill, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

.........4 Ella Harrington b: 1883

 

.........4 Annie E. Harrington b: 22 Mar 1884 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

+Florence W. McCarthy b: Abt. 1884 in Springhill, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada, m: 04 Jan 1908 in Amherst, Nova Scotia; Methodist

 


 


Click here to return to the Table of Contents

123

 

 

 


Descendants of possibly "Dutch" Harrington

 


 


Generation 1

 

1.      POSSIBLY "DUTCH"1 HARRINGTON . He married "MOTHER" HARRINGTON.

 

Notes for possibly "Dutch" Harrington: Our Harrington Family in the New World

 

Until early 2013, research to discover the ancestors of my grandfather, William Alvin Harrington (1866-1951), had been unsuccessful. Great grandfather, Charles William Harrington, was a proverbial “brick wall.” My father, Ira Edward Harrington (1899-1983) recalled his grandmother, Sarah Jane Valentine, telling her family that 1) the name of the father of her son, William Alvin Harrington, was Charles William Harrington and that 2) Charles was of Irish descent and 3) had been born in Nova Scotia. 4) Charles had arrived in Kansas on a cattle boat and 5) had given their son his middle name, William. It was not until I (Richard Edward Harrington (1931-living)), had my DNA analyzed by Ancestry-DNA that my quest began to bear fruit. My first clue came in the form of an e-mail from Ancestry-DNA advising of a DNA match with another member named Linda McNeil. Linda e-mailed me that she did not know the source of our DNA match but she speculated that it might be from the several Harrington’s in her family tree from Nova Scotia. Subsequent research persuaded me that the Harrington’s in her family tree likely were the source of the DNA match. I made a trip to Nova Scotia with my wife in the summer of 2013 to further research this possibility. In Parrsboro, Nova Scotia we found a plethora of Harrington information and descendants. Confirmation of all of the clues that had been passed down from Sarah Jane Valentine seemed to point to Charles William Harrington being my long-sought-after great grandfather. We found records that identified Charles parents as Thomas Harrington and his wife Mary Webb. We also found a detailed family tree of the family of Mary Webb. We gathered as much information on the Nova Scotia Harrington line as possible and met with many of the descendants of Charles that are living there. We even visited the graves of Charles, his Nova Scotia wife, and many of his descendants. In spite of our apparent success, we were never able to prove, beyond a doubt, that the Nova Scotian Charles William Harrington was the correct great grandfather. While it seemed highly unlikely, it was still possible that the DNA match could have been with another related surname.

 

On 16 November 2014 I received another e-mail from Ancestry-DNA announcing their new “DNA Circles” project. This feature of their services involves identifying members whose DNA and/or family tree, show a match with a common ancestor. The name given to such a Circle is the name of the common ancestor of the Circle members. Within days, Ancestry-DNA identified two Circles that were in my Nova Scotia family line. They were the parents of Mary Webb, Jane Sarah Rushton (1784-1869) and Samuel James Webb (1785-1828). These Webb and Rushton Circles made the possibility that the match with Linda McNeil could be from another related surname, a certainty, since Linda also shares the Webb and Rushton ancestors. Further, DNA results from any of the Nova Scotian descendants would be similarly compromised since they also share the Webb and Rushton DNA. The only way to prove my Harrington linkage with Charles William and his father, Thomas Harrington, would be to find a DNA match with another Harrington descendant who was independent of the Webb and Rushton family. Finding such a match would seem to be highly unlikely, but it happened.

 

In January of 2016, my Ancestry-DNA account showed a new Circle that had been named the “Eliza Anne Herington Circle.” This DNA match was with a person who was known by the pseudonym “J.M.” and was administered by Sharon Ann Balts. The match was identified as being a possible 2nd - 3rd cousin and the confidence level was rated “Extremely High” by Ancestry-DNA. The J.M. turned out to be Jennie Marie Mygatt (1919-living), daughter of James Franklin “Frank” Mygatt (1868-1956). Sharon Ann Balts is the daughter-in-law of Jennie Marie Mygatt. Frank’s mother was Eliza Anna Herington (1835-1895), daughter of Charles Herington (about 1807-?), an immigrant to America. Charles Herington (about 1807-?) was the son of a fisherman known only as “Dutch” Charley.

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

Sharon Balts-Stauffer made me aware of and provided a copy of a family history document originated by James Franklin “Frank” Mygatt (1868-1956) and transcribed by his niece. Sharon

 


 


124


Generation 1 (con't)

 

Balts-Stauffer believes the document to have been transcribed by Mary Going Kelso, in Tulsa, Oklahoma in the period 1953-1956. The full text of this document can be found in the entry for James Franklin “Frank” Mygatt (1868-1956) in this book and should be read and understood as the basis of conclusions that follow and support the premise that the events of the Nova Scotia Harrington family and the events of the James Franklin “Frank” Mygatt (1868-1956) document are related and support each other. The most important evidence, of course, is that the DNA matches from each scenario focus on the author, Richard E. Harrington (1931-living) and independently tie the two scenarios together.

 

According to the interpretation of the data and information by Richard E. Harrington, the story of the Harrington family in America begins with the James Franklin “Frank” Mygatt (1868-1956) document, hereafter referred to as the Mygatt document.

 

“Dutch” Charley was a fisherman. According to the Mygatt document (James Franklin “Frank” Mygatt (1868-1956) document), “Dutch” Charley was from Holland. This may be true but considerable data exist to argue that the family originated from Ireland. Either possibility is credible since under the heel of English rule, Ireland in the late 1700s and early 1800s was in a desperate economic condition. Holland had developed a successful, world-class fishing fleet and enjoyed a thriving fishing industry. Ireland on the other hand did not begin to promote their fishing industry until the early 1800s. So, it is likely that Irish fisherman would have looked to the established Holland fishing industry as a more profitable place to apply their trade.

 

Whether the early Harrington clan was from Holland or Ireland is of little importance. It is clear that they were accomplished seamen. The Mygatt document has Charles Herington, Jr. (about 1807-?) going to sea in his teens and soon establishing himself as a knowledgeable seaman. He quickly allied himself with the fur trading industry in the new world and made several crossings of the Atlantic Ocean. His work was undoubtedly as a sailor which was what he had been trained to do. Since he was saving his money to move his wife to America, it seems obvious that he was not paying for his Atlantic passages. It also seems clear that his alliance with the fur trading industry was probably as a sailor in the industry’s fleet of ships that crossed the Atlantic regularly, transporting furs from the new world to their main markets in Europe. At that time, the fur trading industry was the most profitable and best paying employers in the world.

 

According to the Mygatt document, Charles Herington, Jr. moved with his wife, Anna Eliza Coopper-Herington and her brother, John Coopper, to America, landing at Hoboken, New Jersey on 5 March 1835. At this time Charles Herington, Jr. and his wife, Anna Eliza Coopper-Herington had a 3-year old son, Charles 3rd Herington. Within a few days of their arrival in Hoboken, they added a daughter, Eliza Anna Harrington (9 Feb 1835 - 1 Jan 1895) (note the difference in the date of arrival and Eliza’s date of birth.) They settled in western New York on the Great Lakes where they lived several years. Charles Herington, Jr. continued to work for the fur trading industry. At this point the Mygatt document says that Charles Herington, Jr. was killed by Indians in northwest Wisconsin. The Mygatt document also says that sometime in the 1840, Anna Eliza Coopper-Harington and John Cooper moved to Millwaukee, and they settled in Oshkosh, Wisconsin where they lived for several years. Then in 1849 or early 1850s Anna E. Coopper-Harington & John Cooper moved to Leavenworth, Kansas. The Mygatt document does not mention Anna E. Coopper-Harington and John Cooper again. This is assumed to mean that they stayed in Leavenworth, Kansas. The Mygatt document continues to track Eliza Anna Harrington (9 Feb 1835 - 1 Jan 1895) through 2-marriages and to Leavenworth, Kansas between about 1861 and 1865, as the wife of James G. Mygatt. After retirement from the Army, Eliza Anna Harrington-Mygatt and James G. Mygatt moved to Clay County, Kansas, a distance of about 120 miles west of Leavenworth, Kansas. It was from Eliza Anna Harrington-Mygatt that the Harrington DNA was passed on to the descendants, including me, that now register the DNA matches among us.

 

Click here to return to the Table of Contents

At this point, keep in mind that we are dealing with two sources of Harrington DNA. One source is the DNA of the Herington line that originated from “Dutch” Herington, that we have just discussed and is detailed in the Mygatt document. This DNA was channeled through Charles Herington, Jr. to

 


 


125


Generation 1 (con't)

 

his daughter, Eliza Anna Harrington (9 Feb 1835 - 1 Jan 1895) and on to several Ancestry-DNA members, including me. So, for the transmission of this Harrington DNA, it doesn’t really matter whether Charles Herington, Jr. was killed by Indians in Wisconsin, or not.

 

Now, let’s look at the Nova Scotia Harrington DNA and its connection with the Harrington DNA in Leavenworth, Kansas in the paragraphs above. Our Thomas Harrington first appears in the Nova Scotia records in 1841 when he married Mary Webb (1810-after 1971). He appears later in the records of the births of his three sons; Harris in 1842, Charles in 1844 and John in 1846. His name appears in miscellaneous records of his descendants but not in a way that establishes his presence. Thomas sort of breezes onto the scene in 1841 and disappears sometime after the birth of his sons. No records have been found of his birth or his arrival in Nova Scotia. Yet, today we find strong DNA matches with both the Nova Scotia and Kansas Harrington’s. How could this be?

 

Three possibilities come to mind. The first is that the DNA data are wrong or misleading. I reject this possibility on the basis that there are too many DNA matches in both locations (Kansas and Nova Scotia) and too many match-ups of information such as the clues from Sarah Jane Valentine and subsequent data found that match the clues. Another is the coincidence of the geography that will be discussed below.

 

The second possibility is that the Nova Scotia Thomas Harrington had at least one more Harrington relative in America. That relative would have been a brother or cousin and he would have likely been Charles Herington, Jr., son of “Dutch” Charles in the Mygatt document.

 

A third possibility is that Charles Herington, Jr. and Thomas Herington were the same person. This could be possible since Charles Herington, Jr. supposedly was killed by Indians, far from his home, before 1840. The Mygatt documents states that sometime in the 1840s, the wife of Charles Herington, Jr. and her brother, John Cooper moved to Oshkosh, Wisconsin and in 1849 or early 1850s moved to Leavenworth, Kansas. (It is possible that Charles Herington, Jr. and his wife were having problems before 1840 and they separated. The story that Frank Mygatt knew about Charles Herington, Jr. having been killed in western Wisconsin, could have been a cover-story to hide the separation and Charles Herington, Jr. later marriage to Mary Webb.) The timing surely fits. On 27 October 1841 Thomas Herington married Mary Webb. (Thomas Herrington and Mary Webb may have met in Nova Scotia on one of his many trips while working for the fur trading company.)

 

One more event tends to support the possibility that Charles Herington, Jr. and Thomas was the same person. Charles William Harrington (1844-1904), son of Thomas Harrington and Mary Webb, was born in Nova Scotia. Like his father before him and several of his sons, Charles William Harrington was a sailor. In 1865, at the age of 21-years, Charles William was in or near Leavenworth, Kansas when he conceived William Alvin Harrington (1866-1951) with Sarah Jane Valentine. At that time both Anna Eliza Cooper-Herington, wife of Charles Herington, Jr. of the Mygatt document, and Eliza Ann Herrington-Mygatt (probable half-sister of Charles William Harrington of Nova Scotia) were living in Leavenworth, Kansas. It is my speculation that at some point over the previous 20 years, Charles William Harrington of Nova Scotia learned from his father about his father’s family in Leavenworth, Kansas and had gone there to meet them. It is likely that all of these ancestors could have been in communication via postal mail if such a trip were planned. The scenario in which Charles Herrington, Jr. and Thomas Harrington is the same person, of course, is speculation. But, as with many of the other events in the lives of these ancestors, I can’t help but believe that they are too frequent and improbable to be mere coincidences. And then, there are all those pesky DNA matches.

 

It doesn’t really matter to me whether Charles Herington, Jr., son of “Dutch” Harrington, and Thomas Harrington, parent of Charles William Herrington were the same person or that they were brothers or cousins. Of course it would be nice to know. But the DNA matches prove that they were involved in two related lines of Harrington’s in the new world, and that I am related to both lines. I believe that Charles Herrington and Thomas Harrington was the same person.

 

There is still a need to search the passenger lists of ships arriving from Ireland and Holland to both

 


 


126


Generation 1 (con't)

 

America and Nova Scotia.

 

 

Possibly "Dutch" Harrington and "Mother" Harrington had the following children:

 

2.               i. CHARLES2 HARRINGTON was born about 1805 (Notice: read the notes associated with this Charles Harrington entry.). He died date Unknown. He married ELIZA ANN COOPER. She was born in 1807.

 

3.               ii. THOMAS HARRINGTON was born about 1813 in County Cork, Ireland. He married Mary Webb, daughter of Samuel James Webb Sr and Jane Sarah Rushton, on 27 Oct 1841 in Nova Scotia, Canada. She was born on 19 Nov 1810 in Nova Scotia, Canada. She died after 1871.

 


Generation 2

 

2.      CHARLES2 HARRINGTON (possibly "Dutch"1) was born about 1805 (Notice: read the notes associated with this Charles Harrington entry.). He died date Unknown. He married ELIZA ANN COOPER. She was born in 1807.

 

Notes for Charles Harrington:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 190

The following is an explanation of why there is an apparent disconnect in the Harrington family tree with this entry of Charles Herrington. Also, it is an explanation of why there are several DNA matches but that we cannot prove a connection. That there are 9 DNA matches, most of which are rated "Extremely High," argues strongly that they are part of our family tree.

 

The Charles Harrington in this entry was a name extracted from a family tree on Ancestry.com that was identified simply as "J.M." on Ancestry.com on 8 February 2016. This J.M. family tree and a person identified on the tree as being "J.M." was called to my attention by AncestryDNA.com as being a posssible 2nd - 3rd cousin with a confidence level that was "Extremely High." J.M. turned out to be Jennie Mygatt and the Ancestry account was administered by Sharon Balts-Mygatt. The surname in the account that is common to both the J.M. tree and my tree, based on a comparison of J.M.'s and my DNA, is "Harrington." The Harrington surname, of course, is highly prominent in my database. The given name, Charles, appears in my database, but, does not match my Charles William Harrington because it is one genearation earlier. A DNA in both trees match, however.

 

To streamline my ongoing research of this "Extremely High" DNA match, I wanted to be able to use my Family Tree Maker file for its storage and analytical capabilities. I therefore made an "assumption" that the Charles Harrington found in the J.M. tree was the brother of my 2nd great grandfather, Thomas Harrington. This assumption is based on the observation that they occupy approximately the same generational time-period. This assumption is not irreversible. The assumed link can be modified or removed at any time if better data becomes available. But it allows for the use of my Family Tree Maker file as a storage location for the data from the ongoing Charles Harrington research.

 

Upon further research of Ancestry.com data, I discovered that there were no fewer than 9 DNA matches, all of which lead back to the common ancestor, Eliza Ann Herrington. Five of the 9 matches are totally independent and were likely the results of independent DNA analyses that were unknown to each other. The remaining 4 matches involved siblings or close relative's analyses and could have been known to the other.

 

The matching DNA family trees have been included in my database with enough information that someone could pursue the results with the owner of the analysis. The value of these DNA matches is that they further verify the presence of my own Harrington ancestors in America. Even though we are unable to track the parentage of Eliza Anna Herrrington (9 Feburary 1835), she is clearly a common ancestor.

 


 

 


127


Generation 2 (con't)

 

At this time (February 2016), we cannot prove the Harrington line any further back than Thomas Harrington, father of Charles William Harrington. This is one of the reasons that the "assumption" was made that the Charles Herrington, who has been identified as the father of Eliza Anna Herrington, is the brother of Thomas Herrington. There are other possibilities, of course, that could explain why there are 9 DNA matches to our Thomas and Charles William Harrington's DNA. One could be that they were cousins, not brothers. Another could be that the parent of Eliza Anna Herrington, identified as Charles Herrington, is the same person as Thomas Harrington; perhaps, he was Charles Thomas or Thomas Charles Herrington. I believe that this could be the more likely explanation. Eliza Anna Herrington was born 9 February 1835 possibly in New York, USA. Our Thomas Harrington first appears in the records in 1841 when he married Mary Webb and later in the records of the births of his three sons; Harris in 1842, Charles in 1844 and John in 1846. His name appears in miscellaneous records of his descendants but not is a way that establishes his presence. Thomas sort of breezes onto the scene in 1841 and disappears sometime after the birth of his sons. No records have been found of his birth or his arrival in Nova Scotia. There was sufficient time for Thomas to have left the event of Eliza Anna Herrington's birth and his marriage to Mary Webb in Nova Scotia 6-years later. Also, no death record for Thomas has been found. There is a need to search the passenger lists of ships arriving from Ireland to both America and Nova Scotia.

 

Charles Harrington and Eliza Ann Cooper had the following child:

 

4.               i. ELIZA ANNA3 HERRINGTON was born on 09 Feb 1835. She died on 01 Jan 1895 in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, Oklahoma, USA. She married (1) JAMES GERMAN MYGATT in 1859 in Denver, Denver, Colorado, USA. He was born about 1823. He died in Mar 1870 (died of consumption). She married (2) CHARLES CALVIN COVEY. He was born in 1825. He died in 1856.

 

3.      THOMAS2 HARRINGTON (possibly "Dutch"1) was born about 1813 in County Cork, Ireland. He married Mary Webb, daughter of Samuel James Webb Sr and Jane Sarah Rushton, on 27 Oct 1841 in Nova Scotia, Canada. She was born on 19 Nov 1810 in Nova Scotia, Canada. She died after 1871.

 

Notes for Thomas Harrington:

 

No documentation has been found for Thomas Harrington in Nova Scotia prior to his marriage to Mary Webb on 27 Oct 1841. His presence in Nova Scotia is well established by the record of his marriage to Mary and subsequent records of his sons. Except for these records, however, Thomas Harrington is not found in Nova Scotia again. This is not terribly surprising since records from the early 1800s in Nova Scotia are sparce.

 

According to the marriage record of Thomas Harrington, the father of Charles William Harrington, to Mary Webb, Thomas was an immigrant to Nova Scotia from County Cork, Ireland. The evidence of his being in Nova Scotia are 1) a marriage record for Thomas Herington and Mary Webb dated 27 Oct 1841; 2) a marriage record for Thomas' son, Charles William Harrington to Caroline Couch in 1867; and 3) a marriage record for Thomas son' John Harrington to Nancy Embree in 1866. At the time of Thomas' marriage he declared himself as a blacksmith. Since Nova Scotia was known primarily for its large ship-building industry, it is likely that he would have been in the service of ship-building as a blacksmith making iron products for ship construction.

 

The marriage records of Thomas' sons confirms their father's presence in the mid-1840s when they were conceived, but not his presence at the time of their wedding. The 1871 Canadian Census shows Thomas' wife, Mary, living with her brother's family. In that census she was listed as a 60-years old widow of "unsound mind."

 

In spite of extensive research to further document Thomas Harrington, I have found only one document that could be a record of the end of his life. All of the data fit our Thomas Harrington nicely but there is no direct link to confirm that this is, in fact, our correct ancestor. In this document a Thomas Harrington voluntarily sought refuge on 1 December 1890 at the Alms House in New York City. He was 77-years old at that time which would have him born in 1813, just 3-years younger than his wife, Mary Webb. He stated that he had been in the U.S. about 50-years and that he had spent 3-weeks in the hospital in about 1862. This would have indicated that he may have left Nova Scotia shortly after his 3 sons were born. Additional information found on his application to Alms House in New York City are as follows:

 


 


128


Generation 2 (con't)

 

Record of Inmates New York City Alms House, under Act Chap. 140, Laws of 1875 Name: Thomas Harrington

Record Number: 101816

Date of Admission: Dec. 1, 1890 Sex: male

 

Color: white

Marital Status: Widowed

Birth Place: Ireland, County Cork How long in U.S.: 50-yr.

 

How long in this state: 50-yrs Port Landed: New York Naturalized: No

 

Birth Place of father: Ireland, County, Cork Birth Place of mother: Ireland, County, Cork Education: can read and write

 

Habits: Temperate Habits of father: Temp Occupation: Laborer

Occupation of father: Land Surveyor

Condition of Ancestors - grandparents Paternal: S.S. (self supporting) grandparents Maternal: S.S. (self supporting)

 

father: S.S. (self supporting) dead mother: S.S. (self supporting) dead brothers: 4 Ireland S.S. (self supporting) sisters: none

 

other relatives: S.S. (self supporting) children living: none

 

Cause of dependence: old age, rheumation, gen debility, homeless & destitute Kind of labor person can pursue: none

 

Has person received prior public or private relief: No Has the parents of person received relief: No

 

Has person been inmate in Poor House: yes, 28-years ago

Has person been inmate in any other institution: Bellarises Hosp. for 3 weeks Probable destiny of person: Permanently dependent

 

Remarks: Wm. McSamara, the Warden of Alms House. B. J.

 

Thomas Harrington in the New York, Census of Inmates in Almshouses and Poorhouses, 1830-1920

Name: Thomas Harrington Gender:Male

Age:  77

 

 

Birth Year:

abt 1813

Birth Place:

Cork

 

Admission Date:1 Dec 1890

Father's Birth Place:

Cork Ireland

Mother's Birth Place:

Cork Ireland

 

Notes for Mary Webb:

 

From the 1871 Census of Canada for District 198, Westchester, Cumberland Co., Nova Scotia [no specific date or scribe for this census given][all family members were born in Nova Scotia, were English, and were Baptist]

 

David Webb, age 53, farmer Esther Webb, age 44 Jacob Webb, age 21, farmer John Webb, age 19, farmer

George Webb, age 16, farmer Thomas Webb, age 14

 


 


129


Generation 2 (con't)

 

Sarah Webb, age 11

 

Susan Webb, age 9

Merit Webb, age 7

Joseph Webb, age 5

Mary Harrington, age 60, widow, unsound mind

Edward Webb, age 24

Amelia Webb, age 23

Sophia Webb, age 2 months

 

Thomas Harrington and Mary Webb had the following children:

 

i.        HARRIS D.3 HARRINGTON was born in 1842 in Nova Scotia. He died in 1916.

 

Notes for Harris D. Harrington:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 190

 

5.               ii. CHARLES WILLIAM HARRINGTON was born on 20 Aug 1844 in Wallace, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. He died on 20 Aug 1904 in West Bay, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada (Black Rock Cemetry, West Bay, Cumberland, Nova Scotia). He met (1) SARAH JANE VALENTINE. She was born on 28 Jun 1848 in Washington Township, Pickaway County, Ohio. She died on 15 May 1933 in Home Hospital, 4 Ward (buried in St. Paul United Methodist Church, near Circleville, Ohio). He married (2) CAROLINE COUCH WILLIGAR, daughter of Jacob Willigar and Lavinia Crane Couch, on 23 Feb 1867 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. She was born on 27 Feb 1849 in Black Rock, Cumberland County, Nova Scotia. She died on 08 Oct 1924 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

6.               iii. JOHN WEBB HARRINGTON was born on 26 May 1846 in Granville, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. He married Nancy Anne Embree, daughter of Jacob Romer Embree and Melinda Jane Dobson, on 26 May 1866 in River Philip, Cumberland Co, Nova Scotia, Canada. She was born on 24 Mar 1843 in Greewnville, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 


Generation 3

 

4.      ELIZA ANNA3 HERRINGTON (Charles2 Harrington, possibly "Dutch"1 Harrington) was born on 09 Feb 1835. She died on 01 Jan 1895 in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, Oklahoma, USA. She married (1) JAMES GERMAN MYGATT in 1859 in Denver, Denver, Colorado, USA. He was born about 1823. He died in Mar 1870 (died of consumption). She married (2) CHARLES CALVIN COVEY. He was born in 1825. He died in 1856.

 

Notes for Eliza Anna Herrington:

 

From the 1860 U.S. Federal Census for 2nd Ward, Leavenworth City, Leavenworth County, Kansas, Post Office Leavenworth City; enumerated 14 July 1860 by J.M. Gallagher

C H Robinson, head, age 36, born in Penn, bridge builder, value of real estate $600, value of personal estate $50

Ann Robinson, female, age 42, born in New York Eliza H Corey, female, age 25, born in New York Eva M Corey, female, age 6, born in Wisconsin Julia L. Corey, female, age 4, born in Kansas Charles Corey, male, age 23, born in Wisconsin

 

From the Web: Western States Marriage Index, 1809-2011

 

Name: E A Covey

Spouse:           James C Mygatt

Marriage Date: 1862

Marriage Place: Arapahoe, Colorado

 

From the 1870 U.S. Federal Census for Sherman Township, Clay County, Kansas, Post Office Gatesville; enumerated 19 July 1870 by S. gates

 


 


130


Generation 3 (con't)

 

Eliza Mygatt, head, female, age 35, born in New York, keeping house, value of real estate = $800, value of personal estate = $400

Eva Covey, age 16, female, born in Wisconsin, at home Ninnie Covey, age 14, female, born in Kansas, at home Henry Mygatt, age 8, male, born in Colorado

 

Arys Mygatt, age 6, female, born in Colorado Susan Mygatt, age 4, female, born in Kansas James Mygatt, age 1, male, born in Kansas

 

From the Kansas, Enrollment of Civil War Veterans, 1889

 

Name:

Eliza A Mygatt

 

Spouse:

James G Mygatt

Residence Place:

Morganville, Clay

 

Notes for James German Mygatt:

 

From the Iowa, State Census Collection, 1836-1925

Name:

James Mygatt

 

Age:

33

 

 

Birth Year:

abt 1823

Birth Place:

NY

 

Residence Date:

1856

Residence Place:

Iowa City, Johnson, Iowa, USA

Gender:Male

 

 

From in the American Civil War Soldiers

Name: James Mygatt

 

Enlistment Date:

7 Oct 1861

Enlistment Place:

Denver, Colorado

Side Served:

Union

 

State Served:

Colorado

Sources:

304,79

 

 

From in the U.S. Civil War Soldiers, 1861-1865

 

Name: James G. Mygatt

Side:  Union

Regiment State/Origin: Colorado Territory

Regiment:         2nd Regiment, Colorado Infantry

Company:         I

Rank In:     First Sergeant

Rank Out:    Sergeant

Film Number:  M534 roll 2

 

From a copy of James Mygatt's Civil War discharge: To whom it may concern:

Know ye that James G. Mygatt Sargent of Captain E.D. Boyd's Company G. Second Regiment Cavelry of Colorado Volunteers who was enlised on the 16 sixteenth day of May (1862) to Serve three years or during the war is here by Discharded from the Service of the United States this Fourteenth day of June 1865 at Fort Riley Kansas by reason of Expiration of Term of Service. No objection to his being reenlisted is known to exist. Sargent James G. Mygatt was born in the State of New York is 42 yrs of age, five feet nine inches high, light complexion, Blue Eyes, brown hair, occupation (looks like "coupeter"). Given at Fot Riley this 14 day June 1865, E.D. Boyd, Capt. Co. G. 2nd Colo Cavelry, UB

 

From the U.S. Federal Census Mortality Schedules, 1850-1885

 

Name: James Mygatt

Gender:Male

Race:  White

Marital Status: Married

 


 


131


Generation 3 (con't)

 

Estimated Birth Year:  abt 1823

 

Birth Place:   New York, USA

Age:  47

Death Date:   Mar 1870

Cause of Death:Consumption

Census Year:  1870

Census Place: Sherman, Clay, Kansas, USA

 

James German Mygatt and Eliza Anna Herrington had the following children:

 

7.               i. JAMES FRANKLIN "FRANK"4 MYGATT was born on 06 Sep 1868 in Clay County, Kansas, USA. He died on 13 Aug 1956 in Tulsa, Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA. He married Ethel Minnie Braker, daughter of Henry Fredrick Braker and Issie Isabella "Belle" Epperson, on 16 Aug 1908 in Marquette, McPherson, Kansas, United States. She was born on 13 Apr 1886 in Malvern, Mills County, Iowa, USA. She died on 26 Apr 1957 in Independence, Macon, Missouri.

 

8.               ii.  SUSAN COON MYGATT. She married CHARLES ALBERT GOING.

 

Charles Calvin Covey and Eliza Anna Herrington had the following children:

 

9.               i. EVA MONIRA4 COVEY was born on 26 Oct 1853 in Wisconsin, USA. She died on 21 Mar 1925. She married ROBERT LITLE SHIRLEY.

 

10.            ii. MINNIE JULIE COVEY was born in Jan 1854. She died on 16 Apr 1916. She married FRANK L. TURNER.

