He married first to Idella Hayden on Feb. 4, 1895 in Fancy Farm, Graves Co., KY. Idella died Feb. 11, 1896. They had 1 child, Mary Lucella Carrico born Feb. 7, 1896 who died as an infant.

He marrried 2nd to Ludie May Ballard on Aug. 27, 1899. Ludie died 1904 or 1905. They had 2 children, Letha Edna born Oct. 5, 1901, became Sr. Mary Anarita who died in Clinton, IA Oct. 17, 1963 & Charles Raymond born Feb. 6, 1904, died as a child. 

He married 3rd  on Oct 1, 1906 in Graves Co., KY to Anna "Ellis" Thompson, dau. of Samuel Philip Thompson & Susan Frances Raley born March 14, 1877 in Union Co., KY. Samuel & Ellis raised a family of 8 children, 2 sons & 6 daughters.

Samuel Pious Carrico died June 4, 1943 in Fancy Farm, Graves Co., KY
Anna "Ellis" (Thompson) Carrico died June 10, 1955 in E. St. Louis, MO. Both are buried at St. Jerome's Cemetery in Fancy Farm, Graves Co., KY