INTRODUCTION TO JOHN AND CATHERINE DAVIS
TAYLOR
Research by Gloria Taylor and Martha Mewborn Marble
It has been thought that this Taylor family was seated in
Duplin County and moved into Lenoir County and the same was
true for the James Davis family. This was based on the
records found in Duplin County which lists the heirs of
Rachel Davis, daughter of James and Catherine Davis
including the children of Catherine Taylor. A study of all
available information proves both families never lived in
Duplin County, but were seated in Lenoir County on South
West Creek near Woodington. It appears that some of the
families moved north on South West Creek over the years.
For years it has been written that Catherine Davis' husband
was Richard but there is no evidence of a Richard in the
area. Information from the Alabama cousins indicated there
was an old Journal that stated the husband was William and
it gave dates of birth that fit. In Edwin Taylor's Will, he
mentions land adj to William Taylor's old patent and without
question there was a William of the right time to have been
married to Catherine; however, efforts to locate the Journal
have failed. For several years I went with William as the
husband but as a result of this study and the circumstantial
evidence found, I now feel that John was the husband. John
may have been John Taylor Jr and he possibly had a brother
William and one by the name of Edward or Edwin.
Because Taylor is such a common name and the lack of records
in Lenoir County would make proving anything impossible, I
put off any work on this family for years. In the meantime,
a young cousin of the Alabama branch, Robert Taylor, Jr.,
contacted me and then started an in-depth study of the
Alabama branch. The information that Robert has turned up is
incredible and he has left no stone unturned &endash; and he
wanted it taken back further. Persistent is his middle name
so this study is more for Robert. Then Gloria and I combined
forces and although we could not prove a lot, some
enlightening information was uncovered.
A number of years ago, Mrs. Robert Taylor of Lenoir County
compiled a booklet on the Edwin Taylor family which is
fairly complete. She did the legwork on the later family
mostly by talking with all the branches of the family and we
are indebted to her. I have a copy of this record and there
is one at Heritage Place, LCC. I have backtracked a little
on the family but not up to the present. One thing that is
consistent in this family is the use of the name Windal in
every branch &endash; it is a dead give away of a connection
to this family.
It appears there were at least two families on South West
Creek &endash; the Abraham Taylor family of Maryland, and
the John Taylor family. Again, there are indications our
John may have been a Junior. John was not a son of Abraham
although it is possible he could have been a grandson but
probably only the two oldest sons of Abraham, Jacob and
Robert, could have been his father and there is no
indication this was the case. These two families were
neighbors and appear to have had numerous land dealings but
we can't connect them although I think there was a
connection. The names are not the same but they appeared
about the same time along with the Richard Caswell Sr family
and possibly other families from Baltimore County, Maryland
where they were all neighbors near Joppa and attended the
same church.
Abraham Taylor's father was Abraham Sr. and in Abraham Sr.'s
Will, he left land to a son John. Within a year or two of
Abraham Jr. moving to Craven Co, his brother John sold his
inheritance in Maryland. Unfortunately, there were several
John's in the church and land records and I can't sort them
without a full study of the Taylors in Baltimore County. I
have seen in various histories of this family, the
contention that the brother John stayed in Maryland but I am
not so sure he stayed given the number of John's in the area
as well as other Abrahams. I am inclined to think the
brother John moved to South West Creek and is our ancestor,
being the John Sr. Abraham first lived maybe in New Bern and
then on Core Creek and then moved to SW Creek where he died
with a Will.
There is more information available on the family of Abraham
but even so, there is not enough to put them together. That
will be covered in another section.
There is more family tradition down the Alabama lines than
the Lenoir County lines &endash; some of it can't be proven
but there is some circumstantial to indicate some of it is
correct. One of the traditions is that Catherine died, John
remarried and the youngest daughter was reared by her
siblings and then moved with them to Alabama. There is a
John Taylor on the 1790 Dobbs Census that is a perfect fit
with the exception of the daughter, Elizabeth, born after
1790. Neighbors were the Millers, Harpers, and Herrings. In
1800 John does not appear on the Census but his son Wendal
does. In 1810 a John appears next to Wendal and James, his
sons. There is a small girl in the household but it is not
known if this was the daughter Elizabeth or some other
child. Family tradition states that Catherine died ca 1801
but that is not proven. John does not appear after this and
it is assumed he died. It is possible that Elizabeth, on the
1820 Census was his widow but there appears to be more
slaves that John would have had. It is about this time that
all of his children, except for Edwin moved to Alabama.
In Book 17 CA 1796 &endash; 1798 of the Cross Indices there
are two conveyances &endash; one from John to Wendal and one
from John to Edwin who was still a minor at the time. In
Book 23 &endash; 1805-1810 there is a conveyance from John
to W and E Taylor on page 410 &endash; assumed to be Windal
and Edwin. On page 414 there is a conveyance between
Elizabeth Taylor to Bartholomew Cauley a known son in law of
John and Catherine. It is possible that deed book dates are
incorrect and these deeds were registered after John's
death. In Book 24 Aug 1810 - Aug 1819 there is
a conveyance between James and Edwin the two assumed
brothers. This would indicate that John was dec and James
had inherited something and was probably selling to Edwin at
which
point he left
for Alabama. In the same book is a conveyance between Isaac
Taylor to Elizabeth and W. Taylor. Isaac may have been the
administrator of John's estate which is another indication
of the close relationship between the Abraham and John
families. Every one of John and Catherine's children had a
son named John &endash; not one had a son William.
The records found in Duplin County for Catherine Davis
Taylor's sisters prove her children but of course, if John
had another child by another wife, that child would not be
listed. It has been written there was another girl in this
family but if that was the case, she was not a child of
Catherines. Rachel Davis' heirs were among others - Catey
Taylor and her heirs were - Serena, James, Windal, Edwin,
Winnie, Betsey.
Nothing is known about Serena. Betsy was Elizabeth and she
married Absolem Wall in Alabama. Winifred married
Bartholomew Cauley and moved to Alabama with her brothers
James and Windal. Scott Smith has published a book on this
family and is planning on updating the book in the future.
Only Edwin remained in Lenoir County where he has many
descendants. In a letter written by a son of Elizabeth Wall
many years ago, he states his mother told him she was reared
by her siblings &endash; probably Windal after her mother
died and her father remarried.
Any additional documentation for this family would be
greatly appreciated and can be sent to me.
Martha Mewborn Marble
[email protected]
|