 

5.      CHARLES WILLIAM3 HARRINGTON (Thomas2, possibly "Dutch"1) was born on 20 Aug 1844 in Wallace, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. He died on 20 Aug 1904 in West Bay, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada (Black Rock Cemetry, West Bay, Cumberland, Nova Scotia). He met (1) SARAH JANE VALENTINE. She was born on 28 Jun 1848 in Washington Township, Pickaway County, Ohio. She died on 15 May 1933 in Home Hospital, 4 Ward (buried in St. Paul United Methodist Church, near Circleville, Ohio). He married (2) CAROLINE COUCH WILLIGAR, daughter of Jacob Willigar and Lavinia Crane Couch, on 23 Feb 1867 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. She was born on 27 Feb 1849 in Black Rock, Cumberland County, Nova Scotia. She died on 08 Oct 1924 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

Notes for Charles William Harrington:

 

 

By the year 2009 the story of great grandmother, Sarah Jane Valentine (1848-1933), was pretty well known. Her meeting with Charles Harrington in Kansas and the subsequent birth of William Alvin Harrington are a matter of record. But, Charles Harrington remained a mystery. About all that was known of him to later generations had been passed down by Sarah Jane Valentine to her son, William Alvin Harrington. By the time it reached the author of this book, Richard E. Harrington, the information was spotty and disconnected. Sarah had described Charles as being an Irishman and a seaman who had arrived in Kansas on a cattle-boat by way of the Mississippi River. He had been born in Nova Scotia, his father having emigrated there from Ireland. A trip to Kansas by the author, Richard E. Harrington, and his niece, Candice Kay Harrington, in 2010 in search of almost anything that could be a clue to Charles Harrington’s identity, proved futile. The only other clue had also come from Sarah Jane in a statement that Charles Harrington had given their son, his middle name.

 

In January of 2013, I decided to have my DNA analyzed by Ancestry.DNA in part to see if that might lead to further information about great grandfather, Charles William Harrington. Within a month I received a report from Ancestry.DNA identifying a match with a possible cousin by the name of Linda McNeil. Upon contacting her, she responded that the likely relationship was through her Harrington line. Linda gave me access to her family tree that included three generations of Harrington’s as follows: Thomas Harrington, an immigrant to Nova Scotia from Ireland; Thomas’s son, Charles William Harrington (1844-1904), a seaman born in Nova Scotia; and Charles’s daughter, Edith Mabel Harrington (1884-1955). Edith married Mayford Phinney (1884-1943) establishing the branch in which Linda McNeil is a member.

 

Further research about Charles William Harrington resulted in the discovery that he was

 


 


132


Generation 3 (con't)

 

born in Nova Scotia the son of an Irish immigrant, Thomas Harrington, and his wife, Mary Webb (1810-after 1871). Mary Webb was English and born in Nova Scotia. Her grandfather had immigrated to Nova Scotia from Connecticut, USA, and could well have been one of the British Loyalists who chose to emigrate about the time of the USA Declaration of Independence. Charles William Harrington was a mariner throughout his life. His occupation as a mariner first appears as a declaration by Sarah Jane Valentine. Then on his marriage application to Caroline Couch (1849-1924) on 23 Feb 1867 he again gave his occupation as mariner. Over the next 22 years (1869-1891), the birth records of no fewer than 8 of Charles and Caroline’s 10 children gave his occupation as Mariner or Sea Captain. The marriage record of his daughter, Edith Mabel Harrington, on 02 Apr 1884 was the first record of Charles W. Harrington as a Sea Captain. An earlier birth record of his son, Freeman Harrington, on 22 May 1877 and all previous birth records listed him as mariner. The 1880 Federal Census for Boston, Massachusetts, USA, Boston City Prison contains an entry that could well be our Charles William Harrington that also shows him to be a sailor.

 

The dates of relevant events surrounding Charles Harrington fit well with known dates. Charles William and Sarah Jane’s son, William Alvin Harrington, would have been conceived in late August or early September1865 and was born on 10 Jun 1866. Charles would have just turned 21-years old; Sarah Jane was 17. According to Sarah Jane Valentine, Charles William Harrington gave their son, William Alvin Harrington, his middle name. Charles William Harrington’s middle name, of course, was William. That their son’s given first name was William Alvin Harrington would seem to justify Sarah Jane’s emphasis on this fact.

 

There appears to be no evidence that Sarah Jane Valentine and Charles William Harrington were married. We had determined from our 2010 trip to Kansas that the records that would be needed to prove their marriage were lost in a flood. One piece of subsequent information suggests that they may have been married. When Sarah Jane and William H. Anderson applied for a marriage license in Pickaway County, Ohio on 9 October 1969, Sarah gave her name as Sarah Jane Herrington. The application was subsequently canceled and they married on 04 Nov 1872 in Kenton, Kenton County, Kentucky. I tend to think that Sarah Jane may have believed that Charles would return to Kansas to form the family, so she named her son Herrington. Upon her return to Pickaway County, Ohio, she may have chosen to represent herself as a Herrington to account for her bastard son. Being unable to produce proof of marriage and divorce could account for the unused Pickaway County marriage license of 9 October 1969 and the subsequent marriage to William H. Anderson in Kentucky on 4 November 1872.

 

About 8-months after his son, William Alvin Harrington, was born Charles William Harrington married Caroline Couch Willigar on 23 Feb 1867 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. Over the next 24+ years Charles fathered 10-children with his wife, Caroline Couch, most of whom were born in Parrsboro, NS.

 

Pursuaded by my initial research on Charles William Harrington and following the DNA linkage to Linda McNeil, my wife and I made a trip to Nova Scotia, Canada beginning 21 August 2013 thru 3 September 2013. After a few days of basic genealogy research in the Nova Scotia archives in Halifax, N.S. we drove to Parrsboro, Cumberland County, Nova Scotia to do local research. We hit pay-dirt there. Due in no small part to the hospitality of the people we found there and their eagerness to help, we identified and met several generations of descendants of Charles William and Caroline Couch Harrington. We found and photographed Charles and Caroline's graves and the graves of a son and other kin. The closest relative met on the trip was Haley Jollymore Harrington, an 89-year old half-1st cousin, and his wife Elsie Evelyn MacAloney. Haley was also a sea captain for Imperial Oil Limited (IOL), commonly known as ESSO in Canada. Haley subsequently died on 26 Aug 2014. Meeting over a dozen descendants of Charles William Harrington was exciting and pleasant, however, we were still no closer to proving that Charles was the father of my grandfather, William Alvin Harrington. To prove this relationship, we planned a second trip to Nova Scotia in 2015 to try to collect additional DNA samples from known descendants of Charles William Harrington.

 

Then came a big development in the Ancestry-DNA technology that made the return trip to Nova Scotia unnecessary. On 16 November 2014 Ancestry.DNA introduced their "Circles" technology that analyzes their entire DNA database for matches of members who relate to a common ancestor. The Circle is identified by the name of the common ancestor and all members who belong to that Circle are made known to each other. In reality, since most members use

 


 


133


Generation 3 (con't)

 

pseudonyms instead of their own names, their identity remains unknown unless an effort is made to contact and identify them.

As of January 2015, my (Richard E. Harrington) DNA data was matched to the Circles of Jane Sarah Rushton (1784-1869) and Samuel James Webb (1785-1828), the parents of Mary Webb who was Charles William Harrington's mother. There were no fewer than 12 individual DNA Circle matches to the Jane Sarah Rushton and Samuel James Webb Circles. Of the 12 DNA Circle matches, 4 matches were also direct matches to my DNA. Four of the 12 matches were via different childen of Jane Sarah Rushton and Samuel James Webb. Two of the 4 direct matches were via a different child of Jane Sarah Rushton and Samuel James Webb than mine and two were direct matches via the same child of Jane Sarah Rushton and Samuel James Webb as mine. The only possible way in which the lines of ancestors for Linda McNeil and Richard Harrington to make a Circle match to Jane Sarah Rushton and Samuel James Webb is through Mary Webb, wife of Thomas Harrington and mother of Charles William Harrington. Also, the match between Linda McNeil's and my DNA which was originally assumed to be based on our Harrington line DNA, could have been the result our having Jane Sarah Rushton and Samuel James Webb as our common ancestors. That is, our match may not have been from the Harrington line but through Mary Webb's line. This constitutes absolute proof that Mary Webb was the grandmother of my grandfather but leaves open the question of there being a match with the Harrington line. But since there is ample proof that Thomas Harrington and Mary Webb were married and that they had at least 3 children together, one of whom was Charles William Harrington, it also proves that Thomas Harrington was the father of my grandfather, William Alvin Harrington (1855-1951) It also confirms that Marney Moore Gilroy is my 5th cousin, 1x removed. See the entries under Jane Sarah Rushton in this book for details of the 12 Circle matches discussed above.

 

 

Nova Scotia, Canada, Marriages, 1763-1935 about Charles H. Harrington [sic, Charles W. Harrington]

Name: Charles H. Harrington Gender: Male

 

Spouse Name: Caroline Cooch Spouse Gender: Female Marriage Date: 1867

 

Marriage Place: Amherst, Cumberland Registration Year: 1867

 

Registration Book: 1809

Registration Page: 23 Registration number: 5

 

From the marriage application record for Charles H. Harrington (sic, Charles W. Harrington), age 22, and Caroline Crouch (Crouch was crossed out) Cooch, age 18, the date of the wedding was given as 23 February 1867. The "where and how" were answered: Parrsboro, Cumberland County, Nova Scotia, by license, Bap Ch. Charles listed his vocation as a Seaman. Caroline did not list a vocation. Charles gave his residence at the time of marriage as Five Islands and his place of birth as Wallace, [Pictou County, Nova Scotia]. Caroline gave her residence as Parrsboro but gave no place of birth. Charles gave his parents as Thomas and Mary Harrington. Caroline gave her parents as Lavinia Couch. Charles gave Thomas vocation as a blacksmith. Caroline gave Lavinia's vocation as Servant. The minister was Baptist, Rev. David McKeen. The marriage place was given as Amherst, Cumberland. Witnesses were Frances Jenks and James Cooch. This information was collected in Nova Scotia and may be found also at: www.novascotiagenealogy.com

 

From the 1871 Canadian Census for the town of Parrsboro Shore, District No. 12 Cumberland, Nova Scotia; enumerated [no date census was taken] by [no name of census taker][all born in Nova Scotia and all were Baptist]

 

John Cooch, age 48, English, Seaman Jane Cooch, age 38, English

 

Thomas Cooch, age 27, English, Seaman Charles Herington, age 28, Irish, Seaman Caroline Herington, age 26, Irish

 


 


134


Generation 3 (con't)

 

Thomas Herington, age 2, Irish

 

Flora Herington, age 5-mo., Irish (born Oct. 1870) [The birth dates of Florence and Thomas appear to be reversed as compared with other family data; e.g., the birth records.]

 

(A remark following the Herington family reads: "this family boards with John Cooch and have no property.)

 

At the time of the 1871 census, the population of Parrsboro was about 1,000 people in about 170 family units. These numbers are from a count of the Parrsboro 1871 census.

 

From the 1880 United States Federal Census for the City Prison, House of Industry (Deer Island), Boston, Suffolk County, Massachusetts; enumeratd 15 June, 1880 by M. P. Bown

Name: Charles W. Harrington

Age:

35

 

 

Birth Year:

abt 1845

Birthplace:

Nova Scotia

Home in 1880:

Boston, Suffolk, Massachusetts

Race:

White

 

 

Gender:Male

 

 

Marital Status:

Married

 

Father's Birthplace:

Ireland

Mother's Birthplace:

Nova Scotia

Occupation:

Sailor

 

Cannot read/write:

Charles W. Harrington, age 35 (plus over 100 other prisoners)

 

There is no proof that the Charles W. Harrington of the 1800 U.S. Federal Census was our family's Charles William Harrington (1845-1904), great grandfather of the author, Richard E. Harrington, but, the author believes that this probably was our ancestor. All the limited data fit. So, some limited research was done to learn more about his place of incarceration, the City Prison, House of Industry (Deer Island), Boston, Suffolk County, Massachusetts. The following was copied from the website, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deer_Island_Prison. "The Deer Island Prison (c. 1880-1991) in Suffolk County, Massachusetts was located on Deer Island in Boston Harbor. Also known as the Deer Island House of Industry and later, House of Correction, it held people convicted of drunkenness, illegal possession of drugs, disorderly conduct, larceny, and other crimes subject to relatively short-term sentencing. When it closed in 1991, some 1,500 inmates were being held at Deer Island."

 

"An article in the national Frank Leslie's Sunday Magazine (1884) described the prisoners on Deer Island in the 1880s: "they in the main are from the lowest stratum of the cosmopolitan society of New England's metropolis, embracing representatives of almost every nationality under the sun, and from the shortness of the sentences, many being confined for 10 days only, for nonpayment of one dollar and costs for drunkenness, and none for more than a year."["The Boston Institutions at Deer Island". Frank Leslie's Sunday Magazine 15 (3). 1884. Retrieved 21 January 2010.]

 

From the 1901 Canadian Census for the town of Parrsboro, District No. 30 Cumberland, Nova Scotia; enumerated [no date census was taken] by Arthur W. Jackson [all are Irish, born in Nova Scotia and Baptist except as noted; all of the children are single]

 

Charles Harrington, head, age 56 born Aug 20, 1844, occupation Seaman Caroline Harrington, wife, age 52, born 27 Feb 1849, English

 

William Harrington, son, age 28, born 27 Dec 1872, occupation Sailor Harris Harrington, son, age 26, born 4 July 1874, occupation Sailor Ann Harrington, dau., age 19, born 7 Feb 1882

 

Banford Harrington, son, age 21, born 4 Mar 1880, Serracna (unclear) maker Edith Harrington, dau., age 17, born 15 Jan 1884

 

Howard Harrington, son, age 10, born 20 Mar 1891

Mary J Harrington, dau., age 25, born 25 Mar 1876, domestic

 


 


135


Generation 3 (con't)

 

Freeman Harrington, son, age 22, born 22 May 1878, occupation Sailor

 

Nova Scotia boasted the 4th largest private merchant marine until Canada ended Nova Scotia's right to Free Trade in 1867. Nova Scotians nearly went to war with Canada and Britain over this.

 

I found the following website that includes a brief listing of the Charles William Harrington line. The entire Rushton line (38-pages) is at: http://familytreemaker.genealogy.com/users/s/u/m/Carla-J-Sumner/ODT5-0001.html

 

1 John RUSHTON  d: Unknown

 

. +SARAH  m: Bef. 1719 d: Unknown

. 2 John R. RUSHTON, Sr. b: Abt. 1727 in Westchester Co., New York, USA d: December 02, 1799 in Westchester, Cumberland Co., Nova Scotia

 

.... +Mary COON b: Abt. 1727 in Westchester Co., New York, USA m: Bef. 1751 d: January 18, 1822 in Westchester, Cumberland Co., Nova Scotia

.... 3 John RUSHTON b: 1751 in WESTCHESTER , NOVA SCOTIA [CUMBERLAND]

d:

November 01, 1831 in WESTCHESTER , NOVA SCOTIA [CUMBERLAND]

 

....... +Mary COLEFIELD b: 1760 in WESTCHESTER , NOVA SCOTIA [CUMBERLAND]

d:

February 01, 1821 in WESTCHESTER , NOVA SCOTIA [CUMBERLAND]

 

....... 4 Jane RUSHTON b: 1784 in WESTCHESTER , NOVA SCOTIA [CUMBERLAND]

d:

October 10, 1869 in Eagle Hill Cem, Canada

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

.......... +Samuel WEBB b: 1785 m: October 06, 1802 in WESTCHESTER , NOVA SCOTIA

[CUMBERLAND] d: April 08, 1828 in Eagle Hill Cem, Canada

 

 

 

 

.......... 5 John Rushton WEBB b: September 22, 1804 in Nova Scotia

d: August 24, 1811 in

Eagle Hill Cem, Canada

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

.......... 5 Samuel WEBB b: March 18, 1806 in Nova Scotia

d: Unknown in Eagle Hill

 

Cem.,Canada

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

............. +Mary DOYLE b: 1810 m: February 15, 1831 in Nova Scotia d: October 03, 1845 in

Eagle Hill Cem, Canada

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

............. 6 Mary Jane WEBB b: May 09, 1834

d: June 08, 1916

 

 

................ +Charles H. LEWIS

m: 1851 in Nova Scotia d: Unknown

 

 

................ 7

Miriam LEWIS b: 1859

d: Private

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

................ 7

? LEWIS b: 1860

d: Private

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

................ 7

Anne LEWIS b: 1863

d: Private

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

...................

+Francis WELTON

m: August 12, 1891 d: Unknown

 

 

................ 7

Samuel LEWIS b: December 21, 1865

d: Private

 

 

 

................ 7

Ustace Woodbury LEWIS b: December 26, 1867

d: Private

 

................ 7

Ida May LEWIS b: August 13, 1870

d: Private

 

 

 

 

...................

+Blair SEARS b: 1861 m: March 20, 1889 d: Private

 

 

................ 7

Owen Webb LEWIS b: January 22, 1873

d: Private

 

 

............. 6 Owen Doyal WEBB b: January 07, 1836

d: Unknown

 

 

............. 6 Eunice WEBB b: September 23, 1838

d: Private

 

 

 

............. 6 Esther Melina WEBB b: August 01, 1843

d: Private

 

 

................ 7

William Osmond WEBB b: February 01, 1865

d: Private

 

 

............. 6 Agnes Angevine WEBB b: June 06, 1845

d: Private

 

 

................ +Janes Barnabus WEATHERBEE b: 1834 m: May 27, 1861 in Nova Scotia d: Private

................ 7

James Nathaniel WEATHERBEE b: November 10, 1864

d: Private

 

................ 7

Mary Maria WEATHERBEE b: June 07, 1867

d: Private

 

 

................ 7

Elisha C. WEATHERBEE b: May 16, 1869

d: Private

 

 

................ 7

Frances WEATHERBEE b: May 13, 1871

d: Private

 

 

............. 6 Clarase WEBB b: April 03, 1847

d: Private

 

 

 

 

 

................ +Samuel Durning GRAHAM b: 1846 m: November 19, 1866 in Nova Scotia d: Private

................ 7

Clarence WEBB b: October 30, 1864

d: Private

 

 

 

................ 7

Agnes O. GRAHAM b: April 23, 1868

d: Private

 

 

 

................ 7

Minnie Matilda GRAHAM b: September 09, 1869

d: Private

 

............. 6 Caroline WEBB b: January 27, 1850

d: Private

 

 

 

 

............. 6 Shubael Dimock Marsters WEBB b: May 29, 1852

d: Private

 


 

136


Generation 3 (con't)

 

............. 6

Ellenor WEBB b: August 29, 1854  d: July 07, 1911

................

+Charles Morris THOMPSON b: 1854 m: July 14, 1875 d: November 23, 1898

................

7

William Clay THOMPSON b: April 11, 1876  d: May 25, 1876

................

7

Minnie THOMPSON b: 1877

d: Private

................

7

Elsie THOMPSON b: January 1881

d: Private

................

7

Bessie THOMPSON b: 1882

d: Private

................

7

Nina THOMPSON b: 1885

d: Private

................

7

WILLIETHOMPSON b: 1888

d: Private

............. 6

Thomas Perk WEBB b: February 03, 1857  d: Private

............. 6

Charles M. WEBB b: August 22, 1863

d: 1928 in Eagle Hill Cem, Canada

................ +Margaret C. WEBB b: August 23, 1871 m: June 10, 1891 in Nova Scotia d: 1943

................ 7

Raymond WEBB b: August 27, 1892

d: Private

................ 7

Earl WEBB b: June 15, 1895  d: Private

................ 7

Ella WEBB b: January 07, 1897  d: Private

................ 7

Russell WEBB b: January 18, 1899

d: Private

................ 7

Amy Dressa WEBB b: Private

 

.......... *2nd Wife of Samuel WEBB:

............. +Matilda MARSTERS b: September 02, 1822 m: April 27, 1842 in Nova Scotia d: June

08, 1900 in Eagle Hill Cem, Canada

 

 

 

.......... 5 Mary WEBB b: November 19, 1810

d: Private

 

............. +Thomas HARRINGTON  m: October 27, 1841 d: Unknown

............. 6 Harris HARRINGTON b: February 02, 1842

d: Private

............. 6 Charles William HARRINGTON b: August 20, 1844

d: Private

................ +Caroline COUCH b: 1848 m: February 23, 1867 d: Private

................ 7

[2] Florence HARRINGTON b: January 29, 1869

d: Private

...................

+[1] John HARRINGTON b: April 10, 1873 m: May 26, 1896 d: Private

................ 7

Thomas Stewart HARRINGTON b: December 25, 1871  d: Private

...................

+Lina RUSHTON b: 1888 m: June 27, 1908 d: Private

................ 7

John William HARRINGTON b: December 25, 1872  d: Private

................ 7

Freeman HARRINGTON b: 1878  d: Private

 

...................

+Sarah Alice COUCH b: 1887 m: December 20, 1905 d: Private

................ 7

Mary HARRINGTON b: 1880

d: Private

 

 

...................

+Harvey HENWOOD b: 1882 m: August 18, 1902 d: Private

................ 7

Howard Joseph HARRINGTON b: 1881

d: Private

...................

+Mary Emily ANDERSON b: 1890 m: November 11, 1912 d: Private

................ 7

Edith HARRINGTON b: 1884

d: Private

 

 

...................

+Mallford PHINNEY b: 1881 m: August 27, 1903 d: Private

............. 6 John Webb HARRINGTON b: May 01, 1846  d: Private

................ +Nancy Anne EMBREE b: 1843 m: May 26, 1866 d: Private

................ 7

Mary A. HARRINGTON b: February 07, 1867

d: Private

...................

+Silas P. MILLS b: 1865 m: November 25, 1887 d: Private

................ 7

Alexander McPhee HARRINGTON b: March 18, 1871  d: Private

...................

+Elizabeth J. NELSON b: 1872 m: October 28, 1890 d: Private

................ *2nd Wife of Alexander McPhee HARRINGTON:

 

...................

+Rachel BENTCLIFF b: 1873 m: April 27, 1896 d: Unknown

................ *3rd Wife of Alexander McPhee HARRINGTON:

 

...................

+Sarah Ann HENNESSEY b: 1879 m: December 22, 1897 d: Unknown

................ 7

[1] John HARRINGTON b: April 10, 1873

d: Private

...................

+[2] Florence HARRINGTON b: January 29, 1869 m: May 26, 1896 d: Private

................ 7

Ellen Louisa HARRINGTON b: May 31, 1875

d: Private

................ 7

Charles W. HARRINGTON b: 1878  d: Private

 

...................

+Nellie FARRELL b: 1882 m: March 13, 1901 d: Private

................ 7

Marguerite May HARRINGTON b: 1879

d: Private

...................

+Frank Robson LAMY b: 1875 m: December 02, 1902 d: Private

................ 7

Anne E. HARRINGTON b: 1883  d: Private

 

................ 7

Lucy HARRINGTON b: 1883  d: Private

 

 

...................

+John G. THOMPSON b: 1878 m: August 10, 1903 d: Private


 

137


Generation 3 (con't)

 

.......... 5 John WEBB b: May 08, 1813  d: Private

 

............. +Charity WEBB b: March 04, 1817 m: August 17, 1836 d: May 01, 1839

............. 6

Charity WEBB b: October 12, 1841

d: Private

............. 6

Olive WEBB b: January 01, 1844

d: Private

............. 6

Susannah WEBB b: May 17, 1846

d: Private

 

Notes for Sarah Jane Valentine:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 2, 3

Sarah Jane Valentine was born June 28, 1848 and died May 15, 1933. She was the third child and the first daughter in the family of Levi and Mary Bolinger Valentine*. Sarah Jane's long, 84-year (almost 85-years) life was eventful and would have been the subject of an exciting book if it had been written. This may be the first attempt to organize the adventures of her life in writing.

 

We have no documentation that tells us exactly where in Ohio Sarah Jane Valentine was born. It could have been in Pickaway County, Ohio where her parents had married or possibly at the next stop in Seneca County, Ohio of a long, arduous trek that would take nearly 20-years to complete. Her parents had married three years before Sarah Jane's birth and had her two older brothers, Isaac and Elias Valentine, over the next three years. In the 1850 Federal Census, when Sarah Jane was 2-years old, we find the family in Adams Township, Seneca County, Ohio. The family was still in Ohio in 1851 when David Valentine was born. The only and best clue that we have is Sarah Jane's statement on her marriage application to William H. Anderson on 4 October 1872 that she was born in Pickaway County, Ohio.

 

Sarah's parents, Levi and Mary, were likely following the course of many other families in the 1850s; namely, the call to move West. Many were focused on the 1849 California gold rush. Being farmers, however, Levi and Mary's goal was probably to find cheap or free land upon which to settle and raise their growing family. Levi's older brother, Samuel, had settled in Indiana so Sarah Jane may have met her Uncle Samuel on Levi family's trek to their interim home in Illinois in about 1854. Sarah Jane would have been 6-years old in the summer of 1854.

 

The Levi Valentine family had reached Illinois by 1855 where their son, George W. Valentine, was born. The family remained in Pike County, Illinois for at least 4-years. During this period Sarah Jane gained 4 siblings including George W., Almira, and the twin boys, Sylvester and Sylvanus. Additional research may pin-point more precisely where in Pike County, Illinois they lived. Sarah probably started her schooling in Illinois.

 

The Kansas Territory was the new frontier. Land was cheap or free for settling. In what would become Brown County, Kansas in a few short years, the land was flat and fertile. The climate was similar to central Ohio and for the few brave pioneers who already lived there, their crops were plentiful, even exceeding expectations. For the Levi Valentine family, the Kansas Territory must have seemed to be the new life they were searching for. Once again the family moved settling on a rented farm about 2-miles south of what is now the boundary between Nebraska and Kansas in the northeast corner in Walnut Creek Township, Brown County, Kansas.

 

When they arrived in the Kansas Territory in about 1858, Sarah Jane may have believed their traveling had come to an end. The long slow miles of uncomfortable travel that had stretched over many weeks and months had been hard for her. As the oldest girl at the age of 10 or 11-years she had and would continue to share much of the responsibility for her younger siblings. Here in the Kansas Territory, though, they would at last stop moving and begin the hard work of building their future.

 

Sarah Jane would soon begin to understand the life of a Kansas pioneer. The new land was big and flat and almost empty of people. The nearest neighbor lived miles away. The nearest trading post was many miles away. There were no churches or schools so education came to a halt except for what her parents could provide. There were plenty of rattlesnakes and gophers (groundhogs), some deer, coyote and a few wolves. And, there were Indians, but they were peaceful and usually did not bother settlers. Being a pioneer was certainly different from the neighborhoods of Ohio and Illinois and would take some getting used to.

 

During the first year or two in Kansas, Levi's crops flourished and the family prospered. Then came the drought. The second year after the Valentine arrived in the Kansas Territory was a year without rain and all of the crops failed. Like all the other pioneers in the Territory, the Valentine's had staked everything they had on the 1860 harvest; a harvest that never occurred. Sarah Jane had just turned 12-years old in June when it became clear by August that there would

 


 


138


Generation 3 (con't)

 

be no harvest. The crop failure was a serious and life-threatening event for most of the pioneers in the Territory but for the Valentines it was especially tragic. They had arrived on the eve of the disaster and gambled all that they had on the coming year - a year that claimed their resources and efforts and yielded little in return. Sarah Jane, now going on 13-years old, was of an age that she could understand the severity of the situation. The mood within the family must have been very difficult for the young woman.

 

We do not know for sure what happened to the Levi Valentine family over the next 7 or 8 years. The record-keeping in the Territory that became the State of Kansas the following year, 1861, was poor at best. Birth records of their children born during this period seem to indicate that they remained in Walnut Township, Brown County, Kansas.

 

It seems likely that Sarah Jane may have left the Levi family about 1864 or 1865, perhaps in search of work. This speculation is based on the understanding that the Levi family was still living in Walnut Twp., Brown County, Kansas when Sarah Jane’s youngest sister, Nora Ellen, was born on 22 February 1867. Yet 18-months before Nora’s birth, in autumn of 1865, Sarah Jane became pregnant by Charles William Harrington (Herrington, Herington), a sailor from Nova Scotia who most likely had arrived by way of the Mississippi and Missouri Rivers. It appears likely that Charles had arrived as part of the brisk trade by foreign vessels in livestock and other food products. Kansas had become a major supplier of cattle to support the Civil War effort that was just closing. It is likely that Sarah Jane may have gone to Fort Leavenworth where work was plentiful at the end of the Civil War. Sarah Jane later told her son, William Alvin Harrington, that he was born in Kickapoo, Kansas, a small town about 2-miles north of Fort Leavenworth.

 

Over the years, Sarah Jane told her son several things that became useful to the discovery of his father, Charles William Harrington, by the author in 2013. Among the items she shared with her son were: 1) his father’s name was Charles William Herrington; 2) he was of Irish descent; 3) he was from Nova Scotia; 4) his father gave him his own middle name, “William”; 5) he was a sailor; 6) he had arrived on a cattle boat.

 

On 22 February 1867, Mary Bolinger Valentine,* gave birth to her 12th child, Nora Ellen Valentine. Perhaps during childbirth or shortly thereafter Mary Bolinger Valentine died leaving her family of 10-children (apparently Isaac and Elias had left the family by then) without a mother.

Faced with the task of rearing a family without a wife, Levi wasted little time reorganizing his family. On 21 May 1868, within a year of Nora Ellen’s birth, Levi married Emily Jane Walker, a young woman of 27 or 28-years who had been a foster member of his family for over a decade. Emily Jane became pregnant with Levi’s son in 1867 or early 1868. He then moved the family to Liberty Township, Clay County, Missouri where later in 1868 Emily gave birth to her first child, Henry C. Valentine. [In an ironic but unrelated event, Liberty Township, Clay County, Missouri was the location of the Clay County Savings Bank that was robbed of $60,000 on 12 February 1866 by Jesse and Frank James and Bud and Donnie Pence.]

