The Butler Band  Somewhere between 1920-1925.  Probably 1925.
This picture belonged to Clara McCague.

Front row l to r:  Carl Hanes, Earl Bechtel, Leighton Tombow, and James Cherry.

2nd row:  Wallace Knepper, Floyd Raney, Director Charles Apt, Dale Higley, Lester Firestone, and Vincent Holtzberg.

Third row:  Charles Smith, Lloyd Oberlin, Edward Swift, Ralph Madden, Harry Preston, Arthur Latson, and Lyndon Hewey.

Back row:  Cleveland Grube, Earl Parker, Aaron Strong, Charles Stell, Harold Hewey, Millard Capp, Dee Baker, Oscar Fuller, and Cleland Croniger.