To read more about this cemetery, see:
A History and Biographical Cyclopaedia of Butler County OH and The Old George Burial Ground

Surname	First name	Age	Tombstone	Death date	Photo #	More info
ARMSTRONG	Christopher	38 y, 10 m, 19 d		August 5, 1835	161 162	Although a Christopher Armstrong was a grandson of John Skyles Sr, according to John's 1827 will, the September 16 or 17, 1797 birthdate of this Christopher Armstrong, (1797-1835) suggests that his mother, John's daughter, had already died. Some researchers have thought Rebecca Skyles married James Armstrong. In 1808 (Miami Valley Genealogy Index and Armstrong Ancestry of the Jansen Daughters), Rebecca Stiles married James Armstrong - 11 years after this Christopher was born. The Butler Co OH 1830 census lists James, John, Rebecca, William, and (Morgan, pg 169) Christopher Armstrong.
Stroup's "Butler County Ohio Cemetery Records", Vol XI, p 45 also lists a tombstone for Martha ARMSTRONG (1802-1831) - wife of Christopher - died 6 Aug 1831 at the age of 29 yrs. [and notes that Butler Marriages lists her marriage: Martha Johnson to Christopher Armstrong 1 Nov 1821 - also see Miami Valley Gen Index]
Stroup's "Butler County Ohio Cemetery Records", Vol XI, p 45 also lists a tombstone for Euphenia J. ASHCRAFT (1866-1871) - daughter of B. and S. - died 14 Oct 1871 at the age of 5 yrs-7 mo-7 da.
ASHCRAFT	Rachel			(no dates)	177
BROWN	John			(date broken off?)	568	John Brown was the husband of Martha Jane (George) Brown.
BROWN	Joshua G.				564	Joshua G., son of John and Martha Jane BROWN (rest illegible here, but Stroups show he died 12 Mar 1854, aged 5 y-7 m-14 da)
Stroup's "Butler County Ohio Cemetery Records", Vol XI, p 45 also lists a tombstone for Susan BROWN (1832-1854) - wife of John S. and daughter of Charles and Lavina SHIELDS - died 13 Dec 1854 at the age of 22 yrs-9 mo-10 da.
COUGLE	Elizabeth	23 y, 10 mo, 10 d		Aug 20, 1839	171	Listed as "Congle" in the Butler Co History. Consort of Madison Cougle.
DAVIS	Ann	61 y, 1 m, 27 d		March 22, 1832	170	Ann, according to Sam Lawson's post at GenForum, is likely Meshach Davis' wife Nancy Ann Lewis Davis, born ca 1769, died 2 March 1832 in Butler Co OH, and buried in the George Cemetery.
DAVIS	Meshach	b Sept 4, 1764		October 11, 1845	166	Meshach was buried next to Rachel Davis. More information on Meshach at GenForum, including his wife, Nancy Ann Lewis Davis, and their 9 children. No Rachel is listed.
DAVIS	Rachel	39 y, 27 d		February 13, 1839	165	Rachel was buried next to Meshach Davis
DAVIS	Samuel	62 y 3 mo 19 d ?		Mar 14, 1861	553
DeARMOND	Alexander H.	b 1818		d 1896 ?	517 Michigan connections	Alexander H. was buried next to Isabelle DeArmond
DeARMOND	Isabelle	b 1818		d 1901	516	Isabelle was buried next to Alexander H. DeArmond
DeARMOND	Joseph A.	b 2 Nov 1857		d 6 Jan 1862	551	Joseph was the son of John Randolph and Mary George DeARMOND
DeARMOND	King	10 m, 17 d		Sept 9, 1855	183 (top) 184a	"King, infant son of K. and Esther DeArmond"
DeARMOND	King	43 y, 1 m, 8 d		Sept 22, 1855	183 (bottom) 184b	King was buried near his infant son, King
ELBY	Mabel NUGENT	b 1875		d 1901	512	Mable was buried next to Sally Nugent
GEORGE	Catherine			Oct 20, 1862	562	Catherine Thompson Gough George was wife of Joshua George (1801-1835), who was said to have been buried under a tree. Catherine was widowed twice.