 

It is probably important to shift the focus of our Sarah Jane Valentine story, for a moment, to Charles William Harrington because it helps us to better understand Sarah Jane's subsequent actions. Until recently, early 2013, Charles William Harrington was a genealogical "brick wall."

While he had been searched for by many, no clue as to who he was, where he was from, or where he had gone had been found. Only the meager information imparted by Sarah Jane to her son, William Alvin Harrington, and mentioned above was available. Even that information was considered highly questionable since it was so old and had been passed down 3-generations from Sarah Jane.

 

The break came in early 2013 when the author, Richard E. Harrington, great grandson of Sarah Jane Valentine, submitted a DNA sample to Ancestry.DNA for analysis. One of the half-dozen or so matches was with Linda McNeil who lives in the New England area. The common ancestral connection appeared to be Linda's Harrington line that lived in Nova Scotia. Within that line we found a sailor named Charles William Harrington who was born 20 Aug 1844. Further research established that all of the first 5-snippets of information provided years later by Sarah Jane Valentine to her son, fit what we learned about this Charles William Harrington. Only the 6th snippet could not be confirmed but it did help provide an explanation of how, why and when Charles might have been in Kansas. Early in the Civil War the Union forces had secured the Mississippi and Missouri rivers from control by the Confederacy and provided safe passage to vessels transporting food supplies essential to the war effort. All available Union vessels had been enlisted into the Union Navy. So, the majority of the water transportation was provided by neutral

 


 


139


Generation 3 (con't)

 

foreign-nation ships such as those from Nova Scotia. Apparently, Charles William Harrington was a sailor on one of those ships.

Charles returned to Nova Scotia in late 1865 or early 1866, abandoning Sarah Jane. In Nova Scotia, Charles married Caroline Couch on 23 February 1867. Caroline was born 27 February 1849 and was 8-months younger than Sarah Jane Valentine. Charles and Caroline had 10 children together. For more about Charles William Harrington see the section on this important ancestor elsewhere in this book.

 

Sarah Jane Valentine's situation in Kansas in the waning years of the1860s was probably bleak. She had apparently left her parent's home, probably in search of employment. Throughout the winter months of 1865 she was pregnant. Less than 3-weeks short of her own 18th birthday, she gave birth to her son, William Alvin Harrington, in the little town of Kickapoo near Fort Leavenworth, Kansas. If she returned to her parents after her son's birth, she would have found her mother, Mary Bolinger Valentine then aged 42, pregnant with her 12th child. Sarah Jane's mother died in 1867, likely during childbirth or shortly after Nora Ellen Valentine was born. Sara Jane's son, William, and her mother's 12th daughter, Nora, were only 7-months apart in age. If Sarah Jane's mother died in childbirth, the feeding and care of Nora Ellen would likely have fallen to Sarah Jane. That period of time would have been desperately hectic for the 18-year old Sara Jane Valentine and the entire family.

 

During this time Levi would have been challenged as he tried to provide for his large and exploding family. He had lost his mate and found himself with even more responsibilities. On 21 May 1868 he married his "foster daughter," Emily Jane Walker whom he soon got pregnant. With his new family begun, Sarah Jane and her son and Levi's older children became an increasingly difficult burden. It is likely that it was about this point in time when negotiations with members of the Pickaway County, Ohio Valentine family occurred. About 1868 arrangements had been made that resulted in Sarah Jane, her son, her new baby sister, and possibly some of her other siblings traveling to Pickaway County, Ohio.

 

We pick up the trail of Sarah Jane Valentine from an unexecuted marriage license application with William Anderson dated . In this application Sarah Jane appears as Sarah J. Herrington. This marriage did not take place - the marriage application was cancelled. A few months later, in the 1870 Federal Census, she is enumerated in the household of William H. Anderson as his housekeeper. Her son, William Alvin Harrington, was not enumerated with her in the 1870 census. He may have been missed by the census taker or he could have been residing with another relative. Because of her young age when she left Pickaway County, Ohio, Sarah Jane most likely had not met William H. Anderson before returning to Ohio in the late 1860s. He was not exactly a stranger, however, having been reared by Sarah's grandparents, Joshua and Margaret Drum Valentine, whose farm was enumerated next to Williams's. Interestingly, but not suprisingly, Sarah Jane's other grandparents, Benjamin and Elizabeth Leist Bolinger, and her Uncle John Bolinger's families were also enumerated on the same 1870 Federal Census page along with two families of Leist who were almost certainly close relatives of her grandmother, Elizabeth Leist Bolinger.

 

On 4 Nov 1872 Sarah Jane Valentine and William H. Anderson married in Kenton, Kentucky. There were no children from this marriage. In the 1880 Federal Census, Sarah Jane Valentine Anderson appears as the wife of William H. Anderson. Also enumerated in the household, are her son, William A. Herrington (age 14); Sarah's brother, George W.L. Valentine (age 26); and her youngest sister, Nora E. Valentine (age 13).

 

In 1902 William invested $1,750 in the Scioto Canning Company located in Circleville, Ohio. Three of the four bonds he purchased were for $500 each, the 4th was for $250. Each of the 4 bonds was dated May 15, 1902. A year later, on July 18, 1903, William H. Anderson prepared his Will in which he stated, “I will and bequeath to my wife, Sarah J. Anderson, all my personal property.” His Will continued, “I will and devise to my said wife, Sarah J. Anderson, all the real estate of which I may die seized, for and during the term of her natural life, with the provision, however, that if it should become necessary for her support to sell my interest in the farm on which we now reside, then I hereby authorize and empower her to sell and dispose of the same, together with her part of said farm, either at private or public sale, and upon such terms of credit as she may deem best, and to make a proper deed to the purchaser therefor, and the purchaser thereof shall not be required to look to the application of the purchase money.” The above terms of the Will were particularly appropriate and useful to Sarah Jane in her later life as will be seen below.

 


 


140


Generation 3 (con't)

 

William's Will continued, and while the subsequent terms were never applied that we know of, they provide useful information for us, his genealogy researchers. “I will and bequeath that after the death of my said wife, that part of my property which has then not been consumed, shall be divided and paid as follows: First: To Nora E. Ramsey, the sum of Five hundred Dollars ($500.00). Second: To Samuel Ressler, the sum of Seventy-five Dollars ($75.00). [In the probation of this will, Samuel Ressler is identified as William's half brother.] Third: -To Savanus Valentine, the sum of Two hundred Dollars ($200.00). Fourth: To Pansey Valentine and Elsie Marie Valentine, children of said Savanus Valentine, each the sum of Fifty Dollars ($50.00).” Finally, William stated, “I hereby appoint my said wife, Sarah J. Anderson, executrix of this my last Will and Testament ...”

 

On September (est.), 1906, Sarah Jane and William Anderson went to Independence, Missouri where they visited with Sarah's sister, Nora E. Valentine Ramsey. While there, on October 4, 1906, William died suddenly. He was 70 years old. His body was embalmed in Independence, MO and transported back to Ohio. He arrived on Saturday evening and funeral services were held Sunday morning. He was buried at St. Paul's Church in Washington Twp., Pickaway County, Ohio.

Sarah Jane Valentine Anderson was 58 years old when William died on October 4, 1906. They had been married one month short of 34-years. Sarah Jane received $350 widows allowance from the estate for her support for up to one year until William's Will could be probated. Upon probation of the Will, Sarah inherited $1,790.07, the majority being the value of the Scioto Canning Company bonds. She also inherited the William Anderson family farm.

 

Sarah Jane lived another 27 years after the death of her husband. The Federal Census and public records tell us little about her later life except that she continued to live in Pickaway County, Ohio. A photograph taken about 1925 shows Sarah Jane with her son William A.

Harrington, some of her grandchildren and a great-grandchild, June L. Harrington, daughter of Ira E. Harrington. At some point members of the Herrington family changed the spelling of their surname to Harrington.

 

June Harrington Franklin Walters recalled that in the 1920s, Sarah Jane traveled with some frequency between Circleville, Ohio and Independence or Kansas City, Missouri spending time with her relatives. Likely she also visited other siblings on these treks.

 

Ira Harrington recalled that during the last few years of her life, his grandmother, Sarah Jane, turned over property to the Circleville Home and Hospital in return for a home and support for the rest of her life. The 1930 Federal Census lists Sarah Jane as an inmate of that facility. Interestingly, the same census gives her date of birth as about 1851 and her age as 79. This might have an error promulgated by the staff of the Circleville Home and Hospital or it could reflect Sarah Jane not remembering her exact date of birth.

 

Sarah Jane died on May 15, 1933 just 44-days short of her 85th birthday. Her obituary states the cause of death to be “... complications after an illness of six months.” She was survived by her son, William A. Harrington of Circleville, OH; a sister, Nora Ramsey of Kansas City, Missouri; and two brothers, George W. Valentine of Kansas City, Missouri and Lewis Valentine of Washington C.H., Ohio. Burial was in St. Paul Cemetery, Washington Twp., Pickaway County, Ohio.

 

Federal Census for the period 1850 and 1860 for Sarah Jane Valentine Anderson can be found in the Levi Valentine section of this book.

 

Sarah Jane Herrington and William H. Anderson planned to marry in the Fall of 1869. The Pickaway County Marriage Book for 1869-1878 contains an application for a marriage license dated 9 October 1869. The application was signed by William H. Anderson and Probate Judge, W.C. Brinkle but not Sarah Jane. The application was subseqently voided. Their marriage took place three years and a month later on 4 November 1872 in Kenton, Kentucky.

 

From the 1870 Federal Census for Washington Township, Pickaway County, Ohio; enumerated 3 June 1870 by John Muiden [all born in Ohio]

William Anderson, head, age 32, farmer Sarah Valentine, age 22, keeping house David Stout, age 14, farm labor

 

Kentucky Marriages, 1785-1979:

 


 


141


Generation 3 (con't)

 

Groom's Name: Wm Anderson

 

Groom's Birth Date: 1837

Groom's Birthplace: Pickaway County

Groom's Age: 35

Bride's Name: Sarah J. Valentine

Bride's Birth Date: 1847

Bride's Birthplace: Pickaway Co, Ohio

Bride's Age: 25

Marriage Date: 04 Nov 1872

Marriage Place: Kenton, Kentucky

Groom's Marital Status: Single

Indexing Project (Batch) Number: M01510-4

System Origin: Kentucky-EASy

Source Film Number: 1943299

Reference Number: rerg 1863-76 p 111

 

From the 1880 Federal Census for Washington Township, Pickaway County, Ohio; enumerated 14 June 1880

William Anderson, (head), age 43, farmer, born in Ohio

Sarah Jane Anderson, wife, age 32, keeping house, born in Ohio William Herrington, son, age 14, at school, born in Kansas

 

George W.L. Valentine, brother [sic, brother-in-law], age 26, born in Illinois Nora E. Valentine, sister [sic, sister-in-law], age 13, at school, born in Kansas George W. Stout, servant, age 19, laborer, born in Ohio

 

From the 1900 Federal Census for Washington Township, Pickaway County, Ohio; enumerated 14 June 1900

William H. Anderson, head, age 63, farmer, born March 1937 in Ohio

Sarah Valentine, wife, age 51, born June 1848 in Ohio; Mother number of living children = 1 Mother number of children = 1

 

From the 1910 Federal Census for Circleville, Union Street, Circleville Township, Pickaway County, Ohio; enumerated 19 April 1910

Sarah Anderson, head, age 62, widow, born in Ohio

 

From the 1920 Federal Census for Circleville, East Union Street, Circleville Township, Pickaway County, Ohio; enumerated 9 January 1930

Sarah Anderson, head, age 72, widow, born in Ohio

 

From the 1930 Federal Census for ju,enumerated 17 April 1930 Sarah Anderson, Inmate, age 79, widow, born in Ohio

 

(Other inmates enumerated in this entry were:)  Alice B. Downs, matron, age 58, widowed

 

Aletha Lucas, daughter, age 35, divorced Jean Lucas, grandaughter, age 10, single 

Mary Will, inmate, age 76, single

 

Millie Burton, inmate, age 70, widowed

Mary J. Waples, inmate, age 80, widowed Rebecca Smith, inmate, age 86, widowed Susan A. Milligan, inmate, age 75, widowed Mary J. Williamson, inmate, age 82, single Elizabgeth Bier, inmate, age 55, single Drusilla Dayton, inmate, age 85, widowed Jane E. Tritah, inmate, age 80, single

Mary A. Fitzer, inmate, age 82, widowed Wilson Pontius, inmate, age 75, married Addie Pontius, inmate, age 83, married

 


 


142


Generation 3 (con't)

 

Julia Steege, inmate, age 86, widowed

 

Lucy McMannus, inmate, age 76, widowed

 

U.S., Find A Grave Index, 1600s-Current about Sarah Jane Anderson

 

Name: Sarah Jane Anderson

Birth Date:

28

Jun 1848

Death Date:

15

May 1933

Cemetery:

Saint Pauls Evangelical Church Cemetery

Burial Place:

Pickaway County, Ohio

 

Obituary of Sarah Jane Valentine Anderson:

 

Mrs. Sarah J. Anderson, aged 84, passed away at the Home and Hospital Monday [May 15, 1933] at 8:30 a.m. of complications after an illness of six months.

 

Mrs. Anderson was born June 28, 1848 [Wednesday], a daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Levy Valentine. She was twice married both her husbands, Charles Harrington, the first husband, and William H. Anderson, preceding her in death.

 

Surviving are one son, William A. Harrington, 560 E. Franklin St; a sister, Mrs. Nora Ramsey of Kansas City, Mo., and two brothers, George W. Valentine of Kansas City and Lewis Valentine of Washington C.H.

 

Funeral services were held Wednesday [May 17, 1933] at 3 p.m. at the Albaugh Co. chapel with Rev. C.W. Ruhlman of Calvery Evangelical church officiating.

 

Burial was in St. Paul cemetery Washington Twp. [Note: St Paul' Church is located in Washington Township, Pickaway County, Ohio, about 5-miles east of Circleville, Ohio.]

 

 

Charles William Harrington and Sarah Jane Valentine had the following child:

 

11.            i. WILLIAM ALVIN4 HARRINGTON was born on 10 Jun 1866 in Kansas. He died on 24 Jul 1951 in at the home of his son, Roy William Harrington, in Circleville, Ohio (buried in Hitler Cemetery near Circleville, Ohio). He married Sarah Elizabeth Pence, daughter of Josiah Pence and Sarah Jane Lockwood, on 02 Nov 1890 in Hocking County, Ohio (by James Milhon, V Dr. M). She was born on 29 Apr 1872 in Benton Twp., Hocking County, Ohio. She died on 19 Jan 1948 in Circleville, Ohio, Pickaway County, Ohio (buried in Hitler Cemetery near Circleville, Ohio).

 

Notes for Caroline Couch Willigar:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 190

For the 1871 and 1901 Canadian Census for Caroline Couch Willigar Harrington, see the entries for her husband, Charles William Harrington in this book.

 

From the 1911 Fifth Census of Canada for District 42, Cumberland, Sub-District 20, Parrsboro (West Part) and Black Rock and West Bay, Nova Scotia; enumerated June 10 & 12, 1911 by John E. Dickenson

 

Caroline Harington, head, age 62, born Feb 1849 in NS, widowed, Baptist, income, Ins Nova Harington, grand daughter, age 13, born Sept 1990 in NS, Baptist

 

From the 1921 Census of Canada for District 55, Sub-District, Green Hill (rural), Moore St., Parrsboro, NS; enumerated [no date that census was taken] 1921 by J.E. Warmer; all born in Nova Scotia [all born in Nova Scotia; both parents of all born in Nova Scotia, Canada]

 

Harris Harrington, head, age 45, Baptist, mariner, father born in NS, Baptist Emily Harrington, wife, age 27, Church of England

 

Marjorie Harrington, dau., age 8, Church of England Doris Harrington, dau., age 5, Church of England Ralph Harrington, son, age 3, Church of England Caroline Harrington, mother, age 72, Baptist

 

Charles William Harrington and Caroline Couch Willigar had the following children:

 


 


143


Generation 3 (con't)

 

ii.       FLORENCE MAY HARRINGTON was born on 29 Jan 1869 in Mill Village, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. She died on 20 Apr 1905. She married John Patrick Harrington, son of John Webb Harrington and Nancy Anne Embree, on 26 May 1896 in Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. He was born on 10 Apr 1873 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

Notes for Florence May Harrington:

 

The birth record for Florence Harrington gives her date of birth as 29 January 1869 in Mill Village, N.S. [Note: Mill Village, NS was an early name for Parrsboro, NS] Her father was Charles W. Harrington, a mariner by vocation. Her mother was Caroline Couch. Charles and Caroline marriage date was given as 23 February 1867 in Mill Village. (Mill Valley was the name of the village of Parrsboro before it was renamed.) The birth was reported by Charles W. Harrington

 

Notes for John Patrick Harrington:

 

John Patrick Harrington was born 10 April 1873 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. This Item can be found in Registration Year:1873- Book:1805-Page:192- Number:147

 

John Patrick Harrington's residence in 1891, at age 18, was Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. his Marital Status: Single; Relation to Head-of-house: Son

 

John Patrick Harrington married Florence HARRINGTON on 26 May 1896 at age 23 in Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. Item can be found in Registration Year:1896- Book:1810- Page:154- Number:74 / Witnesses: Purdy Mills and Mrs. Geo McLean/ Rev. R. Williams // John's occupation: Miner. Florence was his 1st cousin, daughter of Charles William Harrington and Caroline Couch.

 

See the 1891 Census for Alexander M. Harrington under the entry for his father, John Webb Harrington in this book.

 

12.            iii. THOMAS STEWART HARRINGTON was born on 25 Dec 1870 in Black Rock, Cumberland County, Nova Scotia. He married (1) ANNIE EDNA MESSOM, daughter of Frederick Messom and Hannah Munro, on 03 Feb 1900 in Kentville, Kings, Nova Scotia, Canada. She was born on 03 Feb 1880 in Kentville, Kings County, Nova Scotia, Canada. She died on 29 May 1903. He married (2) AMEY WITHROW. She died in 1908. He married (3) PAULINA (LINA) RUSHTON, daughter of James Edward Balkem Rushton and Adelia Dunn, on 27 Jun 1908 in Truro, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada. She was born on 14 Jun 1888 in Great Village, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada. She died on 18 Apr 1922 in a house fire.

 

iv.      JOHN WILLIAM HARRINGTON was born on 25 Dec 1872 in Port Greville, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. He died on 15 Sep 1917 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada (died of Consumption).

 

Notes for John William Harrington:

 

Nova Scotia, Canada, Births, 1836-1910 about John William Harrington Name: John William Harrington

Birth Date: 1872

Birth Place: Port Greville, Cumberland Registration Year: 1872

Book: 1805 Page: 181

Registration number: 446

 

From the 1901 Census of Canada for the town of Parrsboro, District No. 30,

 


 


144


Generation 3 (con't)

 

Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada; enumerated (no date) by Arthur W. Jackson Charles Harrington, head, age 56, born 20 August 1844, Irish, Baptist,

 

Seaman

Caruline Harrington, wife, age 52, born 27 February 1849, English, Baptist William Harrington, son, age 28, born 27 December 1872, Irish, Baptist, Sailor Harris Harrington, son, age 26, born 4 July 1874, Irish, Baptist, Sailor

 

Ann Harrington, dau., age 19, born 7 February 1882, Irish, Baptist

Banford Harrington, son, age 21, born 4 March 1880, Irish, Baptist, (can't     read this word) maker

 

Edith Harrington, dau., age 17, born 15 January 1884, Irish, Baptist Howard Harrington, son, age 10, born 20 March 1891, Irish, Baptist,

Mary J Harrington, dau., age 25, born 25 March 1876, Irish, Baptist, domestic Freeman Harrington, son, age 22, born 22 May 1878, Irish, Baptist, sailor

 

William Harrington in the Canada, Seafarers of the Atlantic Provinces, 1789-1935 [Note: It is not proven that this is a record for William Harrington, s/o Charles William Harrington, but, most of the data such as his age, his place of birth, his date of birth, and the place where he joined the ship all seem to point to his being correctly identified.]

NAME: William Harrington

 

 

RECORD TYPE:

Crew

 

 

AGE:  19

 

 

 

BIRTH YEAR:  abt 1874

 

 

BIRTH PLACE: Parrsborough, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

VESSEL NAME:

Avoca

 

 

VESSEL TYPE: Barque

 

 

 

VOYAGE DEPARTURE DATE:

27 Jul 1893

 

VOYAGE DEPARTURE PORT:

Liverpool, England

 

VOYAGE ARRIVAL DATE:

10 Dec 1893

 

VOYAGE ARRIVAL PORT:

Sharpness, England

 

VESSEL REGISTRATION NUMBER:

W885007

VESSEL REGISTRATION PLACE:

Windsor, Nova Scotia

YEAR VESSEL CONSTRUCTED:

1885

 

DATE JOINED PRESENT SHIP:21 Oct 1893

 

PLACE JOINED PRESENT SHIP:

Parrsborough, Cumberland, Nova Scotia,

Canada

 

 

 

 

 

CREW NUMBER:

23

 

 

 

LITERACY:

Signed name

 

 

 

COMPLETED WHAT SIGNED ON TO DO?:

No

COMPANY FROM LAST SHIP: 0

 

 

CAPACITY (RANK):

Able-bodied Seaman

 

PAYMENT TYPE (TIME):

By the month

 

WAGE: 20

 

 

 

 

 

WAGE CURRENCY:

Canadian dollars

 

CASH ADVANCE:

10

 

 

 

CASH ADVANCE CURRENCY: Canadian dollars

 

13.            v. HARRIS HARRINGTON was born on 04 Jul 1874 in Nova Scotia, Canada. He died on 15 Oct 1925. He married Emily Rita Willigar, daughter of Jacob Willigar and Susan Ann Pettis, on 02 Mar 1916 in Oxford, NS. She was born on 08 Mar 1894 in West Bay, Cumberland, Nova Scotia.

 

14.            vi. MARY JANE HARRINGTON was born on 25 Mar 1876 in Five Islands, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada. She died on 21 Mar 1943 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada (Buried in St. George's Cemetery, Parrsboro, NS). She married Harvey David Henwood, son of Jeremiah Henwood and Philipa Melissa Phinney, on

 


 


145


Generation 3 (con't)

 

18 Aug 1902. He was born on 18 Apr 1878 in Nova Scotia, Canada. He died on 19 Nov 1962 in Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

15.            vii. FREEMAN HARRINGTON was born on 22 May 1877 in Five Islands, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada. He died on 30 Jul 1965 in Parrsboro, Cumberland Co., Nova Scotia, Canada. He married Sarah Alice Couch, daughter of Thomas Couch and Elgenora (Nora) Phinney, on 20 Dec 1905 in Parrsboro, Cumberland Co., Nova Scotia, Canada (Baptist). She was born on 02 Apr 1888 in West Bay, Cumberland, Nova Scotia. She died on 16 Sep 1946 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

viii.    BANFORD HARRINGTON was born on 04 Mar 1880 in Nova Scotia, Canada. He died in Mar 1921.

 

Notes for Banford Harrington:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 190

ix.      ANN E. HARRINGTON was born on 07 Feb 1882 in Nova Scotia, Canada. She died in 1917.

 

Notes for Ann E. Harrington:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 191

16.            x. EDITH MABEL HARRINGTON was born on 15 Jan 1884 in Nova Scotia, Canada. She died on 10 Feb 1955 in Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. She married Mayford Phinney, son of William Phinney and Rebecca Jane Pettis, on 27 Aug 1903 in Parrsboro, Cumberland Co., Nova Scotia, Canada. He was born on 02 Apr 1884 in Black Rock, Cumberland Co, Nova Scotia, Canada. He died on 08 Feb 1943 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

xi.      BESSIE MAUD HARRINGTON was born in 1885.

 

Notes for Bessie Maud Harrington:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 204

xii.     HOWARD JOSEPH HARRINGTON was born on 20 Mar 1891 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. He died on 02 Nov 1960 in Parrsboro, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada (Alternative dod = 24 Nov 1960 ). He married (1) MARY EMILY ANDERSON, daughter of Fred Anderson and Elizabeth ?, on 11 Nov 1912 in Truro, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada (RC). She was born about 1892. He married (2) RAE LAURINE MELVIN, daughter of Robgert Melvin and Catherine MacLeod, on 29 Mar 1934. She was born about 1908.

 

Notes for Howard Joseph Harrington:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 204

From the marriage application of Howard Joseph Harrington, age 21, and Mary Emily Anderson, age 22, we learned that Howard was a mill-hand born in Parrsboro, N.S. His parents were Charles & Caroline. His father was a Sea Captain. Mary gave no occupation. She was born in Halifax to Fred and Elizabeth. They were married in Truro, N.S. on 11 November 1912. Mary Emily Anderson was a Catholic

 

Howard's second marriage in Halifax, Halifax County on 29 March 1934 at age 43 was to Rae Laurine Melvin, age 26, an Anglican. Her father, Robert Melvin was born in England. Her mother was Catherine MacLeod. Her occupation was clerk. His parents were Charles and Caroline. Although he had the options of identifying his marital status as: Bachelor, Widower or Divorced, he listed Bachelor. Howard Joseph Harrington gave his profession as Seaman. Howard's marriage license application listed the birthplace of his father, Charles Harrington, as Iceland (Ol County).

 

6.      JOHN WEBB3 HARRINGTON (Thomas2, possibly "Dutch"1) was born on 26 May 1846 in Granville,

 


 


146


Generation 3 (con't)

 

Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. He married Nancy Anne Embree, daughter of Jacob Romer Embree and Melinda Jane Dobson, on 26 May 1866 in River Philip, Cumberland Co, Nova Scotia, Canada. She was born on 24 Mar 1843 in Greewnville, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

Notes for John Webb Harrington:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 191

John Webb Harrington was the youngest son of Thomas and Mary Webb Harrington. He appeared to be a man of several professions. From his marriage application to Nancy Embree on 26 May 1866, John's occupation was a Farmer. From the birth record of his daughter, Mary A. Harrington, John is a laborer living at Gray's River in 1867. From the marriage of his son, John Webb Harrington, on 26 May 1896 John is a Lawyer. Finally, the 1901 Census of Canada below indicates he was a carpenter.

 

From the 1881 Census of Canada for District No. 22 (Cumberland), sub-district River Philip; enumerated (no date or name of enumerator)

John Harington, head, age 34, (profession looks like Servant), Baptist Nancy Harington, wife, age 37

 

Mary E. Harington, dau., age 14 Alexander A. Harington, son, age 10 John P. Harington, son, age 8

 

Ella L. Harington, dau., age 6 Lucy L. Harington, dau., age 4 Maggie M. Harington, dau., age 2

 

From the 1891 Census of Canada for District No. 30 = Cumberland, Sub-District 15 = Oxford, Nova Scotia Province; enumerated 9 April 1891 by (no name of enumerator) [all Methodists, all family members and all parents born in Nova Scotia, except as noted]

 

John Harrington, head, age 45, lawyer

Annie Harrington, wife, age 48, Annie's mother born in New Brunswick, Canada Alexander Harrington, son, age 20

 

John Harrington, son, age 18 Lucy Harrington, dau., age 14 Maggie Harrington, dau., age 12 Charles Harrington, son, age 9 Annie Harrington, dau., age 7

 

From the 1901 Census of Canada for District No. 30 = Cumberland, Sub-District 3 = Amherst, Nova Scotia Province; enumerated 24 April 1901 by (no name of enumerator) [all Methodists, all family members born in Nova Scotia and identified as Irish]

 

John Harrington, head, age 54, born 26 May 1846, carpenter Annie Harrington, wife, age 58, born 24 Mar 1843

 

Lucy Harrington, dau., age 22, born 8 May 1878, tailor Annie Harrington, dau., age 17, born 21 Mar 1884, typesetter

Charles W Harrington, son, age 19, born 28 Mar 1882, boiler maker Ella Harrington, sister-in-law, age 18, born 28 July 1882

 

Lila Harrington, grand sister, age 10, born 31 Jan 1891

[Note: Lila was the daughter of Alexander Harrington (and possibility Elizabeth J. Nelson)]

 

John Webb Harrington and Nancy Anne Embree had the following children:

 

i.        WILBERT BARRY4 EMBREE was born on 03 Jan 1863.

 

Notes for Wilbert Barry Embree:

 

From the 1921 Sixth census of Canada for District 55, sub-district 20 in Athol (St. or Twp.), Southampton, Nova Scotia, Canada; enumerated by L.S. Barnes

Wilbert B. Embree, head, age 58, Methodist, farmer, own farm Augusta Embree, wife, age 57, Methodist

 


 


147


Generation 3 (con't)

 

17.            ii. MARY ALICE HARRINGTON was born on 07 Feb 1867 in Gray's Road, Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. She married Silas Purdy Mills, son of Silas Mills and Sarah Mills, on 25 Nov 1887 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. He was born on 12 Jul 1865 in Nova Scotia.

 

18.            iii. ALEXANDER MCPHEE HARRINGTON was born on 18 Mar 1871 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. He married (1) ELIZABETH J. NELSON, daughter of David Nelson and Isabella, on 28 Oct 1890 in Truro, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada. She was born in 1872 in Nova Scotia, Canada. He married (2) RACHEL BENTCLIFF on 27 Apr 1896 in Truro, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada. She was born in 1873 in Truro, Colchester, Nova Scotia, Canada. He married (3) SARAH ANN HENNESSY on 22 Dec 1897 in Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

iv.      JOHN PATRICK HARRINGTON was born on 10 Apr 1873 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. He married Florence May Harrington, daughter of Charles William Harrington and Caroline Couch Willigar, on 26 May 1896 in Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. She was born on 29 Jan 1869 in Mill Village, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. She died on 20 Apr 1905.

 

Notes for John Patrick Harrington:

 

John Patrick Harrington was born 10 April 1873 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. This Item can be found in Registration Year:1873- Book:1805-Page:192- Number:147

 

John Patrick Harrington's residence in 1891, at age 18, was Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. his Marital Status: Single; Relation to Head-of-house: Son

 

John Patrick Harrington married Florence HARRINGTON on 26 May 1896 at age 23 in Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. Item can be found in Registration Year:1896- Book:1810- Page:154- Number:74 / Witnesses: Purdy Mills and Mrs. Geo McLean/ Rev. R. Williams // John's occupation: Miner. Florence was his 1st cousin, daughter of Charles William Harrington and Caroline Couch.

 

See the 1891 Census for Alexander M. Harrington under the entry for his father, John Webb Harrington in this book.

 

Notes for Florence May Harrington:

 

The birth record for Florence Harrington gives her date of birth as 29 January 1869 in Mill Village, N.S. [Note: Mill Village, NS was an early name for Parrsboro, NS] Her father was Charles W. Harrington, a mariner by vocation. Her mother was Caroline Couch. Charles and Caroline marriage date was given as 23 February 1867 in Mill Village. (Mill Valley was the name of the village of Parrsboro before it was renamed.) The birth was reported by Charles W. Harrington

 

v.       ELLEN LOUISA HARRINGTON was born on 31 May 1875 in Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

vi.      LUCY L. HARRINGTON was born on 08 May 1878 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

Notes for Lucy L. Harrington:

 

For the 1881, 1891 & 1901 Canadian census for Lucy Harrington's see the entries for her father, John Webb Harrington in this book.

 

vii.     MARGUERITE MAY HARRINGTON was born about 1879 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 


 


148


Generation 3 (con't)

 

Notes for Marguerite May Harrington:

 

For the 1881 & 1891 Canadian census for Marguerite May (Maggie) Harrington's see the entries for her father, John Webb Harrington, in this book.

 

Maggie Harrington's residence in 1891 at the age of 12 was Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

viii.    CHARLES WARREN HARRINGTON was born on 28 Mar 1882 in Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. He married Nellie Farrell, daughter of James Farrell and Annie ?, on 13 Mar 1901 in Springhill, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. She was born on 28 Jul 1882 in Newfoundland.

 

Notes for Charles Warren Harrington:

 

All of the available records spells his name Harington

 

Elsewhere Charles Warren Harington's birthplace is given as Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

Charles residence in 1891 at the age of 9-years was Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

Charles residence in 1901 at the age of 19-years was Amherst (Town/Ville), Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

See the 1891 & 1901 Census for Charles Warren Harrington under the entry for his father, John Webb Harrington, in this book.

 

From the 1911 Census of Canada for District 32, Saint John City and County, of the province of New Brunswick, sub-district, Saint John, number 30, place of habitation 82 Broad, enumerated on June 12 & 13, 1911 by Sydney Ward St. John's City

Charles Harington, head, age 29, Tribal: Irish Methodist, Boiler Maker Nellie Harington, wife, age 28, born in Newfoundland, Canada Heath Carnige, age 25, boarder

 

ix.      ELLA HARRINGTON was born in 1883.

 

x.       ANNIE E. HARRINGTON was born on 22 Mar 1884 in Oxford, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. She married Florence W. McCarthy, son of Isaiah McCarthy and Letitia ?, on 04 Jan 1908 in Amherst, Nova Scotia (Methodist). He was born about 1884 in Springhill, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

Notes for Annie E. Harrington:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 191

The residence of Annie E. Harrington in 1891 at age 7 was Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada. Her residence in 1901 at age 17 was Amherst (Town/Ville), Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada

 

From the marriage application of Florance (male) W. McCarthy, age 24, and Annie E. Harrington, age 24, Florance lists his vocation as a Moulder. He listed his residence as Amherst and his place of birth as Springfield. His mother was Letitia and his father was Isaiah. Isaiah was a miner. Annie's parents were given as John and Annie.

 

From the 1921 Sixth Census of Canada, District No. 62 - Pictou District, Sub-District 19 = New Glasgow (Town), Nurses Home, Stellarton Rd., New Glasgow, Nova Scotia, Canada; enumerated (no date of enumeration) by George Gammon [all residents and their parents were born in Nova Scotia except as noted]

 

Annie Harrington, Matron/head, age 38, single

 


 


149


Generation 3 (con't)

 

Jessie Lameron, nurse, age 21, single Mona Morrison, nurse, age 25, single Isabella Dailey, nurse, age 24, single Ida Doming, nurse, age 24, single Annie Mahoney, nurse, age 23, single Flora Conrod, nurse, age 21, single Jean Dick, nurse, age 24, single Alice Sutherland, nurse, age 24, single Grace Maker, nurse, age 21, single

 

Majorie Harrington, nurse, age 21, single Vera Pushie, nurse, age 23, single Adeline Hammilman, nurse, age 23, single Mary McDonald, nurse, age 22, single Evelyn Munn, nurse, age 22, single

Peral Wry, nurse, age 24, single, Peral Wry and her parents were born in New Brunswick

 

Edna Salitar, nurse, age 21, single, Edna Salitar and her parents were born in P.E. Island

 

Nora Galbert, nurse, age 22, single, Nora Galbert and her parents were born in England

 

Alice Fraser, nurse, age 25, single Mamie Mahoney, nurse, age 22, single Ethel McDonald, nurse, age 28, single Edna Machon, nurse, age 23, single Christina Fraser, nurse, age 24, single

 


Generation 4

 

7.      JAMES FRANKLIN "FRANK"4 MYGATT (Eliza Anna3 Herrington, Charles2 Harrington, possibly "Dutch"1 Harrington) was born on 06 Sep 1868 in Clay County, Kansas, USA. He died on 13 Aug 1956 in Tulsa, Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA. He married Ethel Minnie Braker, daughter of Henry Fredrick Braker and Issie Isabella "Belle" Epperson, on 16 Aug 1908 in Marquette, McPherson, Kansas, United States. She was born on 13 Apr 1886 in Malvern, Mills County, Iowa, USA. She died on 26 Apr 1957 in Independence, Macon, Missouri.

 

Notes for James Franklin "Frank" Mygatt:

 

From the 1870 U.S. Federal Census for Sherman Township, Clay County, Kansas, Post Office Gatesville; enumerated 19 July 1870 by S. gates

 

Eliza Mygatt, head, female, age 35, born in New York, keeping house, value of real estate = $800, value of personal estate = $400

 

Eva Covey, age 16, female, born in Wisconsin, at home Ninnie Covey, age 14, female, born in Kansas, at home Henry Mygatt, age 8, male, born in Colorado

 

Arys Mygatt, age 6, female, born in Colorado Susan Mygatt, age 4, female, born in Kansas

James Mygatt, age 1, male, born in Kansas

 

From the 1910 United States Federal Census for Boon Township, Caddo County, Oklahoma; enumerated 25 April 1910 by Roy H. Gilbreath

James F Mygatt, head, age 41, born in Kansas, farmer, general farm [father born in Ohio; mother born in New York]

 

From the 1920 United States Federal Census for Boon Township, Caddo County, Oklahoma; enumerated 21 January 1920 by Everett E. Tims

James F Mygatt, head, age 51, born in Kansas, farmer, general farm Ethel Mygatt, wife, age 32

 

Eugene F Mygatt, son, age 9

 


 


150


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Victor H Mygatt, son, age 7

 

Phillip R Mygatt, son, age 6

Richard Mygatt, son, age 3-yr 4-mo

James L Mygatt, son, age 2-yrs 1-month

Jennie Mygatt, son, age 0-yr 8-months

 

From the 1930 United States Federal Census for Artesia, Graham, Arizona James R Ledford, head, age 49, born in Tennessee, farmer, own farm Letha M Ledford, wife, age 37, born in Nebraska

 

Ervin Ledford, son, age 18, born in Colorado, laborer, father's farm John Ledford, son, age 15, born in Colorado

 

Roy Ledford, son, age 12, born in Colorado Joseph Ledford, son, age 8, born in Oregon

Barbara J Ledford, mother, age 89, born in Tennessee Susan Going, mother-in-law, age 65

 

Frank Mygatt, uncle, age 61, divorced

 

From the 1940 United States Federal Census for Douglas City, Cochise County, Arizona Eugene F Mygatt, head, age 29, born in Oklahoma, share-crop farmer, fruit orchard [lived

 

in New Jersey in 1935]

James F Mygatt, father, age 71, born in Kansas

 

From the U.S., Find A Grave Index, 1600s-Current

 

Name: Pvt James Franklin Mygatt

Birth Date:

6 Sep 1868

 

Death Date:

13 Aug 1956

 

Death Place:

USA

 

Cemetery:

Memorial Park Cemetery

Burial or Cremation Place:

Tulsa, Tulsa County, Oklahoma, USA

Has Bio?:

Y

 

Spouse:

Ethel Minnie Mygatt

Children:

Phillip LeRoy Mygatt

James L. Mygatt

Pfc Richard Mygatt

Harold Victor Mygatt

Fredrick Eugene Mygatt

James Lloyd Mygatt

 

In about 1853 to 1856 James Franklin "Frank" Mygatt (he went by "Frank") told his family history story to a niece who transcribed it as follows: [Note: For the ease of reading and if they did not change the sense of the text, many of the obvious spelling and punctuation errors were corrected when this was transcribed to this book by R.E. Harrington on 20 February 2016]

 

In the beginning of the eighteenth century there was a family by the name of Harington lived in Holland and lived by fishing, catching herring. They owned their own fish Dorey and made their own square nets and caught great boat loads of herring and packed them in small kegs the same as we do today. He became known as Dutch Charley. They had one son, Charley Jr. He became engaged to a merchants daughter by the name of Anna Eliza Coopper. Of course there wasn't a chance of them ever getting married - a great merchant's daughter ever marrying a common fisherman's son. Young Charley learned to be a good sailor and finally ran away and went to sea and became a first class seaman and navigator. He finally got a job with a fur trading company on the Great Lakes about the time Milwaukee was started and was gone for two or three years. And finally came home with his pockets full of money and young Charlie and Anna slipped off and got married on the sly. He could not convince their parents that he could make a good living in the new country so he came back to America and the Great Lakes to his old job with the fur trading company. He saved his money for about three years, then went back after his wife. When he got there he had a young son, Charles the 3rd. He stayed several months getting ready and in

 


 


151


Generation 4 (con't)

 

the winter of 1834 the two families sailed for America; Charles Harington and John Coopper. They landed at Hoboken, N.J. on March 5, 1835 and my mother, Eliza Ann Harington was born the next morning March 1835. The two families settled along the west part of New York on the Great Lakes and they lived there for several years. Grand father Harrington made many trips on the Lakes with the fur trading company and was finally killed by the Indians in the northwest of Wisconsin.

 

Sometime in the 1840, grandmother Herington and Uncle John Cooper emigrated to Milwaukee and settled at a small town called Oshkosh, Wisconsin. They lived there until the later part of forty nine or early fifties, then they moved to Leavenworth, Kansas. My mother Eliza Anne Herington was married to a man Calvin Covey and they lived at Westport Landing on Missouri and kept a tavern at the foot of what is now the north end of Main Street. Calvin Covey was killed by the Indians on a trip from Kansas City to Fort Riley, Kansas about the year 1856. There was two children, Eva M. Covey and Minnie Julie Covey. They moved back up to Leavenworth, Kansas. In the late fifties they crossed the plains to the city of Denver, Colorado and it was in the late fifty-nine that Eliza Anna Covey met and married James G. Mygatt and lived there until the Civil War broke out in 1861. Mygatt joined the Second Colorado Cavelry, Co. G, Second Cavelry and was transferred to Fort Leavenworth, Kansas. He served until in sixty five, was discharded at Fort Rilely, Kansas at the expiration of his service. In 1866 they moved onto a homestead in Clay County. This union there was born four clhildren: Henry G Mygatt, born 6/12/1862, died Jan 27, 1880 (died from Otitis); Ayres M. Mygatt, born Nov 21, 1863, died Jan 16 1883 (a girl); Susie Coon Mygatt, born Apr 23, 1866, died 1936 (15 March); (James Franklin "Frank" Mygatt, born 6 Sep 1868, died 13 Aug 1956). Eliza Ann Herington, born 9 Feb 1835, died 1 Jan 1895.

 

James G Mygatt, Sargent of Captain E.D. Boyds Company G, Second Regiment of Colorado Cavelry Volunteers who was enlisted on the 16 day of May 1862 to serve three years or during the war is hereby discharged from the service of the United States this fourteenth day of June 1865 at Fort Riley, Kansas by reason of expiration of term of service. No objections to his being reenlisted is known to exist. Sargent James G. Mygatt was born in the state of New York is 42 years of age, five ft nine inches high, light complection, blue eyes, brown hair, occupation carpenter. Given at Fort Riley this 14 day of June 1865 by E.D. Boyd, Captain, Co. G, 2nd Colo Cavly. Born 1823, died 1870 March (9). Grandfather Mygatt lived in the city of Cincinnati, Ohio. James G. Mygatt was educated at a military academy in Cincinnati and served five years.

 

****************************************

The following note was written by Sharon Stauffer: This was hand written by James Franklin Mygatt (I, Sharon a Balts Shauffer, believe he wrote this at his niece's home, Mary Going Kelso, in Tulsa, OK., between the time 1853 to 1956

 

All ( ) are written by Sharon Stauffer.

All mis-spellings are written exactly as on the original hand-written letter.

 

James Franklin "Frank" Mygatt and Ethel Minnie Braker had the following children:

 

i.        EUGENE FREDRICK5 MYGATT was born on 30 May 1910 in Apache, Caddo, Oklahoma. He died in Wymore, Gage, Nebraska, USA.

 

ii.       VICTOR HAROLD MYGATT was born on 02 Feb 1912. He died in Jun 1989 in Kansas City, Missouri, USA. He married (1) MARGARET B BUCKLEY on 13 Jul 1935 in Jackson, Missouri, USA. She was born on 03 Apr 1917 in Missouri. She died on 07 Feb 2009 in Kansas City, Jackson, Missouri. He married (2) MARY MARGARET HILL in 1953 in Missouri.

 

iii.      PHILLIP R. MYGATT was born about 1914.

 

iv.      RICHARD MYGATT was born about 1916.

 

v.       JAMES L. MYGATT was born in 1917.

 

vi.      JENNIE MARIE MYGATT was born on 02 Apr 1919. She married Harold Austin Stauffer, son of John Manasses Stauffer and Leona Myrtle VanDeusen, on 05 May 1949 in Kansas City, Missouri. He was born on 31 Mar 1924 in Lawrence, Cloud, Kansas, USA. He died on 13 Feb 2013 in Forest Lake, Washington, Minnesota, USA.

 

Notes for Jennie Marie Mygatt:

 

For the 1920 U.S. Federal Census for Jennie Marie Mygatt, see the listing for her

 


 


152


Generation 4 (con't)

 

father, James F. Mygatt.

 


For the 1930 U.S. Federal Census for Henry, Vernon, Missouri Jake T Heney, head, age 59, born in Iowa, farmer, farm Lizzie M Heney, wife, age 60, born in Missouri

 

Charles W Heney, son, age 22, born in Missouri, laborer, farm Marie Mygett, lodger, age 11, born in Missouri

 

From the 1940 United States Federal Census for Maplewood City, Jefferson Township, St Louis County, Missouri; enumerated 10 April 1940 by Francis J. Hanna

 

John M Stauffer, head, age 40, born in Kansas, appraisal engineer, Missouri Public Service Commission

 

Leona M Stauffer, wife, age 38, born in Iowa Harold A Stauffer, son, age 16, born in Kansas Jean E Stauffer, dau., age 14, born in Kansas Norma L Stauffer, dau., age 13, born in Kansas Glen L Stauffer, son, age 10, born in Missouri Betty J Stauffer, dau., age 8, born in Missouri

 

From the Missouri, Marriage Records, 1805-2002

 

Name: Jennie Marie Mygatt

Age:  30

 

 

Race/Ethnicity: White

 

Birth Date:

2 Apr 1919

Marriage Date:

23 Apr 1949

Marriage Place: Jackson, Missouri

Registration Place:

Jackson, Missouri, USA

Spouse:

Harold Austin Stauffer

Spouse Birth Date:

31 Mar 1924

Spouse Race/Ethnicity:

White

 

From the Missouri, Marriage Records, 1805-2002

 

Name: Harold Austin Stauffer

Age:  25

Race/Ethnicity: White

Birth Date:

31

Mar 1924

Marriage Date:

23

Apr 1949

Marriage Place: Jackson, Missouri

Registration Place:

Jackson, Missouri, USA

Spouse:

Jennie Marie Mygatt

Spouse Birth Date:

2 Apr 1919

Spouse Race/Ethnicity: White

 

Jennie Marie Mygatt is still living at the age of 96-years in February 2016.

 

Notes for Harold Austin Stauffer:

 

From the Missouri, Marriage Records, 1805-2002

Name: Harold Austin Stauffer

Age:  25

Race/Ethnicity: White

Birth Date:

31

Mar 1924

Marriage Date:

23

Apr 1949

Marriage Place: Jackson, Missouri

Registration Place:

Jackson, Missouri, USA

Spouse:

Jennie Marie Mygatt

Spouse Birth Date:

2 Apr 1919


 

153


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Spouse Race/Ethnicity: White

 

 

8.      SUSAN COON4 MYGATT (Eliza Anna3 Herrington, Charles2 Harrington, possibly "Dutch"1 Harrington, James German). She married CHARLES ALBERT GOING.

 

Charles Albert Going and Susan Coon Mygatt had the following child:

 

i.        LETHA MAY5 GOING. She married JAMES RANDOLPH LEDFORD.

 

9.      EVA MONIRA4 COVEY (Eliza Anna3 Herrington, Charles2 Harrington, possibly "Dutch"1 Harrington) was born on 26 Oct 1853 in Wisconsin, USA. She died on 21 Mar 1925. She married ROBERT LITLE

SHIRLEY.

 

Robert Litle Shirley and Eva Monira Covey had the following child:

 

i.        ROSE EVA5 SHIRLEY. She married WILLIAM HENRY SHAW.

 

10.      MINNIE JULIE4 COVEY (Eliza Anna3 Herrington, Charles2 Harrington, possibly "Dutch"1 Harrington) was born in Jan 1854. She died on 16 Apr 1916. She married FRANK L. TURNER.

 

Frank L. Turner and Minnie Julie Covey had the following child:

 

i.        LOLA MAE5 TURNER. She married ALBERT AUGUST ANDERSON.

 

11.      WILLIAM ALVIN4 HARRINGTON (Charles William3, Thomas2, possibly "Dutch"1) was born on 10 Jun 1866 in Kansas. He died on 24 Jul 1951 in at the home of his son, Roy William Harrington, in Circleville, Ohio (buried in Hitler Cemetery near Circleville, Ohio). He married Sarah Elizabeth Pence, daughter of Josiah Pence and Sarah Jane Lockwood, on 02 Nov 1890 in Hocking County, Ohio (by James Milhon, V Dr. M). She was born on 29 Apr 1872 in Benton Twp., Hocking County, Ohio. She died on 19 Jan 1948 in Circleville, Ohio, Pickaway County, Ohio (buried in Hitler Cemetery near Circleville, Ohio).

 

Notes for William Alvin Harrington:

 

Album, Pages: 2-5, 9, 55, 169

William (Bill) Alvin Harrington was the son of Sarah Jane Valentine and Charles William Herrington. The earlier spellings of the Harrington surname included Herington, Herrington and all three are found in the historical literature. Bill Alvin's children used "Harrington," so, that is the spelling that will be used here.

 

Little is known of Bill Alvin Harrington's youth and early family life. He claimed that he was born in Kickapoo, Kansas, a claim that almost certainly would have been based on information that he got from his mother. But the period between his birth on 10 June 1866 and the 1880 Federal Census when he appears as a 14 year old son in the William H. and Sarah Jane Anderson household of his mother is a blank.

 

It is not known whether Bill Harrington finished high school. It is doubtful that he did although he was literate in both reading and writing. It was common practice in American farming families of the period, that children would drop out of school after their 6th or 8th grade to work on the farm. This is likely what William Alvin Harrington did. However, the 1880 U.S. Federal Census shows him still in school. So, he at least went as far as the 8th grade.

 

At the age of 24 years Bill married Sarah Elizabeth Pence on November 2, 1890 in Hocking County, Ohio. Eleven months and a few days later, Bill and Lizzie had their first of nine children. The baby was Nellie Mae Harrington and would be the first of 4-girls and 5-boys. All 9-children lived to adulthood and except for Easter Marie Harrington Thompson who died at the age of 28, all lived relatively long lives.

 

Bill and Lizzie's children, as adults, enjoyed each other's company and would get together fairly frequently to play cards, share meals, cook sweetcorn, make ice cream, drink beer, tell stories of their life experiences and just talk. Grandpa Bill was a frequent participant in these get-togethers. He always came by himself - Lizzie never joined in except when someone visited her house. Bill did not contribute much to the story-telling but was a frequent subject of some of the stories. His children agreed that he was a no-nonsense, authoritarian parent and was quite capable of backing up his authority with corporal punishment when needed. Each of his progeny

 


 


154


Generation 4 (con't)

 

had tales to tell of his discipline. Ira once told of coaxing his dad into sparing with him using boxing gloves. Ira was of an age that he was pretty sure that he could whip his dad in a boxing match. During the course of the match, Ira landed a solid blow on his dad's nose. The result was that it made his dad angry and he was going to take off the gloves and give Ira a good thrashing. But the boxing gloves were laced-on and he could not use his hand to grab and hold Ira. His solution was to put his gloved hand between his knees and rip the glove off tearing the boxing gloves and breaking the lacings in the process. While his dad was freeing himself of the gloves, Ira climbed the fence and escaped. Bill recovered from his sore nose and hot temper and reestablished his composure before Ira could return home.

 

Throughout his life, Bill would collect his weekly pay and on his way home from work, go to the store and buy the groceries. Lizzie seldom went to the store or handled money. One can speculate that there was some conversation with his wife as to what to buy, but he otherwise controlled the menu for the table.

 

Bill Alvin Harrington was a laborer. Census records list him as initially being a farmer, farm laborer, and general laborer. He worked in construction, poured and finished concrete, built fences, worked at the canning factory, worked on truck farms and about anything that would earn a dollar. He was a hard worker giving full value for his pay. He finished his career as a janitor, laborer and handy man working many years for the Ohio Electric Power and Lighting Company just south of Columbus, Ohio. He finally retired at the age of 72 with a pension from that Company. The Ohio Electric Power and Lighting Company is now an operating plant of the American Electric Power Company (AEP).

 

Bill was well liked by all who knew him. Unlike his wife who was usually secluded and largely antisocial, Bill was forthcoming and pleasant. He loved to play cards and would seldom pass up a game. He liked to gamble at cards but never for high stakes. Usually he played for a nickel or dime; a quarter a hand was about his limit.

 

John Greene, Jr. son of John and Esther Mae Eblin Greene and Grandpa Bill's great grandson recalls: "When we lived on the south end of Frankin County in old Marion Township from 1941 to 1949 grandfather Bill Harrington would come to visit us. He would ride the Greyhound bus from Circleville, and walk the short distance from High Street to our house (about a 1/4 mile ). That weekend there wasn't much sleeping. It was an all-night poker party. I remember his pointer finger had a heavy deformed finger nail, and he would thump it on the table when he wanted to make a point. When he came, he always brought along his bottle of Four Roses."

 

Bill Harrington’s deformed fingernail was on the index finger of his right hand. It was the result of an auto-accident. He was driving a model-A Ford and bumped into the back of a similar vehicle. Neither car was damaged but the bumper of Bill's car went over the bumper of the other car. He got hold of the bumper of his car and raised it a little and it slid off. The tip of his finger was between the sliding bumpers and it sheared off the end of his finger. It just cut off the tip leaving the 'quick' of the nail so that it continued to grow but in a thick, deformed nail, that he kept well-trimmed, that looked like a bit like a talon of a bird.

 

Grandpa Bill Harrington lived about a dozen years after he retired at the age of 72. At 72 he was pretty well worn out but made good use of his retired years. He liked to fish and, of course, play cards. The 1940 Federal Census enumerated Bill and his wife, Lizzie, living with their son, Roy and Kathryn Payne Harrington. After Lizzie moved out of their home, he made his residence with his son, Roy and Kathryn Harrington who lived on Main Street on the far-east side of Circleville. He no longer drove a car. One of his remaining pleasures was to walk the full length of Main Street to the far-west side of Circleville - a distance of about a mile. The attraction on West Main Street was a little bar named "Mary's." It was run by the owner whose name was Mary. Weather permitting, Grandpa Bill would make the walk once a day. At Mary's he was well known. He knew and liked all the patrons - it was a comfortable, fun place to be and he felt at home. Moreover, Mary was a good friend and although she was a couple of decades younger than Bill, she gave him a lot of attention calling him her 'boyfriend' and other endearing names. Bill enjoyed the attention. Undoubtedly, it was attention that he had not received for a long, long time at home, if ever. It filled a need of being liked and needed. Bill, at the age of about 80-years, misread Mary's interest and decided to propose marriage to her. He bought her a nice engagement ring and prepared to make his 2nd proposal of marriage in his life. As his plan matured, he took some of his children into his confidence. Their vision and advice was more clear than Bill's had become and they advised him against his plan. Being the stubborn old cuss that he was, he did not take

 


 


155


Generation 4 (con't)

 

their advice and proceeded with his plan. The discussions with his kids and their advice, however, probably helped soften the blow when Mary rejected his proposal. Bill continued his daily walk, though. Perhaps he found the beer was as important as Mary.

 

Grandpa Bill returned from his daily walk about 3:00 p.m. on July 24, 1951. He always took his supper with Roy and Kathryn and would usually help Kathryn prepare it if he could. On this day, he told Kathryn that he was not feeling good and thought he would lie down on his bed and rest a little. When Kathryn went to call him for dinner she found him dead. At the age of 85, Grandpa Bill finally wore out.

 

William Alvin Harrington never owned his own home. He always rented and was therefore relatively mobile. In the course of his life he moved many times remaining in the same house just a few years.

 

The author’s mother, Audra L. Young Harrington, frequently remarked how much she liked her father-in-law, Bill Alvin Harrington. Audra first met her future father-in-law when he was about 62-years old. Audra was taken aback by the brash, boisterous, and unpolished nature of some of his children, but, in contrast the man she knew as her father-in-law, Bill Harrington, was a soft-spoken, real gentleman. The author, Audra’s son, first remembers his grandfather a decade or so later and confirms Audra’s description of him.

 

Obituary of William Alvin Harrington:

 

William Alvin Harrington, 85, died Tuesday afternoon [July 24, 1951] at 126 1/2 West Main Street where he made his home with his son, Roy Harrington, who survives.

 

He was born June 10, 1866 in Kickapoo, Kan., the son of Charles and Sarah Valentine Harrington and is a retired employee of Pickaway Power plant.

 

Also surviving are four other sons, Ray of Canal Winchester, Lewis of Columbus, Fred of East Main Street and Ira Harrington of West Mound street; three daughters, Miss Nellie Harrington and Mrs. Ruth Pennell of Columbus and Mrs. Viola Eblin of East Main street; 17 grandchildren and 13 great grandchildren.

 

Services were held at 2:30 p.m. Thursday in Defenbaugh Funeral Home with the Rev. Joseph Bellcastro of Columbus officiating. Burial was in Hitler-Ludwig cemetery with grandsons acting as pallbearers.

 

Being relatively isolated in the rural farming area east of Circleville, I had only limited contact with my grandparents and my aunts and uncles. So, much of the impression that I have of the Harrington family members came from my mother, Audra L. Young Harrington. Audra found the loud, boisterous and unpolished nature of some of Ira's siblings not to her liking. Nevertheless, she was sociable and courteous with them and without exception, they all seemed to like her. It was not until I was in my own autumn years that I was able to view her inlaws more objectively and better appreciate her point of view. I will review Audra's relationship with her inlaws more when I write about Audra later, but that is not the point of the current observation. Rather, the point is to try to understand my dad's family a little better and appreciate why they were as they were.

 

To better understand my dad's parents and siblings it is probably only necessary to remember how they were reared and the environment of their lives. Grandpa Bill Harrington spent his formative years on his step-father's farm. He was poorly educated but not illiterate. He married Sarah Elizabeth Pence in 2 November1890 when he was 24 and she was 18 years old. Within about one year they began their family of 9-children with the birth of Nellie on 17 October 1891. Babies came rapidly so that for the next 4-decades their house would be filled with their children and grandchildren. Grandpa Bill Harrington's early training on his step-father's farm prepared him for little more than hard work and farm labor. Bill and Sarah's family was dirt-poor. Ira recalls that while they always seemed to have enough to eat, it was important that he be at the table and get his share because there were no seconds helpings. They ate a lot of beans, corn bread and potatoes. As the boys got bigger, their meals were supplemented by wild game and fish.