GEORGE	Electa J.	4 y 3 m 12 d		30 Sept 1856	566 567	Electa Jeanette, granddaughter of Catherine George and first child of Enoch "Jackson" and Margaret Ellen DeArmond George, died in a fire accident at home. (Cannot tell if something else is written on the toppled stone)
HANDLEY	Archey	53 y, 5 m, 19 d		August 7, 1842	181	Archey, son of James and Isabella Handley, was the husband of Rebecca
HANDLEY	Rabecca	50 years		Nov 14, 1839	179 180	Rebecca was the wife of Archibald "Archey" Handley
HUGHES	Thomas	about 42 y		Oct ....	508
JENKINS	Isabell	37 y, 9 mo, 2 d		Nov 14, 1832	175 176	Isabell Handley Jenkins, the wife of Evan Jenkins, was a niece of Ann Handley George
JONES	Charles	29 y, 10 m, ? da		d Aug 14 1866	539 | 547 | 559-group |	Charles JONES was buried close to Mary Elizabeth STROUGHTON's and behind Cornelius STROUGHTON's tombstone
JONES	William	56 y, 3 m, 27 da ?		d Sept	540 548
McCLAIN	William	b 22 Dec 1765		d 9 Sep 1849	552
MERCER		b		d July 2, 1851	545
NUGENT	Millie	b 1859		d 1897	511	Millie, buried with William
NUGENT	Sally	b 1886		d 1894	513	Sally was buried next to Mabel Nugent Elby
NUGENT	William	b 1840		d 1924	511	William, buried with Millie
PATTERSON	Samuel	84 y		Dec 3, 1853	182	Samuel Patterson Sr and his son Samuel were neighbors of Christopher Armstrong in section 9 per the 1836 map, and lived across the Dry Fork River from Reuben George and this cemetery. The year after Samuel Patterson Sr died, Joshua George's youngest son David W. George married Samuel Sr's granddaughter Nancy Patterson.
PERRY	Oliver S.	10 y, 1 mo, 21 d		March 18, 1840	168 169
RUGSDALE	Walter	10 y, 4 m, 29 d		September 21, 1840	163	Walter (1830-1840) was a son of Wilson and Mary RUGSDALE
SHIELDS	Charles	b 1807		d 1888 ?	524 525 overview	Charles Shields (1807-1886/8?) was the husband of Lavina. According to Stroups, Susan BROWN (1832-1854) was their daughter.
SHIELDS	Eliza A.				534	Eliza "wife of Samuel C. Shields, daughter of John and Nancy ?"
SHIELDS	Lavina	b 1807		d 1903	524 525 overview	Lavina (1807-1903) was Charles Shields' wife
SHIELDS	Mary ?			Aug 9, 1863	532 back of stone
SHIELDS	S. C.			(no date)	185 186
STOUGHTON	Cornelius			May 24? 18??		Cornelius STROUGHTON was a veteran of the Civil War, having been a corporal in Company B of the One Hundred and Sixty-seventh Regiment, National Guard.
STOUGHTON	Cornelius	25 y?		Feb? 18??	561	Another Cornelius STOUGHTON. Is he the Civil War veteran?
STOUGHTON	Mary Elizabeth	18 yr, 8? mo, 21 da		July 21 1881 ?	538, 546, 560
STOUGHTON	Henry A.				560
STOUGHTON		5 yr 7 mo 7 da		Oct 14, 1871	515
STOUGHTON?					563	?
WAER	John B.	b Sept 1, 1860		d Jan 8 1883	521 522 523 569	Pedistle and overview of John's stone
WAER	Nathan (L?)	b May 13, 1812		d Jan 20, 1869	526	Nathan Waer (1812-1869) was the husband of Susan
WAER	Susan	b Nov 20, 1819		d Jul 27, 1889	526	Susan (1819-1889) was the wife of Nathan Waer

Still undeciphered...
Surname	First name	Age	Tombstone	Death date	Photo #	More info
(?)					509	Near 508 (Thomas Hughes) and 510, a baby
?		baby			510	Near 509 and 511 (Millie Nugent)
?					514	Near 513 and 515
?					518	"Father & Mother" Near 517 and 519
?					519	Near 518 and 520 (A. S.)
?	A. S.				520	Near 518 and 521
?	Eve				527 527a
?					528 528a
?					529
?					530
?					531
?					535
?					536
?					537
?					541
?					542
?					543
?					544
?					549
?					550
?					554
EMALI?					555
GO?					556
?					557
?					558
?					560a	near 560 (Henry STOUGHTON) - tall monument not ided and another unknown at 561
?					561	near 560 (Henry STOUGHTON) and 562 (Catherine GEORGE)
?					565	Near 564 (Joshua G. BROWN) and 566 (Electra GEORGE)