 

There was no extra money for anything, only the bare necessities. Bill and Sarah never owned real estate property. They either rented or traded labor for housing. With so large a family, space was very limited, particularly, in winter when it was not possible to spend time out-of-doors. Living was hard and the decades of the end of the 1800s and beginning of the 1900s found technology just

 


 


156


Generation 4 (con't)

 

beginning but still offering little opportunities other than farming and hard-labor jobs. Bill and Sarah were both poorly-qualified to help their children find careers. So, it is not surprising that the children grew up as competitive, poorly mannered, and largely uneducated and ill-prepared for adult life.

 

What may be a little surprising is that as adults they remained friends and frequently socialized together.

 

From the Federal Census for 1880 for Washington Township, Pickaway County, Ohio; enumerated 14 June 1880

William Anderson, head, age 43, occupation: farmer Sarah Jane Anderson, wife, age 32, housekeeping William Herrington, son, age 14, at school

George W.S. Valentine, brother, age 26 Nora E Valentine, sister, age 13, at school George W. Stout, servant, age 19, laborer

 

From Federal Census of 1900 for Circleville Township, Circleville Ward 5, East Town Street, Pickaway Co., Ohio, enumerated 26 June 1900 by Samuel Kindler [Note: the William Herrington family was enumerated 4-houses away from the Josiah Pence house on the same street, East Town Street. See the Josiah Pence entry for details.]

 

Herrington, William, head, age 33, born June 1866 in Kansas, occupation: day laborer Sarah E. Herrington, wife, age 28, born Apr. 1872 in Ohio;

 

Nellie M. Herrington, dau., age 8, born Oct 1891 in Ohio; Charles R. Herrington, son, age 6, born Sept 1893 in Ohio; Ruth I. Herrington, dau., age 4, born July 1895 in Ohio; Viola G. Herrington, dau., age 2, born Aug 1897 in Ohio;

Ira E. Herrington, son, age 9-months, born August 1899 in Ohio

 

From the Federal Census of 1910 for Circleville Township, Pickaway County, Ohio, Lancaster Pike; enumerated 26 April 1910 by Ira L May [all born in Ohio, except as noted. William Harrington born in Kansas; William's father's birthplace given as Wisconsin]

 

William Harrington, head, age 44, occupation: concret works, sidewalks; born in Kansas, father born in Wisconsin, mother b: Ohio

 

Ella Harrington, wife, age 37

Chas Wm, Harrington, son, age 17, laborer, farm

Ruth I. Harrington, dau., age 15, working out, private family Viola Harrington, dau, age 13

 

Anna [sic Ira], son, age 11 Roy Harrington, son, age 9

Easter Harrington, daughter, age 6 Lewis Harrington, son, age 4 Fred Harrington, son, age 11-mo

 

From the Federal Census of 1920 for Walnut Township, Pickaway County, Ohio, Little Walnut Road; enumerated 31 January & 2 February 1920

William Harrington, head, age 53, occupation: laborer, farm (General) Lizzie Harrington, wife, age 48

 

Roy Harrington, son, age18, occupation: laborer, farm (General) Easter Harrington, daughter, age 15

 

Louis Harrington, son, age14 Frederick Harrington, son, age 11

 

From the 1930 U.S. Federal Census for Ward 2, 560 East Franklin Street, Circleville City, Circleville Twp., Pickaway County, Ohio; enumerated 21 April by Mary Campsa Eagleson [All born in Ohio except as noted]

 

William A Harrington, head, age 63, born in Kansas, both parents born in Ohio, laborer, light plant

 

Sarah E Harrington, wife, age 57

 


 


157


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Frederick M Harrington, son, age 20, father born in Kansas, laborer, ice plant June L Harrington, granddaughter, age 9

 

From the Federal Census of 1940 for Circleville, Pickawy County, Ohio; enumerated 11 April 1940 by Mrs. Nina B. Reid

Roy Harrington, head, age 38, lineman, utilities Catherine Harrington, wife, age 34

 

William Harrington, father, age 72, laborer, utilities Elizabeth Harrington, mother, age 67

 

Norma Harrington, niece, age 9 Jack Harrington, nephew, age 6

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Wm A Harrington (Sara E); Residence year 1947; Address 405 E. Main, Circleville, OH; Publication title: Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1947

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Wm A Harrington; bartender John's Pl; Residence year 1949; Address 405 E. Main, Circleville, OH; Phone: 608; Publication title: Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1949

 

The tombstones of Stella, William A., Sara Elizabeth Pence-Harrington, and Nellie Harrington are located at the edge of the road, 53 paces (about 160 feet) from the rear wall of the chapel on southernly line of projection of the west wall of the chapel in the Hitler-Ludwig Cemetery, Pickaway County, about 3 miles from Circleville, Ohio. Note: In the late 1990s, the Hitler-Ludwig Cemetery is under the care of Craig and Don Fausnaugh. Don took care of it for about 21 years; now (2001) his son, Craig, is caring for it. The cemetery records which only go back to about 1946 shows the ownership of the lots along the road described above to be as follows: (lots along the road begin with # 17 which is the south-most lot before reaching another road that "Tees" with the road along which the Harrington lots are located. The numbering of lots runs from 17 to 6 in the direction of the chapel -- i.e., lot is # 6 is closest to the chapel). Lots # 17, 16 & 15 = Walter (Barney) Rolfe; # 14, 13, & 12 (no owner listed); Lot # 11 = Fred Harrington (appears to be occupied by Stella, Fred's wife); Lots # 10 & 9 = Harrington Brothers (appears to be the lots occupied by William A. and Sara Elizabeth Harrington); Lot # 8 = Don Young; Lot # 7 = Lewis Harrington; Lot # 6 = Nellie Harrington.

 

Notes for Sarah Elizabeth Pence:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 2, 6

 

Sarah Elizabeth Pence first appears in the records as a 9 year old in the 1880 Federal Census. Since the 1890 Federal Census was destroyed by fire she never again appeared as a Pence. Her marriage license was found, however, documenting her November 2, 1890 marriage to William Alvin Herrington (later changed to Harrington by the family). On October 17, 1891 she bore the first of nine children. The author of this book, her grandson, Richard E. Harrington, recalls her as a very serious lady who seldom smiled. Most records of her life indicate that she preferred to use her middle name or some variation of it: Elizabeth, Lizzie, Liz, Eliza, etc.

 

Elizabeth and Bill Harrington's family was large and poor and no doubt she had a difficult life with few conveniences. Ira E. Harrington, the author’s father, described the family life as stark, poor, busy, and with little time for affection. In addition to her own immediate family, she also reared her granddaughter, June Harrington. June was the daughter of Ira Harrington and Dortha Moore. Then, shortly before June Harrington graduated from high school and left the home, two more grandchildren, Jack and Donna Lee Harrington, children of her son, Lewis Josiah Harrington, joined her household for rearing. No wonder that she seldom smiled.

 

Lizzie was religiously inclined. Perhaps her religion was one of her own few comforts because while her house was adorned with a few religious pictures, she did not recruit her children into religion. She attended a Christian church that was described as being both fundamental and radical. The audience was described as active participants in the service with some "speaking in tongues," shouting, and becoming physically involved by marching about. It may have been this radical activity that discouraged members of her family from following in her religious footsteps.

Although of little resources, Lizzie always managed to prepare a small white bag of hard

 


 


158


Generation 4 (con't)

 

ribbon candy and an orange or apple for her grandchildren at Christmas time.

 

June Harrington was reared by Lizzie and William Alvin Harrington from about the age of 5-years until she graduated from high school at age about 18. June's memory of her grandmother was that of a strict, impersonal lady who could seldom muster a smile. June recalled an event that I had nearly forgotten. Lizzie and her husband, Bill Harrington, agreed to act as over-night baby-sitters for her grandchildren, Dick and Bill Harrington, June's half-brothers. Dick and Bill were 5 and 3 years old, respectively. Lizzie's house was small and had no extra beds so a bed was prepared on a couch for Dick and two chairs were pulled together as a bed for Bill. Bill was not ready for bed but it was bed-time and Lizzie put him to bed anyway with the admonition that he had better be good and be quiet or the "boogyman" would get him. He retorted that the "boogyman" would get her; a response that both surprised Lizzie and that she found funny. June recalled that she smiled, almost laughing; a response that June had seldom seen and one of the few times that June ever saw her smile.

 

Even though my own family lived only about 3-miles away, in the country, I did not see my grandparents often enough to develop much of a feeling for their home life or how they got along. Considering the morose personality of Lizzie which did not seem to be shared by her husband, Bill, I would conclude that their home life was not always pleasant. Toward the end of her life, perhaps about 1945, Lizzie rented her own house in Circleville and moved out. She declared that she saw "snakes" crawling around her husband's chair and took it to be a sign that he was possessed by the "devil." Several descendants of the Pence line had moved to Circleville by then and had congregated in a close area in the north-end of Circleville. Lizzie moved close to where several other families of Pence lived in Circleville.

 

On the 19th of January 1948 Lizzie passed away at her home.

 

From the Ohio, Births and Christenings Index, 1774-1973

 

Name: Sarah Elizabeth Pence

Gender:Female

 

 

Race:  White

 

 

Birth Date:

29 Apr 1872

Birth Place:

Benton, Hocking, Ohio

Father: Josiah Pence

 

Mother: Sara J. Lockwood

FHL Film Number:

912314

 

For the 1880 Federal Census data for Sarah Elizabeth Pence, see the entries for her father, Josiah Pence, in this book.

 

For the 1900, 1910, 1920, 1930, and 1940 Federal Census data for Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington, see the entries for her husband, William Alvin Harrington, in this book.

 

Sarah E. Harrington obituary:

 

Sarah Elizabeth Harrington, 76, wife of William Harrington, Hayward Avenue, died in her home at 2:15 PM Monday of complications.

 

In addition to her husband, Mrs. Harrington is survived by eight children. They are Nellie Harrington, Columbus; Mrs. Carlton (Ruth) Pennell, Columbus; Viola Harrington (Eblin), Circleville; Charles and Lewis, Columbus; and Ira, Roy and Frederick of Circleville. Mrs. Harrington also is survived by 17 grandchildren and nine great grandchildren.

 

Funeral services were held in the Defenbaugh Chapel at 2:30 PM Wednesday with Dr. Joseph Belcastro officiating. Burial was in the Hitler-Ludwig cemetery.

 

Friends may call at the Defenbaugh Chapel until time for the funeral.

 

William Alvin Harrington and Sarah Elizabeth Pence had the following children:

 

i.        NELLIE MAE5 HARRINGTON was born on 17 Oct 1891. She died on 16 Oct 1975 in Pickaway County, Ohio (buried in Hitler Cemetery near Circleville, Ohio). She

 

married Matthew Sterling Harrington (27 Apr 1983 - living) Matthew Sterling Harrington (27 Apr 1983 - living), son of John J.G. Zwicker and Frances E. Snyder, on 23 Nov 1909 in Circleville, Ohio, Pickaway County, Ohio. He was born on 21

 


 


159


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Feb 1884 in Circleville, Ohio. He died on 11 May 1946.

 

Notes for Nellie Mae Harrington:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 7

 

Nellie Mae Harrington (1891-1975) was the oldest child of William (Bill) Alvin and Sarah Elizabeth Pence-Harrington. She was a hard, independent lady with fixed ideas that favored her and frequently offended others. Being the oldest child in a family that grew rapidly, she had a major role in raising her younger siblings. A family story was told that involved her younger brother, Ira. When she was about 12 years old, her mother was working as a gleaner in a bean or pea field. Nellie was charged with keeping an eye on her siblings and possibly also helping with the gleaning. Ira was approaching 2-years old and wondered onto the nearby rail road track. He was rescued from being run over by a brakeman who made his way to the cow-catcher and snatching him a second before the train hit him. Nellie escaped the family early and married young.

 

Family lore was that Nellie Mae Harrington never married. She was referred to as the old-maid of the family. But, from the Pickaway County, Ohio, Marriage Book number 14, page 459 - I found a marriage on 20 November 1909 of Nellie Mae Harrington, born 14 October 1891 in Circleville, Pickaway County, Ohio, to, William Ottis Zwicker, born 22 February 1884 in Circleville, Pickaway County, Ohio. Their marriage was performed by D.H. Jemison, pastor of the M.E. Church, in Circleville, Ohio. Nellie Mae Harrington’s gave her residence as Circleville, Pickaway County, Ohio. Her occupation was left blank. Her father was William Harrington and her mother was Sarah Pence. William Ottis Zwicker’s residence was Circleville, Ohio. His occupation was carpet weaver. His father was George Zwicker and his mother was Fannie Francis. Both William and Nellie claimed that they had not been previously married.

 

My earliest recollection of Nell was when she was about 50-years old. She was a woman of average height, perhaps 5’-6” tall, slim, weighing perhaps 115 pounds, red thinning hair, and almost always well dressed. She was independent and somewhat arrogant. In reality she may have suffered from an inferiority or insecurity complex that she tried to hide.

 

Nellie lived and worked in Columbus, Ohio for much of her life. She visited other members of the family, infrequently. When she did, she made clear that she did not like children, an impression that no-doubt colors my opinion of her, even yet, since I was a child when most of my memories of her were formed.

 

Most of the stories told about Nellie usually reflect her controlling and frequently disagreeable personality. In about the 1960s, her younger brother, Roy Harrington, divorced his wife, Kathryn and moved into his own apartment. Nell moved into his apartment with his permission. Shortly after moving-in, she took charge of the apartment which included re-arranged Roy’s furniture to her liking. This was typical of Nell but was not an arrangement that Roy could approve. Roy soon asked her to leave.

 

The latter years of her life were spent in Circleville, the town of her birth. There she was a resident in an assisted living facility not far from where Ira’s son, my brother, William (Bill) Young Harrington, lived. Bill’s wife had baked a pie and had their son, also named William (Billy) Young Harrington, Jr., deliver a piece to Nellie. Nellie accepted the offering without a “Thank You.” Instead, she sent the message back to Bill, “Next time don’t send your brat, bring it yourself.” Perhaps the message got garbled by the carrier, but it was typical of Nellie.

 

From the 1900 United States Federal Census for Circleville City, Circleville Township, Pickaway County, Ohio; enumerated 26 June 1900 by Samuel Kindler [all born in Ohio, except as noted]

 

William Herrington, head, age 33, born June 1866 in Kansas, day laborer Sarah E Herrington, wife, age 28, born April 1872

 


 


160


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Nellie M Herrington, dau., age 8, born October 1891, at school Charles R Herrington, son, age 6, born September 1893, at school Ruth I Herrington, dau., age 4, born July 1895

 

Viola G Herrington, dau., age 2, born August 1897

Ira E Herrington, son, age 9-months, born August 1899

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Nell M. Harrington; Residence year 1919; Address b585 Carpenter, Columbus, Ohio [Chas R. Harrington, mech, Nellie's brother, is also a boarder at this address]; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1919

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Nell Herrington; Residence year 1922; Address 417 E. Main, Columbus, OH; occupation: none given; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1922 [living with Ira and Ruth (waitress) at 417 E. Main]

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Nell M. Harrington; Residence year 1925; Address 917 E. Cherry, Columbus, OH; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1925

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Nell M. Harrington; Residence year 1926; Address 917 E. Cherry, Columbus, OH; occupation: waitress; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1926

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Nell Harrington; Residence year 1928; Address r481 Carpenter, Columbus, Ohio [Chas R. Harrington, garage, 1287 E. Engler, is also at the 481 Carpenter address]; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1928

 

From the 1930 Federal Census for Columbus City, Ward 8, Block No. 115, S. Grant Ave., Franklin County, Ohio; enumerated: 10 April 1930 by Stanley D. Burke [all born in Ohio, except as noted]

 

Fred J Clark, head, age 35, occupation: waiter, restaurant

Inas E. Clark, wife, age 38, born in Virginia, occupation: waitress, restaurant

 

Ethel M. Schmidt, lodger, age 19, occupation: waitress, restaurant Nellie Harrington, lodger, age 38, occupation: waitress, restaurant Carl Fishbaugh, lodger, age 36, occupation: salesman, printing Jennie E. Baker, lodger, age 39, occupation: none

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Nellie Harrington; Residence year 1930; Address 232 S. Grant Ave., Columbus, OH; occupation: waitress, Neil House Coffee Shop; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1930

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Nell M. Harrington; Residence year 1931; Address 991 E. Mound, Columbus, OH; occupation: waitress; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1931

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Nell M. Harrington; Residence year 1954; Address 948 E. Whittier, Columbus, OH; occupation: chkr, Atheletic Club of Columbus; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1931

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Nell M. Harrington; Residence year 1959; Address: 144 1/2 Watt, Circleville, OH; Publication title: Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1959

 

From Ohio, Deaths, 1908-1932, 1938-1944, & 1958-2007 about Nellie Harrington

 


 


161


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Nellie Harrington; birth date: 1892; residence: Circleville, Pickaway, Ohio; death date: 16 Oct 1975 at Long-Term Care Facilities, Pickaway County; age 83

 

Social Security Death Index about Nell Harrington

 

Nell Harrington; Social Security Number = 275-03-5160; last residence: 43113 Circleville, Pickaway, Ohio; born: 17 Oct 1891; died Oct 1975

 

No children. Buried in Hitler Cemetery near Circleville, Ohio.

 

Ohio, Deaths, 1908-1932, 1938-2007 about Nellie Harrington

Name: Nellie Harrington

Birth Date:

1892

 

Gender:Female

 

 

Race:  White

 

 

Residence Place:

Circleville, Pickaway, Ohio, United States

Death Date:

16 Oct 1975

Hospital of Death:

Long-Term Care Facilities

Death Place:

Pickaway, Ohio, USA

Certificate:

076772

 

Age at Death:

83

 

Certifier:

Physician

Marital Status: Never Married (Single) (sic, not correct, married once to William Ottis Zwicker)

 

Notes for Matthew Sterling Harrington (27 Apr 1983 - living)

Matthew Sterling

Harrington (27 Apr 1983 - living):

 

From the Ohio, Births and Christenings Index, 1800-1962

 

Name: Zwicker

 

 

 

[Zwyker]

 

 

 

Gender:Female

 

 

 

Race:

White

 

 

 

Birth Date:

21 Feb 1884

 

Birth Place:

Circleville Township, Pickaway, Ohio

 

Christening Place:

Pickaway, Ohio

 

Father: J. G. Zwyker

 

 

Mother: Frances Snyder

 

 

FHL Film Number:

288391

 

From the U.S., World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917-1918

 

Name: William Ottis Zwicker

 

County: Pickaway

 

 

State:

Ohio

 

 

 

Birth Date:

22 Feb 1884

 

Race:

White

 

 

 

Permanent Address: 428 East Main St., Circleville, Pickaway County, Ohio Age: 34

 

Present occupation: laborer Employer's name: self

Nearest relative: Fannie Francis Zwicker

Description: Height, medium; build, medium; eyes, blue; hair, Sandy Registrar: Noah A. Warner

 

Registration date: 12 Sept 1918

 

From the 1920 United States Federal Census for Circleville Village, Circleville Township, Pickaway County, Ohio; enumerated 6th & 7th January 1920 by Mary Congers [all born in Ohio; parents of both John and Frances born in Germany]

 

John J G Zwicker, head, age 71, vocation, none

 


 


162


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Francis Zwicker, wife, age 66, vocation, none

 

William O Zwicker, son, age 37, cutter, shoe factory

 

From the 1930 United States Federal Census for First Ward, Circleville City, Circleville Township, Pickaway County, Ohio; enumerated 4 April 1930 [all born in Ohio]

 

Robert G Zwicker, head, age 37, mechanic, automobile works Nellie B Zwicker, wife, age 38

 

Charles O Zwicker, son, age 15 Fannie Zwicker, mother-in-law, age 77

W Otis Zwicker, brother, age 44, laborer, odd jobs

 

From the U.S., World War II Draft Registration Cards, 1942

 

Name: William Otis Zwicker

Birth Date:   22 Feb 1884

Residence:       Circleville, Ohio

Serial Number: 229

Address: E. Clinton St., Circleville, Pickaway County Age: 58

 

Name & Address of person who will always know your address: Circleville Iron & Metal Co. E. Clinton, Circleville

 

Employer's Name & Address: Harry Gordon, Mound St., Circleville, OH From the U.S., Find A Grave Index, 1600s-Current

Name: William Otis Zwicker

 

Birth Date:

22

Feb 1886

 

Death Date:

11

May 1946

 

Cemetery:

Green Lawn Cemetery

Burial or Cremation Place:

Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio, USA

Has Bio?:

N

 

 

From the Web: Columbus, Ohio, Green Lawn Cemetery Index, 1780-2010

Name: William Otis Zwicker

 

Birth Date:

22

Feb 1886

 

Age at Death:

60

 

 

Death Date:

11

May 1946

 

Burial Place:

Columbus, Franklin, Ohio, United States

Father: John Zwicker

URL:  http://greenlawn.delaohio.com/...

 

ii.       CHARLES RAYMOND (RAY*) HARRINGTON was born on 20 Sep 1893. He died on 16 Mar 1966 in Canal Winchester, Franklin County, Ohio. He married (1) FLORENCE PRICHARD before 1912. She was born in Ross County, Ohio. He married (2) BERTHA (BETTY) ARBELLA KIMMERLING, daughter of William Kemmerling and Ella Cupper, on 30 Nov 1914 in Pickaway County, Ohio. She was born on 06 Dec 1891 in Ashville, Ohio. He married (3) ESTHER SPETNAGLE after 1915. He married (4) GRACE HARLOR about 1940.

 

Notes for Charles Raymond (Ray*) Harrington:

 

Charles Raymond (Ray) Harrington (1893-1966) was the second child and the oldest son of William (Bill) Alvin and Sarah Elizabeth Pence Harrington. He was short, about 5’-5” and when I knew him at about age 65, he was bald except for a rim of remaining hair. He was a little over-weight; perhaps 220-pounds. Ray was one of only three children of Bill and Lizzie Harrington, other than Ira and Fred, who owned property. I recall visiting Ray with my dad, Ira, once when Ray lived in Canal Winchester, Ohio. He lived in a cute single-story house with a well-manicured lawn. I believe that by then his wife was Grace Harlor, a school teacher. Grace would have been Ray’s 3rd wife. Ray had no living children. His 1st wife had a stillborn

 


 


163


Generation 4 (con't)

 

child, the only child that Ray was known to have sired.

 

Ray had only a limited education, perhaps 8th grade, and had chosen to go into the automobile maintenance business as a mechanic working at a garage. Unlike most of his Harrington siblings, Ray apparently discovered early in life that cultivating manners and some culture would get him ahead in life faster than the loud, boisterous personality of some of his siblings. As he grew older, his personality began to pay off in his career. He moved from the dirty-fingernail work of the mechanic to the parts department and eventually to a mid-level management position. Ray even passed the gentleman-test of my mother, Audra L. Young Harrington, who had a good feel for such things and generally did not like the manners of some of the Harrington family.

 

Ray liked his beer. However, I have never seen him drunk or boisterous. Ira told me the story of going somewhere with Ray in Ira’s 1920-ish model Ford. Ira was driving; Ray was his passenger. Both had been drinking and Ray had fixed himself a mixed drink for the road. Ray was holding his drink by the upper lip of the glass but between his knees and as they drove along, Ray went to sleep. They drove for many miles over rough roads with Ray holding his drink near the top of the glass suspending the weight of the glass below his fingers. His hand formed a gimbal that minimized the movement of the glass and contents so it did not spill a drop. Upon arriving at their destination, Ira stopped the car while Ray slept on. Ira called to Ray that they had arrived, upon which Ray awoke, startled and jumped; spilling the full contents of the drink in his lap.

 

For the 1900 and 1910 U.S. Federal Censes entries for Charles R. Harrington, see the entries for his father, William Alvin Harrington in this book.

 

From the Pickaway County, Ohio, Marriage Book number 15, page 415 - Marriage on 25 November 1914 of Charles Ray Harrington, born 17 September 1892 in Pickaway County, Ohio, to, Bertha A. Kemmerling, born 6 December 1891 in Ashville, Pickaway County, Ohio. Their marriage was performed by Rev. P.E. Wright, Ashville, Ohio; no church affiliation given. Bertha A. Kemmerling’s residence was Ashville, Pickaway County, Ohio. Her occupation was Telephone Operator. Her father was William Kemmerling and her mother was Ella Cupper. Charles Ray Harrington’s residence was Circleville, Ohio. His occupation was laborer. His father was William Harrington and his mother was Lizzie Pence. Both Charles and Bertha claimed that they had not been previously married.

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Chas. R. Harrington; occupation: mech; Residence year 1919; Address b585 Carpenter, Columbus, Ohio [Nell M. Harrington, was also a boarder at this address]; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1919

 

From the 1920 Federal Census for 18th St., Fulton Street, Gilbert St, Ohio Ave, Columbus, Precinct I, Franklin County, Ohio; enumerated 8 January 1920 by Glenn Stokes

 

Ed M. Murphy, head, age 47, occupation: clerical work, office Anna Murphy, wife, age42, occupation: none

 

Nell Murphy, daughter, age18, occupation: none

Charles R. Harrington, boarder, age 26, occupation: clerk, office

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ray C. Harrington; occupation: garage, 1287 E. Engler; Residence year 1928; Address: r481 Carpenter, Columbus, Ohio [Nell Harrington, waitress, was also at the 481 Carpenter address]; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1928

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ray C. Harrington; occupation: garage, 1281 E. Engler; Residence year 1930; Address: [in this 1930 directory, the address

 


 


164


Generation 4 (con't)

 

was given as "do." which probably means it was the same as for 1929. We do not know his address in 1929 unless it was the same as in 1928. If it was the same as in 1928, it would be the same as Nell Harrington, waitress, who was also at the 481 Carpenter address]; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1930

 


From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ray C. Harrington; occupation: garage, 1281 E. Engler; Residence year 1931; Address: [in this 1931 directory, Ray's address was given as "do." which probably means it was the same as for 1930 and 1929. We do not know his address in 1929 unless it was the same as in 1928. If it was the same as in 1928, it would be the same as Nell Harrington, waitress, who was also at the 481 Carpenter address]; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1931

 

Registration Card for WW I; registration date: 5 June 1917; Charles Ray Harrington; residence; Ashville, Ohio; age 24; place of birth, Pickaway County, Ohio; date of birth: 29 Sept. 1893; Name of person who will always know your addresss: wife, physical disability; description, medium height, medium weight, blue eyes, light hair; no disabilities; registrar, E.E. Fraunfelter; Ashville precinct, Pickaway County, Ohio, 5 June 1917.

 

Registration Card for WW II; registration date: about 1941; serial number: 1628 Charles Raymond Harrington; residence; 1465 Wilson Ave., Columbus, Franklin Co., Ohio; mailing address: 300 So. Prospect St., Marion, Ohio; age 48; place of birth, Pickaway County, Ohio; date of birth: 29 Sept. 1893; Name of person who will always know your addresss: Mrs Esther Harrington, 1465 Wilson Ave., Columbus, Ohio; employer's name and address: Area Engineers - War Dept, Marion, Ohio; Place of employment: Scioto Ord. Plant, Marion, Marion Co., Ohio (D.S.S. Form 1 - Revised 4-1-42

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Residence year 1954; Ray Harrington (Grace); occupation: driver, Pennsylvania Rubber & Sup; r Canal Winchester, Ohio 1954 [Grace Harlor was a school teacher.]

 

Charles R Harrington in the Ohio, Deaths, 1908-1932, 1938-2007 NAME: Charles R Harrington

BIRTH DATE:

1894

 

GENDER:

Male

 

RACE: White

 

 

RESIDENCE PLACE:  Franklin, Ohio, United States

DEATH DATE:

16 Mar 1966

HOSPITAL OF DEATH: Home

DEATH PLACE:Franklin, Ohio, USA

CERTIFICATE: 19265

 

AGE AT DEATH:

72

CERTIFIER:

Physician

AUTOPSY:

Yes, not used for certification

MARITAL STATUS:

Married

CENSUS TRACT:

0940

 

Charles Harrington in the U.S., Social Security Death Index, 1935-2014

 

NAME: Charles Harrington

SSN:  273-22-6368

LAST RESIDENCE:

43110 Canal Winchester, Fairfield, Ohio, USA

BORN: 20 Sep 1893

DIED: Mar 1966

STATE (YEAR) SSN ISSUED:  Ohio (Before 1951)

 


 


165


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Charles Ray Harrington in the U.S., Find A Grave Index, 1600s-Current

NAME: Charles Ray Harrington

 

BIRTH DATE:

20 Sep 1893

 

DEATH DATE:

Mar 1966

 

CEMETERY:

Union Grove Cemetery

 

BURIAL OR CREMATION PLACE:

Canal Winchester, Franklin County, Ohio,

USA

 

 

HAS BIO?:

N

 

 

 

Notes for Esther Spetnagle:

 

Esther Spetnagle was a school teacher.

 

Notes for Grace Harlor:

 

Grace Harlor was a school teacher.

 

iii.      RUTH IMO HARRINGTON was born on 27 Jul 1895 in Hocking Co. Ohio. She died on 17 Sep 1965 in Pineville, Rapides Parish, Louisiana (She died of cancer. Interment date: 23 Sep 1965). She married (1) GEORGE HENRY PURCELL, son of William Franklin Purcell and Agnes Marie Bateman, on 05 Dec 1911 in Circleville, Ohio. He was born on 25 Dec 1892 in Jackson Twp., Pickaway Co., Ohio. He died on 06 Feb 1968 in Dunedin, Pinellas, Florida. She married (2) HURSHEL SCOTT HEETER, son of Peter Heeter and Anna M. ?, on 03 Feb 1918 in Pickaway County, Ohio. He was born on 28 Jul 1896. He died on 28 Feb 1932 in Circleville, Ohio, Pickaway County. She married (3) CARLTON PEARL PENNELL, son of John Sherman Pennell and Elizabeth (Lizzie) Downing, on 05 Apr 1924 in Franklin County, Ohio (Carlton Pennell died of cancer). He was born on 07 Jun 1892 in South Salem, Ohio. He died on 01 Mar 1951 in Columbus, Ohio (buried in Glen Rest Cemetery, Reynoldsburg, OH). She married (4) STERLING UMPHENOUR, son of Upton Cooms Umphenour and Grace Ethelyn Bunce, in Feb 1961 in Dade County, Florida. He was born in Aug 1898 in Illinois. He died in Dec 1976 in Louisiana.

 

Notes for Ruth Imo Harrington:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 8, 9

 

From the Hocking County, Ohio birth record book: Ruth Imo Harrington born 27 July 1895 in Benton Township, Hocking County, Ohio to W.A. Harrington and Sarah E. Pence. In a search of the records for 1890 to 1903 I found no other Harrington children born in Hocking County, Ohio.

 

Ruth Imo Harrington (1895-1965) - was the opposite from her sister Nellie. She was short, personable, congenial, slightly plump but a good figure for her age. She was a people-person and judging from her looks when I first knew her at about age 45-years, she must have been a beautiful younger woman. She had a good work ethic and was working as a housekeeper for a family when she was 15-years old. Ruth first married George Henry Purcell (1892-1968) and had her oldest son, George Purcell, who became a local radio star. Her second marriage to Hurshel Scott Heeter lasted only a few years. I have no data on that marriage. Her third marriage on 05 Apr 1924 was to Carlton Pennell with whom she had her second and last son, Roger Carlton Pennell. This marriage ended with the death of Carlton who sucumbed to cancer in March of 1951. Ruth's final marriage was to Sterling Umphenour in 1961, four and a half years before her own death.

 

In early 1932, in the depths of the Great Depression, Ruth and her family and Ira and his new wife, Audra Young Harrington and their new son, Richard Harrington, headed for Florida. Their plan was to build a fishing boat, fish, and sell their catch to the food market. They figured that the food market would somehow be immune from the national depression that gripped the economy. Their plan worked

 


 


166


Generation 4 (con't)

 

reasonably well except for being able to sell their catch to the food market. They soon discovered that the price being paid for fish was so low that it would not pay for the price of fuel.

 

Concern over the economics of the venture was soon overtaken by the sudden death of Easter Mae Harrington-Thompson on 25 July 1932. This was an unexpected shock to Ira and Ruth since Easter was their baby sister. The Ira Harrington family drove back to Ohio for Easter’s funeral in a marathon, non-stop except to refuel, run of 21-hours. Following the funeral, the Ira Harrington family remained in Ohio.

 

On the Marriage License Application for George H. Purcell and Ruth Harrington, Ruth gave Hocking Co. Ohio as her place of birth. They married on 5 December 1911.

 

Ruth and George Purcell divorced before 1918.

 

On the Marriage License Application for Hurshel S. Heeter and Ruth Harrington Purcell (03 Feb 1918), Ruth gave Vinton Co. Ohio as her place of birth. However, Hocking County birth records confirmed that she was born in Hocking County, Ohio.

 

Ruth apparently divorced Hurshel Scott Heeter before 1922.

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ruth Herrington; Residence year 1922; Address 417 E. Main, Columbus, OH; occupation: waitress; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1922 [living with her siblings, Nell and Ira Harrington, at 417 E. Main]

 

Ruth married Carlton P. Pennell before 1925.

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Carlton P. Pennell (Ruth I. Reliable Plumbing Co.); Residence year 1925; Address h w s N. Gould Rd 2 n E.Broad, Columbus, OH; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1925

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Carlton P. Pennell (Ruth I. Reliable Plumbing Co.); Residence year 1926; Address h w s N. Gould Rd 2 n E.Broad, Columbus, OH; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1926

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Carlton P. Pennell (Ruth I. Reliable Plumbing Co.); Residence year 1927; Address h Koebel Rd, Columbus, OH; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1927

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Carlton P. Pennell (Ruth I. Reliable Plumbing Co.); Residence year 1928; Address h Koebel Rd, Columbus, OH; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1928

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ruth I. & Carlton P. Pennell; Residence year 1930; Address h Collingwood Av, Columbus, OH; Carlton occupation: factory worker, Scott-Viner; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1930

 

From the 1930 United States Federal Census for Collingwood Rd., Cedarhurst, Truro Twp., Franklin Co., Ohio; enumerated 19 April 1930 by Harry J. Poth (all born in Ohio)

 

Carlton P Pennell, head, age 37, plumber, pipe fitting Ruth I Pennell, wife, age 34

 

Roger C Pennell, son, 1-month George W Purcell, step-son, age 18

 


 

 


167


Generation 4 (con't)

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ruth I. & Carlton P. Pennell; Residence year 1931; Address h 1288 E. Engler, Columbus, OH; Carlton occupation: plumber; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1931

 

Ruth I. Pennell, Carlton P. Pennell, Roger Pennell, George W. Purcell, Audra L. Harrington, Ira E. Harrington and Richard E. Harrington went to Miami, Florida in the spring of 1932 where they constructed a boat and began a commercial fishing business. They all returned to Circleville, Ohio about July 26, 1932 for the funeral of Easter Marie Harrington Ward. They did not go back to Florida.

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ruth I. & Carlton P. Pennell; Residence year 1933; Address h 2952 Maryland Av, Bexley, Columbus, OH; Carlton occupation: laborer, Scott-Viner; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1933

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ruth I. & Carlton P. Pennell; Residence year 1935; Address h 2952 Maryland Av, Columbus, OH; Carlton occupation: lab, Scott-Viner; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1935

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ruth I. & Carlton P. Pennell; Residence year 1939; Address h 2977 E. 11th Ave, Columbus, OH; Carlton occupation: plumber; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1939

 

From the 1940 United States Federal Census for 2975 E. 11th Ave., Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio; enumerated 17 April 1940 by Thomas P. Coady (all born in Ohio)

 

Carlton Pennell, head, age 47, plumber, Modurn Plumbing Ruth Pennell, wife, 44

 

Rodger Pennell, son, 10

 

Carlton P. Pennell died 01 Mar 1951 of cancer.

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ruth I. Pennell (wid of Carlton); Residence year 1953; Address h940 Oak, Columbus, OH; occupation: food chkr, Athletic Club of Columbus; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1953

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ruth I. Pennell (wid of Carlton); Residence year 1954; Address h940 Oak, Columbus, OH; occupation: chkr, Athletic Club of Columbus; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1954

 

Ruth Umphenour in the U.S. Veterans Gravesites, ca.1775-2006 NAME: Ruth Umphenour

SERVICE INFO.:

SSG US AIR FORCE

BIRTH DATE:

27 Jul 1895

 

DEATH DATE:

17 Sep 1965

 

RELATION:

Wife Of Umphenour, Sterling G

INTERMENT DATE:

23 Sep 1965

 

CEMETERY:

Alexandria National Cemetery, La

CEMETERY ADDRESS:209 East Shamrock Street Pineville, LA 71360

BURIED AT:

Section R Site 473

 

Ruth Umphenour in the U.S., Find A Grave Index, 1600s-Current

NAME: Ruth Umphenour

 

BIRTH DATE:

27 Jul 1895

 

DEATH DATE:

17 Sep 1965

 

CEMETERY:

Alexandria National Cemetery

BURIAL OR CREMATION PLACE:

Pineville, Rapides Parish, Louisiana, USA


 

168


Generation 4 (con't)

 

HAS BIO?:   N

 

Note: Pineville, Louisiana is located in the exact center (well, almost exact center) of Louisiana.

 

 

Notes for George Henry Purcell:

 

From the 1900 United States Federal Census for Jackson Twp., Pickaway Co., Ohio

F William Purcell 30

M Agnes Purcell 29

H George Purcell 7

M Golden Purcell 5

F Helen Purcell 3

A Sarah Purcell 1

 

 

Notes for Hurshel Scott Heeter:

 

For the 1900 & 1910 Federal Census for Hershel S. Heeter, see entries for his father, Peter Heeter.

 

From the 1920 Federal Census for 209 Pickaway St., Circleville City, Circleville Township, Pickaway County, Ohio; enumerated 9 January 1920 by Mary Conyers

 

Hershel S Heeter, head, age 23, farm laborer Ruth I Heeter, wife, age 23

 

George W Heeter, son, age 7 [sic, step-son]

 

Hurshel Scott Heeter in the U.S., World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917-1918 Date of registratio: 5 June 1918 by Florence L. Warner

NAME: Hurshel Scott Heeter

 

COUNTY:

Pickaway

 

STATE:

Ohio

 

BIRTHPLACE:

Ohio,United States of America

BIRTH DATE:

28 Jul 1896

 

AGE:

 

 

OCCUPATION: W.E. Pickens, 116 S. Court St., Circleville, OH

NEAREST RELATIVE: Pete Heeter

 

HEIGHT/BUILD: medium/medium

 

COLOR OF EYES/HAIR: Blue/D. Brown

SIGNATURE:

 

 

Hershel S Heeter in the Ohio, Deaths, 1908-1932, 1938-2007

NAME: Hershel S Heeter

 

DEATH DATE:

28 Feb 1932

 

DEATH PLACE:Pickaway, Ohio, USA

 

Herschl Scott Heeter in the U.S., Find A Grave Index, 1600s-Current

NAME: Herschl Scott Heeter

 

BIRTH DATE:

1896

 

DEATH DATE:

1932

 

CEMETERY:

Jackson Township Cemetery

BURIAL OR CREMATION PLACE:

Pickaway County, Ohio, USA

HAS BIO?:

N

 


 

 

 

169


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Notes for Carlton Pearl Pennell:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 8

Carlton Pennell in the Ohio, Births and Christenings Index, 1800-1962

 

NAME: Carlton Pennell

 

 

GENDER:

Male

 

 

RACE: White

 

 

 

BIRTH PLACE: Chillicothe, Ross, Ohio

BIRTH DATE:  7 Jun 1892

 

FATHER'S NAME:

John Sherman Pennell

MOTHER'S NAME:

Lizzie Downing

FHL FILM NUMBER:

281657

 

Carlton Pennell in the Ohio Military Men, 1917-18

NAME: Carlton Pennell

 

 

SERIAL NUMBER:

170294

 

RACE: White

 

 

 

RESIDENCE:  R. F. D. 2, Shepard, O.

ENLISTMENT DIVISION:

Enlisted Reserve Corps

ENLISTMENT LOCATION:

Philadelphia, Pa.

ENLISTMENT DATE:

4 Jun 1917

BIRTH PLACE: South Salem, O.

BIRTH DATE / AGE:

24 11/12 Years

ASSIGNS COMMENT: Co E 9 Engineers to 2 Sept 1917; Co A 19 Engineers (Co A 19 Regiment TC) (111 Co TC) to Discharge Private American Expeditionary Forces 9 Aug 1917 to 19 Apr 1919. Honorable discharge 29 Apr 1919.

VOLUME #:   13

 

From the 1900 United States Federal Census for Columbus, Montgomery Township, Franklin County, Ohio; enumerated 8 June 1900 by John M Hughey [all born in Ohio]

 

John S Purcell, head, age 34, born 19 January 1866, boiler maker Lizzie Purcell, wife, age 28, born 5 March 1872

 

Nina Purcell, sister, age 19, born 25 December 1880, Seamstress Carlton Purcell, son, age 8, born 7 June 1892

 

Lyle Purcell, son, age 5, born 9 January 1895 Mary Purcell, dau., age 3, born 20 Oct 1896

M* Purcell, dau., age 1, born 17 January 1899 [Minerva M ]

 

From the 1910 United States Federal Census for Jullivant Ave., Precinct G, Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio; enumerated 2 & 3 May 1910 by Rudolph L. Heid [all born in Ohio]

 

John S Pennell, head, age 43, boiler maker, railroad Lizzie Pennell, wife, age 34

 

Mary E Pennell, dau., age 13 Minerva M Pennell, dau., age 11 Lorna M Pennell, dau., age 9 Leona E Pennell, dau., age 7 Melvin L Pennell, son, age 6 Anna L Pennell, dau., age 4 Ora M Pennell, dau., age 2

 

From the 1920 United States Federal Census for Precinct A, E. Gay St., Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio; enumerated 9th & 10th January 1920 by Cora B. Ogiline [all born in Ohio]

 

Lizzie Pennell, head, age 47

Carlton P Pennell, son, age 27, boiler maker, railroad

 


 


170


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Henry L Pennell, son, age 24, laborer, flower mill

 

Minerva M Pennell, dau., age 20, Seamstress, Regalice Man

Lorna M Pennell, dau., age 19, Seamstress, Regalice Man

Eva L Pennell, dau., age 17, Seamstress, Regalice Man

Melvin L Pennell, son, age 15

Anna L Pennell, dau., age 13

Ora M Pennell, dau., age 11

Russell R Pennell, son, age 8

Elsie J Pennell, dau., age 7

Harley Downing, nephew, age 23, carpenter, house

 

From the U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995

 

Name: Carlton P Pennell [and Ruth I. Reliable Plumbing Co.]

Residence Year:     1925, 1926

Street address: h w s N Gould rd 2 n of E Broad Bex

Residence Place:    Columbus, Ohio, USA

Publication Title:     Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1926

 

From the U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995

 

Name: Carlton P Pennell [and Ruth I. Reliable Plumbing Co.]

Residence Year:     1927, 1928

Street address: h1791 Koebel rd UmD

Residence Place:    Columbus, Ohio, USA

Publication Title:     Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1926

 

From the U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995

 

Name: Carlton P Pennell [and Ruth I. Reliable Plumbing Co.]

Residence Year:     1929

Street address: h25 Collingwood av

Residence Place:    Columbus, Ohio, USA

Publication Title:     Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1926

 

From the 1930 United States Federal Census for Collingwood Rd., Cedarhurst, Truro Twp., Franklin Co., Ohio; enumerated 19 April 1930 by Harry J. Poth (all born in Ohio)

 

Carlton P Pennell, head, age 37, plumber, pipe fitting Ruth I Pennell, wife, age 34

 

Roger C Pennell, son, 1-month George W Purcell, step-son, age 18

 

From the U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995

 

Name: Carlton P Pennell [Ruth]

Gender:Male

 

1930

 

Residence Year:

 

Residence Place:

Columbus, Ohio, USA [h25 Collingwood av]

 

Occupation:

Factorywkr [Scott Viner Co.]

 

Spouse:

Ruth Pennell

 

Publication Title:

Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1930

 

 

Roger Carlton Pennell, son of Carlton and Ruth I. Harrington-Pennel was born on 2 Mar 1930.

 

From the U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995

 

Name: Carlton P Pennell

Gender:Male

Residence Year:     1931

Street address: 288 E Engler

 


 


171


 

Generation 4 (con't)

Residence Place:

Columbus, Ohio, USA

Occupation:

Plrabr

Spouse:

Ruth I Pennell

Publication Title:

Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1931

 

The families of Carlton and Ruth I. Harrington-Pennell and Ira and Audra L. Young-Harrington went to Florida in early 1932.

 

From the U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995

 

Name: Carlton P Pennell

Gender:Male

Residence Year:

1933

Street address:

2952 Maryland av Bex

Residence Place:

Columbus, Ohio, USA

Spouse:

Ruth I Pennell

Publication Title:

Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1933

From the U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995

Name: Carlton Pennell

[Ruth I]

Residence Year:

1934

Street address:

2952 Maryland av Bex

Residence Place:

Columbus, Ohio, USA

Occupation:

Laborer

Publication Title:

Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1934

From the U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995

Name: Carlton Pennell

[Ruth I] [cooper Scott Viner Co.]

Residence Year:

1938

Street address:

h2977

[E 11th av]

Residence Place:

Columbus, Ohio, USA

Publication Title:

Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1938

 

From the U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995

 

Name: Carlton P Pennell

Gender:Male

Residence Year:

1939

Street address:

2977 E 11th av

Residence Place:

Columbus, Ohio, USA

Occupation:

Plumber

Spouse:

Ruth I Pennell

Publication Title:

Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1939

 

From the 1940 United States Federal Census for 2975 E. 11th Ave., Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio; enumerated 17 April 1940 by Thomas P. Coady (all born in Ohio)

 

Carlton Pennell, head, age 47, plumber, Modurn Plumbing Ruth Pennell, wife, 44

 

Rodger Pennell, son, 10

 

From the U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995

 

Name: Carlton Pennell [plumber - Wm J Trott]

Residence Year:     1941

Street address: 2977 E av

Residence Place:    Columbus, Ohio, USA

Publication Title:     Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1941

 

Ruth Imo Harrington Pennel made application for a military headstone or marker on

 


 


172


Generation 4 (con't)

 

21 January 1953. Ruth received a pension C 2 072 947

 

 

Notes for Sterling Umphenour:

 

From the 1900 U.S. Federal Census for Hubbell Precinct, Thayer County, Nebraska; enumerated 18 June 1900 by Daniel C. Roderick

 

Upton C Umphenour, head, age 30, born in Illinois on May 1870, farmer Grace E Umphenour, wife, age 27, born in Minnisota on July 1872 Sterling G Umphenour, son, age 1, born in Nebraska on Aug 1898

 

From the 1910 U.S. Federal Census for Avoca Township, Precinct 4, Pottawatomic County, Oklahoma; enumerated 17 & 18 May 1910 by Albert J. Nicklass

 

Edgar H Bunce, head, age 66, born in Wisconsin, farmer, general farm Mary Bunce, wife, age 63, born in New York

 

Upton Umphenour, son-in-law, age 40, born in Illinois, farm labor, general

 

farm

Grace Umphenour, dau., age 37, born in Minesota

Sterling Frank Umphenour, grandson, age 11, born in Nebraska Helen Umphenour, granddau., age 6, born in Oklahoma Forest Umphenour, grandson, age 3, born in Oklahoma

 

From the 1920 U.S. Federal Census for Bellingham City, Watcom County, State of Washington; enumerated on 2nd & 3rd January 1920 by Mrs. Ruth R. Brown

Upton C Umphenour, head, age 49, born in Illinois, machinist, machine

shop

Grace Umphenour, wife, age 47, born in Minnesota

Sterling J Umphenour, son, age 21, born in Nebraska, mechanic, auto

garage

Helen Umphenour, dau., age 15, born in Oklahoma Forrest Umphenour, son, age 13, born in Oklahoma

Frances Umphenour, dau., age 3-yr, 4-mo, born in Oklahoma

 

From the 1930 U.S. Federal Census for Bellingham City, Watcom County, State of Washington; enumerated on 7 April 1930 by Margaret W. Dillon

Upton Umphenour, head, age 60, born in Illinois Emma D Umphenour, wife, age 57, born in Wisconsin Frances Umphenour, dau., age 12, born in Oklahoma

Sterling Umphenour, son, age 31, born in Nebraska, manager, popcorn

stand

Thelma Umphenour, dau-in-law, age 22, born in Utah

 

Sterling G Umphenour in the U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989

 

NAME: Sterling G Umphenour

GENDER:

Male

1930

 

RESIDENCE YEAR:

 

STREET ADDRESS:

1022 16th

 

RESIDENCE PLACE:

Bellingham, Washington, USA

 

SPOUSE:

Thelma Umphenour

 

PUBLICATION TITLE:

Bellingham, Washington, City Directory, 1930

 

 

Sterling G Umphenour in the U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989

 

NAME: Sterling G Umphenour

GENDER:

Male

1934

 

RESIDENCE YEAR:

 

STREET ADDRESS:

1022 16th

 

RESIDENCE PLACE:

Bellingham, Washington, USA

 

SPOUSE:

Thelma Umphenour

 


 

173


Generation 4 (con't)

 

PUBLICATION TITLE: Bellingham, Washington, City Directory, 1934

 

Sterling G Umphenour in the U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989

 

NAME: Sterling G Umphenour

GENDER:

Male

1935

 

RESIDENCE YEAR:

 

STREET ADDRESS:

2431 Lynn

 

RESIDENCE PLACE:

Bellingham, Washington, USA

 

SPOUSE:

Thelma Umphenour

 

PUBLICATION TITLE:

Bellingham, Washington, City Directory, 1935

 

 

Sterling G Umphenour in the U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989

 

NAME: Sterling G Umphenour

GENDER:

Male

1936

 

RESIDENCE YEAR:

 

STREET ADDRESS:

2725 Humboldt

 

RESIDENCE PLACE:

Bellingham, Washington, USA

 

SPOUSE:

Thelma Umphenour

 

PUBLICATION TITLE:

Bellingham, Washington, City Directory, 1936

 

 

Sterling G Umphenour in the U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989

 

NAME: Sterling G Umphenour

GENDER:

Male

1937

 

RESIDENCE YEAR:

 

STREET ADDRESS:

2725 Humboldt

 

RESIDENCE PLACE:

Bellingham, Washington, USA

 

SPOUSE:

Thelma Umphenour

 

PUBLICATION TITLE:

Bellingham, Washington, City Directory, 1937

 

 

Sterling G Umphenour in the U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989

 

NAME: Sterling G Umphenour

GENDER:

Male

1940

 

RESIDENCE YEAR:

 

STREET ADDRESS:

2725 Humboldt

 

RESIDENCE PLACE:

Bellingham, Washington, USA

 

OCCUPATION: Laborer

 

 

SPOUSE:

Thelma Umphenour

 

PUBLICATION TITLE:

Bellingham, Washington, City Directory, 1940

 

 

From the 1940 U.S. Federal Census for Bellingham City, Watcom County, State of Washington; enumerated on 10-11 April 1940 by Esther Marshall

Sherling G Umphenour, head, age 41, born in Nebraska, laborer, WPA Park maintenance

 

Thelma Umphenour, wife, age 32, born in Colorado Sherling G Umphenour, Jr., son, age 7, born in Washington Donald I Umphenour, son, age 4, born in Washington

 

Sterling G Umphenour in the U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989

 

AME:  Sterling G Umphenour

GENDER:

Male

1941

 

RESIDENCE YEAR:

 

STREET ADDRESS:

2725 Humboldt

 

RESIDENCE PLACE:

Bellingham, Washington, USA

 

OCCUPATION: Laborer

 

 

SPOUSE:

Thelma Umphenour

 

PUBLICATION TITLE:

Bellingham, Washington, City Directory, 1941

 


 

 

174


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Sterling G Umphenour in the U.S. World War II Army Enlistment Records,

1938-1946

 

 

 

 

NAME: Sterling G Umphenour

 

 

BIRTH YEAR:

1898

 

 

 

RACE: White, citizen (White)

 

 

NATIVITY STATE OR COUNTRY:

Nebraska

STATE OF RESIDENCE:

Washington

COUNTY OR CITY:

Whatcom

 

ENLISTMENT DATE:

22 Nov 1945

 

ENLISTMENT STATE:

California

 

ENLISTMENT CITY:

Hamilton Field

 

BRANCH CODE:

Air Corps

 

GRADE:

Sergeant

 

 

GRADE CODE: Sergeant

 

 

TERM OF ENLISTMENT:

Enlistment for Hawaiian Department

COMPONENT: Regular Army (including Officers, Nurses, Warrant Officers, and

Enlisted Men)

 

 

 

 

SOURCE:

National Guard in Federal Service, within 3 months of Discharge

EDUCATION:

4 years of high school

 

MARITAL STATUS:

Divorced, with dependents

HEIGHT:

06

 

 

 

WEIGHT:

856

 

 

 

Sterling G Umphenour in the Honolulu, Hawaii, Passenger and Crew Lists,

1900-1959

 

 

 

 

NAME: Sterling G Umphenour

 

 

PORT OF DEPARTURE:

Tokyo

 

PORT OF ARRIVAL:

Honolulu, Hawaii

ARRIVAL DATE:

20 Aug 1957 (time = 2040)

This trip was from Tokyo, Japan; via Wake Island; to Honolulu, T.H. on Military Air Transport Service (MATS); cargo Mil., 5-passengers

 

Sterling G. Umphenour was listed as a first lieutenant

 

Sterling G Umphenour in the Florida Marriage Collection, 1822-1875 and

 

1927-2001

 

 

 

NAME: Sterling G Umphenour

 

SPOUSE:

Ruth I Pennell

 

COUNTY OF MARRIAGE:

Dade

MARRIAGE DATE:

Feb 1961

VOLUME:

1945

 

 

CERTIFICATE: 3570

 

 

SOURCE:

Florida Department of Health

Lucy Thomas in the Texas, Marriage Collection, 1814-1909 and 1966-2011 (1970)

NAME: Lucy Thomas

 

 

GENDER:

Female

 

 

BIRTH YEAR:

abt 1912

 

AGE:  58

 

 

 

MARRIAGE DATE:

24 Oct 1970

MARRIAGE PLACE:

Harrison, Texas, USA

SPOUSE:

Sterling G Umphenour

SPOUSE GENDER:

Male

 

SPOUSE AGE: 72

 

 

SOURCE:

Texas Marriage Index, 1966-2002

 

Sterling Umphenour in the U.S., Social Security Death Index, 1935-2014 NAME: Sterling Umphenour

 


 


175


Generation 4 (con't)

 

SSN:  539-03-6452

 

LAST RESIDENCE: 71010 Blanchard, Caddo, Louisiana, USA

BORN: 20 Aug 1898

DIED: Dec 1976

STATE (YEAR) SSN ISSUED:  Washington (Before 1951)

 

iv.      VIOLA (OLIE) GRACE HARRINGTON was born on 29 Aug 1897 in Pickaway Township, Pickaway, Ohio. She died on 12 Feb 1996 in Columbus, Ohio (buried in Forest Cemetery, Circleville, Pickaway Co., Ohio). She married WILLIAM ALLEN EBLIN. He was born on 17 Apr 1894. He died on 02 Sep 1948 in Ohio, USA (buried in Forest Cemetery, Circleville, Ohio).

 

Notes for Viola (Olie) Grace Harrington:

 

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 17, 19

 

Grace V. Harrington in the Ohio, Births and Christenings Index, 1800-1962 Name: Grace V. Harrington

Gender:Female

Race:  White

 

 

Birth Place:

Pickaway Township, Pickaway, Ohio

Birth Date:

29 Aug 1897

Christening Place:

Pickaway, Ohio

Father's Name: Wm. Harrington

Mother's Name: Elizabeth Pence

FHL Film Number:

288392

 

From Federal Census of 1900 for Circleville Township, Circleville Ward 5, East Town Street, Pickaway Co., Ohio, enumerated 26 June 1900 by Samuel Kindler [Note: the William Herrington family was enumerated 4-houses away from the Josiah Pence house on the same street, East Town Street.]

 

Herrington, William, Head, age 33, born June 1866 in Kansas, occupation: day laborer

 

Sarah E. Herrington, wife, age 28, born Apr. 1872 in Ohio; Nellie M. Herrington, dau., age 8, born Oct 1891 in Ohio; Charles R. Herrington, son, age 6, born Sept 1893 in Ohio; Ruth I. Herrington, dau., age 4, born July 1895 in Ohio;

Viola G. Herrington, dau., age 2, born Aug 1897 in Ohio;

Ira E. Herrington, son, age 9-months, born August 1899 in Ohio

 

From the Federal Census of 1910 for Circleville Township, Pickaway County, Ohio, Lancaster Pike; enumerated 26 April 1910

William Harrington, head, age 44, occupation: laborer, farm

Ella Harrington, wife, age 37

 

Chas Wm, Harrington, son, age 17 Ruth I. Harrington, dau., age 15 Viola Harrington, dau, age 13 Anna [sic Ira], son, age 11

 

Roy Harrington, son, age 9

Easter Harrington, daughter, age 6 Lewis Harrington, son, age 4 Fred Harrington, son, age 11-mo

 

From the 1920 Federal Census, Pickaway Co., Circleville Twp., Ward 4: enumerated 10th & 12th of January 1920 by Patrick H. Malone (William Allen Eblin and Thomas Thomas were enumerated consecutively.)

 

William A. Eblin, head, age 26, machine tender, strawboard co. Viola G. Eblin, wife, age 23

 

George W Eblin, son, 5

 


 


176


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Leonard L. Eblin, son, 4-yr 7-mo Esther May Eblin, dau., 2-yr 8-mo Roy E., son Eblin, 7-mo.

 

Residence: Walnut Street; occupation: Machine tender, Strawboard

 

From the 1930 Federal Census, Pickaway Co., Circleville Twp., First Ward: enumerated April 26 1930 by Mrs. Edith Black Ulm

William Eblin, head, age 37, laborer, ice plant, mar’d  19yr Viola Eblin, wife, age 34, married 17 yr

 

George Eblin, son, 16 Leonard Eblin,son, 15 Esther Eblin, dau., 12 Roy Eblin, son, 11

 

From the 1940 Federal Census, Rual (sic) Route 3, Pickaway Co., Circleville Twp., First Ward: enumerated April 15 1940 by Mrs. Nina B. Reid

William Eblin, head, age 46, laborer Ice Plant Viola Eblin, wife, age 42;

 

George Eblin, son, 26, laborer, common labor Leonard Eblin, son, 24, laborer, common labor

Roy Eblin, son, 21, delivery, Ice Plant, 8th grade education

William Eblin attended school through the 6th grade. George, Leonard and Roy attended school through the 8th grade. Address was Rural Route 3

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989 record for Viola G. Eblin (wid W A) cook Weaver & Wells Restr; h 115-1/2 E. Main Circleville, Ohio; phone: 413 (year =

 

1949)

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989 record for Viola G. Eblin (wid W A) cook Pickaway Arms h 115-1/2 E. Main Circleville, Ohio; phone: 413 (year = 1952)

 

Social Security Death Index about Viola G. Eblin; SSN: 269-18-4004; Last Residence 43207 Columus, Franklin Co., Ohio; Born: 29 Aug 1897; Died: 12 Feb 1996

 

From Ohio, Deaths, 1908-1932, 1938-1944, & 1958-2007 about Viola Grace Eblin; NAME: Viola Grace Eblin

[Viola Grace Harrington]

 

 

BIRTH DATE:

29 Aug 1897

 

BIRTH PLACE:

Circleville, Pickaway, Ohio, United States

GENDER:

Female

 

 

RACE: White

 

 

 

DEATH DATE:

12 Feb 1996

 

DEATH TIME:

09:00 AM

 

HOSPITAL OF DEATH: Long-Term Care Facilities

DEATH PLACE:Columbus, Franklin, Ohio, USA

CERTIFICATE:

010661

 

 

AGE AT DEATH:

98

 

HOSPITAL STATUS:

Other/Nursing Home

SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER:

269-18-4004

FATHER'S SURNAME: Harrington

MOTHER'S MAIDEN NAME:

Pence

MARITAL STATUS:

Widowed

EDUCATION:

12

 

 

ARMED FORCES INDICATOR: No

INDUSTRY OF DECEDENT:

Private households

OCCUPATION OF DECEDENT: Cooks, private household

 


 


177


Generation 4 (con't)

 

CENSUS TRACT:    8740

 

PRIMARY REGISTRATION DISTRICT: 2501

 

Obituary of Viola Grace Harrington Eblin

 

Viola Grace Eblin, 98, of Circleville, died February 12, 1996, at Regency Manor Nursing Home, Columbus, Ohio.

 

She was born August 29, 1897 in Circleville to the late William and Elizabeth (Pence) Harrington. She was also preceded in death by her husband, William A. Eblin, in 1948; two sons, Roy Eblin and George Eblin; two sisters and five brothers. She was a champion cook, a member of the United Brethern Church, the Moose Lodge Auxiliary and the Eagles Lodge Auxiliary. She is survived by one son, Leonard (Ruth) Eblin of Circleville; one daughter, Ester May Greene of Pickerington; eight grandchildren; numerous great and great grand children; and several nieces and nephews.

 

Graveside service was held at noon Wednesday at Forest Cemetery with the Rev. Don Bachman officiating. No calling hours were observed. Arrangements were completed by the Defenbaugh-Wise funeral home.

 

 

Notes for William Allen Eblin:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 18

 

On May 22, 2003, John Edward Greene, Jr., wrote in an e-mail: "I know little of my grand parents. When my parents and grandparents were living, it was difficult for them and others to talk. Apparently early deaths and divorce were a detriment for them. My parents were not divorced, but what little I know about Bill Eblin could be written on a small note pad. I remember going to their Circleville home at the Circleville Ice Plant. I liked to go with my uncles to the horse barn and watch them work with the horses that pulled the ice wagons. I remember one time when Grandpa Eblin took me with him to feed the hogs. And I remember when he shot the hogs with a .22 rifle and the big butchering event. Bill and Ollie fought like cats and dogs. Drinking was the usual problem. I knew that Bill was raised by the Thomas's. I guess you knew that Bill died when he was playing the slots and pulled them over on himself and broke both legs. He never recovered from that. His death was some time after the divorce. I was always afraid of Bill. He seemed to have difficulty relating to me."

 

From the 1900 Federal Census of Ward 5 of Circleville, Pickaway Co., Ohio, Huston Street, enumerated 26 June 1900:

Martin Eblin, head, age 28, born 1872 (sic) in Ohio Mary Eblin, wife, age 35, born May 1865 in Ohio Rosetta E. Eblin, dau., age 1, born Dec. 1898 in Ohio

Thomas Thomas, boarder, age 26, born June 1873, in Ohio Anna Hessinger, sister, age 23, born Dec 1876 in Ohio William Eblin, nephew, age 6, born June 1894 in Ohio Nancy Eblin, mother, age 74, born Mar. 1826 in Ohio

 

On 3 November 1902, William Allen Eblin's mother, Anna Eblin Hessinger, married Thomas Thomas. They were married by Rev. A.E. Wright, minister. According to their marriage record, Thomas Thomas was 29 years old on 4 June 1902; Anna was 25 years old. The marriage record did not include the day and month of her birth. It did, however, provide the names of Thomas' and Anna's parents.

 

From the 1910 Federal Census of Ward 4 of Circleville, Pickaway Co., Ohio, Weldon Street, enumerated 19 April1910: (Thomas Thomas and Martin Eblin were enumerated consecutively.)

 

Thomas Thomas, head, age 36 born in Ohio, laborer, odd jobs

 


 


178


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Anna Thomas, wife, age 33 born in Ohio William Allen 'Thomas,' son, age 17 born in Ohio George H. Thomas, son, age 4 born in Ohio

 

Number of years [Thomas & Anna] married = 4-years; number of children born = 4; number of children living = 2.

 

Registration Card for WW I for William Allen Eblin; age 24; address: 376 Walnut St., Circleville, Ohio; date of birth: 17 April 1893; place of birth: Circleville Ohio; occupation: Backtender; employer: American Straw Board Co, Circleville; dependents: wife and 2 children; marital status: married; date of registration: 5 June 1917

 

From the 1920 Federal Census, Pickaway Co., Circleville Twp., Ward 4: enumerated 10th & 12th of January 1920 by Patrick H. Malone (William Allen Eblin and Thomas Thomas were enumerated consecutively.)

 

William A. Eblin, head, age 26, machine tender, strawboard co. Viola G. Eblin, wife, age 23

 

George W, son, 5 Leonard L., son, 4-yr 7-mo

Esther May, dau., 2-yr 8-mo Roy E., son, 7-mo.

 

Residence: Walnut Street; occupation: Machine tender, Strawboard

 

From the 1930 Federal Census, Pickaway Co., Circleville Twp., First Ward: enumerated April 26 1930 by Mrs. Edith Black Ulm

William Eblin, head, age 37, laborer, ice plant, married 19-yr Viola Eblin, wife, age 34, married 17 yr

 

George Eblin, son, 16 Leonard Eblin, son, 15 Esther Eblin, dau., 12 Roy Eblin, son, 11

 

From the 1940 Federal Census, Rual (sic) Route 3, Pickaway Co., Circleville Twp., First Ward: enumerated April 15 1940 by Mrs. Nina B. Reid

William Eblin, head, age 46, laborer at Ice Plant Viola Eblin, wife, age 42;

 

George Eblin, son, 26, laborer, common labor Leonard Eblin, son, 24, laborer, common labor

Roy Eblin, son, 21, delivery, Ice Plant, 8th grade education

William Eblin attended school through the 6th grade. George, Leonard and Roy attended school through the 8th grade. Address was Rural Route 3

 

Registration Card for WW II for William Allen Eblin; age 49; address: 376 Walnut St., Circleville, Ohio; date of birth: 17 April 1892; place of birth: Circleville Ohio; occupation: unemployed; name and address of person who will always know your address: Esther May Green - 55 Deering St. Columbus, Ohio; Serial Number U 959

 

William Eblin in the Ohio, Deaths, 1908-1932, 1938-2007

 

Name: William Eblin

Death Date:   2 Sep 1948

Death Place:  Ohio, USA

 

William A Eblin in the U.S., Find A Grave Index, 1600s-Current

 

NAME: William A Eblin

BIRTH DATE:  1893

DEATH DATE: 1948

CEMETERY:  Forest Cemetery

 


 


179


Generation 4 (con't)

 

BURIAL OR CREMATION PLACE:    Circleville, Pickaway County, Ohio, USA

 

v.       IRA EDWARD HARRINGTON was born on 28 Aug 1899 in Circleville, Ohio. He died on 23 Nov 1983 in Circleville, Ohio (at his request, he was cremated and his ashes buried in Forest Cemetery, Circleville, Ohio). He married (1) DORTHA ELLEN MOORE, daughter of John William Moore and Nettie Marlina Rowland, in 1920. She was born on 21 Jul 1901 in Tarlton, Pickaway, Ohio. She died on 01 Oct 1997 in Columbus, Franklin, Ohio. He married (2) VIVIAN (LIL) RADFORD, daughter of Charles James Radford and Esther Chambers, on 14 Jul 1923 in Franklin County, Ohio. She was born on 15 Jan 1900 in Athens Township, Athens, Ohio. He married (3) AUDRA LAVADA YOUNG, daughter of William Edward Young and Julia Viola (Ola) Hodge, on 24 Feb 1931 in Circleville, Ohio. She was born on 24 Jan 1907 in Lewisville, Ohio. She died on 08 Apr 1990 in Columbus, Ohio (buried in Forest Cemetery, Circleville, Ohio).

 

Notes for Ira Edward Harrington:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 47-51, 53, 63, 132, 155, 165

 

It is true that we can never fully know our parents. When we enter the family, our parents life is already about 30% over. Our grandparents' lives are already about 60% complete. Our earliest concept of family is therefore made up of, us kids, middle-aged people, old people, and, if there are great grandparents still living, very old people. Each of these groups of people have their own characteristics, their own history, life spans and their own attitudes and impacts on our own life. If asked to describe any of these individuals, the only real description we can give must be within the limits of our own experience with them. Our description, however, would likely include historical events that have been told to us by these individuals or by others. This we all take for granted and seldom even think about until we attempt to describe an ancestor or a contemporary or a progeny. A result is a time-based myopia that is one source of bias in a descriptive genealogy such as this.

 

In my own immediate family, the earliest recollection of my parents began about 1937. My dad, Ira Edward Harrington, was about 39 years of age; my mother, Audra Lavada Young Harrington, was about 31 years old. Both sets of grandparents were still living and in their 60s and 70s. One great grandparent still living was in her 80s. So everything I describe in this book that preceded 1939 had to be derived from records and stories that were told to me.

 

I am about to tell you of my father, Ira Edward Harrington, a guy whom I should know very well. But, some of the most exciting parts of his life happened before I was born. We are fortunate that among his many attributes, Ira was a story teller. Maybe his telling of his life-stories was motivated by the knowledge that he would never write his own biography and he used the role of a bard to communicate his history. Like a bard he repeated his stories with very little variation, many times over during the period we lived together.

 

In the spring of 1977 my daughter, Pamela Anne Harrington, was in college and had been given an assignment to write a paper. She decided to interview her grandfather, Ira, for some of his many stories, as the basis for her academic paper. She recorded the interview and transcribed several of his stories just as he had told them. I recognized most of the stories as almost exact versions that Ira had told many times to his children and others. These were his first 40-years that began with his birth in 1899. Several of these stories have been repeated in this book below just as Ira told them, retaining Ira's unique vernacular. In this book each story is identified with an asterisk and enclosed with quotation marks for easy identification of the source.

 

Ira Edward Herrington in the Ohio, Births and Christenings Index, 1800-1962 NAME: Ira Edward Herrington

 


 


180


Generation 4 (con't)

GENDER:

Male

 

RACE: White

 

 

BIRTH PLACE: Circleville, Pickaway, Ohio

BIRTH DATE:

28 Aug 1899

CHRISTENING PLACE: Pickaway, Ohio

FATHER'S NAME:

William A. Herrington

MOTHER'S NAME:

Sarah Pence

FHL FILM NUMBER:

288392

 

From the 1900 U.S. Federal Census for East Town Street, Circleville City, Ward 5, Circleville Twp., Pickaway County, Ohio; enumerated 26 June 1900 by Samuel Kindler [all born in Ohio except as noted]

 

William Herrington, head, age 33, born June 1866 in Kansas, day laborer, can read, write and speaks English

 

Sarah E Herrington, wife, age 28, born April 1872, can read, write and speaks English

 

Nellie M Herrington, dau., age 8, born October 1891, at school, can read, write and speaks English

 

Charles R Herrington, son, age 6, born September 1893, at school Ruth I Herrington, dau., age 4, born July 1895

 

Viola G Herrington, dau., age 2, born Aug 1897

Ira E Herrington, son, age 9-months, born Aug 1899

Note: William Herrington was enumerated 4-houses away from the family of his father-in-law, Josiah Pence. See the entry for Josiah Pence for details.

 

1902

 

A family story was told that involved Nellie, the oldest child in the Harrington family and her younger brother, Ira. When Nellie Mae Harrington was about 12 years old, her mother was working as a gleaner in a bean field that was bordered on one side by the railroad tracks. Nellie was charged with keeping an eye on her then 4-siblings and possibly also helping with the gleaning. Ira was about 2-years old and wondered onto the nearby rail road track. Perhaps amazed by the on-coming train that was approaching with its whistle screaming, and coming too rapidly to stop, Ira stood transfixed on the track. He was rescued from being run over by a brakeman who made his way to the cow-catcher and snatching him a second before the train would have run him over. [Each time I read about this event I shudder at the thought of what my history and the history of our family would be if that brakeman had failed to connect with Ira as he did. Other events have occurred that are mentioned in this book that in similar fashion would have drastically influenced the outcome of our family history. I shudder at them too and realize how deminishingly small the probability is that this book could ever be written.]

 

From Federal Census of 1910 for Circleville Township,Lancaster Pike, Pickaway Co., Ohio, enumerated 26 April 1910

Harrington, William, Head, age 44, born in Kansas (father born in Wisconsin), occupation: Concret (sic) worker, sidewalks;

 

Ella Harrington, wife, age 37, born in Ohio;

Chas. Wm. Harrington, son, age 17, born in Ohio, occupation: laborer, farm; Ruth I. Harrington, dau., age 15, born in Ohio, occupation: working out,

(private family);

Viola Harrington, dau., age 13, born in Ohio;

Anna (sic - Ira) E. Harrington, dau., age 11, born in Ohio; Roy Wm. Harrington, son., age 9, born in Ohio;

 

Easter M. Harrington, dau., age 6, born in Ohio; Lewis Harrington, son., age 4, born in Ohio; Fred Harrington, son., age 11-mo., born in Ohio

 


 

 


181


Generation 4 (con't)

 

1912

 

Many of the freight trains that hauled coal from Kentucky and southern Ohio came through Circleville, Ohio from south to north. These trains used steam powered locomotive engines that burned coal in their boilers to convert water into steam. Periodically they needed to replace the water used during their trip. There was a water tower located about 2-miles south of Circleville where the steam engines stopped to replenish their water supply. Being long heavy coal trains, they took several miles to get back up to speed for their continuing trip. Also, there was a curve in the railroad tracks that caused the trains to swerve around Circleville rather than going through the heart of town.

 

When Ira was a boy, he and several other boys would walk along the railroad tracks toward the water tower. They would board the slow moving train and as it approached the south end of Circleville where they lived and they would kick lumps of coal off the coal cars. Later they would pick up the coal in sacks and take it home for fuel.

 

This operation was pretty successful. The railroad was aware that they were doing it and would sometimes have detectives posted to try to catch them. On one occasion, one of Ira's friends put a lump of coal in their stove and it blew up. It had been drilled and a dynamite cap had been placed in the hole. This was done by the railroad detectives as a deterrent to stealing coal.

 

1915

 

* Ira's stories begin, "Before I ever went to Florida or California either one, we used to catch a train here in Circleville and go to Portsmouth, Ohio and back, just like that. Just for fun, when I was 15 years old. If my folks knew that I rode a train when I was 15, I'd a had nothing to sit on!"

 

1915-1916

 

I recall hearing Ira tell stories about camping on an island that had formed in the Scioto River, west of his hometown, Circleville, Ohio. Flood waters had carved a new but shallow course that isolated a small piece of land from the river bank creating the island. Ira and a friend pitched a tent on the island in the Spring and lived a life of Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn for part of a year. They lived off the land by hunting, fishing and eating young corn from a neighbor’s field. One day they had prepared a large skillet of corn that they cut from the cob and fried over an open fire. It was still early so they decided to run their trotlines before eating. The weather had been dry and the river level was low. When they returned, they found that a herd of cattle had waded across the shallow stream that isolated their island and helped themselves to the nice warm skillet of sweet corn licking it clean. Supper was late that evening since it was necessary to clean the camp site, wash the soiled dishes and prepare a new skillet of corn. This camping adventure ran well into the winter, as the story goes. Ira told that as the winter came on, they banked the outside of the tent with folder from a farmer's corn field that provided a good insulation from the weather. It was so well insulated that they were able to warm the tent from the heat of a lantern.

 

1916

 

* "Chet Workman and I pert' near growed up together. Once when we was about 16 years old, we were down here below town about - oh, a mile - and we were in a woods. Well, we come to a rail fence that was around a cemetery, and beyond the cemetary was bluegrass, so we figured on goin' up through there. So I throwed my leg over the fence, to climb over and Chet; I'll never forget, there were sheep in the cemetery, and he got one leg over the fence and the sheep started to get up. Now they don't get up like a cow. When they get up, they raise up on all fours. I don't know how they do it, I never watched them. But they just raise up. We were about 30 feet away from them and I had my lantern, and he seen 'em. I didn't see 'em myself 'til they raised up, and when they raised up they pert' near

 


 


182


Generation 4 (con't)

 

scared Chet to death. He thought they were ghosts!"

 

*               "I was up to see Chet day before yesterday. He's been a life long friend. Tried and true. We run around together about all our lives. We still run around together. He's 74.

 

*               "He's a guy that, I don't care where you're at, what you're doin', or who you're with, he keeps you laughin' all the time. Just naturally comical. It all had no importance, nothin' didn't mean anything, yet we had a lot of fun. Fishin' together, huntin' together, running' around together, went with girls together.

 

*               "One of the funniest things that I can remember, he set me up a date one time, with a girl that we knew. That was the horse and buggy days, so I rented a horse and buggy and went and picked her up. We went for a mile and a half or two miles, and I turned around and went straight back 'cause she stunk. She looked clean enough, and was a nice enough lookin' girl, but she had that damn odor about her when you don't take a bath. Her name was Claire Meyers. It's funny how I can remember things back there and I can't remember something

 

somebody told me yesterday. Oh, I've had a lot of fun in my time."

 

1916-1917

 

* "When I was about 16 or 17, this guy I knew had a big ol' upstairs, and they'd have prizefighting up there. He'd give me five dollars to fight."

 

1917

 

Ira grew to manhood as the Industrial Revolution was in full swing. Prohibition had become the law of the land a few years earlier and the world was hurdling toward World War I. Ira had no formal career training and the hard manual-labor of his father was looking less and less appealing to him. What he did find interesting was the rapidly evolving automobile and motorized transportation industry. No doubt this was further inspired by his older brother, Ray. Ray was 6-years Ira’s senior who had launched a career as an automobile mechanic and was progressing rapidly with the burgeoning industry. Ira described his passage into the automotive business this way.

 

* "My first mechanical experience was, I bought a motorcycle and I tinkered and worked 'til I knew it, and I understood how a motorcycle and a gasoline engine operates. Then I was working for a contractor here in town, and I had experience with small gas engines, so I worked for him and I took care of his cement mixers and their drive engines."

 

1918

 

As Ira became older, he began to travel farther from home in search of work. His main mode of travel was hopping freight trains. It was upon returning from such a job, when he was about 18 years old, that he was on his way back from Hog Island. He had been shoveling sand for a Navy yard. Hog Island is at the mouth of the Delaware River and he was coming back by way of train. Because he hadn't eaten in about three days, he was forced to do something that he had never done before - ask for food. He finally decided to approach a woman's house to ask for a hand-out.

 

* "There was a picket fence about three feet tall, and I was comin' back from Hog Island. I went and asked her for something to eat. She said 'Well, wait a minute.' So I waited. And I heard a dog's tonails hittin' the linoleum, so I took off running' and she opened the door and a big ol' dog gets out and took to running' me out the yard and down the street. I went on down the street and here was a boy about nine years old. I'll never forget this, I was really hungry. I hadn't had much to eat in three days, and here come this boy out of this house. He had a great big slice of homemade bread, all piled with butter and jelly, and he wouldn't stand still and he wouldn't come close enough. I was going to take it away from 'im. I says 'Hey boy, come here!' but he wouldn't come. It's kind of funny now, but it wasn't funny then, when you're hungry, with no money, and miles and miles from home."

 


 


183


Generation 4 (con't)

 

"I never begged anything in my life. I just couldn't beg. It just wasn't in me. I was walkin' down the railroad track about that same time and I saw this piece of bread layin' in the middle of the tracks. I looked at it and passed on. I was really hungry. I must have walked, oh, maybe a mile, and I thought, 'Oh hell. Some conductor or something throwed that off the train. It wouldn't be poisoned.' And I walked clear back, and I looked at it and I just couldn't pick it up. I never got nothing to eat until I hooked up with a fellow by the name of Brown. I'll never forget him. He was a muleskinner, he drove mules. I run into him and we got to talkin' and he says 'You look hungry.' 'I am hungry.' I says, 'I haven't eaten for three days.' Well, we got to a little town and he went out to get me something to eat and he sat down and ate three breakfasts. They'd take him in and sit him down and give him something to eat, and they'd never give him something to bring back to me. He finally run on to a woman. She was a middle aged lady, and she gave him two big slices of bread. One covered with butter and one covered with apple butter. That was the best I ever ate. You get real hungry and take a piece of plain bread, and it will taste like cake."

 

1918

 

On September 12, 1918, Ira registered for WWI draft at Circleville, Ohio. C. E. Stout signed the registration card. Ira gave as his profession, Linesman for the Citizen Telephone Co., Place of employment: N. Court St. Circleville, Pickaway Co., Ohio. He gave as his permanent contact point: Elizabeth Sarah Harrington , address: 6076 Mound St , Circleville, Pickaway, Ohio. He also gave this same address as his own address. He gave his date of birth as Aug 28, 1898 and his age as 20

 

1919

 

Ira became the proud owner of an Indian motocycle. In the years that included 1919 there were only a few paved roads and these did not include the gravel roads that served most rural residents and farms. On one occasion, Ira was riding on a gravel road with a passenger seated behind him. As he approached a place in the road where a ditch had been cut across to install a tile and refilled leaving a bump, Ira jokingly told his passenger that the road was out ahead and he should jump off. The passenger jumped off throwing the motorcycle out of control. Ira rode the vehicle off the road and into a fence row where he broke-off three fence posts. Ira was knocked unconcious. He remained in a coma for 8-days before waking up. This was one of Ira's near-death events that had a happy ending and, by extension, made possible the writing of this book.

 

1920

 

On 1 June 1920 Ira's first child, June Lucille Harrington, was born. June's mother was Dortha Ellen Moore. Information regarding this event is sparce and research has yielded little. Dortha abandoned June to her father, Ira Harrington. Unable to provide June with a home and without the experience or resources to care for a child, June lived with and was reared by her grandparents, Bill and Lizzie Harrington, until she graduated from high school. I have looked through the marriage license records in Fairfield, Pickaway, Ross and Franklin Counties, and more recently, Ancestry.com, for a record or Ira's marriage to Dortha Moore. I found none. I have come to the conclusion that Ira and June’s mother, Dortha Moore, probably were never married.

 

1922

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira E. Herrington; Residence year 1922; Address 417 E. Main, Columbus, OH; occupation: Auto Mech; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1922 [living with Nell and Ruth (waitress) at 417 E. Main]

 


 

 


184


Generation 4 (con't)

 

1923

 

On 14 July 1923 Ira Edward Harrington and Vivian (Lil) Radford married.

1924

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira E. Harrington; Residence year 1924; Address 678 Mohawk Av, Columbus, OH; occupation: Auto Mech, McClure-Nesbitt Motor Co.; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1924

 

1924

 

Ira and Vivian went to Florida by way of a Model-T Ford when he was 24 years old. This trip lasted at least 2-years since Vivian and Ira Harrington are registered in the Tampa, Florida City Directory in 1926 residing at 31 9th Ave, Tampa, Florida.

 

1924-1926

 

* "In Tampa Florida, some boy, I don't remember his name, was crookeder than hell, and he said I held him up! His older brother owned two or three filling stations, and three times he robbed that filling station. He would go and stay there while his brother went out to lunch or something, and three times he had a 'hold up' while his brother was out to lunch. One of 'em was right next to the shop where I worked, and he said that I held him up. They took me in for questioning, and I stayed overnight in jail. There was all kind of proof that I wasn't no ways near there at that time. He said that I had on a gray suit of clothes, and I didn't own one. I had a brown suit and a white suit. In fact, I was down at the Latin American Club. I had all kinds of alibis."

 

1924-1926

 

* "Once, on the corner of 9th Avenue and Maryland, in Florida, I stopped in a store. While there, I heard what sounded like a car backfiring. I went out and there was this guy that shot a nigger. This guy wanted me to swear and I wasn't even there. I was in a drugstore, and while I was in the drugstore, he shot 'im. And I went out, and the nigger was lyin' there bleedin' and that guy kicked a half a brick over to the side of the nigger and he wanted me to say I saw it and that the nigger was goin' to hit him with the brick. I said I don't want a damn things to do with it. I didn't see it and I don't want nothin' to do with it; got in the company car and just went on about my business."

 

U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989 about Vivian Harrington

 

Name: Vivian Harrington

Gender: Female

Residence Year: 1926

Street address: 031 9th Av

Residence Place: Tampa, Florida, USA

Spouse: Ira Harrington

Publication Title: Tampa, Florida, City Directory, 1926

 

1927

 

Ira ran over a little girl with his auto breaking both of her legs. He was exiting an alley in Columbus, Ohio where he lived and she ran across the alley from the obscured front of a building in front of his car. No charges were filed against Ira. He paid for the little girl’s medical treatment and visited her while she was in the hospital.

 

1929

 

Pam wrote, "When Ira was 29 years old, my grandfather took another trip. This went to California with his brother Lou. They took another Model-T Ford and set out for more adventures - which they found. They had a few problems with the Ford, though. In Arizona, the top of the car caught fire because of the wood support

 


 


185


Generation 4 (con't)

 

rubbing against the metal hood. Because they were in the desert, there wasn't any water to put it out with. How it was finally quenched will have to be passed down from generation-to-generation by word of mouth. After this happened they wrecked the Ford, and since they were low on money, instead of paying to have it fixed, they sold it, and came back by way of train. Not the conventional way, mind you, they hopped freight trains. This wasn't a new form of transportation to them, although the experiences they had were.

 

1929?

 

* "Another time, comin' back from Calfornia, I got to Texas, Sante Fe, and this railroad detective was puttin' everybody off the train, to keep 'em from ridin' and this detective caught up with me. I wasn't on the train, 'cause the train had stopped, and you better get off the train and get hidin' while you were stopped. So I got off the train and this detective caught me. He talked to me a little bit, I wasn't really a bum, see, I had some money and was dressed pretty good, so he talked to me a little bit. I told him where I was from and everything and he said, 'I believe you.' Then he said, you see that straight embankment down there? There's a road that goes across that and the train has to go upgrade. Now you start walkin', and when the train pulls out you get on it and get in the box car and shut the door.' So I did. There was another feller in there, a young guy from Texas, so I got in there and here was this guy. He was about, oh, I'd say 20 years old, but he was great big. Well I told him that the man said that if we keep the door shut, we could go on through. Well, we come to another town and made a stop, for somethin' and when we started to pull out, these two spicks got on, Mexicans. They were maybe between 20 and 25, they pulled in the rope and jumped in. So, that was pretty wild country through there. After we got out a piece, they throwed the door wide open and one sat on one side and one sat on the other. I tried to tell 'em that the man said that if we'd shut the door we could ride. They'd say 'no speak.' They didn't know English too well, and in order to get to ride, I insisted that they get back and shut the door.

 

Well, they didn't like that and one pulled out a switchblade about six inches long and started to clean his fingernails. So I got the other guy to come back to the other side of the car, and I sat down and he sat down along side of me. I asked him where he was goin' and everything, and he told me, but anyhow, I said 'We got to get rid of them if we want to ride this train clear through.

 

"'What'd ya want to do?', he says,

'"Well, we can talk to 'em a little bit, and you get on one side and I'll get on the other . . .'

 

"When the train got to rollin' real good, we just put our foot in their backs and kicked them onto the ground. They just rolled like balls! For the next two days I bought papers whenever we stopped in a town, to see if there was any account of them. I never heard anything. I don't think they were hurt, just a little scratched up.

 

1929?

 

* "Lou and I got separated on the way back, in Alburquerque, New Mexico. I didn't know where he was, but I knew he was on his way home. This was in Joliet, Illinois. I was ridin' on top of the merchandise in a box car, and we pulled in to Joliet. Well, I had to get off the train, so when it come to a stop, I looked both ways, and here come guys with lanterns, that was after dark, and here come a guy walkin' over top. They was lookin' for guys like me. And there was only one thing for me to do, make a dash for it. And I did. There was an old cabin set back off the railroad and I just went around that ol' cabin, it was all overgrown with weeds, kind of swampy down there, there was burdock and grass. I just made a dive around that house and went back in there quite a ways, crawlin' in the grass and big ol' burdock. They stomped all around me with their flashlights, they saw me run that way, and here they come with flashlights. One guy pert' near stepped on me. They give up, and I figured that was a pretty good place to spend the night, so I just

 


 


186


Generation 4 (con't)

 

stayed there. The next morning, shortly after daylight I woke up. I didn't dare to go back on them rails, because they'd be watchin' for me, so I started the other way, and come up to a big stone wall. I crawled up it, and looked right down in the back of a prison. I was out side of the prison. I went out to the trough where they watered the mules and washed my face and hands. There was a great big guard there and he come over and talked to me. He asked me where I was headed for and I told him. He said, 'Do you know where you're at?'

 

"I said, 'No.'

"You're in Joliet, Illinois. You're in the penitentiary. You're in the yard!' "I said, That's rough, ain't it?'

 

"I don't know whether to open that gate there and put you over in the penitentiary yard or let you go.'

 

"'Well,' I said, 'I haven't committed no crime, and I haven't offended you

have I?'

"'No.'

"'Well, then, I can't see no sense in putting me over in the prison yard.' "'Well, " he says, 'I guess I can't either."

 

"The prison gate where I went out was about a quarter of a mile out towards the street. He walked out to the gate with me. We just got out the gate and here come the city patrol. They didn't have cruisers then, they all walked on foot. We stood there and talked a little bit, and he said, 'Here's a guy that wandered in the back end this morning here. I'm going to turn him over to you.'

 

"The policeman asked, 'What did he do?' "'Oh, I don't know what he's done.' "They was kiddin' me, you see.

 

"So the patrolman said, 'Well we're pretty well filled up down there, I think I'll let 'im go.'

 

"So he told me where a hobo jungle was. A hobo jungle is where a bunch of hobos concentrate and cook and sleep and tell lies. Before I got there I went to a bakery and got some sweet rolls and, oh, a little ham I guess. There were ten or twelve guys there, with a big ol' lard can over a fire cookin', and I had this stuff to eat, and here comes another'n, says 'what you got?' and I give it to 'im and he tears the bread all up and tossed it in there and took the balony or whatever it was, cut it up and throws it in the can. They call it scumgullion. Everybody ate some. I had a little money, $60 or $70 and I was afraid to go to sleep, or stay there after dark 'cause those guys would cut your throat for a dime. So about an hour before dark I walked out through the jungle to a hill. I knew the steepness of the grade would slow the train down, so I sat down there in the grass agin' a tree and went to sleep until I heard a train whistle."

 

1929?

 

* "In New Mexico I stopped once and got some ham and eggs. The girl there was baitin' me or something, I don't know. She told the railroad detective to watch me." (He was referring to the waitress.) "He was a nasty ol' guy. Three days before that he had shot a 15 year old boy in the back. I went out and stayed away from the railroad until dark. When it got dark I knew that nobody could see which direction I was goin' or anything, but I had to walk out about a mile away from that town, then circle back to get to the railroad. That's when the guy got me. There was a light in the station, and I could see 'im bobbin' back and forth in that light comin' in my direction, so I got off the railroad, back onto the highway, He tried to get me back on the railroad so that he could arrest me. He pulled a gun and told me to get back down on the tracks. I said, 'If you're the kind of man that would shoot another man for nothin', than you go ahead.'

 

"He said, 'Where are you from?' "Ohio', I told him.

 

"Well, you're going to learn something, 'cause down here, we shoot first and investigate later.'

 


 


187


Generation 4 (con't)

 

"Well, you go ahead and shoot, 'cause I ain't gettin' down on no damn railroad. I'm up here on a public highway, and it ain't any of your business.'

 

"I watched him out of sight, and started walkin' on the highway. I figured that the highway would come back to the railroads somehow 'cause it was kind of curving towards the railroad, I must have walked a mile, and sure enough it did.

The road went under the railroad, so I got up against the buttress there, and later, it was just breakin' day when a train come along. Goodbye! I was gone.

 

1930

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira Harrington; Residence year 1930; Address 1159 E. Fulton, Columbus, OH; occupation: Mech; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1930

 

From the 1930 Federal Census for Columbus, Ward 4, Block 203, Franklin County, Ohio; Fulton Street; enumerated 4 April 1930 [all members of this house were born in Ohio; both of Katherine Loos parents were born in Germany; father:

 

Alsace-Lorraine; mother: Bavaria, Germany] Katherine Loos, head, age 58, occupation: none

William Loos, son, age 38, occupation: city Salesman, machine Wipers Marjorie Loos, dau., age 13

 

Jean Loos, dau, age 12 Isabelle Loos, dau., age 6 Robert Loos, son, age 4

Ira Harington, lodger, age 30, occupation: none

 

1930

 

While lead mechanic at a garage in Columbus, Ohio (it could have been the McClure-Nesbitt Motor Co.) Ira was asked to start an old Dussenberg automobile that had been taken in on trade. The Dussenberg was an American-made luxury automobile made in Des Moines, Iowa between 1917-1937. Although several mechanics had worked on it, it would not start. Ira was too busy to get to it for several weeks. Finally Ira told Jimmie, the garage handyman, to pull the car out on the floor. It had a magneto spark source. Ira dropped the pan so he could see the position of the pistons and synchronized the spark with the firing order of the cylinders. He put the pan back on and had Jimmie put oil in it and give it a crank. It fired on the first pull and ran well.

 

Another Ira story was about a customer who bought a new car. He was Italian and spoke only broken English. He was particularly careful with it and drove it very slowly. He would not use the high speed gear on the car. One day he brought the car in for repairs having been hit on the side in an intersection. Ira told him that he was hit because he was driving too slow. Ira pointed out that if he were going faster, he would have been well out of the intersection by the time the other car came along. The customer speeded up. Sometime later, he brought his car in again. Again it was hit in an intersection. He was furious with Ira. He complained that if he had not been driving faster, he would not have been even close to the intersection when the other car was there.

 

1931

 

On 24 February 1931, Ira E. Harrington and Audra Lavada Young Hines married in the Trinity Lutheran church in Circleville. They had met in Columbus, Ohio where Ira and Audra were each renting rooms from the sister of Audra's brother-in-law. Audra had lost her husband, Lawrence Hines, about 2-years before and was enrolled in a beautician school. Ira was working as a mechanic at a new-car dealership near by. Soon after their marriage, they moved to a shared facilities with the family of Ira's older sister, Carlton and Ruth Imo Harrington Pennell. The Great Depression was raging and the Country's economic system was

 


 


188


Generation 4 (con't)

 

on the rocks. Richard E. Harrington, the author of this book, was born on 23 December 1931 in St. Frances Hospital in Columbus, Ohio.

 

1931

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira E. Harrington (Audrey L.); Residence year 1931; Address 1288 E. Engler, Columbus, OH; occupation: Mech, McClure-Nesbitt Motor Co.; Publication title: Columbus, Ohio, City Directory, 1931 [Ruth I. & Carlton P. Pennell are also listed at this 1288 E. Engler address]

 

1932

 

Audra L. Harrington, Ira E. Harrington, with their new son, Richard E. Harrington; and Ruth I. Pennell, Carlton P. Pennell, with their sons, Roger Pennell, and George W. Purcell, went to Miami, Florida in early 1932 where they constructed a boat and began a commercial fishing business. The new business was financed with money that Audra had from a life insurance policy from her departed husband, Lawrence Hines. The venture was cut short and they all returned to Circleville, Ohio about July 26, 1932 to attend the funeral of Easter Marie Harrington Ward, youngest sister of Ira and Ruth. They did not go back to Florida.

 

1933

 

Ira told a story about he and a friend going gigging for frogs. They had finished gigging and returned to the friends Model-A Ford when they discovered that were being pursued by the game warden. Ira had a Model-A Ford just like the friend's car in which they were being chased. They outran the game warden and Ira was dropped off at his home. His friend drove on just seconds ahead of the game warden arriving at Ira's house. Ira ran into the house, closed the door and waited in the dark, looking out the window. The game warden drove up, felt the radiator of Ira's car and found it cold. The game warden drove away.

 

1934

 

In about 1934 Ira and Audra decided to buy a house with a little acreage in the country near Circleville, Ohio . The Great Depression was in full control of the National economy and work was hard to find and uncertain. Property with a little acreage would provide shelder and land to raise sufficient food to provide for the family. They had no money to buy their dream, however, and decided to borrow it from Audra's father, Will Young. Upon request, Audra's father took a shoe box from under his bed full of government bonds that he had bought from income from oil wells on his property. He removed enough bonds for the $600 loan, cashed them and provided the money.

 

1936

 

In 1936 the Great Depression still gripped the Nation. Ira was working at about any job he could find. At the suggestion of a friend, Carl Dutro, he agreed to try selling Watkins Products. This involved using his own car and peddling the Watkins-brand of products house-to-house. The product line was very large and included some staple foods, Watkins Liniment, Watkins Salve, Watkins Salt and Pepper, brushes, sponges, soap, and many more products. Sales were on commission. As a promotion, the Watkins agency gave away song books and other paper products. Ira was never a good salesman and hated the job. He soon decided that he wasn't making any money at it and stopped.

 

1937

 

Shortly after giving up on selling Watkins Products, Ira and and his youngest brother, Fred Harrington, who was 9-years his junior, went into the home-butchering business. They would go the stock market and buy one or more pigs. Ira had a trailer that he used for hauling pigs and all of the equipment for butchering. Ira and Fred would kill the pig, scald it, scrape off the hair, butcher it

 


 


189


Generation 4 (con't)

 

and prepare the meat for sale. Audra helped with the preparation and wrapping of the meat products. Ira and Fred would then peddle it around the country side and sell it. It was a lot of work -- butchering is no easy job. Uncle Fred had no investment in the business except for his labor. He was a good peddler, however, and outsold Ira. The business went on the rocks when Ira discovered that Fred was making sales and keeping the money. Fred also went back to customers who had bought on credit, collected the outstanding credit and kept the money.

 

1938

 

With the election of Franklin D. Roosevelt, several programs were undertaken to try to pull the country out of the depression. One was the Works Progress Administration (WPA). This was largely a make-work program that did public work on a wide range of infrastructure, cultural and arts. One such activity was the repair and painting of bridges. Ira applied to and was hired by the WPA. His job was to help paint bridges. He didn't particularly like the work but it was a job. Before long he became a specialist at painting the reflective stripes on bridges. He worked for the WPA until he could find a job more to his liking.

 

From the 1940 Federal Census for Pickaway Township, Pickaway County, Ohio; Dresbach road through county line enumerated 19 April 1940 by Fred Dudleson [all members of household born in Ohio]

 

Ira Harrington, head, age 40, occupation: mechanic, auto mechanic Audra Harrington, wife, age 32

 

Richard Harrington, son, age 8 William Harrington, son, age 7 Patricia Sue Harrington, dau., age 3

 

1940?

 

This potentially lethal accident occurred on the return trip home from a visit to Audra's parents, Will and Ole Young's house. Ira was driving in his Model-A Ford sedan. Ira's father, Bill Harrington, was with us. It had been raining and the road was wet. As we crested a small hill and were descending on the other side, Ira applied his breaks and the car started into a spin. It slid making a complete 360 degree spin but remaining on the paved road and came to a stop pointed in the same direction that we had been traveling. Not much was said at the time of the event. Later both Audra and Ira commented that their passenger, Ira's dad - Bill Harrington, who was riding in the front seat between them, turned as white as a sheet. The Harrington kids, myself included, were riding in the back seat, fully enjoying the maneuver.

 

1941

 

With World War II raging, American Industry was gearing up for maximum war materials production. The draft had syphoned much of the man-power needed for the building of the war machine and its operation. The older men and the women of the Nation had to fill in the gap left by the military. Ira joined the operation by helping construct new manufacturing plants in Marion and Ravenna, Ohio. This required that he rent a room for over-night during the work-week and commute home for the weekend.

 

1943

 

Ira Harrington was in the hospital with pneumonia in the Spring of 1943. This date is fixed by June coming from Indianoplis for a visit and was pregnant with her only son, Bobbie Franklin. Ira had been painting the eve-spouts while standing on a ladder that reached to the 2nd story. He was using an aluminized, oil-based paint to protect the iron-based eves. Ira complained of the harsh smell of the paint solvent. Whether the solvent was exaserbating an existing condition or was causing it, was unclear. Whatever the case, the condition soon turned into pneumonia. Ira

 


 


190


Generation 4 (con't)

 

was never one to take more than home-remedies but he eventually agreed to seek medical help. He went to Dr. Black who was an old physician who practiced in Circleville. Dr. Black perscribed two placebos; a sugar pill and a charcoal pill. Ira did not benefit from either and soon became delirious and uncontrollable. At the insistance of his wife, Audra, the doctor was changed to Dr. Vemont Kerns who immediately put Ira in the Berger Hospital and on antibiotics. After 2 or 3 very troublesome days and nights during which a neighbor, Roy Strawser, stayed throughout the night to keep Ira in bed and under control, he began to improve. This turned out to be another of several near-death experiences for Ira. Ira had been expected to die from this pneumonia. Had he died, this book would have a significantly different ending.

 

1946

 

Ira was the union steward at the Containers Corporation of America. This role pitted him against management, a role that he enjoyed. He told a story of saving a guy's job, who was named Shorty, that the management wanted to fire. Ira said that he probably should have been fired, but it was his job to keep it from happening.

 

1947

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira Harrington; Residence year 1947; Address RD 1, Circleville, OH; phone: 1922; occupation: emp Container Corp; Publication title: Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1947

 

1948

 

In 1948 Ira decided to start his own business in the form of a welding shop. His work at the Containers Corporation of America had given him ample experience welding and plently of opportunity at equipment and metal construction to qualify for the work. His wife, Audra, however, was quite concerned that he may not be qualified to manage the finances and administrative part of the business. She volunteered to help provide administrative assistance and support. Ira opened his business that he named "Harrington's Welding" in a moderate sized, all wooden, two story building that he bought on Western Avenue near the corner of Mound Street in Circleville, Ohio. The business thrived until he retired in 1960. It was strictly a one-man shop that would not have supported more than one family. His clients were largely farmers in the area for which he did miscellaneous welding, re-shoeing or re-laying of plow points, building farm wagons, etc. He did a small amount of welding and repair on automotive equipment. A circus company regularly wintered at the Pickaway Fair Grounds which kept him busy during the winter months building and repairing their equipment. Ira bought the large, three-story, red brick house and lot on which the shop was located. He sold the property in the country and moved into the first floor of the red brick making his commute to his welding shop the short walk of about 70-feet thru the back yard to the shop.

 

1949

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira E, Harrington (Audra L); Residence year 1949; Address RD 1, Circleville, OH; phone: 1922; (Harrington's Wldg Shop); Publication title: Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1949

 

1949

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: (Ira E, Harrington) 216(r) W Mound; year 1949; phone: 139; Publication title: Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1949 [second 1949 City Directory entry.]

 

1949

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira E. Harrington; Spouse: Audra L. Harrington; Residence year 1949; Address Rd 1, Circleville, OH; Publication title:

 


 


191


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1949 [third 1949 City Directory entry.]

 

1950

 

Ira and Audra's oldest son, R.E. Harrington, left home in the autumn of 1949 to begin college at The Ohio State University. Ira built a motor scooter for Dick to travel to classes. In 1952 Ira bought a new 1952 Ford sedan and gave Dick the old 1936 family Plymouth.

 

In 1950 with the help of his youngest son, William "Bill" Young Harrington, Ira started construction on a small two bedroom house on the empty lot beside the large red brick house. He and Audra moved into the new house where they lived the remainer of their lives. Ira converted the large house into three apartments that he rented. The third floor apartment was usually empty because it had no toilet facilities. However, even that space was occasionally rented as a sleeping room to a single renter. Rent from the red brick along with social security was Ira and Audra's main source of income in their retirement. Audra resumed working as a beartician after Ira's retirement, more out of boredom than need. With the children gone, Ira and Audra slowly prospered and their lives included travel and more recreational activities.

 

1952

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira E. Harrington; Spouse: Audra L. Harrington; Residence year 1952; Address: Circleville, OH; occupation: Wldg (welding); Publication title: Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1952

 

1955

 

Ira vowed that he would retire at the age of 60. His plan was to build a power-boat that he would take to Florida and fish. He bought plans with patterns for the components to construct a 26-foot long, 8-foot beam, power boat. During periods of slack business, he built his boat in his welding shop. It was equipped with a converted 8-cylinder, Lincoln automobile engine and transmission.

 

1959

 

From U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989: Ira E. Harrington (Audrey); Residence year 1959; Address: 216 W. Mound, Circleville, OH; Publication title: Circleville, Ohio, City Directory, 1959

 

1960

 

Ira retired from the welding shop at age 60. He sold most of his equipment to a local Circleville, Ohio competitor who had recently opened his own shop. Ira kept his service truck to pull his newly completed boat. In the summer of 1960 he headed for Venice, Florida. He bought a mobile home near Venice and launched his boat. Venice is on the western coast of Florida about 90 miles south of St. Petersburg. A year or two before Ira arrived in Florida, a periodic event of the Red Tide occurred which sickens and kills many of the fish in the Gulf of Mexico unlucky enough to be in it path. The result is a cessation of fishing for from a few months to a few years.

 

1961

 

Audra rented their furnished house in Circleville to two school teachers and joined Ira at Venice, Florida.

 

1962

 

By the summer of 1962, Ira and Audra tired of Venice, Florida and decided to go back home to Circleville, Ohio. On their return trip to Ohio they stopped for a visit with the author, R.E. Harrington, who was living and working in Pensacola, Florida. During that visit, Ira gave Dick the boat that they had left in Venice. Dick moved the boat to a marina in Pensacola within about a month. In 1963 the marina

 


 


192


Generation 4 (con't)

 

caught fire and burned all of the boats, including the un-insured boat that Ira had built.

 

1965

 

After retiring at about age of 60, Ira became bored. He built himself a small light weight fishing boats. A friend who saw it wanted to buy it, so he sold it. He built another for himself and again sold it to a friend. Before long, he was taking orders for his boats. He made and sold perhaps a dozen boats. The project helped him get over his retirement bordom but it, too, soon became boring. He made one more boat which he kept.

 

1972

 

About 1927, Ira, his oldest son, Dick, and Dick's two sons, Daniel and Gregory went to Canada on a camping and fishing vacation.

 

1974

 

Ira vowed that he would never fly. His claim was that if he were ever killed by an airplane, it would have to fall on him. In the early 1970s, his oldest son, R.E. Harrington, worked in Washington, D.C. Ira and Audra wanted to visit but did not want to drive. Ira finely relented and took a plane to and from Washington, D.C.

 

1980

 

Ira's health began failing with obvious signs of dementia. He was diagnosed as having insufficient oxygen to the brain because of decreased blood flow to that area brought on by hardening of the arteries. His doctors said that it was likely a product of life-long smoking.

 

1983

 

Ira died 24 November 1983.

From the Ohio, Deaths, 1908-1932, 1938-1944, & 1958-2007 NAME: Ira E Harrington

 

BIRTH DATE:  1899

BIRTH PLACE: Ohio, United States GENDER: Male

 

RACE: White

RESIDENCE PLACE: Circleville, Pickaway, Ohio, United States DEATH DATE: 23 Nov 1983

 

HOSPITAL OF DEATH: Home

DEATH PLACE:Circleville, Pickaway, Ohio, USA

CERTIFICATE:

085377

 

AGE AT DEATH:

84

CERTIFIER:

Physician

SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: 288-01-4159

MARITAL STATUS:

Married

 

Mr. Ira Harrington obituary:

 

Mr. Ira E. Harrington, 84, 212 W. Mound St. died this morning at 3 a.m. at his residence.

 

Born August 28, 1899, in Circleville, he was the son of William A. and Elizabeth Pence Harrington.

 

He was the retired owner of Harrington Welding Shop.

He was preceded in death by four brothers and three sisters.

Survivors include his wife, Audra Young Harrington; two sons, Richard E. Harrington of Washington, D. C., and William Harrington of Circleville; two daughters, Patricia Reynolds of Circleville and Mrs. Martin (June) Walters of Washington (state of Washington); 13 grandchildren and five great-grandchildren; one sister, Ola Eblin of Columbus.

 


 


193


Generation 4 (con't)

 

Graveside memorial services will be held Friday at 2:30 PM in Forrest Cemetery (Circleville, OH) with Pastor John Mittermaier officiating. Memorial contributions may be made to Trinity Lutheran Church.

 

Ira was creamated and his ashes are buried at the site of his and his wife's tombstone in Forest Cemetery, Circleville, Ohio. When Ira's daughter, Patricia Sue Harrington Hutchinson Reynolds died on 28 Apr 2013, she was buried in the grave of her father. Ira's urn of ashes were removed and reburied in the same grave at her request.

 

Such is the chronology of the life of Ira Edward Harrington as best it could be described from public records, stories related by Ira about himself, and from the author's memory. So, who then was Ira Edward Harrington? Was he a complex or simple man? Was he wise or irresponsible? The following are the author's personal assessment. As you read the following conclusions, keep in mind the contents of the of the opening paragraphs. Also, keep in mind that it is very difficult - almost impossible - for one to assess a member of the family without significant bias. But, I will try to be objective.

 

Ira was a smart yet average man. Some terms that come to mind that apply to Ira, to varying degrees, include: macho, confident, independent, proud, honest, courageous, hard working, mechanically inclined, intellegent, prejudice, self-centered, loyal, a limited formal education and a temper. He enjoyed hunting, fishing, dogs, hard work, mechanical challenges, his family, close friends, coon hunting, and complements. His taste in foods were limited to basic foods. He did not like fancy dishes, wine, mixed drinks, sandwich meats, carrots, or any wild meats such as wild rabbit, squirrel, groundhog, etc.

 

As with most people, I suspect, it is likely that the experiences of Ira in his parental family were among the most important factors in forming who Ira E. Harrinton would be throughout his life. Some of the main factors include the period in history when he lived, the size of his parental family, the poverty of the family, the competition within the family, the role-models of the extended family, the education level of his parents and himself, the priority of education by his parents, and more. Many of these factors can be overcome or reoriented in later life. In Ira's case some were, some were not.

 

The lack of education of both of Ira's parents would have been a major factor in his upbringing. It kept the family in poverty throughout Ira's formative years. Life was hard. There was barely enough to eat and ware. Competition within the family was keen. Etiquette and manners were subordinate to needs.

 

A family trait within the members of Ira Harrington and his siblings was competition with other siblings. This competion manifest itself in several ways. One was an apparent need to brag about one's own accomplishments and the need to minimize achievements of other siblings. While the siblings seemed to like to get together, each sibling seemed to display an overly competitive focus on themselves. It could bring out a boisterous level of discussion and give the impression that each sibling was selfish and considered himself or herself to be the most important person in the gathering. In the case of Ira, this attitude carried over into the home. Perhaps this could be an impression of a child-member of the Ira Harrington family. But it was clear that Ira was always right, always the decision-maker and disciplanarian, always the person who controlled all aspects of the family. In reality, this was probably more a reflection of how things were in his parent's home. It probably also reflected the fact that while 'dad' was the law, there was not much law. It was more an environment in which the kids ran wild, without much guidance.

 

Another manifestation of being self-centered was that almost all family activities involved things that interested Ira. Ira was an outdoors man. Only bad weather and darkness kept him inside. Family entertainment included hunting, fishing, occasional camping trips. He liked to work and always had a project in mind

 


 


194


Generation 4 (con't)

 

or in progress. He was talented, cleaver, and good at almost everything he undertook. He also

took great pleasure in his accomplishments. He was frequently helpful to neighbors since it provided an opportunity to demonstrate his ability to figure out a problem and demonstrate his ability to solve it. He would frequently brag about accomplishments that he experienced on his job. This trait served Ira well when he had his own welding business.

 

Ira took great pride in his ability to provide for himself and his family with almost all of their material needs. It appeared to be the pleasure of the sense of accomplishment that drove him. He had both a need, a desire and a drive to be a harvester. With the help of his wife and family, he raised most of his own family's food. He was almost totally independent of the supermarket from the four acre small farm. He hunted and fished for food. He kept honey bees; planted, harvested and preserved a full range of vegetables; raised and butchered his own meat; kept a milk cow; and more. He also hunted and trapped for pelts for extra money. He made his own electricity with a home-made windcharger that he built. He cut his own wood for fuel. He expanded his house with used blocks and lumber. He dug his own well, piped the water into the kitchen where it was pumped with a hand pump into a concrete sink that he built. He built his own house. He did most of this by himself, without help other than from family members.

 

Ira had a deep dislike for politicians and people in authority. He viewed politicians of any level to be one of the main sources of problems that the Country faced. His dislike extended to most of the laws and regulations he encountered. He was pursuaded in his views by the observation that he was born and lived much of his life without many of the laws and regulations and felt that things ran well. He could never admit that the rise in population might need regulations and rules to more smoothly govern the interaction and conduct of people. He saw all such things that inhabited his freedom only as they applied to him. This was likely a manifestation of his early up-bringing.

 

Ira belived in religion but distrusted organized religion. He used to say that he could go into the woods, away from people and be closer to God than in any church. He viewed the church, any church, as a human manipulation of religion for profit.

 

On most subjects, Ira had thought long and hard and had developed his own views and theories of his world. If they differed for others, he was willing to argue them but seldom modify them. He had great confidence and faith in himself and believed that he had an equal or better chance of being right as someone else. He was an island of confidence and would quickly agree that his views might differ but never agree that he was wrong.

 

Ira was a product of a dying - perhaps now dead - survival culture. A culture when neighbor helped neighbor without expecting pay or immediate return of the favor. A time when trading was common and payment in services and products one had to offer were acceptable. Dad paid doctor bills with produce from the garden -- he didn't have the money. He worked nights at the Containers Corporation of America and would get out of bed during the day to repair a neighbors tractor. They in turn would plow his garden or give him straw if he needed it. People seemed to trust that in the longer run things would even out - no one would take or get an advantage. Agreements didn't have to be detailed to the letter. Later in his life this resulted in a number of misunderstandings and disagreements. An example of such a contract was when he agreed to buy used concrete block from a nearby church that was dismantling a block wall. Ira's understanding of the agreement was that he could buy only the block that he needed. The church elder's understanding was that he would buy all of the block and haul away the rest. On another occasion he bought hay from a farmer for cow feed. When the hay was delivered, it was a beautiful, high-grade hay that came at a price that was 2 to 3 times more expensive than he expected. Still another time, Ira agreed to clear-cut wood on a neighbor's farm for the wood. Well into the job, the

 


 


195


Generation 4 (con't)

 

neighbor asked Ira for his half of the wood. Fortunately, this kind of misunderstanding did not happen often.

Ira could be very judgmental. He had a dislike for certain "kinds" of people including sissies, homosexuals, cowards, effeminate men, and liars. He distrusted politicians, lawyers, preachers, high-pressure salesmen and salewomen, advertisers, the wealthy, and people whom he thought were grossly overpaid for the work they do, such as sports figures, movie stars, business executives, etc.

 

Love was a difficult emotion for Ira. Love seemed to collide with his sense of macho, masculinity, effeminate men, and even sissy. Yet, he clearly loved his wife, Audra, and his family. He could not apply the term to his siblings or parents, but, he "liked" them. I never heard Ira tell his wife that he loved her, although I suspect he did. He never told his childen he love them and seldom cuddle with them. It was a word and emotion that was somehow connected to his image of a sissy. It was important that his sons not be sissies. Being a sissy meant that you didn't cry. And, you didn't yield to non-masculine emotions like hugging or showing affection.

 

But Ira had all those emotions. He just couldn't expose them. He clearly was proud of his kids. He would eagerly acknowledge or even raise the subject of certain attributes in his kids that he admired, like talent on the basketball court, track and other sports, honors won in school, going to college, Patty's attractiveness, and more. He had fear for our safety or having had a near injury -- he would sometimes hide his feelings with scolding or anger. In later years after I had left home, he was clearly glad to see me return. Perhaps the closest he ever came to showing affection was in an admonition at the end of a visit, "Don't stay away so long."

 

Yet in spite of Ira's hard exterior and the taboo of ever appearing to be a sissy, we had some wonderful times. They mostly involved doing things together. More times than not it was some work-related event; sometimes it involved hunting or fishing or visiting the Old-Mans-Cave or visiting Gm and GP Harrington or Young.

 

When it came to love, Ira had all the emotions of any well adjusted man. He just couldn't express them. He could not allow himself to even try.

 

Ira was 5-feet, 8-inches tall. He weighed 175 lbs all of his adult life with little variation. He had a full head of hair throughout his life that went from a brown/red to snow white. He always considered himself a read-head. He always claimed Irish as his ethnicity. Ira was seldom sick during his life. He periodically suffered from a strained back that at times made him bedfast. His two most serious bouts with ill health were: 1) In about 1919 he was in an 8-day coma from head injuries suffered in a motorcycle accident, and 2) In 1943 he had a serious bout with pneumonia. As he approached the end of his life, around 1980, he began suffering from dementia. Over a period of about 3 years he was reduced to a condition similar to a new-born baby. He died in his sleep at home.

 

 

Notes for Dortha Ellen Moore:

 

Photos in Album, Pages: 51

 

Dorothy E. Moore in the Ohio, Births and Christenings Index, 1800-1962 NAME: Dorothy E. Moore

GENDER:

Female